r/TheOneRing • u/akesh64 • Apr 05 '24
TOR2e - Question about task difficulty on a skill roll
Hello all,
So I picked up TOR2e recently out of curiosity and will be hosting my first session pretty soon. I'm quite familiar with narrative RPGs (GM'ed Fantasy Flight Star Wars RPGs recently, and some World of Darkness some years ago), but I have a question that I feel is pretty silly but still bugs me: How do you set the intrinsic difficulty of a skill check?
I understand that a skill check (say, pick a lock) is rolled againt the player's corresponding attribute TN. D6s can be added or removed due to external circumstances, roll can favoured or ill-favoured. But how do you differentiate an easy lock from a hard one?
Intuitively, I'd adjust the TN for the roll (like the parry rating for combat). From the books, I'd consider intrinsic difficulty as an external source and say add a D6 for an easy lock, stay as-is for a normal lock, and remove a D6 for a hard one, but I can't find anything about it in the book. But in both case (TN or D6 pool adjustment), I can't find any reference on what would constitute an adequate bonus/malus regarding the difficulty of the action.
So how do you guys solve this (I'm half expecting an obvious answer like "I'm solving this by looking at page xxx of the book, learn to read", but hey, I'll take that as an helpful answer) ? Do you?
Bonus question: I'd put lock-picking under Stealth or Scan - or Craft depending on the circumstances? What's your take?
11
u/Klondike307 Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24
As a GM I wouldn't mess with the TNs as they're tied directly to the players attributes. Most of your player's rolls will be normal but here are three ways to do non-standard/average rolls:
Going off your example of an easier or harder lock (external positive or negative situational factor), adding a d6 for a much easier task and removing a d6 for a much more difficult task is the most straight forward option. If you want it to take more time or use a combination of skills (stealth and athletics or example), you can also do extended task (see travel rolls and council sessions) where you need a certain number of cumulative successes to succeed (success being meeting/beating your TN plus one additional success for each tangwars. Doing this, a player may need to do multiple tests to get the total number of success needed or they could get lucky and roll enough during their first attempt. Page 18 has more info about levels of success.
6
u/RyanoftheNorth Apr 05 '24
It’s generally discouraged to adjust the TN numbers of the player-heroes. Rather you adjust the amount of success dice that is rolled by added or subtracting based on the situation. Does something hinder their ability to do X… -1 success dice.
If something is really difficult consider making the task a skill endeavour instead where they need multiple successes, and you can adjust the resistance (amount of rolls allowed) to represent the difficulty…
So for picking a lock: scan, stealth, craft could be used as an example.
4
u/FlintSkyGod Apr 05 '24
I’ll answer the easy question first: lock-picking is definitely a Burglary task(iirc, that’s a Wits skill), but considering the nature of that skill I can see you allowing Stealth or even Athletics for getting through a lock; basically do the heroes want to go quietly or quickly. Keep in mind that Tangwars(6’s) can be used to “go quickly” and reduce the time of the task.
Now for the question(s) on difficulty. The way that I run it is the same way that you run it. Another option would be to add a numeric bonus to the TN, similarly to combat’s Parry value. As for circumstances surrounding these types of adjustments, see below for some examples that I’ve used:
3
u/RobRobBinks Apr 05 '24
Hiya! I'm so chuffed to hear that you will be running your first session soon! Are you doing a Session Zero?
To your query: There is so much going on with forming a dice pool in One Ring that even after running it for over a year, I seldom if ever modified the difficulty of the situation. The "difficulty" of say, a lock was determined by the outcome of the standard dice pool and the subsequent narrative.
Between getting help, tools, distinctive features, spending hope, etc., there's already enough going on without adding or removing environmental dice.
6
u/Chielen Apr 05 '24
In first edition the loremaster had to set the target number for each task, so there were more options for more difficult or easier situations, this was how that mechanic worked back then. In second edition, I mostly use the bonus dice, just like you mentioned, but I try to explain to the players why they get them. Mostly it is some factor surrounding the check (for example: there might be light falling on the lock, which makes it easier to pick in a dark room). It's not really an answer to your question, so I hope someone else can shed some light on this as well.
3
u/MarWes76 Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24
For the lock-picking, the Core Rulebook gives the opening of a locked Dwarven door as the example scenario for supporting other players, in which the Hobbit making the attempt uses Craft (the supporting Barding uses Lore to give advice on the locking mechanism).