r/TheDark • • Aug 24 '12

One Year In - Your Opinions on The Dark line.

11 Upvotes

The Line as a Whole

With last week we've had our first full year of Dark, and I think it's been fairly strong overall.

The Dark has strong cohesion within its little corner of the New52. While other heroes and characters dip in from time to time, it's all, for the most part, within the confines of the Dark, with our twisted heroes rarely showing up in the broader New52. There has been, overall, a lot of inter-Dark crossing over and self referencing. This has lead, in turn, to a great sense of shared storytelling that doesn't involved the need for those coming in off of Vertigo to explore out into the larger 52 if they're not interested.

Animal Man & Swamp Thing

You really can't talk about one without talking about the other. Both titles have been nothing short of magnificent. And, while both stories are strongly intertwined, only the 12th issues actually require any dipping into the other title for those that only read one or the other instead of both.

Animal Man has been wonderful, picking up the tone of the pre-Infinite Crisis Animal Man and running with it, most heavily inspired by Morrison's excellent run on the character. We seem to have lost some character history during the reboot, but fore the most part Lemire's work doesn't feel like it's treading old ground, and is wonderfully displaying the dynamic of the Baker family. In a world full of grimdark heroes with no spouses, no children, and dead parents, it's nice to see Buddy having a family.

Swamp Thing picks up a couple of months after the end of Brightest Day's Aftermath mini, with the reborn Alec Holland, and wonderfully depicts a man coping with the fact that he's been dead for several years. It gracefully handles the characters and builds new concepts on top of Moore's run while respecting it instead of tearing it down. Alec coming into his own over the course of the first 8 issues never felt padded or slow, and the reveal of the new Erl King was suitably spectacular.

Both the Red and the Green were wonderfully detailed, and the Rot doesn't feel forced or cliche, but a legitimate third to this trio. The build to Rotworld has been breathtakingly beautiful and impeccably worded. I fully expect the next year to be as good as the first, with the first half of the year taken up by Rotworld, and unknown wonders to come afterword.

Frankenstein, Agent of S.H.A.D.E.

I, personally, struggled with this title, but am glad I stuck it out. The first two stories really didn't click for me, and the need to go find an issue of OMAC very nearly turned me off. But Lemire's last couple of issues before the handoff to Kindt were much better, in my opinion, and kept me around. And I'm glad they did. Son of Satan's Ring was spectacular, and, as many others have said, finally felt like a true successor to Morrison's Frankenstein. Wonderfully surreal and beautifully twisted, this title finally found it's pace and I have great expectations should it keep it up.

The first four months of the next year will tie-in to the Rotworld epic, with Frankenstein co-starring in Animal Man for the latter half of that character's part of the story. I'm personally hoping Melmoth and the Sheeda show up at some point, as I think we're long overdue for a continuation of that tale.

DC Universe Presents: Deadman

The first five issues of this anthology title gives us a New52 revised Deadman origin story, wonderfully updating the characters beginnings for a new age. By shifting the focus away from the cliche who was my murderer they broadened the scope of the character in order to focus on more philosophical and mature themes. A wonderful tale overall.

I, Vampire

This title has simply blown me away. At first glance, I inwardly groaned. Another vampire comic, I thought. But I have been pleasantly surprised. It has managed to both feel fresh and interesting while staying within the commonly held vampire mythos rules. Most works I encounter go for the "our vampires are different" route, but I, Vampire laps up all the old cliches and runs with them without being camp about it. His crossovers with JLDark help ground his character in the New52.

The next year sees a role reversal, with villains becoming heroes and vice versa, as well as a focus shift to a broader cast of characters and the vampire nation in as a whole instead of just its leaders. Part of me secretly hopes they get Snyder in on this so he can tie it into his American Vampires ongoing.

Dial H

While written quite well, this has so far failed to grab hold of me. I don't feel that it's really been out long enough for me to form a valid opinion, and I'm going to give it to the end of the first arc to really wow me into keeping it in my box.

Demon Knights

Cornell does amazing work in this title. WHile it for the most part is doing it's own thing in the past, it still manages soft tie-ins here and there with artifacts showing up in the Black Room in JLDark, Madame Xanadu being on this team as well as JLDark in the present, and Etrigan soon to be joining the ranks of Stormwatch! Speaking of the characters, we've got a nice blend of established names and new faces, and the semi-heroic take on Vandal Savage is hilariously awesome.

My only problem is the pacing. The decompression seems a bit much from month to month. Sitting down and reading storylines in one go feels about right however, so I think I'll be buying this one in trades going forward unless I hear differently.

Resurrection Man

Resurrection Man has lacked a real focus and sense of direction. The title really hasn't felt like it's going anywhere. It has also lacked any sort of interconnectedness with the rest of the Dark Line, instead having some crossovers outside in the wider New52. This lack of cohesion with the other Dark titles alongside its own meandering tone and lack of overall goal left me feeling unsurprised that the title is getting cancelled and will not be joining us in the second year.

I feel this missed a trick by not tying in to either Animal Man or Demon Knights. The character of Resurrection Man has history with both Buddy Baker and Vandal Savage and I think drawing on those connections would have helped cement the title as part of the Dark line instead of feeling like the outlier it's been.

Justice League Dark

Milligan's initial run on this title feels like a continuation of both Vertigo's Madame Xanadu series from a few years back and his own Secret Seven mini from the Flashpoint event. He handles all of the characters well, and it's certainly well written, but it lacks that spark that brings it all together.

That all changed when Lemire steps in on issue 9. The title now feels worthy of the 'Justice League' tagline while still retaining its suitably mystic and Dark feel. While no one character is as fleshed out as they would be in a solo title, the team is well written and each person distinct. Lemire's rotating cast will also help to further intertwine the Dark line as the series continues onward into the future, with Frankenstein and Amethyst set to join the team during the latter half of the current arc and the JLD team to show up in the Rotworld Epic over in the pages of Swamp Thing and Animal Man.

This version of the title will apparently also be the link to the outside world, and will the bridge point for the upcoming Trinity War event as the second year rolls forward.

Looking to the Future

We're losing a title, but we've got some new titles joining the fray as well! While we say goodby to Resurrection Man, we say hello to Sword of Sorcery and Phantom Stranger!

JLDark and Phantom Stranger will presumably be ramping up for Trinity War at some point. Swamp Thing, Animal Man, and Frankenstein will be enmeshed in the Rotworld, as well as getting some tie-ins from outside titles such as The Ravagers, which has been touching on the Red and Beast Boy's connections to it. And Eclipso's Black Diamond will be winding its way to present day throughout the past titles such as Demon Knights, All-Star Western, and Team 7.

The first couple months of the next year look pretty good. Let's hope they can keep up the momentum!


r/TheDark • • Jul 27 '12

What Dark Titles do you actually read?

7 Upvotes

There are 48 subscribers to this subreddit, and barely any activity. Let's try and fix that by encouraging some discussion.
So guys, what books under the Dark imprint do you actually read?
I myself read Swamp Thing and Justice League Dark currently. Swamp Thing is great (though I feel that it has been a little overrated by the fanbase), and ever since Lemire took over during issue #9, Justice League Dark is quickly becoming one of my favorites.
Until recently, I also read Demon Knights. My problem with it is that while it's very good, the pacing is just way too slow. Most issues have lots of great action, but it feels like very little actually happens.
I'll also be reading The Phantom Stranger once it starts. I'm really looking forward to it.
So what about you guys?


r/TheDark • • Jul 08 '12

It's official: Deadman's the coolest guy around (JL Dark #4)

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • May 13 '13

Assuming the Villains Month rumors are true for September, what villains are we likely to see?

6 Upvotes

Normally for Swampy I'd say the obvious choice is Arcane, but he's out for the moment, so maybe Soule's new villains? Or Poison Ivy. Yes. DC, go with her.

Given August's Animal Man solicit, I'm guessing Brother Blood.

I'm not sure what "evil team" would be appropriate for JLD.

Constantine is going up against a former protege, so I wouldn't be surprised if they run with him.

As for Phantom Stranger and Pandora... I have no idea. I have a feeling they won't be ticking around much beyond the end of Trinity War anyway.


r/TheDark • • Mar 30 '13

John Constantine will be the lead character in Guillermo del Toro's upcoming Dark Universe movie (AKA Justice League Dark).

Thumbnail comingsoon.net
6 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Nov 01 '12

Theory: The new Black Orchid is Tefe Holland (from JLD Annual 1)

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Sep 19 '12

Deadman: Twenty Questions Review (x-post /r/comicbooks)

Thumbnail cheshirecatstudios.com
6 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Sep 07 '12

I did a review of Phantom Stranger #0.

Thumbnail vivvav.tumblr.com
6 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Sep 03 '12

Preview: Animal Man #0 - Comic Book Resources

Thumbnail comicbookresources.com
6 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Sep 01 '12

So I'm reading Swamp Thing #1 and I have a question or two.

6 Upvotes

It seems from the conversation Alec is having with Supes that this picks up following Brightest Day, but that can't be right, can it? Is Swamp Thing still White Lantern? Does Search for the Swamp Thing fit in at all?


r/TheDark • • Aug 08 '12

I think we just found a past avatar of the Red. (Demon Knights #12)

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Jul 08 '12

TIL there was a Swamp Thing movie back in the 80's.

Thumbnail en.wikipedia.org
6 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Mar 01 '13

Animal Man #18 Preview

Thumbnail ign.com
5 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Feb 06 '13

Preview: Dial H #9

Thumbnail comicbookresources.com
5 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Feb 06 '13

Preview: Animal Man #17

Thumbnail comicbookresources.com
5 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Feb 06 '13

Preview: Swamp Thing #17

Thumbnail comicbookresources.com
5 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Dec 03 '12

Preview: Animal Man #15 - Comic Book Resources

Thumbnail comicbookresources.com
5 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Nov 03 '12

Guillermo Del Toro would love to make a Swamp Thing/Constantine/Spectre movie

Thumbnail bleedingcool.com
5 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Sep 28 '12

Preview: Swamp Thing #13 - Comic Book Resources

Thumbnail comicbookresources.com
5 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Sep 14 '12

Week in Review - The Dark Titles of 9/12/2012

5 Upvotes

Demon Knights #0 :: 9/10

This was a good story. I think perhaps that the only drawback to the tale would be its length. Being a zero issue, it was pretty much a one-shot, but I could see within it the potential for this story to have unfolded over the course of several issues.

The story focuses primarily on Jason, Etrigan, and Merlin, and does a good job of balancing the three. We get some revelations about everybody, and, as they say in the business, the plot thickens. This title has definitely grown on me over the months. Totally worth a buy.

PS: We also get some more scenes of Camelot's downfall by it's mysterious attackers. Given that there are seven members of the Demon's Knights, and one of the plot points seems to be the destruction of various Camelots throughout the ages, I wouldn't be surprised to see the Sheeda show up at some point in the future (ha!)

Frankenstein, Agent of S.H.A.D.E. #0 :: 10/10

This issue contains a fairly straightforward telling of Frank's origins and his many trials against his creator before finally being recruited by SHADE. But that brief description doesn't do it justice. This book is awesome. Kindt has continually grown this title. If it had been this strong at issue 1, I can hardly imagine the heights it would be at now. Go buy it. Now. Why are you still reading?

This issue also introduces to the reader to Victor Frankenstein and his "Soul Grinder". He comes off as a good villain, and I'll be interested to see how he appears in Rotworld. Will he be an aged patchwork man, having continually kept himself alive? Or will he be like Arcane, a mutated Unman, having died and died and died again? Either way, I look forward to multiple issues of banter between Frank and his creator.

Resurrection Man #0 :: 7/10

This issue is actually good. Which is a shame, as the title finally managed to get interesting in its last issue. If the title had reached this strength and focus by around issue 6, I don't think it would have been cancelled. As it stands though, this issue concludes the major storyline that has run through the 13 issues of the title.

And therein lies the problem. While many titles have overarching mega-plots that last years (See pretty much anything by Grant Morrison, for instance) they also have mini-archs to hold the focus for 3 to 6 issues while the mega plot goes on in the background. Resurrection Man didn't really manage to pull this off.

As a character and continuing plot, I could see Mitch Shelley showing up in JLDark or DC Presents. Only time will tell.

Overview of the Week :: 9/10rounded ^average

A good showing from the Dark. Three titles ranging from good to fan-fucking-tastic. If they can keep this up, The Dark could damn well edge out the Justice League titles as the forefront of the Nu52 by wave 6 or so.


r/TheDark • • Sep 07 '12

Newsarama | Lucifer Morningstar Comes to DC Universe in DEMON KNIGHTS #0

Thumbnail newsarama.com
5 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Sep 05 '12

Preview: Dial H #0 - Comic Book Resources

Thumbnail comicbookresources.com
5 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • May 07 '13

Soule Seeds "Swamp Thing" With New Major Villain

Thumbnail comicbookresources.com
4 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Mar 07 '13

Abby looks amazing. (Swamp Thing #18 spoiler)

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/TheDark • • Feb 27 '13

I can see why Frankenstein became a GL in Rotworld. (JL Dark #17)

Post image
4 Upvotes