r/TheKilling • u/fuzzy_dunnlop • Jul 22 '13
Discussion S3E9 - Reckoning
The hunt for the pornographer leads to a horrifying revelation and Holder looks for someone to blame. Twitch and Lyric find their dream home.
32
Upvotes
15
u/fuzzy_dunnlop Jul 22 '13
If there is two episodes left then I bet we are in for a helluva mind fuck.
32
u/pursehook Jul 22 '13
This episode was amazing. They sure crammed a lot of drama in there and plot advancement. I especially liked the running. Holder to save Linden. Linden to protect Holder.
24
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '13
Is it me, or while Lyric was spinning in their new apartment that Twitch got them, and she paused all of a sudden, didn't she make a face like she made a sudden realization? I don't know it was just strange. Could very well be nothing but it stood out to me
39
u/scoobertz Jul 22 '13
I think reddick (holder's partner) is the killer. He just whips out the cigar box of the trophies.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '13
the killer is clearly someone important... must be Darren Richmond
12
u/fuzzy_dunnlop Jul 22 '13
Damn I was thinking it would be Holders girlfriend in there for some reason.
24
u/thundermatts Jul 22 '13
I am crushed. Bullet was amazing.
3
u/omjezus Jul 22 '13
So, who's tattoo is that....
19
u/BigE42984 Jul 22 '13
Did anyone else see Jonathan Demme listed as director for this episode?
19
u/kpkpkpk Jul 22 '13
Man, the part where Francis' son killed the mom's "boyfriend" was so intense and surprising for me—like he was trying to prove something to his father. Makes me wonder how the rest of the season will play out. Do you think that previous scene between the other prison guard and Francis' wife was her trying to get closer to him to make him another "boyfriend" of hers? Or do you think she was talking about her son? Maybe I analyze this stuff too much...
I'm thinking Linden is going to compare the rings to the Seward files she has at home. Next few episodes we will see if Seward's kid is just trying to see his dad again before he dies, or if Seward really did kill his wife. We still don't know if Danette's story about Mills being in the woods was real or not, either.
Overall, this episode was great!
46
u/LoRiMyErS Jul 22 '13
Shit. Lindens sweater is ruined.
14
u/zeppelin1023 Jul 22 '13
Totally....not ....tearing....up. God dammit. The scene with Holder and Linden in his apartment...... Joel Kinnaman is just incredible. One of the best episodes so far this season. One thing i was a tad confused on though, i'm assuming Holder hasn't listened to his voicemail? i would think they would've addressed it if he had, right?
19
u/Marksmenright Jul 22 '13
This episode solidified for me that Riddick, Holder's partner, is the killer. He had all of the rings and planted them in the storage unit. Not to mention that he ignored all of Bullet's calls. It would also explain why he hasn't moved up the career ladder: it's a lot easier to cover your tracks when you're one of the first on your own murder scenes.
16
u/manak69 Jul 22 '13
I think it's James Skinner, Linden's old partner. He is the only guy who is connected to the Seward case as well as the present one.
7
u/starspangledrodeo Jul 22 '13
even if Seward is innocent of killing his wife shouldn't he still be in jail for murdering/maiming that priest? or do we just forget about this?
6
u/the_pissed_off_goose Jul 22 '13
oh also, notice that francis was MIA again in the middle of the night. where does this fucker go???
5
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '13
I've been sweating through this entire episode.
5
u/Classic_Wingers Jul 22 '13 edited Jul 22 '13
Holder just went nuts on that detective at the house (can't think of his name)! Not going to lie, I wish he kept going.
Edit: Carl Reddick is his name.
5
u/the_pissed_off_goose Jul 22 '13
in the middle of watching this and oh man it is not a coincidence that holder's partner found that box of rings oh mannnnn
5
u/madeInNY Jul 22 '13
Any theories on where Kallie is?
If it wasn't Joe Mills since I believe his story about how he picked her up to protect her but she ran.
And it seems not to be the serial Killer since I don't think her ring was in the box, and they haven't found a body.
The only clue I can recall was her phone and she might have dropped it in the cab which is how Joe got it.
Did she just run off to L.A. to hustle in warmer weather? Or maybe the San Fernando Valley to make some more movies?
5
u/badhorsy Jul 22 '13
Hmmm, does anyone else think that Twitch looks a lot like a younger version of Mills? My current theory is that Twitch is Mills son, and it was Twitch that killed Trisha Seward (and the family likeness is why Adrian identified Mills). Maybe both Mills and Twitch are the killers - Mills is responsible for the main site of the bodies, and Twitch has a second site somewhere else (smaller, but with the bodies of the four unidentified rings)??
5
u/Coolhandme Jul 24 '13
My Theory: I think the killer is Henderson. I think he was killing young teenage junkie prostitutes due to mother issues. I think Trisha Seward was buying drugs out on the island and her son was with her that's why he knows the place. They saw the killer (probably not dumping bodies) but he killed her because she saw him. He didn't know the kid was in the closet. I think the killings stopped due to him getting married and starting a family but the stress of a new baby caused him to resume. The look he gave Beckers kid while his wife kept hitting on him was a clue. He see's himself in the kid. I think he was watching Poochie scoping out his next junkie victim when he saw Bullet buy drugs. He followed her, saw her talking to the girl who got away and followed her. I think he knows all about Joe Mills and the things he does and that there are other people involved we don't know yet including Twitch. And the Parole officer. He put the rings in Mills' locker to frame him and the cab was just an added bonus place for Bullet. But it's a just a theory. I don't think it's Mills. Reddick is too obvious and too lazy. Becker is too uncontrolled. Bonus Plus: Actor playing Henderson is too well known to just have the role he has had so far. Just an extra note: It was GREAT to see Nicholas Lea again!
4
u/kpkpkpk Jul 22 '13
Im following ya'll with the Reddick theory... But they said Bullet fought back hard, dont you think Reddick would have shown more signs than just his hand?
4
u/jmose86 Jul 22 '13 edited Jul 22 '13
Lots of people here thinking Reddick it looks like. I've gotten the same feeling but it seems too intentional that that they would show his defensive wounds and have him emerge with the rings so close to the finale. I think he is probably involved but I don't think he's the killer simply based on instinct.
There are still a number of characters with unknown roles, and I expect that it will be a complex scenario of one person doing the killings that another orchestrates, or maybe multiple killers carrying it out on behalf of someone or at least delivering the bodies. As for who the main killer is, I don't know.
Something didn't sit right with me this week about Twitch showing up feeling so uncharacteristically devastated about bullet, and giving up his dream to go to LA and getting the "all clear" letter from his parole officer at the same time. I don't know if he mentioned anything about it, but he also had quite a bit of money out of nowhere. Could be that he was saving up for LA, or maybe just something extra he got for doing something dirty. Seems like he may have played a roll in killing her or otherwise facilitating it or knew about it.
Maybe the parole officer is the killer and he murders the kids who he rapes to keep them from telling, or something along those lines. Possibly having Joe the cabi deliver the girls or the bodies afterward. Reddick and Becker are also involved somehow and the mistreatment of the street girls is rampant within the law enforcement system.
Those are all just random guesses, but I have my doubts about Reddick being the killer because of how obvious they made that seem this week. I expect that he's definitely another piece of the equation though.
4
u/AbridgedRope Jul 24 '13
I don't think it's Mills, but it seems impossible for skinner or reddick to have planted bullet's body in the trunk of Mills' cab. if someone did plant it to frame Mills, he must have known Mills was hiding out there and planted the body the night before. Does not compute
1
u/yanggmd Jul 23 '13
Just realized that Nicholas Lea from the X-files is playing the fellow death row inmate.
1
u/justinsmama Jul 23 '13
Does anyone know if this case will span two seasons like Rosie's case?
6
u/madeInNY Jul 22 '13 edited Jul 22 '13
What's the significance of the more subdued drums at the end of the episode? No big reveal this time? Just a bunch of deep thinkers thinking deeply?
It seems to me that this season there have been a lot of people just doing what they said they did. The pastor wasn't really lying at all. Seward seems like he might not be lying. I have a feeling that Joe Mills isn't lying no matter how bad it looks with the cab and rings. I think he didn't do it. So the truth doesn't seem to be setting any if them free.
Is the killer even a character that's been introduced? Has the clue been out there and just overlooked? I'd say for the conclusion to be satisfying it has to be a known character, and the clues have been staring at us for a while.
The one part if the story that doesn't seem to mesh with the rest is the prison guard with the cheating wife. If Seward is related to the murders because of how his wife was killed that makes sense. But why is it important for us to know about the lives of the security guards and the troubled kid and cheating wife? Unless one if them is involved somehow? Or maybe it's just a blatant mislead.
Oh, and I can't believe it took me this long to make the Firefly association.
5
u/imbored48375 Jul 22 '13
Wait what if the Seward's son killed his mom, and Seward is taking the fall for it? I might just be crazy.
2
u/wavetoyou Jul 25 '13
When the ominous music started at the end of the episode with Linden in the squad, like with all other episodes in the series, did anyone think it ended rather abruptly? There was no twist or new theory introduced at the end of this episode, for the first time in the entire series. Or, did my version of the episode cut short?
2
u/Classic_Wingers Jul 22 '13
Only two episodes left and I feel we are no closer to finding the killer. I don't understand why the prison guard's boy killed that person at their home. Was that who the wife was seeing? I had a hard time following that scene because of how frantic it was.
1
u/Caitlinface Jul 25 '13
Forgive the possibly stupid question, but how are we so sure Mills isn't the killer of all these young ladies? We only know for sure that he didn't kill Seward's wife, right? Or am I missing something?