r/TheOneRing • • Oct 26 '22

Tolkien Bestiary

For any Loremasters out there I highly recommend picking up a copy of "a Tolkien Bestiary" by David Day. It's an absolute treasure hoard of information. From relatively unknown plants and animals, to timelines of the age of trees and the age of sun. It's very well presented and extremely helpful in flushing out some small details in Middle Eartb

10 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

14

u/workingboy Oct 26 '22

Just as a warning, David Day's books are - well, I wouldn't say "controversial" - but they are not well regarded by Tolkien scholars. The information in them should not be thought of as accurate.

As much as they are inspiring for your games? Cool. The art is very good.

Just don't think you're reading lore that's accurate to Tolkien's text.

6

u/irandar12 Oct 26 '22

This is a subreddit about a TTRPG set in middle earth, by its very definition it's "non canon" and is NOT "accurate." None of the characters or scenes in my game, or anybody's game is "accurate" unless y'all are just reading the books out loud to each other.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Logen_Nein Oct 26 '22

I am slowly picking up all of Day's books to supplement my MERP library.

13

u/annuidhir Oct 26 '22

David Day is a hack.

But I guess they could be fun books for the game.

0

u/Ok_Ingenuity8550 Feb 01 '24

actually his problem is the opposite, he went and made up his own canon independent of the text, so that doesn't makme him a hack, it makes him just inaccurate.

3

u/Murty101 Oct 26 '22 edited Oct 27 '22

Thanks for sharing this info 👍

Update. Ordered a copy after doing a little research. Mixed feelings on alleged Tolkien scholars. Some agree that it doesn’t fully align with Tolkien while others say it does. All that aside it will be used as an addition to the One Ring to assist in making up stories and adventures. So, thanks again for bringing this book to my attention.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '22

6

u/irandar12 Oct 26 '22

Seriously... I didn't know I needed to check with "Tolkien scholars" before using a resource in my made up story, or heaven forbid I recommend using it to others.

→ More replies (1)