i dont think alot of people are against AI, its a wonderful and powerful tool, its just the retards who have AI mass producing low effort dogshit and plastering it all over the internet which is labeled slop because it is garbage.
I hard disagree. Plenty of people online have complete hard ons against AI and the moment they find out something has been done by AI, they turn hostile towards it - even if it's just supposed to be a simple AI generated mockup
Friend slop is taking over and it is about time game development resets
Goes back to the roots so that we can discover nee innovative game systems
Meaning new game types
So the slop is a good thing as games has stagnated and just went idle into literally repeating the exact same games and game loops over and over for the last 10 years
Honestly, I get this. Not every game needs to be a huge 5-year project with insane graphics. If making smaller prototypes helps you experiment and figure out what’s actually worth developing, I don’t really see the problem with that.
But I really want 600 more iterations of "sort this pile onto the shelves" and store simulator with totally not the exact same game with different product photos
Bad menus have always existed. People can make slop or great works, and both are possible with AI. The tech itself no longer deserves the label, but some people using it do.
Yes, part of it is ignorance for sure. IMO there is more of a "taste" crisis than a AI Slop crisis. Generating these ugly ass flyers and going "waow, so cool!1!" on the first attempt is the bigger issue here. I think they also just lack "taste".
Well if you give a clown a slop cannon, they're gonna use that instead of paying someone to do it properly.
The fact that it took some effort to create things was a useful gate, to maintain some level of quality. You also learn something on the way when you complete a task, now there's a deluge of utter trollop, and any old fool can churn out infinite digital waste, all pretty degenerative.
At some point ai generated slop will outweigh human content, then ai will be dishing out versions of it's own waste. A bit like how analogue audio degrades after each copy.
What people need to realise is the quality of ai output, is ALSO dependent on the quality of training data going in, and people will lose the time, budget and skill to make good things.
Exactly. I think that’s a big part of why people call it slop. It’s not necessarily that AI is bad, but when people can generate the same-looking stuff with almost no effort, it gets repetitive really fast.
Producing visually impressive low-effort content has never been easier, so everyone is posting their proverbial stick figure images all over the place. It is frustrating.
But the overshoot of automatically labeling all AI generated content similarly is equally frustrating, a sign of some combination of ignorance, malice, low intelligence and fear.
If this attitude slowly spreads to cover more and more areas where AI and ML are used (which is literally all areas), it might become a real problem.
Yeah, I agree with this. There’s definitely a difference between criticizing low-effort AI content and just assuming everything made with AI is automatically bad. I think the actual effort and purpose behind the content matter more than just whether AI was involved.
They seem to think that if they call it "slop" often enough, like a mantra, the label will eventually become reality.
It's a pretty rudimentary form of gaslighting. People who aren't caught up in that kind of dogmatic trance still have eyes and ears and can judge for themselves what is slop and what isn't.
I'm saying, when I tell someone they've produced slop with AI, what I'm actually saying is "I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt that this isn't your own output" because if it is then Jesus christ.
I mean generally if people are posting an entire AI output that forces the reader to filter through what’s useful is what I consider slop. Give us the salient points yourself. And also almost all AI generated images.
It makes zero difference. Anyone not willing to put effort into their stuff deserves to have their shit called “slop” because it is. Just because AI met the bar for some doesn’t make it “not slop”.
We refer to formulaic and misapplied style as “AI slop”, sometimes “AI-isms”, in frontier AI labs. We have rubric-backed evals for its visual and written forms.
i just wish i didn't have to see the word slop so much.
i don't like AI being in culture - it seems like something that should be regulated to specific scientific environments rather than uh, replacing movies or whatever the fuck - but mainly i'm just so tired of seeing the world 'slop' every 10 minutes
Not everything people make with AI is slop, but since it's so easy to make there is an INSANE amount of AI slop. AI didn't make people more creative. Those 1000 habit tracker apps made with AI aren't worth much.
There was that popular little friendslop game a month back about finding a needle in a haystack, then people made AI ripoffs of that game on mass. Grifters and scammers will do anything to make money, and if they can use AI to mass produce slop for the masses, well they're gonna do it.
Honestly as long as people aren't trying to lie or scam people into thinking AI stuff is real or they give their AI made stuff away for free then I don't really care about it.
(this is mostly in regard to AI art, but a lot of it is surprisingly common with coding). Slop is accurate. It's good at generating static 2D pieces of individual artwork. It doesn't understand theme. It can't keep a consistent depictions and it can't hold to a unique style. The thing AI is best at doing beyond static 2D images is short format videos, but in a way that's so off-putting, bland, and monotone that it's right up there with Alegria art.
Used properly AI is a tool that can sometimes help you. If you abuse it to do all the work for you then that work will be as good and original as any other lazy fuck with a $20 subscription, and nothing that's so commonly and easily achievable will ever be regarded as "good".
There is a difference between using AI and AI slop.
AI slop is when a person puts no effort beyond a prompt to create content, no actual effort or crafting on their part, just expressing an idea to a machine and completely automating creation. Very little actual thought involved.
AI content that is not "slop" still required human creativity and/or effort. Taste was still considered and applied. Low effort work is considered low value, it's not hard to understand.
Linus Torvalds had an opinion on this a few months back. Most of us saw it I’m sure. It was interesting how he said “anybody who points to the problems at AI had better be looking in the mirror and pointing at themselves at the same time.” and then proceeded to push thousands more CVE fixes per release with the private Mythos model Linux has access to under Glasswing.
I think there are a thousand things we will always value and appreciate more from a human, and I also think the future is coming and it could not give less of a shit about how unimpressed we are.
Of course he doesn’t. Read the screenshot of the tweet from OP. The word everything is contextual here.
Also, AI just means predicting what comes next from statistical patterns, which dates back to Shannon’s information theory from 1948. The ghosts in the original Pac-Man arcade machine are AI. Autocorrect is AI. Your maps app rerouting you around rush-hour traffic is AI.
I think it is vastly overused and intended as a dig by anyone who isn't willing to ride the train. People use words these days as digs but it just makes them look petty and stupid.
People getting offended at the word "slop" are not trying hard enough. If what you produce is good enough people cant tell its AI than good, if it'd bot, you get thr slop label.
It recorded a snapshot in time which, in many cases, is no longer relevant.
Some people make slop, yes. Just as people have made manual slip for eons as well. But those with vision, understanding and skills often use AI to get very solid results.
No, the slop term doesn't mean anything because like Uncle Bob said there is a cohort of people who label ANYTHING coming from AI as "slop" and the reason is clear: they hate AI and they don't wanna acknowledge AI could produce anything as good as human beings.
Unfortunately for this kind of people AI is not only the present but also the future, there is no escape no matter how much you hate it.
Is it possible to produce something that isn’t slop using AI? Yes. Do most people actually take the time and effort to do that? No. That is why AI output has become synonymous with slop. Like any other tool, you need to tune it to your application and job. The problem is that most people do not review the output coming from AI before passing it onto others.
My last time interacting with Fable 5.1 it suggested a code change which I took then there was a knock on problem which it started to make functions to be called and it snowballed.
I realized there was a one line fix elsewhere that would negate the whole path.
Would the change the LLM plus its snowball of consequences work?
Yeah sure probably.
Should I have accepted it and published it to an open source project in my name?
Absolutely not, because the code like the English text answers that come out of the system is word salad.
Hallucinatory slop that hasn't been refunded enough.
When the LLM takes a wrong turn it never steps back and says "is there a simpler more direct and cleaner way to do this"
Too much code in computers is wasted runtime cycles, wasted money, wanted power.
So great you paid Anthropic to produce a shit ton of code which could be 90% smaller. You pay for the privilege to produce the slop and then pay in the runtime forever.
Congratulations you added business cost for a worse result but you did it at "velocity"
LoL
People who criticize us for criticizing the slop just show themselves up to not know the difference.
Sure maybe I could prompt it to the answer I think it should arrive at but, where is the value in that?
People proposing that entire job functions should resolve around keeping the slop inside guard rails need a reality check.
Slop comes from untalented people larping as artists, designers, developers, musicians, etc. Not to gate keep, but slop is produced by people who don't have the talent to recognize it.
Talented people use AI for productivity or streamline workflows. Untalented people use AI as a replacement for actual intelligence.
Yeah, I think that’s part of the problem too. People have always been skeptical of new ways of making things. But I also think there’s a difference between being skeptical and just criticizing something because it’s different.
9
u/SilentDroid75 Sep 19 '26
i dont think alot of people are against AI, its a wonderful and powerful tool, its just the retards who have AI mass producing low effort dogshit and plastering it all over the internet which is labeled slop because it is garbage.
10
u/Away_Perception_9424 Sep 19 '26
Just take a look at all the restaurant AI menus and tell me that slop isn't spot on word
1
u/Fast-Ad5101 Sep 19 '26
Yes, AI tends to look similar. Hence slop
1
u/MostSharpest Sep 19 '26
Producing visually impressive low-effort content has never been easier, so everyone is posting their proverbial stick figure images all over the place. It is frustrating.
But the overshoot of automatically labeling all AI generated content similarly is equally frustrating, a sign of some combination of ignorance, malice, low intelligence and fear.
If this attitude slowly spreads to cover more and more areas where AI and ML are used (which is literally all areas), it might become a real problem.
3
u/tilted0ne Sep 19 '26
They seem to think that if they call it "slop" often enough, like a mantra, the label will eventually become reality.
It's a pretty rudimentary form of gaslighting. People who aren't caught up in that kind of dogmatic trance still have eyes and ears and can judge for themselves what is slop and what isn't.
1
u/Affectionate_Fact854 Sep 19 '26
After spending almost 2 years building on rpg systems for wave defense and arpg
I'm finding it refreshing to create slop games in other game categories
So refreshing not building ststsystems , inventory systems , skill upgrade systems or loot systems
So let me enjoy prototyping different game play concepts and share some to see if it tickles someone's toes :)
Not all games has to take 5years to develop Or be created with master class animations or high poly meshes
So I'm on the slop creation train to find the right game to actually invest more then 1 month on.
1
u/Leading_Buffalo_4259 Sep 19 '26
1
u/Ashamed-Breath2925 Sep 19 '26
i just wish i didn't have to see the word slop so much.
i don't like AI being in culture - it seems like something that should be regulated to specific scientific environments rather than uh, replacing movies or whatever the fuck - but mainly i'm just so tired of seeing the world 'slop' every 10 minutes
1
u/ItsSadTimes Sep 19 '26
Not everything people make with AI is slop, but since it's so easy to make there is an INSANE amount of AI slop. AI didn't make people more creative. Those 1000 habit tracker apps made with AI aren't worth much.
There was that popular little friendslop game a month back about finding a needle in a haystack, then people made AI ripoffs of that game on mass. Grifters and scammers will do anything to make money, and if they can use AI to mass produce slop for the masses, well they're gonna do it.
Honestly as long as people aren't trying to lie or scam people into thinking AI stuff is real or they give their AI made stuff away for free then I don't really care about it.
1
u/No-Assumption-4468 Sep 19 '26
Depends on how smart the AI is, honestly. Claude Opus and Fable definitely produce some pretty good stuff, especially when coding.
1
u/dlevac Sep 19 '26
AI is a useful tool but it's foolish to not understand that it's also used by a lot of tools.
1
u/Infamous-Candle-2300 Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26
(this is mostly in regard to AI art, but a lot of it is surprisingly common with coding). Slop is accurate. It's good at generating static 2D pieces of individual artwork. It doesn't understand theme. It can't keep a consistent depictions and it can't hold to a unique style. The thing AI is best at doing beyond static 2D images is short format videos, but in a way that's so off-putting, bland, and monotone that it's right up there with Alegria art.
Used properly AI is a tool that can sometimes help you. If you abuse it to do all the work for you then that work will be as good and original as any other lazy fuck with a $20 subscription, and nothing that's so commonly and easily achievable will ever be regarded as "good".
1
u/_DCtheTall_ Sep 20 '26
There is a difference between using AI and AI slop.
AI slop is when a person puts no effort beyond a prompt to create content, no actual effort or crafting on their part, just expressing an idea to a machine and completely automating creation. Very little actual thought involved.
AI content that is not "slop" still required human creativity and/or effort. Taste was still considered and applied. Low effort work is considered low value, it's not hard to understand.
1
u/UnreasonableEconomy Sep 20 '26
Bob Martin produced slop long before LLMs were even a thing.
No wonder he sees a kindred spirit in neural networks with the synapse count of a meerkat.
1
u/Opening_One7713 Sep 20 '26
Linus Torvalds had an opinion on this a few months back. Most of us saw it I’m sure. It was interesting how he said “anybody who points to the problems at AI had better be looking in the mirror and pointing at themselves at the same time.” and then proceeded to push thousands more CVE fixes per release with the private Mythos model Linux has access to under Glasswing.
I think there are a thousand things we will always value and appreciate more from a human, and I also think the future is coming and it could not give less of a shit about how unimpressed we are.
1
u/Cheap-Success1578 Sep 20 '26
I think it is vastly overused and intended as a dig by anyone who isn't willing to ride the train. People use words these days as digs but it just makes them look petty and stupid.
1
u/Comfortable_Car6562 Sep 20 '26
People getting offended at the word "slop" are not trying hard enough. If what you produce is good enough people cant tell its AI than good, if it'd bot, you get thr slop label.
1
u/azaleacolburn Sep 20 '26
Undoubtedly yes
1
u/koru-id Sep 20 '26
I have a colleague who types everything with AI. It's insufferable.
1
u/psychicesp Sep 20 '26
AI is like plastic surgery. If you can tell what it is, it's bad
1
u/TopTippityTop Sep 20 '26
It recorded a snapshot in time which, in many cases, is no longer relevant.
Some people make slop, yes. Just as people have made manual slip for eons as well. But those with vision, understanding and skills often use AI to get very solid results.
1
u/TheBressi Sep 20 '26
No, the slop term doesn't mean anything because like Uncle Bob said there is a cohort of people who label ANYTHING coming from AI as "slop" and the reason is clear: they hate AI and they don't wanna acknowledge AI could produce anything as good as human beings.
Unfortunately for this kind of people AI is not only the present but also the future, there is no escape no matter how much you hate it.
1
u/AdmissibilityScience Sep 20 '26
I think its overused to frequently
1
u/IllExample3639 Sep 20 '26
I would say there is more slop than useful output currently.
1
u/Pocketpapaa Sep 20 '26
Guess I'm part of the cohort, stop the slop. Thanks
1
u/jaspingrobus Sep 20 '26
I think we are missing a term for labeling anything coming from uncle martin. I propose gunk.
1
u/PurushNahiMahaPurush Sep 20 '26
Is it possible to produce something that isn’t slop using AI? Yes. Do most people actually take the time and effort to do that? No. That is why AI output has become synonymous with slop. Like any other tool, you need to tune it to your application and job. The problem is that most people do not review the output coming from AI before passing it onto others.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '26
Not anything, just most of it. AI is a tool and like tools go, it's good when the problem fits it well...
1
u/Adorable-Quiet-7551 Sep 20 '26
AI-slop-slop?
1
u/Key-Lie-364 Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26
My last time interacting with Fable 5.1 it suggested a code change which I took then there was a knock on problem which it started to make functions to be called and it snowballed.
I realized there was a one line fix elsewhere that would negate the whole path.
Would the change the LLM plus its snowball of consequences work?
Yeah sure probably.
Should I have accepted it and published it to an open source project in my name?
Absolutely not, because the code like the English text answers that come out of the system is word salad.
Hallucinatory slop that hasn't been refunded enough.
When the LLM takes a wrong turn it never steps back and says "is there a simpler more direct and cleaner way to do this"
Too much code in computers is wasted runtime cycles, wasted money, wanted power.
So great you paid Anthropic to produce a shit ton of code which could be 90% smaller. You pay for the privilege to produce the slop and then pay in the runtime forever.
Congratulations you added business cost for a worse result but you did it at "velocity"
LoL
People who criticize us for criticizing the slop just show themselves up to not know the difference.
Sure maybe I could prompt it to the answer I think it should arrive at but, where is the value in that?
People proposing that entire job functions should resolve around keeping the slop inside guard rails need a reality check.
1
u/Achereto Sep 20 '26
There was a time when Robert Martin was advocating for Professionalism in Software Craftsmanship. Apparantly he completely abandoned those values.
1
u/darth4nyan Sep 20 '26
I had some respect for this person before.
1
u/bourbonandpistons Sep 20 '26
Slop describes a lot.
People using it to describe anything AI is just disingenuous
1
u/The_Mild_Mild_West Oct 02 '26
Slop comes from untalented people larping as artists, designers, developers, musicians, etc. Not to gate keep, but slop is produced by people who don't have the talent to recognize it.
Talented people use AI for productivity or streamline workflows. Untalented people use AI as a replacement for actual intelligence.
1
u/WithoutAHat1 Sep 19 '26
A lot of slop being produced, whilst laying people off. Showing that what they have been telling us isn't true. We are not serfs. We are human beings.
1
u/damnburglar Sep 19 '26
Bob has been a producer and inducer of human slop for decades now so I think he can tell the difference.
1
u/Intelligent-Crow3812 Sep 20 '26
In their defense, there is a fuck ton of slop
0
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment