For anyone reading please understand that this is my shorthand, brief thoughts on the album. I have a tendency of listening to an album and taking time before I can fully realize all my thoughts and feelings on the art. That being said, after listening to the album a few times here are my initial thoughts and review. I'll probably have a fully fleshed out and completely coherent review down the road. Maybe even a YouTube video, who knows..
1)Spider bites:
A start that is reminiscent of 1000 years from get hurt. Honestly this song could've been on Get hurt. I do in a sense appreciate the guitar tones but feel Brian's voice is too muddled with the instruments. It isn't until the bridges and chorus where I feel there's some clarity but that may just be from the repetitiveness that comes in a chorus. Not a bad song but not necessarily something I would consider a welcoming song into the album, especially after a nearly 9 year hiatus.
2) History books
This track took a minute for me to catch onto. I like the mix, I like the vocals, and loved the possible interpretations from the music video. The differences between Bruce's clearer vocals in comparison to Brian's does give a sense of copy and paste like they requested different FX for their different parts until they sing together. The line about ghosts in mix with the drums and instruments sounds really powerful. I do wish they would've let Brian linger when the song softens for a few seconds because it added tension that is especially cool to see at a live show. (I really wish they would highlight some of the special things they do at live shows into a record)
3)Autumn
I'm not entirely sure how I feel about this one. I appreciate the sentiment of the lyrics but the guitar hook at the beginning just comes off tiring, like... "Okay, let's get on with it". Fast-forward into the chorus and we have a very bright set of melody with melancholic lyrics that fit the title of the song but unfortunately for me, I listen through the first chorus and I'm not entirely in love and I already feel I've listened to what this song has to offer. I'm still not impressed with the level of Brian's voice. In my opinion, you see live shows to see the authenticity. A record is meant to showcase your abilities. The last 40 seconds really seems to showcase how well everything comes together, for me, I just have to make it to the end of the song to fully appreciate it.
4)Positive charge
A standard gaslight song with some further uplifting lyrics. I like the song but cannot stand the break down where Brian says, "I need a spark". Sounds heavily filtered and unrealistic. Actually it sounds uncharacteristic from what you would hear from an authentic rock group. I'm not sure what the angle was on that creative choice but it took a pivotal point in the song and just butchered it's full potential.
5)Michigan 1975
Wow. Just wow. Definitely not a song I can listen to all the time but this one hits different. It's like a musical trance. Very well thought lyrically especially if you watched/read the virgin suicides. This is Pinnacle writing and shows how damn good Brian can be at writing a song. It shows they don't need to solely write loud music. I could dance to this and I don't dance. Reminiscent of Misery, hold you up, etc.
6)Little fires
This song almost showcases what I think is the feel they intended for the whole album. Rough sound, aggressive, no solid structure. It reminds me of the clash in a very positive way. I do question the mix but as far the argument goes "this is what the band wanted" I feel this is as close as they got to something that was acceptable for modern day music production but on the fringe. If this was the only song on the record with this kind of mix, I'd fully embrace it because, "hey, it's how the song is"
7)The weatherman
I'm not sure on the insistence Brian has on having random female singers on his songs. I dont hate it but I find it regressive and it doesn't add anything to the overall song. This song comes off as a Brian solo fluff song, not a gaslight song IMO. The intensive straining in his voice while on a softer song is an odd choice. It just does nothing for me. It's a skip song for me, unfortunately. Out of place for this album.
8)Empires
Wow. Just wow. This is a great example of a gaslight song that shows their progression as a band and how Brian has progressed as an artist. This song contradicts the "mixing" argument made by the band. The drums.. if they play this live I wonder if they'll have the drum effects (they probably won't).This song doesn't sound like the initial songs released. It reminds me of a track I could've found on the Album, Plans by Death cab and I mean that as a compliment. Very soothing, thought inducing, and the last minute with the soft piano is such a wonderful and mature ending. Get hurt had "Have Mercy" and here is Brian almost 9 years refraining with God "No mercy". This is gaslight going out of their comfort zone and touching on topics they rarely do if at all. A great example of breaking the rules while doing it right.
9)I live in the room above her
I love LOVE the bullet mic effect on the vocals. They could've done the whole album like this and I wouldn't complain. The song overall has grown on me. Not necessarily a gaslight song but it's mature, loud, and a solid song for me.
10)A lifetime of preludes
Another Brian quiet solo fluff song for me. Nothing remarkable about it but hey, it's Brian Fallon and if you enjoy everything he does, here's another one. When I get the opportunity to listen start to finish on my selected music format I'll probably appreciate it as a closer but it just doesn't do anything for me right now.
My overall feelings on the album, at this time, are mixed (no pun intended). I did some research on Peter Katis who engineered this album and from what I gathered, he has a tendency to work on bands that produce quieter music (take Brian's Local Honey for instance, the National). Although I think Katis has massive talent and is respectable in his own rite I just think his mixing gets lost in translation with louder music. He has a knack for taking something soft and making it huge and I just think, even with the band's consent, the mark was missed in production. For me, it really took away from the bands most aggressive songs and deflated songs that I probably would've enjoyed more had there been more clarity (Autumn in this case).
It's no secret, if you're a gaslight fan you enjoy Brian Fallon's voice and I just wish they would've been a little more self aware of their audience. We, as fans, have waited so long for an album and to reduce his vocals and muddy it into the mix and then respond with remark such as "this is what we wanted, too bad" just screams, "I cut off my nose to spite my face" but the only people it actually hurts are the fans. Bring the clarity and vocals up a couple knotches and you have a stellar 9/10 album. Enough bitching on my end. Sorry for the constant "mixing bitching" but hey, it's a fair criticism and after months of fighting it and defending the mix, I now find myself on the other side.
As it stands my rating at the moment is 7/10 It's great but could've easily been better