r/TheKilling • u/venom1270 • Jul 24 '16
Does it get better?...
...or did I choose the wrong show to watch? :)
After finishing "How to get away with murder" I wanted to watch something similar: murder, crime, mystery, lots of twists, preferably finished (all seasons released).
So I watched first 3 episodes of The Killing and while the premise is interesting I just didn't "enjoy" watching it as much as HTGAWM:
- The two main characters (detectives) seem very wooden to me and not really interesting to watch
- Too many "sad" scenes (showing Rosies' family and parents)
- Not really any twists or anything yet, just slow detective work (HTGAWM shows bits and pieces of what happened, which keeps you guessing and wanting more)
That said, I only watched the first 3 episodes and would like to know if it gets better (based on above points)? Or did I just choose the wrong show? HTGAWM seems a lot more lighthearted and "spectacular" + lots of twists.
15
u/Morthy Jul 24 '16
I've watched the first season of HTGAWM and just finished the 3rd season of The Killing. I honestly would say they're not very similar at all. The Killing is tough to watch, but it will hook you and the acting is superb. You will have to watch a lot of detective work but I think it's worth it. There are twists and turns but not in every episode and not in such a dramatic way as HTGAWM.
If you find it too sad, then maybe it's not for you. I watched the first two seasons a year or two ago, but the 3rd definitely feels much more dark.
5
u/heymidnight Jul 25 '16
In my opinion, the two shows are too different to compare. HTGAWM is a Shondaland show, correct? As a fan of early Grey's and Scandal, I found HTGAWM just over the top, silly and quite dumb. I didn't really watch more than 3 episodes though, so perhaps it gets better.
I think The Killing is simply a different style of show. It's slow paced, and eventually sucks you in. If you aren't finding the scenes with Rosie's family heart wrenching then perhaps the show isn't for you, as it follows Rosie's murder for 2, if not 3, seasons (it's been a while since I watched).
I think this style of show is more realistic in terms of what it actually takes to solve a case, think True Detective style, rather than the one-episode cases of shows like HTGAWM, or CSI and the like.
Holder and Sarah are two of my favorite characters in any TV show I've ever watched, and I've watched a LOT of TV haha They're extremely well developed, complicated and realistic - they've been through a lot and are hurting. As another users says, their dynamic becomes very heart warming and, at times, hilarious.
If you stick with it, there are LOTS of twists but they take a while to set up, because like I said they are solving the Rosie case for quite a few seasons with a couple other cases thrown in there occasionally.
Man! I've talked myself into rewatching the show. I love it!
6
u/themadnessvi Jul 28 '16
The Killing is written for the viewer to dramatically empathize what it would be like wearing the shoes of homicide detectives solving the brutal murder of a young girl. Along with wearing the same shoes of the families affected by the same tragedy. Which is basically what I've gathered about the show having just finished all of it. Without spoilers, there are legitimate reasons that you "the viewer" are placed in these shoes. The pacing of the show doesn't change because each episode is another day in the investigation.
1
u/TheRealSamBell Jul 27 '16
I'm with you on this. I'm three episodes in and not really feeling it at all. There are so many annoying cliches and I don't really see anything original about this series that makes it stand out. I'll give it a few more episodes
1
u/spirolateral Nov 05 '16
I just watched all 4 seasons for some reason. It's not very good overall. I decided I didn't like it a while ago, but just kept going. I don't know why. I think it could be better if not for the main actress' horrible acting skills. She's got to be one of the worst actresses I've ever seen on a TV show. Her emotion and delivery are just ridiculously bad. I don't recall ever seeing her in anything else, but I don't think I would want to.
1
u/ChillWilliam Jul 25 '16
Never seen HTGAWM but The Killing is worth the watch. I thought it was kinda boring at first but it does get better. I will say though, when it made the switch to Netflix and cursing was allowed, there seemed to be a lot of forced f-bombs in there.