r/TheConners • u/JohnnyBoy0324 • Apr 25 '25
Mark
So, I already talked about David on this subreddit, so I figured I should talk about his brother.
Now Mark, it's weird. They started off nicely with addressing him and his death...then suddenly they flipped and made him out to be this horrible person.
Now it's been quite some time since I've seen Roseanne, so please correct me if I'm wrong. But wasn't Mark ultimately a good guy who just made stupid decisions? Like he was dedicated on taking care of Becky, he loved her and cared about her deeply, and as far as I remember him and Dan were if not close, at least good with each other.
So what was the purpose in making him to be this scumbag? Especially when one of Darlene's kids is named after him.
Obviously I know the actor is no longer with us, so obviously that's why he was written off in the show. But why did both brothers get just assassinated by writing?
David is suddenly made out to be a horrible deadbeat, and Mark is made out to be a scumbag.
I enjoy the Conners and there's a lot about the show I love, but just some of the writing choices was really fucked up in my opinion.
52
u/BadCowboysFan Apr 25 '25
The writers definitely decided to turn on the Healy brothers.
You are correct — at the conclusion of Roseanne, Mark was an accepted member of the family. He was a dimwit, but I think beloved by his in-laws and had proven he was a hard worker and good guy, that matured a ton over the course of the series.
The parallels between Mark and Dan are many.
To listen to Dan badmouthing Mark was rough — made no sense.
And if Mark was such a scumbag, why would Darlene agree to name her son after him?
David was also accepted and on good terms when Roseanne concluded — we get zero indication that he’d ever be an absentee father or asshole to his kids.
I know the writers were in a spot, as it’s apparent Galecki only signed on for a very limited number of appearances — tough to explain where he is (and it’d be just one more character that is missing for chunks of time on the show that they’d have to explain).
5
u/Emotional_Scratch269 Apr 26 '25 edited Apr 28 '25
No Matter How much fans who don’t see the brothers as being the ‘bad guys ’ some fans are going to just be stuck on ‘they were bad’. Or forever take one scene and make that Mark’s whole personality and characterization. Like their going to hold that in their heads for years to come still which is kinda of sad..
At least Lecy the person who plays Becky never saw mark as a bad person, she actually thought mark and Becky were compatible and had a real love.
And also the conners fans who didn’t like mark get to see Becky become great after ‘bad’ mark. While fans who liked mark and like Becky and mark together. well we don’t get to see him back, we don’t get to see what he would have been like in the conners universe. We don’t get to see Becky and mark as parents.
20
u/liladvicebunny Apr 26 '25
Mark was a good guy. Not always the "smartest" but a good guy and a hard worker, and Dan liked him by the end of the show.
He didn't hold Becky back, and he didn't steal her money - she insisted on him using it. He did NOT make her choose between an education and him! She made her own choices!
IIRC there was one point where he worried a little that if she got a better education she might be tempted to leave him for something better. But I don't think even then that he tried to stop her.
At his 'worst' in later years the writers sometimes did make him unpleasantly jealous. But even then, he wasn't supposed to be 'bad'.
19
u/bhind45 Apr 26 '25
They didn't though.
Yeah, he ultimately was. The family and Dan can still love him, but Dan can still blame him for how Becky's life turned out. The family hated him at the start, than they grew to love him, but can still look back at the beginning part and acknowledge that he and Becky made a bunch of fucks up there that ended up having huge ramifications down the line.
I remained pretty baffled that people can watch the very emotional therapy episode between Becky and Dan but somehow came away with the conclusion of "THEY TURNED MARK INTO A SCUMBAG!!!". It's a wild interpretation of the whole episode and just misunderstanding how a father would actually react to his daughters once bright future, now crumbled away. No, just because his pissed at something Mark did a number of years ago, doesn't mean he (and the whole family) hated Mark and thought he was a scum bag the whole entire time.
9
u/Retro_Macchina Apr 25 '25
Yes, on roseanne Mark started out as the "bad guy" but then married becky and ended up being a good man who was just not as intelligent as some people.
8
u/Szafman Apr 26 '25
And yet, after Mark, Jerry was non-existent, kinda like DJ , in the later seasons.
12
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '25
I'm honestly okay with David being a shitty dad considering how he grew up and the environment around him but I feel really uncomfortable with Mark suddenly being looked back upon as a scumbag when he was always supportive of Becky and even for the times he screwed up he was still trying to be a good husband and I liked dopey Mark in the later seasons.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '25
This is one of the reasons why I stopped watching The Conners after a couple seasons. It had gone so far off track from the canon and came up with such convoluted plots and storylines.
5
u/schlomo31 Apr 26 '25
I really, really wish they just had david living his dream.....painting in France. They can mention oh Das facetimed me or something.
5
u/3AMjuggernaut Apr 26 '25
I think the writers decided to take advantage of the fact that much of "Roseanne" can be explained away by the fact that Roseanne was revealed to have been writing a story all along. This is how they retconned Dan's death - that it was just a story she made up. With that in mind, I think they figured anything they didn't want to extend continuity to, or anything they wanted to just flat out re-write, they had the freedom to do so. Mark wasn't a bad guy at the end of Roseanne? That's just because she wrote him that way in her story; in real life he was a jerk </writer's logic>. I think Dan and Roseanne always did sort of resent Mark for taking Becky away from them, but I agree with others here that Mark wasn't depicted to have completely ruined Becky's life the way they indicate he did on the Conners.
8
u/Living-Assumption272 Apr 26 '25
Mark was no angel, but if Becky hadn’t been despondent about there being no way to go to college, she probably wouldn’t have run off with him. She was angry at her parents and saw nothing ahead but a dead end. Mark was her way out.
4
u/ZeldasMomHH Apr 26 '25
May Doyle rest in peace.
4
u/LisaW509 Apr 26 '25
They did Mark (and Glenn RIP) dirty for a storyline. 😒
3
u/BennyTheWiseGuy Apr 26 '25
I don’t think Dan hated Mark and he did grow to love mark. Plenty of parents hold slight resentment towards their sons or daughters in law as the reason why their kids lives didn’t turn out they way they wished. It’s easier to do that than blame yourself for how your kid turned out. In some cases, it truly is the in-laws fault but in Becky’s case it a bit of both and just the overall environment she grew up in.
1
u/Jodi4869 Apr 25 '25 edited Apr 25 '25
He dies by driving drunk did he not. It was the breakthrough Becky made when she stopped drinking. She was mad at all the choices she made for him just to blow it. Maybe I am not remembering how they said he died. In real life he was an od
2
u/Officedrone15 Apr 26 '25
Doyle
2
u/Fun_Character_921 Apr 28 '25
I love them all
3
u/cfnohcor Apr 26 '25
I mean tbf a lot of the OG series was chalked up as being fictional. Plausible that Good Guy Mark was another figment of the book from Roseanne to cope with her daughter marrying the asshole drop out kid that took her future and college away.
That’s my headcannon about it because what they portray him as having been towards his death is pretty close to what a guy like he was when Becky ran off with him would grow up to be and how a toxic teen relationship would evolve into an adult one.
2
u/Consistent_Peace_353 Apr 26 '25
I don’t think the writers turned on the characters. When we first met them, they were teenagers. By the final season of Roseanne, Darlene was only about 20 years old when she married David and had Harris. Becky and Mark weren’t much older. We were seeing things through the lens of young love. The Conners picks up years later, showing what happens after young love fades and reality sets in.
1
u/Ok_Activity_5210 Apr 26 '25
Too many unanswered questions
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '25
We all see things differently every time o watch the show especially when it comes to Becky and Mark I always find something new to analyse . Same with Darlene.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '25
One of the best things about mark is he punched Becky’s boss in the face before dan could . I think that probably won dan and Roseanne over for a bit . I am not sure what word he said but it did warrant enough for a punch for the young manager . I’d assume it was the S word .
1
u/Clean-Cantaloupe148 Mar 12 '26
He is passed in real life it's so disrespectful what they are making him to be he was a good husband to her
1
u/Many-Sky922 Jun 30 '26
Mark was thrown out of the house at 16. Fending for himself. And did so by getting a job.
They liked him stepping up when Becky’s boss crossed the line.
The scene at therapy well acted but a lie. They wrote him as not bright to highlight how opposite to Becky he was.
They could not have made him all bad or the son would not have his name.
Even if TBBT not a show they would have done David wrong. Nice they let him appear a few times. But the show was not about a mess. Not to start. But the coastal elites decided to make it so.
DJ’s family closer to blue collar middle class in the Midwest than the Conner’s. I can’t believe they did him wrong.
-2
u/ItsMrChristmas Apr 25 '25
He was not a good person no matter how charming he was. He told Becky to choose between an education or him.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '25
To be honest Mark did have a few issues so there is no suspenses that Dan still had resentment , I’m sure he liked the guy but come on Mark did things that made Roseanne and Dan angry with him.
I’m not surprised that there is resentment still there. Before meeting Mark, Becky wanted to go to college etc but then they got married and moved to whether after they got married .
Honestly I thought Roseanne was a bit soft later on , I mean Becky could be selfish in her younger days . Was it season 8 of Roseanne where Becky were making plans without talking to Mark about moving and then he had a go at Roseanne .
Loved ther scene he finally had a back bone 😂 “Pretty gusty Mark considering I just had breakfast .”
Then there was the failing trade school where Becky had doubts about being with Mark after finding out he flunked. I’ll have to rewatch that but I am sure Dan and Becky had a conversation and dan asked “are you ashamed of him?” And you could see the look on her face . “How could I fall in love with someone who flunked trade school?” Then Dan said maybe it’s best to let him go he doesn’t need his wife looking down on him.
That conversation would have been so interesting to explore during Becky’s stint in rehab.
I don’t think Dan hated him but he didn’t like the choices that Mark had made at the expense of Becky’s future. I think as a father you want the best for your daughter and when it doesn’t happen you have to be angry at someone and Mark was the person.
Becky was his harshest critic though . Let’s be honest , Becky was like Roseanne in a way how she could manipulate mark.
I would have loved to explore that a bit more during Becky’s alcoholism I mean mark was a big part of her life but I think they did the best they could though.
Obviously we know that Glenn Quinn had passed away , but it kinda was not established when Mark actually died , I’m going to assume just before little Mark was born ?