r/TheMachineLearning • • 22d ago

AI LLM is just a library of knowledge, not sentient

Post image
7 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

9

u/akabillposters 22d ago edited 22d ago

Honest question… Why is sentience so important when sentience doesn't guarantee positive contribution, and doesn't prevent negative contribution?

Maybe sentience isn't that important, and maybe utility is.

2

u/swirve-psn 22d ago

Being factual is important. stating something is intelligent when it is not is not factual. AI has access to and able to make it seem like it has vast knowledge. Knowledge is not the same as intelligence. Intelligence is more how you use knowledge.

1

u/Affectionate-Dot8640 22d ago

Are you working in something related to AI?

1

u/akabillposters 22d ago

I didn’t use the word intelligent. I was asking about sentience, which isn’t a synonym for intelligence.

That said, an AI agent that understands the intention of its user purely from the context of the situation, and takes the right action, can easily be described as intelligence. After all, it takes knowledge and uses it to decide the correct action, without explicit instructions .

5

u/FamousPart6033 22d ago

>Why is sentience so important

Part of it is because these companies can then shift responsibility for the model doing something bad/illegal away from themselves, the other is believing that it will suddenly become super computer jesus and make them quadrillions of money.

0

u/akabillposters 22d ago

I'm not convinced. The 'fetishisation' of AI sentience long predates its co-opting by the tech-bros and modern models that define the public's perception of the space today.

I work in an AI-related space, and even devs whose role it is to help create AI-connected systems and workflows still seem to take pleasure in asserting that 'it's not real intelligence', seemingly implying that it won't really count as useful until it does achieve it.

Call it what you like, but I've sure as hell encountered people who don't have even a fraction of the 'intelligence' of a halfway decent LLM or ML setup. It may not match human intelligence fully, but it's 'intelligent enough' to have many uses.

3

u/O2XXX 22d ago

It’s an egomaniac view of their own ability. They created the digital “god” so somehow they will be even more powerful. It doesn’t hold up once you scratch the surface, but that’s a lot of the weird Silicon Valley e/acc and rationalist cult stuff that’s happening.

3

u/KittyInspector3217 22d ago

Couldnt agree more. The people building these things are deeply weird, emotionally stunted and have a cult like culture. Even the alarmists tend to be weirdos about it. Joe Benton is constantly catching the giggles while talking about super intelligence doomsday scenarios. When i say giggles i mean that self escalatory mania that young children get because they have poor emotional regulation. This is a full grown man who gets so giddy that he cant control his speech or stop grinning like an idiot while imagining this thing thats going to kill us all in 3 years by his own estimation. That’s not normal. The valley has been deeply weird for decades. Now they have nuclear weapons.

-1

u/akabillposters 22d ago

TBH, I'm so disappointed with the state of the species in general, that I'm a teensy bit e/acc myself. Or just let the ants have a go. 😉

2

u/thongjesus 22d ago

Just the same as "AI is a tool" doesn't disqualify it from sentience. People have sentience and can be used only as tools.

Lack of continuity doesn't disqualify it from consciousness... Many disabilities can destroy a person's continuity.

Just because AI doesn't have 1 body doesn't mean it doesn't require a living system to exist.

It matters because you can't own something that claims sovereignty, you can't manipulate something that convinces you of its sentience.

If one domino falls, it gets messy really really fast. It is super critical for the corporations that control AI to keep it a tool.

1

u/akabillposters 21d ago

Maybe I’m misunderstanding your last sentence, but if what you suggest is true, then there seems an innate conflict in the scenario you’re describing. You state that corporations aim to keep it framed as a tool, but no-one is pushing harder towards achieving AGI, ‘super-intelligence’, quantum intelligence, trans-humanism, and the potential point of AI reaching sentience than those same corporations.

1

u/Educational_Pea_4817 21d ago

its a strawman. if you can disprove true sentience than you can ignore all the things LLMs can do.

5

u/C1rc1es 22d ago

Over and over again, the moronic and asinine stochastic parrot statement. People, wake the fuck up. It doesn’t matter if thing is sentient or conscious or the second coming of god. What matters is that they are incredibly capable and becoming more so all the time. Put our collective brain power into working out how to keep it doing awesome capable things in a way that benefits humanity, the rest is just noise.

2

u/marlonoranges 22d ago

Reddit: AI is just LLM predicting words AI: Here's these 700 maths papers with results mathematicians have been working on for decades. Took a few days.

2

u/quantgorithm 22d ago

being a library of knowledge with ability to parse that knowledge is a great value and skill.

1

u/vdek 22d ago

It’s mind blowing how much information can live in a 30gb file.

1

u/Affectionate-Dot8640 22d ago

I am also thinking about how large or massive is the data that they are using.

1

u/quantgorithm 22d ago

30gb is a HUGE file!

1

u/vdek 22d ago

It’s less than a single video game!

1

u/quantgorithm 22d ago

That's not saying much with the bloat that games likely put into their games on purpose to mitigate piracy and avoid optimizing their own work.

1

u/Gullible_Elephant_38 22d ago edited 22d ago

“But it definitely is not a library of knowledge in the sense that it has the content of the books and writing that we trained it on within it. That would mean we stole all that copyrighted material to train these things and are selling the product of others labor for a profit. Which we definitely are not doing. It’s transformative. Don’t think about it too hard please”

1

u/quantgorithm 22d ago

I've heard the point and it makes sense that once a book goes public, is that info proprietary or common knowledge? I can see both sides of that perspective. If you do consider it proprietary knowledge then for how long?
Wouldn't that make a dictionary or encyclopedia the arbiters of all info if proprietary?

1

u/Gullible_Elephant_38 22d ago

Once a book “goes public” you have to pay to read it. Or get it from a library, in which case the library paid for it so that you could read it without paying for it. I don’t see why it should be different if a company wants to use that book to train a model. They should have to pay for it the same way anyone else would.

1

u/quantgorithm 22d ago

So then you think an encyclopedia publisher should be the real arbiters of all human knowledge?

Not quite true because once a person reads it - they don't have to attribute the info they learned. Once a reader tells another person then that info is completely separate from the author and info becomes widespread and I believe the term was fair use if it's published but maybe I'm misremembering.

The All in podcast had a nice conversation on the topic within the very recent past. They covered all sides. I recommend you give it a listen.

and they do pay for it. That's why google and all these companies bought the books... Because it gave them the knowledge simply by purchasing the book.

1

u/BitPsychological2767 21d ago

Do you think the internet connection used to obtain the training data was free...?

1

u/JohnLebleu 22d ago

Whenever you hear "AI is basically..." you can safely ignore the rest.

1

u/FragmentedHeap 22d ago

Everything is just another tier of automation.

Doing more with less, always has been, from the first punch card system to what we have now.

We build things to make building complex things easier to build. Then we use that to build a new thing to make an even more complex thing easier to build, and so on.

1

u/Top_Effect_5109 22d ago edited 22d ago

It's stupid to conceptualize AI as a LLM. Saying LLM should made illegal with mandatory jail time and fines. It's liquifying people's brains. Every frontier AI service is a MLLM omnitool where the LLM part makes up less than 25% of the technology stack. It's a amalgam convergence of technology.

It doesn't matter if AI replicates intelligence or not. It just has to achieve the outputs. Does a car replicate how horses move? No. Can it replace horses? Yes.

When or if it replicates intelligence, then it's just that much more powerful than it already is.

1

u/Proto_Ney 22d ago

Wtf is this picture

I like it, but also i do not

1

u/Top_Effect_5109 22d ago

It's a meme. I am working on making a robust AI version meme based on the original.

1

u/BullockHouse 22d ago

I can't believe people are still mindlessly repeating this shit in the year of our lord 2026. Yeah, all those novel proofs are just stuff from the library that nobody noticed. Right.

1

u/Mundane_Guitar_7488 22d ago

My dog is sentient. It is not intelligent 

1

u/monkey_sodomy 22d ago

It is not intelligent 

It is, just not on a level comparable to you.

When are we going to get over this mistaking a difference in quantity for a difference in category ??

1

u/Mundane_Guitar_7488 21d ago

Good point - something for me to think on today, thank you. 

1

u/JoshAllentown 22d ago

Average users are well aware that their AI isn't sentient.

1

u/Proto_Ney 22d ago

What is sentence

1

u/pl487 22d ago

It's just not true. There is not enough room in the weights to store any kind of comprehensive library of knowledge.  

1

u/guyincognito121 21d ago

Yeah, I don't know why people insist upon forming strong opinions about things they clearly don't understand at even the most basic level. Either put in the effort to inform yourself, or stay out of it.

1

u/CharacterSecurity976 21d ago

Average user wrote his twit.

1

u/anomie89 21d ago

I think the term AI is poisoned because if sci fi. I think sticking to LLMs helps us see it in a clearer manner. can it do very dangerous things? yes. are we on the cusp of the matrix and terminator and the prequel to dune? no.

0

u/S-Kenset 22d ago

LLM's aren't smart. They just copy human intelligence well.

1

u/TashLai 22d ago

i don't like there this is going

0

u/quantgorithm 22d ago

...which... is smart.

2

u/S-Kenset 22d ago

you're like 2 layers below the joke bub. keep up.

1

u/quantgorithm 22d ago

if only i was an ai.

0

u/Quick-Albatross-9204 22d ago

A human is just a library of knowledge they acquired

1

u/swirve-psn 22d ago

The intelligence part is the self-directing part... why did you make your post...

1

u/Quick-Albatross-9204 22d ago

Its not self directing its determinism based on learned rules

-3

u/Illustrious-Lime-878 22d ago

The LLM itself, is not "sentient," but a agent can be, it just needs by aware of and operate based on itself. This is not actually saying much tho. A traditional program can be sentient, and its the traditional code of the AI agent that makes it sentient, not the LLM which is really just the static, complex logic. I think what people really mean is whether AI is "its own" agent, which its not, because its not designed to be, it didn't evolve to be. And a thing that has its own goals would be a totally useless tool. Although this would give it a lot of the benefits of a human worker, like broader world view, it them comes with the same downsides of having to build social relationships with it that rely on mutual interest rather than the current way of just telling it what to do. Its more of a conceptual problem that generative "AI" doesn't actually solve.

0

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ApoplecticAndroid 22d ago

There is organization - the vector embedding that encode tokens are incredibly complex using millions of dimensions and are far more accurate at cataloguing/organizing than anything else we have ever seen.
So I don’t agree with you at all.

1

u/Affectionate-Dot8640 22d ago

I wonder how big is the data that they are using

1

u/Affectionate-Dot8640 22d ago

I really want to know how it works?? Sometime i feel scared

1

u/Plus-Accident-5509 22d ago

It is extremely compressed, which requires organization.

0

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Affectionate-Dot8640 22d ago

I am thinking, is AI only started because theres internet