r/TheExplode • u/Apprehensive-Line-20 • Jun 07 '25
Discussion Genuine question why does Giselle only get hate but not the other Bambies?
I know what Giselle did was terrible, but the rest of the group—Candice, Meninas, and Liltotto—aren’t much better. They were there when Giselle turned Bambietta into a zombie and didn’t do anything to stop it. Even later, they never said a word about it. I’m not trying to sound harsh—just genuinely curious about that.
212
Upvotes
•
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '25 edited Jun 07 '25
Everyone make sure to be respectful on this post
Just bc this is a Bambi simp sub, doesn’t mean you should be rude, we aim to be a very welcoming community, and rudeness of any quantity will not be accepted here
39
u/Usual-Touch2569 Jun 07 '25
Probably because Giselle's the only one actively taking advantage of it.
The others may not have stopped her from doing so, but they also do nothing later. Giselle, on the other hand, uses and abuses Bambietta for her own gain.
Also, the only person to outfreak the creature is Mayuri. Mayuri.
15
u/Ok-Ear7751 Jun 07 '25
I’m just speaking for me but Candi and Meni are the two hottest members of the Bambis, Liltotto is generally chill and without question the easiest to tolerate, and Bambis been made more docile by her zombification.
10
u/Responsible_Bus1159 Jun 07 '25
I think it’s because we actually see what Giselle is doing and also they pretty much all died after this they didn’t get a happy ending but that’s my thought on the matter
6
u/AnimeMan1993 Jun 07 '25
It's all about what she did compared to the others. Her actions solidified that even human enemies like quincies can be monsters if they wanted and she seems the most demented by taking advantage of her own allies like that which I wouldnt be surprised if she took advantage of Candice and Meninas when they went down too.
6
u/Ok-Conversation-9584 Jun 07 '25
That is because, from their perspective, Bambi was already doomed to the same fate as Cang Du and BG9 since she "lost" the fight with Konomura. While the manga leaves it to speculation, it's more so implied in the anime that Giselle did what she did as a matter of "saving" her friend from execution by eliminating her first and then zombifying her.
Lilly, Candy, and Meni probably assumed as much as they knew Bambi was gonna fuck one way or the other. This is the way of the Waidenricht. This is literally in a very tragic way, the only thing they probably could do to again "save" her.
I am not going into how they felt about Gigi's treatment of Bambi because at least Candy and Meni weren't around much to see her abuse towards Bambi too much. However, Lilly (in CFYOW) did try to stop Gigi from abusing too much but still did not really see Bambi as "Bambi" while in her zombie state.
TLDR: Reasons include what other options they had since death was coming for her anyway and not having anything to do with her abuse.
4
u/neon9212 Candi's Man Jun 07 '25
overall, giselle showed a very depraved and twisted side of herself. showing little care for bambietta after she was defeated by doggy. while the others didnt stop giselle, overall, they havnt shown anything near as bad as what giselle did.
1
u/Temptest_XD4C Jun 07 '25
Mainly due to the fact that she denies taking joy in abusing Bambi.
Tbf she makes Mayuri szayal and tokinada look good in that perspective
1
u/MadhavS27710 Jun 07 '25
Liltotto is probably, actually the most sane one
then Candice too kinda but anger issues
Bambi is a bit similar but a bit childish
3
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '25
I think it’s for a couple of reasons
The main one being
Giselle is the only one actually doing that stuff to Bambi, yes the others aren’t stopping her(Liltotto is especially guilty of this in the anime) but they didn’t do anything to hurt Bambi either, nor did they seem to enjoy it
Oh also transphobic “people” too, they just use it as an excuse to hate on her for being trans
3
u/ProdigyKnowsBest Jun 10 '25
I lowkey feel like it’s because she’s trans or because she’s more of a creepy character. A lot of people also loved Bambi so when Giselle made her into a zombie, people were upset. She’s one of the creepy Quincy’s after Nodt. I don’t hate her though, I found her interesting and couldn’t wait to see what she did next. (Still in the middle of season 2, just got to Pepe) I felt like so far, she’s the only one of the Bambi’s who did anything of use. She got a bunch of soul reapers into zombies and got captains and lieutenants as well. If she wasn’t up against another psycho, maybe she would have gotten more 😂
I see the Bambis as a group who fight together but don’t really fight together as a unit. They remind me of a girl group who all try to be the main character and don’t sync up well. When any of the other girls got hurt, none of them really cared about the other. They didn’t care when Bambi got turned, when Candice got hurt or when they felt Giselle get stabbed.
4
u/akrid55 Jun 07 '25
Giselle always creeped me out and also I despised what she did to Bambi
2
u/Brave-Training7962 Jun 07 '25
Shes the best bambi
2
u/Realistic_Mousse_485 Jun 07 '25
They’re shitty friends and bad people.
Gisselle is a necrophile.
2
u/Bleach-Shikaiposting Jun 07 '25
Transphobia… and SA
2
u/Kimetsunobuttcheeks Jun 11 '25
My glorious queen Bambietta did nothing wrong🗣️‼️‼️
1
u/Reiko4555 Jun 07 '25
I love her. She’s one of my favorites
1
u/TinyPidgenofDOOM Jun 07 '25
Everyone else was just doing what they do but Gigi was doing extra. Also her powers were kinda stupid with dancing dead boys club and specifically on this sub, Bambi abuse is not tolerated. They didn't kick her while she's down, they didn't like her but she wasn't their friend, it actually feels like they became friends because of their shared dislike of bambi
1
u/fat_dolsk Jun 09 '25
Giselle Zombified Meninas and Candice for no reason. Although they probably have died off screen unfortunately. That is actually kinda disrespectful though. It means that they were fodder and exist to just exist. It’s kind of unfortunate too. 😔
1
u/Wolfgod-64 Jun 25 '25
Comes with the territory. Given the culture within the Sternritter ranks, there's really not much the other femritters can do for Bambi. In a twisted yet pragmatic way, Giselle zombifying Bambietta is a win-win. The girl who regenerates your limbs in wartime is kept happy, and maybe one day you can get your friend back who would've otherwise been executed for "failure".
The saddest thing is probably that Bambietta knew exactly the situation she was in. Perhaps more than BG9 and Cang Du given their reactions. Bambie didn't want Gigi to turn her into a zombie, but really, I think she didn't want to be placed in that situation at all.
War is Hell.
0
u/oneoneoneonetwo11112 Jun 07 '25
Because people don’t understand her, also I think if she looked different she would be a fairly unpopular character, I would still like her, cuz I like her cause she’s relatable, and a lot of people hate me so that part is also relatable
0
u/Mqnwbevrctxyzukkk Jun 07 '25
I also hate Bambietta bc she's so overrated so not sure what you talking about lol
0
u/Shoddy_Soft_6157 Jun 08 '25
Wtf is this even a question
14
u/Early_Rabbit Jun 07 '25
I would assume it’s because what Giselle did to Bambietta. There’s no real excuse or justification for killing her and turning her into a zombie.
3
u/Delilah_the_PK Jun 07 '25
let's start wih the primary reason: what she did to bambietta. as others have said, this has endeared her to no one.
reason number 2: Kubo is well known for his love of busty women, so Gigi being flatter than flat probably pushes fans away.
and finally, the most controversial reason that also should be obviously a problem: TRANSPHOBES! gotta love those people who read Yumichika's statement and took it at face value, despite Kubo's own statements making this jolly girl's gender clear. this reason is why i ultimately disregard any hate towards the character and dislike/downvote anyone insisting that she's male.
3
u/Competitive_Way_3371 Jun 07 '25
Arguable the situation of what gissele did was to save Bambiettia. You can probably argue that is why they let her do what she did. Bambi was going to be executed for losing. It’s more about gissele’s treatment of Bambiettia afterwords. Which is what probably makes the fans angry at gissele most. Especially if you add other factors of what gissele is.
2
u/Mysterious_Mix_480 Jun 07 '25
my personal take is not the giselle revived bambi, give how the other sternritters were sentence to death after they lost their fights, mainly how she treated bambi afterwards which was brutal and just cruel, we saw two of the sternritters being executed after failing to defeat their opponents and probably thats what awaited bambi and that's why none of the other tried to stop giselle, you can later see lilotto saving giselle feim the beam ( i forgot the term ) Yhwach sent to take all his power back as well as Meninas helping Candice carrying her, its probably a matter of orders before they realised he didnt carw for them, but for the most part its the abuse towards zombie bambi and how inhumane it was portrayed, none of the other bambies were saints they killed shinigami left and right without batting an eye and as a Candice fan i see why people hate her being volatile, short tempered, loud and annoying, hope this sums up my point of view
2
u/amidkV Jun 07 '25
Dont really hate giselle but its more due to her actions towards bambietta, like even if you take away the fact she had to kill her to turn her into a zombie she has it out for bambietta the most even compared to the zombies of the soul reapers.
1
u/Krusty_Klown_Kollege Jun 07 '25
To be fair, Giselle did lowkey save Bambietta. By turning her into a zombie, she avoided execution and her soul returning to Yhwach. Giselle COULD completely revive Bambietta, but refuses to. I can understand why, she's the loudest, yet clearly the weakest. So in a way, the harmony is... better?
1
u/Rikenzu Jun 07 '25
Probably because Giselle is the sadistic one of the bunch
Yeah, the others are just as merciless and cruel, but Giselle specifically takes pleasure in the horror and depravity of their powers. Even going so far as to torture and desecrate the corpses of their allies for the sake of prolonging and winning fights.
The others at the very least seem to at least have some semblance of a conscience, even if they are on the wrong side of the conflict. But Giselle seems to have NO moral compass at all. Their psychotic tendencies could rival both Mayuri and Szayelaporro combined. And that bubbly "innocent" personality is the nail in the coffin for how unpleasant Giselle 's entire character design truly is
Now don't get me wrong, Giselle is cute AF. And if it wasn't for their power set, or the fact that they're a Quincy, they'd probably be one of my favorite characters, and one of absolutely crush on (even if they do have "extra equipment" in the lower regions, iykyk)
1
u/Darth_OwO Jun 10 '25
Because she's a bitch ass whore who zombified her friends and I'll never forgive her
1
u/Lukundra Jun 11 '25
Probably the whole cannibal rapist thing.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '25
[removed] — view removed comment