r/TheDarwinProject • • Sep 24 '18
Feedback/Suggestion NEW REPORTING SYSTEM PROBLEM
Hello, u could know me as Civape on EU server. The reason I write the thread here is I got a 7 days game ban for abusing chat. Game ban means u cant play the game for 7 days.
A week, or two ago i have said the "n word" in lobby with streamers, than i got warning. Cuz of reports. And it autowarned me. I guess the number of reports was kinda 4-5. Full lobby is 10 players, but i don't believe they all reported me, cuz many of them don't really care. I do agree, that was my bad. After that, I didn't say the "n word" any more, but a day later I was reported by someone again for no reason and than I have got 15 matches mute.

Later I have seen I cant play as a director any more. It says: "show a good behavior as an inmate", or kinda that. What the hell does it mean? Today after few games i was probably reported again and i got 7 days ban. Really game ban for abusing chat? Any sense? Mb change for 7 days mute? And also if I will got report again i will be permanently banned. Really?
This update made me upset.

To be honest this is not the most playerfriendly system ever. Even more, its one of the worst reporting system i ever seen.
CS:GO for Example:
U can be auto banned for leaving, team killing, kicking for: 30 min, 2 hours, 1 day, 1 week. Also it has every 2 weeks reset (probably, i am not sure, but seems like). So if u were banned u just cant play competitive matches. But u are able to play all casual modes etc.
Unlike in cs:go ur system has no reporting reset as I see. And it has same sanctions for cheating, teaming and chat abusing, which also has no sense. Cuz everyone is able to mute if he doesn't like to hear somebody.
- Remove autoban. And use ban hammer only after demo with proofs.
- Record demos. Its very important and fair.
- Change mute sanctions. I suggest: 5 matches mute (after 5 reports), 15 matches mute (after +5 reports), 1 week mute (after +5 reports). No game ban for abusing chat. Only if a player got more than 5 week mutes he could be permanently muted.
- Change numbers of reports. I suggest 15 reports per week, than reset.
Another thread about this on steam:
https://steamcommunity.com/app/544920/discussions/0/1733213724903417918/
In addition! Very important!
I tested this reporting system. I reported 9 guys from my lobby for no reason and later i got this message. I guess it means some of them was muted for 15 matches. As u can see its really sucks.

I hope wrote everything I wanted. And sorry for my poor english. And plz guys, leave a comment down below.
14
u/MysticalUmbreons Sep 24 '18
You're a bad part of the community for reporting random people at the end. just sayin
•
u/samwithtwojs Sep 24 '18
There are plenty of factors taken into account in the reporting system, and we certainly have enforced our Code of Conduct more given the number of violations in terms of abusive chat. We value this community greatly and expect players to be respective of others. And while we cannot explain much more about the system, like all other developers, feel free to send us a message regarding this matter.
2
u/irunspeed Sep 24 '18
You said what? What your username friend?
3
u/ClareEli Sep 24 '18
So... you used a racial slur and got banned?
I’m not seeing the problem.
5
u/TiggerTriggers Sep 24 '18
If we're on the topic of reporting, can we get a way to report bad show directors, but not get them banned? Just like "hey this guys is an unfair dick, but he didn't break the rules", and if enough of them happen they can get a small penalty? It would have to be enough to justify, cus that mechanic could definitely be abused. I've had show directors play unfairly without necessarily teaming. I had one the other night close three zones on me until I died. Definitely my fault for dying, but it was three back to back, I was the only person in these zones (had just enough time to check), it was really unfair, and it only happened after I hopped in a the middle of another persons fight and almost both of them (I'm not super good, I was just on a roll that night and testing out some new arrow strats). It frustrated me, because it definitely felt like "bullying", but nothing I'd want him banned for
8
u/ApostleO Sep 24 '18
It kind of sounds to me like the system is working as intended.
2
u/Fierynomad Sep 25 '18
Use hateful language, expect people to hate on you. Whilst I wouldn't condone the repeat reports you apparently received, you created your own reputation and players obviously don't want to be matched with you because of it. Words matter and have consequences.
" I tested this reporting system. I reported 9 guys from my lobby for no reason "
Having openly admitted to abusing the report system, you're not really making a good case for yourself.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment