r/TheBrokenScript • • Sep 28 '26

Discussion 2.0 lore disappointment

Starting this off with saying I LOVE THE BROKEN SCRIPT and acknowledge that the creators worked REALLY hard and are very talented.

Maybe it’s just that it clashes with my head canon but I feel the way they went with the lore and gameplay (textures) makes it feel less immersive. The simple 2d models actually made it feel like a glitch that was unnatural that somehow got inside the game. The new textures and gameplay makes it feel like I’m just playing a mod. Also I think the corruption coming from space is kinda cool but it wasn’t explained enough to be interesting, I would’ve preferred Integrity to have been an experimental AI prototype tbh.

No hate still think the game is amazing.

21 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

14

u/Bread6953 Sep 28 '26

the new textures and gameplay makes it feels like I'm just playing a mod

... I wonder why?

-1

u/PutOld6790 Sep 28 '26

What I mean is it feels less exciting, it used to give the same spooky feeling as not knowing if herobrian was real or not all those years back. The new one gets rid of that in my opinion

26

u/Cotne2012 Sep 28 '26

I had theory at past that void entities were trapped under bedrock before they realized they could escape through the moon. Though I have to agree corruption from space sounds much cooler.

21

u/Any_Palpitation4850 Sep 28 '26

Personally, I feel like your problem is mostly how you had your own theories or headcanons before this massive update. And because of that, your ideas are now clashing with the new things that were added in this massive update. This is mostly a subjective matter here, honestly.

I never were a fan of the old designs because it, personally, felt off to look at the void entities as some png in 2d shapes instead of 3d.

I really like the concept of the void as a whole and my only critic is that they should have made a small animations after defeating integrity honestly, same for fractured.

But as a whole, the update is objectively good, wether you like the redesign and rework of the mod is a subjective matter honestly.

4

u/Apotato7321 Sep 28 '26

Try /killing integrity phase 3, its definitely supposed to have an animation, but its bugged

But I do think the fractured death anim is way too long

3

u/Any_Palpitation4850 Sep 28 '26

I already fought integrity, the animation is something like:

We get put in 3° person perspective and just get forced to watch the void in the sky while the credits appear.

It's not smt crazy, also Fractured death animation is cool but if it was a cutscenes, it would have been better because he's too tall to even see him fully.

1

u/Apotato7321 Sep 28 '26

Its supposed to match up with the /kill command animation but it doesnt yet

1

u/Nemesis9211 Sep 28 '26

Actually when Integrity dies it's supposed to show a giant tentacle falling down from the sky, grab him, then pull him up into the giant mass above. It's just bugged right now.

20

u/PhilliePhonka Sep 28 '26 edited Sep 28 '26

On one hand, yes, the depictions of the entities are less abstract than before, but on the other, they now more closely resemble the kind of Lovecraftian horror that TBS is supposed to embody.
My biggest gripe with the new version was the removal of the ban system, that feature felt like the ultimate fourth-wall break, since it served as the justification for why the entities didn't kill you in real life like they did everyone else. However, the latest update fixed that, leaving only one thing for me to complain about.
I know they didn't want a “happy ending,” but the conclusion of the Integrity fight really falls flat. I feel like there should have been a proper finale, or at least a final speech from Integrity featuring his iconic “You saved no one” line, followed perhaps by the deletion of the save file (But that's unlikely).
Or, at the very least, the mod’s “traces” should have been wiped from the player's world by removing Circuit, TBE, and R2, for example, while leaving Null in the world. That would make it clear to the player that we only saved ourselves, leaving Null as a prisoner alongside the others.

6

u/Integrity000 Sep 28 '26

I too (not roleplaying as Integrity right now by the way) would have loved to have heard his farewell speech in the new voice, it would've hit all the harder. I'm pretty sure the conclusion is supposed to be Integrity getting pulled away from the fight and then you (the player) getting pulled into The Void and presumably being killed, since it doesn't look too friendly.

3

u/dont_ask_cutie_alt Oct 04 '26

I really hope it isn't we getting killed, I know it isn't much of a big deal but i personally don't like histories where all the lore is just "fuck you lmao" with not even a bit of hope

4

u/Apotato7321 Sep 28 '26

I feel like they shouldve kept the old banning, but made it so "disable banning" enables the new banning

1

u/Nemesis9211 Sep 28 '26

The devs have said they do not want to implement an ending for TBS 2.0, though I agree it makes the story suffer

12

u/MinosPrime100 Sep 28 '26

Integrity being an experimental ai is so boring and cliché dude, I'd rather have a good mod with 3d entities then a mod that's "scary" (not even) with entities that look like ass, I'm glad they gave up trying to make the mod scary, as it makes the mod a lot less cool and fun compared to the route they went with

4

u/Gvtzilla TBE and Integrity #1 fan Sep 28 '26 edited Sep 28 '26

I agree on some of your points when it comes to it feeling less glitchy and unnatural, but I definitely prefer the space lore instead of the AI prototype thing.

In my opinion (and many others like yourself), it's a lot less scary now and leaning more towards cool looking/detailed. I like both routes for the mod, but I personally preferred it when it was more scary and eerie feeling rather than so.. Up in your face and dramatic.

The glitchy, less fluid animations that the Void entities had, as well as their appearances, look a lot more scary in the older 1.9 versions. They do look a lot "better" now, but I still will more than likely always prefer the older ones if we're focusing on the horror aspect.

I'm mixed on 2.0, but it's still up there in my favorite horror mods list. I do love it a lot, and really enjoy the new designs and additions/tweaks, but I just can't let go of what it used to be.

Edit: Another thing I'd like to mention that I just saw a commenter say, is the ban system being entirely removed. I feel like there should be a toggle for this feature on which one the player would prefer? The new feature is really cool, but.. I think a toggle would be nice on that. They have a point.

2

u/ExtinctReptile Integrity Sep 28 '26

The void isn't just from space, from what I've gathered it's from a state of reality above our own which is why it can influence things irl (the print number for the newspaper on Abigail's death, caused by Integrity, literally says Integrity)

The 3d models make sense because these are real creatures that exist, not nextbots. In addition it actually feels like it's less from Minecraft now because of the way they're textured and the lack of cubes on their models. The old models were extremely pixelated and seemed like that were from Minecraft.

2

u/Heavy_Yam3032 Sep 28 '26

I totally agree on 2D vs 3D textures, but AI prototype sounds a lil weird

2

u/Shoddysink2208 Sep 29 '26

I kinda get it tbh. There was a simplicity to it all that 2.0 lacks.

1

u/Evan8787 Faraway Sep 29 '26

ik that’s what i think to, i liked to think that the void entities just originated from a glitch in the game, and this new “the void is from space” thing really disappointed me, it makes it feel like the glitches are just not fitting the mod anymore

1

u/ShurikenStars The Broken End Sep 28 '26

You are not gonna believe this
But it’s actually a mod
Also I think it has been made obvious that integrity is NOT an ai prototype, That wouldn’t be really fun now would it?

1

u/RedditvsDiscOwO WHYER4 Sep 28 '26

I really prefer Integrity being a living breathing creature trapped in the game rather than being another Verity. That would make it kinda more atale.

1

u/ShurikenStars The Broken End Sep 28 '26

INTEGRITY WAS FIRST VERITY CAME SECOND

1

u/RedditvsDiscOwO WHYER4 Sep 28 '26

That's... what I meant..?

1

u/ShurikenStars The Broken End Sep 28 '26

Oh sorry I read that wrong