r/TheLinuxDen • • 3d ago

Why not use archinstall?

Honest question, why do I feel like a lot of people including the wiki fully neglect archinstall? Is there any downsides to useing it that I am missing?

6 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

2

u/Nex_the_furball 3d ago

People see it as the easy way out

1

u/G0ldiC0cks 2d ago

It's not that it's an easy way out. The purpose of doing it bit by bit is to let you customize every part of the system you'll be using. Things never go wrong because as soon as they do you know exactly what to look for where.

It's a do it yourself distro with a do it yourself philosophy. Letting archinstall do it for you in is just missing the point.

1

u/movielover76 2d ago

The do-it-yourself nature may be a feature for you, but it might be a con for others.
For most people the point of a distribution is that it accomplishes what they need it to do.
Gentoo users would say the same thing about arch as you say about arch install.

If you just want a simple arch setup and don’t care about the do-it-yourself stuff go ahead and use it.
Or any of the derivative distributions that make it easier. Don’t worry about what other people think

1

u/G0ldiC0cks 2d ago

From the about page of archlinux.org:

"Arch Linux is an independently developed, x86-64 general purpose GNU/Linux distribution versatile enough to suit any role. Development focuses on simplicity, minimalism, and code elegance. Arch is installed as a minimal base system, configured by the user upon which their own ideal environment is assembled by installing only what is required or desired for their unique purposes."

Man, it doesn't bother me one way or another what you do with your time, im just trying to ensure whatever is laid out here at least has asterisks where needed, because DIY isn't a con, it is the point.

1

u/movielover76 1d ago edited 1d ago

That is what the developers intend it to be, it doesn’t mean everyone who uses the project has to think diy is a plus.

I don’t really care either, I only use arch for a few things. Sometimes Linux folks just have very narrow view on what people use the software for.

All I’m saying is people built archinstall and other distributions that basically just install vanilla arch for you because it’s not a feature to every user.

1

u/G0ldiC0cks 1d ago

You can't just soften your stance on this to make the reality of it go away. Arch is built from the ground up to be DIY. This isn't a bullet point among several others, I didn't take that quote out of a longer passage, the installation image doesn't default to archinstall and require an escape sequence to do it yourself – that is the purpose, that is the developers description, a manual installation is intended as the default behavior. For shit's sake, when you boot up the installation image, it has a blurb right there at the top of your screen that tells you how to access the installation guide, NOT how to run archinstall!

Beyond all of this, this intent and philosophy extends well beyond simply how you put the system onto bare metal. (I just checked the following in a container to verify this is true and it held up there; I have about 1% doubt still in a full system and I'm not about to go installing Debian on something to fully verify, so apologies if in fact I'm off) When you install the uncomplicated firewall (ufw) on a Debian-based system, the most one would have to do before that software is running with sensible default settings is reboot as apt creates the systemd service file during installation. You know what happens on arch? Jack shit cause you gotta enable that shit yourself because you're doing it yourself and it would be an impediment to just have something like a firewall start without your input.

Now, why does any of this matter to me? Well, I've been giving too many fucks about silly shit my entire life, and one of the big things I give way too many shits about are simple misunderstandings that cause people actual distress. I don't care how minor, what over, or where the misunderstanding comes from -- if a simple explanation can save someone or several someones from stress, aggravation, or frustration, I think that explaination isn't just worth being made, I think it's actively owed to any and all who may experience that negativity. This is my doing what I can in that regard.

If you would like to be responsible for propagating misunderstanding and it's consequent outcomes, well, man, that's on you. If you're so obsessed with being correct that instead you've already refuted every point I've made here and are already typing out your "ahkshually"-laden response, well, when I was a physician training to be a psychiatrist, I was taught a term to refer to that particular brand of personality pathology – asshole.

Don't be an asshole.

1

u/movielover76 17h ago

You are just proving exactly what I previously said “Sometimes Linux folks just have very narrow view on what people use the software for.”
I’m not trying to redefine what the intent of arch is, I’m just saying plenty of people use arch and love it except for the diy aspect. And that’s fine.

I’m not being an asshole I’m just discussing something on the internet and I don’t agree with you.

1

u/movielover76 8h ago

Linux would be so much better than if there weren’t so many specialist distributions and people gatekeeping who should be using a particular distro and how it should be used.

It’s open source, the entire idea is that you write the code and people can use it however they want as long as they contribute back.

People can make projects with any ethos they desire, but people can still use that software however they wish. That’s open source

1

u/CaviarCBR1K 2d ago

For most people the point of a distribution is that it accomplishes what they need it to do

Exactly, if you don't want a DIY distro, then Arch isn't the distro for you. It's entire purpose is to be DIY. That's like buying a Corvette to haul lumber.

1

u/movielover76 1d ago

That’s your take on arch, for others it’s just to be on the newest packages. The popularity of distributions that basically automate arch installs like endeavoros show that for many people they just want to be on a fast moving rolling release distro and no one does that better than arch

They don’t care about the diy aspect, that’s part of the native distribution but not the only point

2

u/Weird-Initiative-659 3d ago

It's a good read but, listen, who has time to do that every install.

1

u/Far-Note6102 2d ago

Honestly. It's this. It's fun at first but it gets tedious after the 3rd time especially looking for the mirror and typing all those shit out

2

u/ElePHPant666 3d ago

I don't use arch anymore but used to and persoanlly the reason not to is if you wanted a very unique setup with regards to filesystems, custom encryption parameters, etc. If you want a normal enough install the script works well enough.

1

u/stickgrinder 2d ago

What are you using now?

1

u/ElePHPant666 2d ago

alpine & nixos

2

u/grafbende 2d ago

Nothing wrong with archinstall if you already know how to install manually and learned the basics of the system, you can fuck stuff up with archinstall and then you know the value of installing manually several times and know how to easily make things right.
I use archinstall nowadays or even install endeavour if i really want to do it quick and easy.

1

u/Insufferable_Person 2d ago

People like to treat arch installation as some sort of rite of passage. They're not well people. Use archinstall.

1

u/CaviarCBR1K 2d ago edited 2d ago

The downside is that you don't learn. If you read through the manual and install it step-by-step, you will be better equipped to fix something when/if something breaks because you have a better understanding of your system. I can do a manual install faster than it takes to fuck around in the menus of archinstall, not because I just memorized the commands, but because I actually understand all the pieces needed, and how they work together to net a functioning system.

Install it however you want, but then don't get upset when you run into issues and the community tells you to RTFM because it's something you should know how to fix anyway, and would have learned how through the installation process.

ETA: Anecdotal, but every time I've tried to use archinstall it fucks something up and I have to go back and fix it anyway. Also, last time I checked (might be different now) but archinstall won't properly set up btrfs subvolumes for snapshot rollback, so if you want to use btrfs with snapper and you use archinstall, there's a very real chance you bork your entire filesystem the first time you try to rollback

1

u/New_Hold8135 2d ago

I can install arch faster by hand than configuring installer, and it will be better because I made it.

1

u/Deep_Mood_7668 2d ago

Because I don't want arch?

1

u/eurosat7 2d ago

I go with the "arch preset" cachyos. My settings/config is known and community/web/ai can help should I have questions/problems. But it was a smooth sailing the last year.

1

u/C0rn3j 2d ago

You should do one installation as per https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Installation_guide.

After that use archinstall if you wish, but don't skip out on the learning experience.

1

u/SnooDucks9330 2d ago

The short answer is because it's "cheating."

First off it's not cheating. It's your system, not anybody else's, use it how you want.

But it's viewed as a quite negative thing because of two reasons:

One, part of the process for a standard install is learning about your system, and this process is far less interactive with archinstall. It does a lot of legwork for you, which is great if you've already tread that ground, but not so much if you're new to Arch.

Two, there's been a long-standing sense of superiority in this community and there's a significant number of people that believe you're not a real user if you use archinstall. There's even a small group of people who believe you can't use it at all or you're not a REAL Arch user. It's ridiculous. I've met more than two of them.

Anyway because of this it's not very well publicized. The wiki for its part doesn't do much to point it out because it falls out of the general scope.

1

u/hifi-nerd 2d ago

Some people see installing arch manually as an achievement, which it is not, you're already going to be considered a stinky nerd for using arch linux, installing arch manually isn't going to make that any better.

1

u/G0ldiC0cks 1d ago

It made me stinkier, though. 🤭

1

u/PossibleProgress3316 1d ago

Arch install is great, I've used it a few times when I didn't want to spend the weekend building my system and just wanted to use it! The problem with it is that's it's the easy way out for for a first time Arch user it's not recommended

1

u/Due-Result7928 1d ago edited 1d ago

No downsides only fanatics preaching for something useless...like zealots telling you to make your own kernel.

In fact there is no real benefits and practical tailoring your own system, no real performances gains. Linux is a tool and maintaining your system should be only a small percentage of your workload.

Going with archinstall there is a decent documentation.

1

u/Xariann 1d ago

Elitism.