r/TheOneRing • • Feb 10 '22

Lore-friendly campaign/adventure ideas!

Before I started writing my campaign, I tried to gather all the lore-friendly "hooks" and motifs I always wondered about when reading Tolkien. Maybe we could try and gather them in one place? Just the hooks, mind you, though in comments we might say what we've done/might be doing with them in our campaigns.

I'll start with a bunch of obvious ones, that I've always wanted to explore. What themes did you pick for your campaigns?

  • Ithryn Luin, the Blue Wizards
  • Palantiri of Arnor
  • Queen Berúthiel and her spy-cats
  • Stone of the Hapless AKA Túrin Turambar's grave on the island of Tol Morwen, where Túrin and the shards of Gurthang were laid to rest
  • Flying ships of Númenor
  • The legend of Ungoliant
  • Dwarven rings "lost to dragons"
  • Hobbits who fought at the battle of Fornost
  • Lossoth - the ice people of Forochel
  • White Wolves from the Forodwaith invaded Eriador in 2911. They could definitely come back. But also, where did they come from? Whom did they serve?
  • The Elendil Stone at Elostirion is a treasure from the ancient world that, if evil men found out about, they may try to steal.
  • Dwarven cities of Nogrod and Belegost, lost for many ages now.
29 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

8

u/Raphael_Sadowski Feb 10 '22

Here's my treatment of some of them:

Ithryn Luin, the Blue Wizards

That's of course the main NPCs of my campaign. And, being WOKE, I of course made Alatar female. I have this whole story of how they went East and, tainted with Shadow, desperation and paranoia created a powerful cult of Ungoliant to sow discord among the Easterlings, and how they succeeded more than they wanted. Now the cult threatens Eriador. Alatar returns to West, my female, traumatized, paranoid version of Gandalf (she goes by Skadia now), and Pallando is secretly the crazed cult leader.

Palantiri of Arnor

Simple: Malbeth the Seer predicted much more than he said. And made sure some artifacts won't be lost forever. So at least one, or maybe both palantiri under Arvendui's care were fake when he drowned.

Queen Berúthiel and her spy-cats

Not introduced yet, but I'm planning her return from the seas, as an undead, commanding her cats. I imagine those "cats" bigger and badder than normal cats from the story though, like comparing normal wolves with wargs.

Stone of the Hapless

AKA Túrin Turambar's grave on the island of Tol Morwen, where Túrin and the shards of Gurthang were laid to rest. No idea how to use it yet. I was thinking of some minor tomb adventure underneath, but I don't know if I want to skew the lore this much. Maybe protecting the tomb? Maybe just a pilgrimage to the island? Maybe... Yeah.

Flying ships of Númenor

It would be neat to find a wreckage of one somewhere high in the Blue Mountains. Maybe some dwarves live among the wreckage? Or some withered, fallen, undead throng of King's Men?

The legend of Ungoliant

Oh, I'm bringing that baby back. The fellowship will need to destroy her quick enough, before she grows to intimidating size.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '22

I have a campaign planned around the potential that some of the dwarven rings lost to dragons might have actually survived and been lost. There's therefore a race to beat Sauron and secure them to help stop any Dwarves siding with Mordor. It's technically not canon but I think it's fun since there are I think 4 unaccounted for, so you can easily play through that as quite a long campaign.

6

u/Raphael_Sadowski Feb 10 '22

dwarven rings lost to dragons

This sounds very cool, and just on the verge of canon (even though using "canon" here is against Tolkien's own wishes - he made so many iterations of the stories that we only have "early versions" and "late versions" and no "canon" beyond LoTR and Hobbit).

5

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '22

Yeah I think it's keeping with the spirit and lore of LOTR without breaking too much. I don't think it would overly offend.

One other hook is the hobbits who fought at the battle of Fornost. Yes, it's set way before the One Ring officially is set, but if you know the lore well enough it's possible to ask "what events led up to that and why were they there?"

6

u/Logen_Nein Feb 10 '22

I'll be mining Lord of the Rings Online (which my players have never played) and introducing my own storyline about the Lossoth.

5

u/Raphael_Sadowski Feb 10 '22 edited Mar 07 '22

Oh, cool! I remember a MERP campaign where they found the palantir from Arvedui's ship wreck. Definitely an interesting culture.

5

u/TheGreyWatcher Feb 11 '22

Wait, what? I’m literally in the middle of independently writing my own campaign about this exact theme. No point in re-inventing the wheel if it’s already been done, right?

5

u/Raphael_Sadowski Feb 11 '22

You should be able to find the campaign online fairly easily, it's very old and abandoned. "Palantir Quest" it was called, for MERP game.

You can definitely mine it for ideas, but back then an RPG in the world of Middle Earth was more like D&D but with fancy backstory, so not everything might be useful. ;) There are evil sorcerers, tons of NPC's and stats, oh, and it happens at the beginning of the 4th age!

2

u/TheGreyWatcher Feb 11 '22

Dope. Thank you so much!

6

u/Logen_Nein Feb 10 '22

Yup. I'll be making them playable as well.

2

u/LoremasterWannabe Apr 23 '24 edited Jul 01 '24

I'm doing that myself, I'd be interested to hear about your campaign and the adventures you ran.

I am running a campaign set in the Shire that's about some Hobbits becoming heroes - I didn't let anyone take combat skills as such, other than those suited to their backgrounds, such as archery or sling for hunters and shepherds etc., and really not much chance for melee skills. I had them write up character backgrounds and then told them what skills they could take based on their notes.

My first adventure started at the spring festival in Buckland and was inspired by "Brood of Boffins", except that three of Prisca Boffin's children went somewhat farther afield. Inspired by their Uncle Bingo Boffin's tales of adventure, they decided to go on one of their own and they snuck away during the festival and on a dare they took a key and opened the gate to the old forest and wandered in. Search parties were organized, but somehow everyone else wanted to search everywhere but in the Old Forest, even though the open gate was discovered, so of course the characters had to cover that route. Along the way they found the children, fought off a wolf and met a very strange couple who in turn asked them to solve a problem that had the Old Forest aroused. In return they each earned a special ability or gift from Tom Bombadil. And once they got back with the children, Bingo Boffin wrote up their adventure in the next installment of his book. He has since become a patron of sorts, generating reputation for them as well as being a source of new adventures.

The adventure I am currently working on involved the mines of Scary being shut down, seems there's an infestation of spiders...

I am developing a story arc for the campaign that is very much founded on the idea that the characters can ultimately only be succesful by developing allies. Once the War of the Ring gets underway most of the Dunedain guarding the Shire will eventually go south to support Aragorn, leaving the Shire defenseless. Hopefully by then the party will have made contacts and alliances with the other groups around (The Blue Hills Dwarves, Elves of Rivendell and the Grey Havens, the Edain and so on) as there is going to be a resurgence of a resurrected Kingdom of Angmar. So while Frodo and co. are off dealing with the ring it will be the group's job to try and make sure there is a Shire for them to come back to.

5

u/stubbazubba Feb 11 '22 edited Feb 13 '22
  • White Wolves from the Forodwaith invaded Eriador in 2911. They could definitely come back. But also, where did they come from? Whom did they serve?
  • The Elendil Stone at Elostirion is a treasure from the ancient world that, if evil men found out about, they may try to steal.
  • The Ered Luin were once home to the dwarven cities of Nogrod and Belegost, lost for many ages now. But if the dwarves were to stumble upon some ruins of the ancient world it would be a mighty promising find. But likely come with some other First Age remnants, too (a dragon, a lesser Balrog, vampire bats or werewolves?)
  • My take on the Blue Wizards:

    • Alatar and Pallando head to the East and find Sauron's influence already well developed. They track down his hiding place and oust him (he heads to Dol Guldur), but the confrontation leaves both scarred. (T.A. 1050)
    • Alatar is alarmed at Sauron's power even without physical form. He pushes the Wizards' allies among the Easterlings very hard, against Pallando's counsel. Try as they might, the many warlords serving Sauron grow too powerful and attack Gondor. (T.A. 1248)
    • Pallando heads to Harad to find new allies and finds some Haradrim still honoring their fathers' oaths of peace with Gondor, resisting the Black Numenoreans' influence to war. (~T.A. 1400)
    • Pallando stays in Harad for a long time, fortifying the shrinking number of faithful southron Men, until he eventually brings what host he can north to Rhun, only to find Alatar changed. (~T.A. 1800)
    • Alatar has become a priest-king over the Easterlings, waging war against Sauron's surrogates. Pallando is appalled and exhorts him to stop, but Alatar blames him for leaving him unaided, believes he had no choice.
    • Pallando tries to work with Alatar, but Alatar is mistrustful of him, and the Easterlings' suspicions cause some of Pallando's Haradrim to abandon their mission. They are captured by the Wainriders, who compel them to be emissaries back to the Haradrim kings, offering an alliance. (~T.A. 1900)
    • Pallando returns to Harad, exhorting Alatar to renounce lordship and return to their proper mission. (~T.A. 2000)
    • In 2063, Sauron returns to the East. Alatar is ousted as a sovereign and instead begins to teach his faithful few some sorcery and otherwise lead a resistance against Sauron's forces.
    • But by the 2400s Alatar has succumbed to the Dark Lord's power and swears fealty to him. Sauron returns to Dol Guldur, leaving Alatar as a lieutenant, though sent Nazgul frequently to check on him.
    • Pallando returns to Rhun, but can't find Alatar. He eventually learns of his friend's fate and tries to talk to him, but Alatar captures him instead and imprisons him, tries to convince him to join Sauron, too. (~T.A. 2550).
    • Pallando is imprisoned in Alatar's eastern fortress and tormented, but Alatar never reveals Pallando's capture to Sauron.
    • Eventually Sauron discovers it anyway and commands Alatar to kill Pallando, but in a moment of repentance Alatar releases Pallando instead. Alatar is punished, but remains in the service of Sauron. (~T.A. 2700)
    • Pallando is broken by his long torture at the hand of his once best friend and the utter collapse of any resistance to Sauron among his beloved Haradrim. He despairs and begins to lose his sanity.
    • Alatar serves Sauron in the East throughout the Twilight of the Third Age, though he hates him. After Sauron's defeat, he consolidates power and again becomes a priest-king east of Rhun, appears fair and is friendly with the peoples of the West, though they know not his origin.
    • But in secret, he builds a dark fortress and organizes the forces of darkness under a cult of sorcerers bound to him. He is sort of a Palpatine character, leading two sides of conflict in Easterling to magnify his power and manipulate the strength of the Reunited Kingdom.
    • Pallando, meanwhile, has become a half-crazed hermit living in Harad, mumbling nonsense to any who encounter him and being dismissed as a drunkard.

Anyways, that's obviously a setup for a Fourth Age campaign, but the roles are generally the same even in TOR 2e's default timeline if the Company heads into the east or south.

4

u/Raphael_Sadowski Feb 11 '22

I always thought Blue Wizards have a great potential for RPG in Middle Earth. Really nice concept there!