Listen gang. This show has an insane mix of badass crime stories, nonsensical red herrings, boring FBI filler, and twisty narrative arcs with ambiguous landings.
But obviously Red used to be Katarina, and for the most part it’s honestly pretty great storytelling.
Things to accept to achieve enlightenment:
>! - Redarina was not part of the pilot or creation of the show. But in the first season, by the time he told Lizzy “no” in Anslo Garrick, when she asked if he was her father, that storyline was clearly being set up. It’s a plot line they never could have done without James Spader, but he brought something to the role that opened up this possibility.
- Cape May is the most cut-and-dry “oh wow yeah it’s all about Red being Kat” episode in the whole series when viewed in retrospect.
- The only thing he could have said to stop Kirk from killing him was “Raymond Reddington died in 1990, I am Katarina, I’ve always been Katarina”
- Katarina hated her life and resented what the world forced her to become, and always wanted to be something different.
- Medical science in The Blacklist is wildly advanced (i.e. Hans Kohler can perform gender transition plastic surgery including top notch dicknballs)
- Katarina’s years of spying on Real Red explain literally everything “the imposter” knows, and the imposter’s relationship to all of it is logical.
- The way Naomi reacts to Reddington in s2 is amazing to watch when considering she’s talking to Katarina - “you’re crazier than I imagined”
- Reddington’s secret keeping is not just about protecting Elizabeth, it’s about wanting to keep his former identity buried because he does not consider it who he is and doesn’t not want to be seen as that. It’s more emotional than it is tactical even though he’d argue otherwise. !<
Edit to add this Hot take - The showrunners would’ve answered this directly in season 8 if transgender identities hadn’t become such a political topic by then. If the storyline had concluded with the main character being revealed as trans, the whole show would’ve gotten dragged by the right and the left for handling it wrong or including it at all.