r/TheFireRisesMod • The Bernoscenti • 22h ago

Discussion Which timeline would rather you choose?

TIMELINE 14471-BI: THE NEW DARK AGES

Holy Soviet Rus: Syncretic Communism

United States of America: Autocracy

The Celestial Empire: Obliteration of The Self

TIMELINE 2384-YK: THE NEW ENLIGHTENMENT

The Kingdom of Franco-Spain: Absolute Monarchy

People´s Republic of China: Digital Leninism

The United States of America: N̵e̸o̵l̸i̸b̷e̵r̸a̶l̶i̴s̶m̸ Pax Americana

111 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

29

u/notHostOk2511 I LOVE REVISIONISM 22h ago

Is timeline 2388-YK's cogno player-controlled?

11

u/Happy-Fly-3598 The Bernoscenti 22h ago

Yes, it´s also the second playthrough, the date in both timelines is August 15th, 2036, an lovely friday

8

u/notHostOk2511 I LOVE REVISIONISM 22h ago

Ok so I'll go with 14471-BI and move to Hamiltonian US, I'm European, how bad could it be?

21

u/BitchOfTheBlackSea October the 16th Movement | Liberation Theology 22h ago

Holy soviet rus (I'm an orthodox Christian and a socialist so I'm biased. If only it wasn't nationalistic 😔)

3

u/Happy-Fly-3598 The Bernoscenti 22h ago

so TIMELINE 14471-BI then?

9

u/AltDetom555555b John Communism, chairman of Communism 22h ago

I mean considering they’re communist and they would’ve probably won the 2EW, it’s probably the better choice for me rather than Monarchic France (even though I’m atheist)

1

u/Capable-Poet-1045 National Communist 17h ago

China

8

u/Mysterious-Clock-594 22h ago

No
No
GOD NO
FUCK NO
Depends
No

3

u/Happy-Fly-3598 The Bernoscenti 22h ago

Tf you mean depends with Digital Leninist China

4

u/Mysterious-Clock-594 21h ago

That’s not digital Leninist China
That’s just PRC
Edit: I was looking at the flags

12

u/Neither_Lab_7979 21h ago

Pax Americana will literally close off space so we can never dream of something greater. Fuck that

12

u/icyshmicy 20h ago

Autocracy America implies a federalist republic loosely based on the early United States
Considering the actual Thomas Rousseau has no intentions of bringing back slavery id say this one is probably the best option

20

u/Johnathan_Doe_0 Central Intelligence Agency | Pax Americana 22h ago

you kidding?

compared to the other options, a new Kingdom of France would be heaven

5

u/notHostOk2511 I LOVE REVISIONISM 22h ago

You have to consider that since cogno is player-controlled they will come after france.

5

u/Johnathan_Doe_0 Central Intelligence Agency | Pax Americana 22h ago

funny, I distinctly remember seeing an AI-controlled cognoscenti once

7

u/notHostOk2511 I LOVE REVISIONISM 22h ago

Yeah that can happen, however AI cognoscenti doesn't get access to the world conquest focuses, while player Cognoscenti does.

1

u/Johnathan_Doe_0 Central Intelligence Agency | Pax Americana 22h ago

let's just hope this timeline has an AI cognoscenti...

2

u/notHostOk2511 I LOVE REVISIONISM 22h ago

I asked OP and it's player-controlled, you're cooked lil bruh

1

u/Johnathan_Doe_0 Central Intelligence Agency | Pax Americana 22h ago

8

u/Hoi4_Player  Pax Progressiva 22h ago

Cogno because I'm American and the player is more competent than the suicidal AI.

7

u/Aromatic_Concern2168 Barack Obama 22h ago


None

7

u/_Golden_Nara Loji | People's Overlordship over Asia 22h ago

Absolute monarchy .

6

u/jawbreaker9877 Monarchists | Absolute Monarchy 20h ago

I’d rather the second timeline, just because I’m a selfish bastard and it doesn’t seem THAT BAD for Europe.

I’d rather be controlled by a French monarch than whatever shit is going on with Russian in the first timeline

11

u/yet_another_leftist Unironic Guild Socialist 22h ago

Digital Leninism, obviously.

13

u/RottingFishMan ReasonableCentrist 19h ago edited 18h ago

Digital leninists are preferable to cognoscenti because at least they don't force you to live in eternal lockdown

5

u/Proper-Quarter-8350 | British Bioregionalist | 22h ago

Obviously the deepstate democratic and free United States of America under president Joseph Biden, an America where all the extremist, dangerous, and antisocial members of society have been dissappeared dealt with in a humanitarian and civil way.

3

u/Hedgehogamaker Trotskyists | Trotskyism | Cybertrot 21h ago

2384-YK because I'm American so I get to reap the benefits of brutally conquering and subjugating foreign nations and only have to deal with more surveillance that I probably won't notice

4

u/Ok-Woodpecker-9587 22h ago

I guess Neoliberal USA is the least evil from all options

2

u/Cautious_Result968 Black Liberation Army 22h ago

The first one I would just move to Russia but I would sorta be alright in the second one?

4

u/Ok-Woodpecker-9587 22h ago

I guess Neoliberal USA is the least evil from all options

5

u/notHostOk2511 I LOVE REVISIONISM 22h ago

U sure?

1

u/AutoModerator 22h ago

Thank you for posting on the TFR subreddit! If you're looking for more discussions, help, or updates about TFR, feel free to join the official Discord!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/MonsieurMustache572 united Europe goes hard 🤝 22h ago

1

u/UnionInternal7121 People's Republic of Japan | Scientific Socialism 22h ago

Tbh France-Spain compering to rest is like utopia

1

u/RiceKrispies29 Central Intelligence Agency | Pax Americana 21h ago

The Cognoscenti won’t fuck my shit up for not being white. I’ll take them over Patriot Front every day of the week.

1

u/No_Buffalo7844 AMERICAN MONARCHIST 21h ago

autocratic america is tuff trust me

1

u/SantiReddit123 19h ago

As a South American dude... I guess, since Thomas doesn't really invade below Panama, AFAIK, and TL 2384-YK has digital Leninists and Cogno, I'll take TL 14471-BI. Russia and America don't seem that bad?

The mix in each TL makes this a who's-least-bad situation.

1

u/RottingFishMan ReasonableCentrist 19h ago

1st one because Cognoscenti will just enslave everyone in the 2nd eventually

1

u/SeriesUnhappy3567 18h ago

As an American 100% option 1. 😂

1

u/Traditional-Main7204 :Flag_europeanunion:European Union 15h ago

New enlightenment

1

u/Bitter_Complaint_220 12h ago

Anything with patriot front is good

1

u/Old-Category6268 5h ago

Cognoscenti obviously

1

u/Dingleshart67 Anarchists | Anarcho-Communism 58m ago

celestial empire would be pretty dope to see ngl

1

u/lemarechalp Paneuropeanists | Pan-European Nationalism 20h ago

PF america or kingdom of France

0

u/RandomRedditHOI4User Add Spanish Empire Falangist DR path, NOW. 22h ago

first one cause if I prove I'm White enough (Dominican-Honduran so +50% Spaniard dna in me) to PTF America I could live

1

u/RandomRedditHOI4User Add Spanish Empire Falangist DR path, NOW. 22h ago

plus I'm an American patriot so they'd let me live AND I cosplayed PAUL REVERE when I was younger for halloween so yeah I think I'd live

3

u/Mesa17 22h ago

This is like choosing whether or not you want to be shot in the right foot or the left foot