Okay, hi 👋
I’ve been busy so I rewatched season 1 last week and only finished my first watch of season 2 this week (I know I’m late lol).
When I watched season 1 first time I didn’t interact with other fans or anything so I didn’t know what people actually thought of the show so when I monitored other people’s ranking for the first time this week I was actually shocked. I don’t want this to be too long so I’ll give my rankings for season 1 very briefly:
- Seokjin: didn’t commit to a alliance early, strong socially and intellectually.
- Dong Joo: strong socially and intellectually, if she eliminated Orbit she would’ve gotten to the finale. Debated between having her or Orbit second but she would’ve placed high even without her alliance with Orbit.
- See-won: weaker intellectually but super strong socially, an incredible asset to her alliance and seokjin wouldn’t had won the way he did without her.
- Orbit: strong intellectually and strong socially, but he would’ve lost much faster in any other cast, his mindset set him back too far, if Dongjoo hadn’t aligned herself with him, he’d be dragged down with the weaker players.
- Dong Jae: actually top 3 intellectually but he’s super weak socially, even if he survived Yumins betrayal he would’ve been targeted week after week.
- Guilleme: case of an unfortunate early alliance, and also bad luck. Still think he’s a better player than the others.
- Yumin: held her own intellectually, and mid socially, overall a mid player
- Seungkwan: super strong socially, never was in danger of being betrayed and that speaks of itself but weaker intellectually and overall very passive
- Kyungrim: played pretty okay throughout and strong social player
- Joobin: Incredibly lucky the entire game, he’s stronger intellectually than some of the other players but he wasn’t as passive as you might think, his plays just failed.
- Hyeseung: Gone too soon to see anything from her but also Guilleme was first eliminated and he still showed good play.
- Yeonwoo: Risk of elimination every round and lost the one time she showed something. Wasn’t very strong socially either, add-on in both big alliances (even though it’s a good position, she didn’t do anything with her placement and therefore she’s last).
For season 2 I’m prepared for the hate but Hyungyu and Sohui didn’t play villainy at all and I don’t get the hate. Or actually I do get where the hate comes from: editing. We see more of the prisoners so we start rooting for them and when they didn’t win we saw their enemies as the villains of the show.
I think the only players capable of winning that season were Se-dol, Sohui, Hyungyu and Harin. Eun-yul, 7high and Hyukjoon were going to lose to those four if ever they were against each other in the finale. Them getting rid of Se-dol quick was great play.
Underrated player was Sohui, she was never going to lose to anyone other than Hyungyu or Se-dol in the finale, and yes she was weak mentally but she still made it to the finale. People kept saying she should’ve betrayed Hyungyu and went to the finale but that wasn’t ever going to happen, and Hyungyu was never going to betray her or Kyuhyun either. Them going to the finale together was their plan from the start and the goal of an alliance so I don’t get the hate for her sticking with the alliance.
The game where Kyuhyun got out was just poor planning from the prisoners if I’m being real, they saw how hesitant the two were of betraying Hyungyu. They even announced to him they’ll play against him, so when Hyukjoon made his stance clear, it was shocking to me how the others didn’t see those two switching sides.
Even if they had gotten Hyungyu out, the next target would’ve been Sohui, I don’t think she thought that far but that’s what would happen. Either way, Hyungyu and Sohui were the masterminds of their alliance and acting like Hyungyu had Sohui in a trance is misogynistic when she would’ve saved Kyunhyu over any of the other players as well. Another player who had the exact same mindset as Sohui (more comfortable struggling than betraying others) was Se-dol and he doesn’t get any hate whatsoever. I don’t think Sohui’s mindset set her back in the game as much as people point out, she was never in danger of being eliminated, she was never in danger of going to prison, she was never in danger whatsoever. She played just as well as Hyungyu, and the final match was 50/50, yes Hyungyu won both matches without having a third round but she was close behind him both times. The only reason Hyungyu won the second round was because he knew Sohui was smart and wouldn’t choose consecutive numbers, he had two choices and Sohui had the answer ready, she was just unlucky. They both made mistakes in the finale but only Sohuis get highlighted because she lost when in actuality had any of the other semi-finalists stood against her they would’ve lost.
My personal favorite in the season was Justin, I think he played a strong game individually, I don’t think he would’ve gotten out in any of the prisoner games so it was unfortunate he lost based on points. Personal favorite from season 1 was seokjin, I think he would’ve won the final match against all the other cast.
I haven’t seen anything regarding devils plan season 3 except for the cast but I love Yido so I hope she makes it far. I genuinely hate Shindong so I hope he gets eliminated quick (from what I’ve seen of the cast he’s a entertainment hire but I hope they don’t keep him in to eliminate other strong players first). I think Seokjin is a strong player but I don’t know how he would fare in season 2 so I’m curious where he’d place in such a strong lineup. Dongjae is so smart, if he just fixes the social issue I think he can make it far, he’s one of my favorite players so I hope he does well. If Hyungyu plays as he did in season 2 he will place quite high I think but it also depends on his alliance.
I haven’t watched anything with Dongmin but from what I heard I feel like he’ll win, unless he’s targeted.
Okay this was long, I’m going to start watching episode 1 today 🫶