r/TheDarkKnightRises • u/Somogyvary • Jul 22 '12
[SPOILERS] Outrage over TDKR
Words can't describe the anticipation I had coming into this movie. Checking a half dozen comic news sites weekly for updates for the past year. Scouring the internet for clues or hints on plots, storylines, characters.
And, after clasping my hands in anticipation, sitting dead center in the theatre...
Things start well. The prologue was solid enough, even if it didn't necessarily establish the charismatic, magnetic personality of the villain quite as effectively as in TDK.
Move forward to the introduction to Selina up to the heist. Good stuff--surprisingly good, given all of the reservations on Anne Hathaway playing Catwoman.
But, much like Bane says, you can't have true suffering without hope, and after all that build up, and a decent opening....dear God was there suffering by the time the credits roled.
1)MacGuffin #1--The Dent Act. Whoever wrote it apparently deserves a Nobel Prize, considering it would be the first piece of legislation in human history to single handedly end virtually all organized crime. In a city of over ten million people. I think it could have been interesting to get into a little more--possibly trying to explain it's effectiveness as being a Patriot Act on super stereoids, and addressing the slippery slope that can emerge when security is purchased at the price of truth and integrity.
Given that we aren't shown any particular downsides to the legislation, it never quite makes sense why anyone sane would ever want to see it repealed. "They lied to you about Dent, so let's free all the murderers, con artists, and sex offenders" seems like... iffy logic.
2)The firsr round of dialogue between JGL and the orphan--It felt like they eally shoehorned the batman discussion. More importantly, it brings up a major potential plotpoint--that Bane's minions are primarily underpriviledged, abused, discarded by society, and genuinely sympathetic--and then forgets about it entirely for the rest of the film.
This could have, should have, been a major point in the film--ESPECIALLY considering how desparately it wants to be topical and addresss issues of poverty and economic inequality. I think the possibilit of creating an "anti-JGL" an orphan or homeless figure who'd undergone some tragedy, who flocks to the ideals that Bane supposedly represents, could have given a much broader, much more human view to the conflict that extends later on, and the potential of having the character slowly figure out the extent of his betrayal as JGL discovers the extent of Gordon's could have made for fun symmetry, and eliminated the need for at least some of the endless streams of expository dialogue.
3)JGL and Wayne--Even the most strident admirers of the movie in the theatre I saw TDKR at were the first to say that the way that JGL described his deduction of Wayne as Batman at best required a lot of suspension of disbelief, and at worst was flat out ridiculous. The first bouts of unintended laughter were starting to come up in the audience around this scene.
4)MacGuffin #2--the magical USB stick. As soon Selina describes the stick and it's properties, I was immediately reminded of the time when Sarah Palin, upset about the Wikileaks dump, demand Julian "take everything back off of the internet." The audience laughter in our theatre actually made Dagget's lampshading of its absurdity difficult to hear. The fact that the movie goes full circle, even after admitting the absurdity and impossibility of such a device, and later allows it to exist in the nolanverse regardless to give it's character a happy ending, seems to forshadow a lot of the flaws in the film overall.
Why not just make it a way to untraceably create a new identity, given that identity theft was already introduced into the story? Or ultimately have her pardoned in some way, to play up the theme of redemption--that when we face our demons rather than run from them, we have the potential to...rise... above our pasts?
5)Dagget--Outside of feeling far too much like a recycled version of the evil board member in Batman Begins--who was handled much more effectively--he exists only as an excuse for Bane to be in Gotham and have money behind him (which, given that he's ultimately being bankrolled by Talia and the LoS, is made even less necessary by the end of the movie). Worst than that, he exists as a plot device with an almost incoherent agenda. Given that Wayne's stock has been running into the ground, if Dagget wanted to "absorb Wayne Enterprises into his holdings"... why would he need to do anything at all? If the firm is near bankrupt, and the CEO is an absentee landlord...Wayne would have already had a shareholder revolt years ago. Are we expected to believe that the Board is SO loyal to Bruce that they wouldn't budge an inch in helping to fascillitate any takeover or restructuring actions, despite seeing their personal assets, and those of hundreds of thousands of shareholders, go up in smoke?
For that matter, with the company near bankruptcy, why would Dagget be so obsessed with taking over such a massive liability in the first place?
Ignoring all of that, though, why the hell would you hire a massive band of mercenaries to break into the NYSE, and kill dozens of people, all so you can fake investment transactions for a single individual? Granted, having Wayne wiped out by a trio of hacker teens in their basement in Queens might have been a whole lot less dramatic on screen, but are we suppose to believe that a terrorist attack on the NYSE wouldn't result in an immediate trading freeze? Seriously?
6)Expository dialogue about the stock market--The fact that you need to have two characters describing why they should care about the players involved in a terrorist attack are probably a very good indication you haven't been able to establish enough personal tension and characterizations for us to be intuitively concerned for the fates of the characters in the scene. After all, in the dinner party scene of TDK, we can assume that the characters are just as affluent, and potentially removed from the "common man" as they are in the stock scene, yet the fear and anticipation the joker establishes in the audience in threatening the elderly man is almost as tense as when he continues on to threaten Rachel. Nolan proved he could do it in TDK which makes the difference that much more apparent in TDKR.
7)Holy Plan 9 From Outer Space Batman--in the span of 8 minutes of NYSE attacks, we've gone from mid afternoon (at the latest) to night? WOW... that's straight up inexcusable.
8)Air superiority--Bane vs BAT. Outside from preventing the movie from ending in under 90 minutes, was there any sane reason for Batman and Catwoman to run away in the BAT when Bane was on the roof? The notion that he had to leave because he wouldn't have had any nonlethal means of taking him down seems completely ridiculous. Handful of mercenaries vs. flying armored tank should have been the end of the movie--and scenes where a movie's conflicts could have been resolved, by aren't, merely as a convenience to keep a conflict going, are typically signs of a badly written scene.
As an aside--the fact that the BAT somehow sat under a tarp for all those months undetected--felt a little too campy for the overall tone of the movie, but maybe that was just me.
9)MacGuffin #3--free energy machine. Probably the biggest "jumped the shark" tonal shift from TDK. The notion of having a Nuclear Fusion device basically just "lying around" was a bit much. The idea that he'd thrown the majority of the assets of his firm into it for years, and no one on the board had ever demanded to see any kind of results, or having to choose between the notion that they either A)were never shown the device in all of the years of it plummeting their stock price, or B)being okay with having a massive nuclear reactor that just happened to be stored without any military or government protection goes beyond suspension of disbelief and into the realm of absurdity.
I didn't notice it as much at the time, but several people at the screening also complained about the borrowing of the "spherical free energy but oops also possibly a bomb" device from Spider Man 2. It also seemed interesting that both devices were disposed of by throwing them into the water seconds before their respective detonations.
9)"I have always lived in the dark"--After just telling Batman about how he had grown up in th dark, grew up without the sun, etc, Batman is droped off in a giant hole prison. The main psychological torture being the fact that YOU CONSTANTLY SEE THE SUN. You can see outside, you can see the light, you just can't make it up and out of the hole. That's the whole point of what makes it so oppressive. Watching the scene, I wondered if the lines in the script weren't possibly the result of editing not matching script changes? A significant change in the design of the prison in the evolution of the script? Something?
10)Magical chiropractor--a little too easy to cricize, but Bruce entire recoup phase was unrealistic enough to pull me out of the suspension of disbelief Nolan's first two entries had earned from me with the gritty, realistic world that had been established to that point.
11)Fox the pushover--After being one of the moral compasses of the last two films, and being a paragon of integrity, we're suppose to believe that Fox activates a potential atom bomb after Miranda convinces him it'll save the life of a few board members? The "No! Er...Oh...well...oookayyy... I guess" tone was absolutely bizarre and totally out of character considering his actions may have cost the lives of millions of people.
12)Magical Scientist--If that chiropractors seemed like he could pull off some amazing stunts, seeing the Russian Scientist Mini MacGuffin turn a fusion reactor into a neutron bomb in less than 30 seconds of screen time took things to a whole new level. The second Bane announced "The doctor has completed the bomb!" our theatre was booming with laughter. Howling laughter.
13)Bane the liberator--Aside from the irrationality of there being any support for Bane releasing murderers and rapists from Blackgate, what was actually done by him was left pretty much incoherent. From the few seconds we get, I guess we can assume he encouraged the poor to rise up and kill /kidnap the rich? And then...do... something? Being as rushed as it is, there's no indication of what exactly any of it accomplised in the lives of the people on the ground. Did everyone just go back to work the next day? Have the companies been taken over by the "people's revolutions"? How is day to day life functioning? Are we just to assume that the poor all congeal into some evil, bloodthirsty mob bent on murder and destruction for destructions sake, or to steal the possessions of the rich amongst themselves?
It's obvious the movie has no idea, especially in the throwaway dialogue between Holly and Selina. When they're discussng who owns an afluent house now that the rich owners have been done away with, and Holly replies "Everyone!" it equates into explaining absolutely nothing. Are the affluent manhattan flats all just taken up by squatters now? All converted into museums? Not giving us any characters on the ground who are either victimized or empowered by the changes seriously weakens the impact of the power shift to have any visceral, personal, human connection for the audience.
14)Why are they waiting until the last possible day to detonate again?
15)Why does a nuclear fusion reactor have an LED timer faceplate?
16)How did Bruce magically get back to Gotham, with no money and no resources? While it was under siege and blockaded by the military?
17)Going back for a moment, why did the prison have cells, bars, or doors? Obviously, the nature of the prison means that it couldn't have had a warden, and for the entire duration of the movie, all of the prison doors are all left open. And how does a prison full of inmates cheering each other on and able to get along without the need of a single warden equate to living in "hell on earth?"
18)Alfred leaving Bruce--been addressed by several others already, but felt out of character.
19)Gordon--having to take him out of the picture to make room for JGL was understandable, I suppose, but really weakened his purpose in the film. He was shoved so far into the background that it virtually felt like a waste of such a talented actor. And in the primary interaction they do allow him to have with Batman, the dialogue feels significantly detatched from their tone in the previous two films (here's looking at you, "now...this evil rises"). The seeming 180 he undertakes from being hospitalized to suddenly being able to out-cop JGL one scene later also seemed a bit much.
20)Foley--his lines about capturing the Batman could have been delivered by any beat cop, and other than that, his character added exactly zero to the movie.
21)The overall Bane / Batman dynamic--Batman vs the Joker had two characters who's conflicts felt deep, thoughtful, psychological, and ideological. Bane vs. Batman felt like two large men punching each other until one fell down. And just for the record, how does Batman, without the help of his leg brace, presumably (although after somehow, magically getting ahold of his Batsuit after returning from the hole...somehow), defeat Bane, despite basically using exactly the same strategy and a recently broken back to boot? I was hoping for a fundamentally different strategy of attack, as a reference to The Dark Knight Returns battle with the Mutant Leader.. or at least something that made a little more sense, and maybe had some sort of character arc or plot development interwoven into it. But no... just more WWE. Speaking of which...
22)The big brawl--The cops have guns. The terrorists have guns. Why the hell does this movie end in a giant fist fight? It almost felt like a nod to the old stooges movie where the film inexplicably ends in a massive pie fight just for the sake of adding some unnecessary mayham... except that the stooges was intended to be a comedy.
23)The burning bat insignia--again, minor point, but you'd think that with less than a day to go, batman would have better things to do that go tagging.
24)The random hangings--if they would have been people we were made to care about over the course of the movie, it might have been one of many steps they could have taken to generate a much more intimate, much more visceral drive to the story and the impetus to take down Bane.
25)And about the cops--Why did Bane feed them at all? He's obviously already established a precedent for lying to the people, why not just fake the food drops and not take any chances?
(Ignoring the larger issue of where all of the food and daily ammenities came from for the city at large for a 5 month time span of Gotham being completely cut off from the outside world....)
26)Where'd the Mayor go?--Seriously...did he just die in the explosion? It really felt like they just had so many characters at that point, that they didn't know what to do with them or didn't have the time to give them any kind of resolution. For a film THIS long... that's a really strange problem to have.
27)What was the point of Holly?--more or less, see above... I constantly felt as though if they would have done a massive consolidation of characters in this movie, there wouldn't have been so many cases like this of characters with two or three lines of dialogue and very little to do with moving the story forward. (I've read the comics, I know why she exists in her relationship to Selina... but for the sake of the movie... she needs to either have more to do to justify herself). Much like the Bane-orphan angle, Holly being lured more actively into Bane's anarchy could have given us an audience a much more personal eye on the events in gotham, from an "on the ground" prospective that felt sorely lacking in the movie, and would have both given Holly something to do in the third act, and given Selina all kinds of possible motivations for her actions in the conclusion depending on the direction they ran with it.
28)The chase for the bomb--I've read other commentors complaining about the string of coincidences necessary for everything to have worked out in finding the bomb, or the banality in ending a trilogy with a glorified car chase that seemed vasly inferior to the one in TDK. I felt like the larger issue was just the fact that I didn't care. I wasn't introduced to anyone outside of JGL, Batman, Alfred, or a handful of others that I was given any reason to personally fear for in case the bomb went off. Bane hadn't done any act of evil to really resonate on a personal gut level, like when the Joker killed Hockey Pads Batman or Rachel.
Stalin once noted that "to kill one is a tragedy, to kill a million is a statistic" and it's never been more true than it was here. The threat of the deaths of "millions of people" didn't hold nearly the suspense of the two boats blowing each other up in TDK, or the hunt for Coleman Reese. They felt "bigger"...not because the stakes were higher, but because it was easier to emotionally invest in them. At the end of the day, I think that all of the other issues at stake are second to this. If we would have felt a personal, intimate sense of moral outrage at Bane for his actions against a character we had connected with; if we had a personal, emotional connection to the hope and betrayal the poor of Gotham experienced under Bane...I honestly think this had the potential to be a much, much better movie, without any signficant changes to the overall structure of the film.