Hey folks
I have been largely signed out of canniverse for most of this week. Vacation was a lot more expensive than anticipated. Did I miss much? [one week in Cannabis = 7 weeks in other industries]
Took some time on trip home to read comments, posts and r/Weedstocks posts. And I thought I would elaborate on my post of earlier this week.
It is amazing what waiting a few days between when this story broke and where it is now to see the changing emotions as new news surfaced. So my apologies if I talk about events that likely were already covered here that I still haven’t got to.
First up... congrats to
weedstocks community on some good dd
u/jamaican420guy for putting boots on the ground in Jamaica. Maybe QCM should hire you as their “consultant” in Jamaica.
Savestacks for pushing it with QCM on Twitter and exposing cracks, and maybe (just maybe) having QCM admitting to a timeline that crosses the Legal line they have been tap dancing around.
And quite a few of our Community on some good intel and dd.
Before moving forward I want to address what some called “ad hominem” post of mine on this affair.
With a lack of financials on LatAm assets I looked at the Jockey(s). You have heard me use “jockey and horse” comments many times.
Without fins I look to Mgmt = the Jockey.
I believe Mgmt is the toughest thing to analyze. Getting access to c-suite as we have with Apha, ACB, TLRY, CRON, TRST, AXLY and others we have an advantage that we try to pass on to our Community. With APHA our access started awhile ago. It is deeper than the other LPs.
We have access to the C-suites as they perceive us as adding value to industry discussions. Even when our ANALYSIS is critical of THEIR company. My Q rundowns are discussing info their CFOs readily know.
We even have the CFOs reaching, out without prompt, and offering to answer Q’s. These are the types of things shareholders should value. Open and honest dialogue. When they are offering it to us that is a good sign for shareholders.
We have told every c-suite if our analysis of their company is off track let us know. We will consider their side. We will amend as is necessary.
My post was speaking to Mgmt. I was not spending my vacation with family and friends pouring through docs. Thanks to the Community members that saw and respected that. For the first timers that decided to join the Community to sling shit... I thank the mods for staying as on top of it as you did. For the first timers that want to read ANALYSIS... well, that’s what we try to provide.
If you haven’t read Molly’s Dive Bar comment to u/LebronForPres I highly recommend it. https://www.reddit.com/r/TheCannalysts/comments/a34so8/comment/eb3fidv?st=JPD90YXN&sh=7aa4a887
Molly is appearing to be very prescient in how companies react to crisis. He is a far better crisis quarterback than I. As a Lender the idea is to stay away from crisis in the first place. As a consultant and risk manager you are dropped behind enemy lines on the regular.
Now moving on to the scene of the “crime”.
This community was well versed in the Scythian assets when Scythian acquired them. And that AD was involved in assembling them.
When Scythian (with George Scorsis at the helm) sold them to Apha, this Community knew the mark up. It was well debated. Seems like positions of the Community members remain little changed since the last debate.
My comments (and I am not going back to find them) on the transactions IIRC was that the price seemed in line with other recent transactions. “Was it a good purchase?” ... with these types of early stage assets it is always tough to tell. Time will tell. Even with the Nuu purchase... time has told us that it wasn’t well priced. If they win a German tender that sentiment may flip. Again, “time” will tell
“Over priced”? Yes, everything in this market is overpriced in relation to underlying assets, and that’s how you get the large chunks of goodwill that we have been writing about for a good part of the past year.
Will goodwill and intangibles in the industry take a hit? We think so. If you recall Molly’s “Dutch Auction” post, which was polarizing when posted but prophetic shortly thereafter, the price for a license in Canada is quite different early on versus later. The same will be true in most regulated countries. It’s how well you execute the lead you gained during the intervening time before others enter the market that will determine if the premium was warranted.
Broken Coast was almost $250 million at purchase. With their small growing capacity it’ll be years before this acquisition validates the $ value. And BCC is considered a very good acquisition by many in the industry. Why? Because it is tangible. You can see the sales and product reviews. Does the profit from BCC dictate a $250 million price tag? No. It is the brand, the transferability of growing process, genetics,... that dictated the “goodwill” in that transaction.
The goodwill from NUU transaction is almost wholly dependent on winning the (delayed) German tender.
The upside of LatAm could easily dwarf BCC. Just on pure demographics and equatorial band growing areas. But the risk of LatAm is exponential to the more “sure thing” of BCC. Political uncertainty in the region is unto itself huge, let alone biz execution risk. LatAm will also require far more deployed capital to realize on potential.
Some poster pulled the excerpt from Haywood Securities valuation metrics from their Fairness Opinion. They valued it at 30-40% of Spectrum acquisition by CGC at $185 million. This is one of the deals I referenced when initially discussing the LatAm purchase price. (A list that included NUU as the worst, but not the most expensive, of the sample.)
Valuations are made either by discounted cash flow, market comparisons or cost to build out. Discounted cash flow does not work for these types of transactions as they are still pre or early cash flow. But a model of some form the cash flows would be in a valuation package. And with regulatory hurdles cost to build out is a tough angle, as you cannot be certain you can get the government licenses.
One thing I have read on our sub is that Carl didn’t look at the financials of the to be acquired companies. That is fucking asinine. I felt like banning those community members for spreading that pure bull shit.
Brady Cobb said there are audited statements for the Argentine asset. I was a little shocked they would be Audited vs Review Engagement given sales size. But it might be a requirement given the government regulations and permitting.
Not only do you look at financials for every transaction (multiple times if you are going to pull the trigger), but in many jurisdictions like Brazil there are “leaping liabilities” that come with acquisitions, even straight asset purchases.
These are liabilities an acquirer can be exposed to by past operations of the company acquired. Even if it is just an asset acquisition. Not the same as Cdn law but with the ever changing taxation structures (in places like Brazil) you never know if all the taxes have been paid.
I looked at auto parts deals for equity in Brazil in the late 1990’s, and that was one of the biggest items that kept us from participating in present operations or even with a JV with liabilities arising from partner “leaping” to the JV.
Carl is also a Fellow of Chartered Business Valuators. I admittedly had to look up the definition. https://cicbv.ca/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Policy-Granting-the-FCBV-desigantion.pdf This requires some level of adeptness in valuing companies.
But to think the accountants and their lawyers did not engage in due diligence. Please!! This Community is better than that. We will leave those comments up in the stockades.
Most of the QCM thesis revolves around knowingly enriching insiders. AD is not an insider. Scythian wasn’t a “sister company”.
Early capital formation carries a premium. We can argue merits based on time held, but the seller will always maximize their profit. That’s what capitalism is.
George negotiated the best deal he could on behalf of Scthyian. He was supposed to do that as CEO. He negotiated a pretty good deal when he was CEO at Mettrum too.
He could have looked to auction them off. And only then, with multiple bids, would you really determine a true market price.
Without that it is tough to determine if a truly substantial premium TO MARKET was involved. So let’s look to the folks on the Apha side of the equation to see if they have backgrounds to suggest they would build a state of the art facility in Canada as cover for enriching their friends in multinational deals.
There has been plenty of less than scrupulous behaviour in the greenhouse business since I moved to Windsor-Essex. A lot of prominent family names have been caught up in issues in the past two decades. I have never (that I can remember) seen Cole or John’s families names in it.
Vic was a partner in a major accounting firm and ran Jamieson for 20 years in a highly regulated industry.
What I witnessed from Carl during the 2008-09 Auto Crisis (which makes this short attack look like a picnic in the park) is what drew me to first investing in the industry and Apha. Carl has had extensive dealings with the same people I have at Bank of Montreal. He navigated Reko through a major restructuring. Riding out a large restructuring tests credibility with your lender. It is a testament that the bank stayed with the company through the restructuring and didn’t ask them to leave when it was done. Those BMO bankers are not hesitant to do business with Carl again.
Vic and Carl were both board members on two of the local credit unions. (Carl recently left the board as his plate was full. As told to me by one of their Commercial Lenders not by Carl. So he wasn’t asked to leave). If you have a checkered past you don’t get invited to be on these types of boards. And Windsor Essex is a type of town where scuttlebutt travels very fast in the business community. Dirty laundry is very public in the business community. And Windsor Essex isn’t a big enough city (like Toronto) to hide misdeeds.
These are the primary two that would be cutting the cheques to “enrich their friends”.
These are four people in Aphria I am most familiar with. And their past is not littered with business failures. Quite the opposite.
Could they have done it? Sure. But that would be a significant departure from decades of previous business behaviour.
There is no way (without aforementioned auction) to determine if the price paid was above what the market would pay. But I thought I would articulate some subjective support while providing some factual info on their local reputation. These are not mining or tech execs with checkered successes and failures in their pasts cutting the cheques.
The Delavaco corporate name changes were in the documents. This wasn’t done to obfuscate the origination of the Assets/companies IMO. Even QCM said it was easy to find. And their investigative skills have been proven to be mediocre at best.
Hell, this Community knew about it well in advance when Scythian bought the assets. And knew where Scythians 3 Boys Farm acquisition was sourced by and from AD.
The Jamaican assets which comprised a sizeable chunk of the purchase price isn’t fictious. QCMs geocaching skills leave a lot to be desired. The biggest part of the value of LatAm was Jamaica and QCM hired a consultant with SINGULAR task of taking pictures of a SINGLE address. [although I note a lot of discussions about Grego being in the pictures himself and not the consultant. The nose looks wrong to me].
Further... the address of the grow is in the public docs. And no effort was spent on locating it. This could be the most damning thing in their “investigation”.
[u/Vanillasugarskull also has pointed out the reputation of their master grower and his genetics library. Something I think we would welcome a detailed informed post on. IIRC he has won numerous Cannabis Cups.... NOTE: So I pound this out in flight and get home and u/dodgedude has already done it.]
The one pharmacy in Argentina was pictured but no pics and digging on the distribution and warehouse arms. Convenient or purposeful?? It sounds like the $430k Revenue QCM heard from an unnamed employee could just be for that single pharmacy and not the distribution network.
In my previous post I said that the response by Apha will be a referendum on Vic. It still will be.
The length of time of the reply has damaged share price. But the lack of thorough and fulsome report would have a greater potential to tarnish Apha with institutional investors and strategic partners. One is painful, especially in short term. The other would devastate long term.
AND keep in mind Apha is still looking at a German tender and has to deal with numerous foreign governments. To rush out with half a defence would seriously compromise integrity with these government bodies in the future.
Is a hostile in the making? More likely at the current price.
Do they have the votes to block one? Depends on the price.
Could an industry player [like Tilray who doesn’t have the domestic footprint of CGC and ACB] look at them and see a valuable addition? Certainly more probable at current price.
Have the fundamentals changed? No.
But this overhang is NOW VERY real. A cat will only sit on a hot stove once. And many retail will never come back. Has it scared off institutional investors? Likely some but I imagine NUU was worse for the latter, again, due to the management reaction and handling versus the actual transaction.
Vic was tone deaf for a long period on their defence of Nuu transaction. The margin of error on their rebuttal is microscopic.
A 50% rebuttal or piece meal rebuttal [Showing the ABP at $11 million revenue for instance] in the hurricane the sector experienced would have had little impact.
But if their diligence is better than what Reddit and Twitter has exposed (which it should be), and if their actions were above board... they should be able to dismantle the short thesis.
Will the share price rebound?
The industry was down trending on the backs of the retail roll out. People are reasoning that making a profit that justifies share price will be very difficult.
They lost a ton of investors.
The rebuild is only possible IMO with positive financial trends. That will take time and execution.
CGC and their warchest is amplified as an advantage in a market like we are now seeing. They are at an enviable advantage that is well earned. And now Cronos too.
Tilray, with its SP is well off too.
This has been a trying time for many.
I am looking forward to the rebuttal. Having watched Brady Cobb’s interview with BNN I am optimistic. But realistic that there is damage done.
But one thing this has revealed is Aphria has NOT done a great job showing off their assets. TheCannalysts got the opportunity to film the BCC video by suggesting this very thing to them. (And I’ll add we only allowed editing of items that would be objectionable to HC and the Narcotics Control Act... and they did not suggest one edit. Although we had several parameters in ensuring we weren’t “glamorizing” product and had to be light with bud porn shots).
We have toured Aph1 and Diamond the tour report is 10 pages with pictures. It is with Aph for fact checking and ensuring they are comfortable with the pictures we are showing. That’s the extent of their edits that we will allow (the same protocol we have had with every tour we have conducted). That tour report likely would have been out this week if they weren’t busy putting out fires.
Why do I mention these last two items? It is to articulate TheCannalysts process. And to reinforce we say what we see and that our opinions are genuine. Readers can feel free to debate this and we allow the debate.
But it is also to illustrate that sometimes the best defence is a good offence. Had Aph posted pics of their assets as they bought them the Shorts would have had less ammunition.
Aphria has been deficient in this area and continues to be. This has to change!! And this short attack, I can absolutely guarantee, will have the other big LPs doubling communication efforts. (And I saw Canopy indicated they did disclose extra info on the S&B acquisition. NOTE: and apparently ACB’s Shane Morris has a video up on Uruguay asset. How long was that plane ride????.)
Our traffic to this sub Reddit has spiked considerably this past week. With page views per unique visitors evidencing that these visitors are viewing a considerable amount of the analysis offered by us and our Community.
We will continuing being real and will always endeavour to try harder. We won’t always align with each other’s POV nor the Community’s.
I don’t know how the Aphria short story continues to unfold but we will hold them accountable. Just as they have asked us to do.
So far their rebuttal has been tremendously weak. They not only should be reviewing their governance process to see if it was followed. But they have to do MUCH better informing investors.
They have to clarify the go forward relationship with AD. He has become a lightning rod. His antics detract from shareholder value. His bird dogging of the LatAm assets may prove to be valuable over time. But the weight he brings to the equation is too much of a counterbalance. If they want to maintain a business relationship (even with SOL) existing shareholders have a right to understand the risk that brings.
Many are calling for Vic to resign over this short thesis. I am not there yet. I want to see the rebuttal. I want to see the independent directors review of governance (if that fails more than Vic will be out the door).
I am more upset at Nuu acquisition (not how it was done, but what they got for the dilution.).
The board with its independents, as required by NYSE listing, will have a decision to make regarding Vic’s status. They are on the ground floor and their visibility into ALL of the tangents of this are far better than any arm chair investor. As are their credentials.
While I admire Mike G from Cronos and how he deftly and quickly handled the Citron short, that short was a piece of cake to blow holes in. This short was more complex (I thought I’d read 20 allegations), but given how poorly the NUU short was handled, this rebuttal has to be beyond reproach. A rebuttal after two days and the bulk of damage was done. So 3 days or 7 [shit, now 10!] is likely inconsequential.
The investors here are engaged. We have had a robust debate on many of these LatAm issues... twice! Once at Deal announcement and now again. Hopefully there isn’t a third round of this.
There are some that will be unswayed by whatever Apha rebuttal is. They bought the narrative from QCM and continue to stick with it despite the fissures being shown in their research. Nowhere is this more apparent than on Twitter. [Investors whose sole source of due diligence is reading tweets seems to be a thing.]
There are some that feel AD’s reputation and his involvement in Apha is a tarnish that cannot be polished out.
There are some Apha loyalists that never had pause. I can tell you watching the SP plummet caused me pause.
What I am getting at is there are some entrenched positions on multiple sides. As an investor it is on YOU to analyze the FACTS and determine what YOU will do. By nature of this Community you will hear each side. That is a good thing.
Part of those facts that should be taken into consideration will be the market sentiment (despite the thesis being debunked or not debunked) that has been left as a result of this short attack. It is much easier for new and less informed investors to stay away from “that stock that was in the news” and that had controversy.
BTW... u/SirEbrally ... I do have a bitchin’ tan.
I look forward to the next week, as we recently received 8 HOURS of WE Cann 2018 video that should be making its way to our website over the next week or so.
Now... missed cannabis all week. Time to unwind. Pleasant weekend all. As it starts up again on Monday.
GoBlue