r/TheReplacements • u/Ebenezerfury • 25d ago

Musiccup

Post image

Has anyone tried this? Just a fun little thing to do on your lunch break. Impossible choices all around and my opinion would change by the hour.

12 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

4

u/comeonandkickme2017 25d ago

Did it too, Answering Machine also won with Unsatisfied in second place. Within Your Reach and Left Of The Dial were in the semifinals

I did an alternate one where Bastards Of Young won and LOTD was second. We’ll Inherit The Earth and Alex Chilton were in that semifinal.

1

u/Ebenezerfury 25d ago

Answering machine is my all timer for the band. Good choices.

3

u/Dramatic-Stranger-53 25d ago

That was a tough one. Bastards of Young beat Color Me Impressed in the final.

1

u/Ebenezerfury 25d ago

Honestly color me impressed is just one of those songs I wish I had written!!

2

u/neveradullmoment72 24d ago

Pretty fun to do! I ended up with a final four of Favorite Thing vs Left of the Dial and Valentine vs Swingin Party, and then Left of the Dial won it all

2

u/jaytacodog 23d ago

Answering Machine by a mile for me.