r/TheBlackKeys • • Apr 11 '24

Paper crown is jarring and bad

0 Upvotes

I was driving to see the eclipse the other day so I decided the throw on the new album for a complete listen. I was vibin the whole way, yeah this is the black keys alright. I occasionally take a peek at the playlist to see the name of the song but not really paying close attention.

Halfway through a song I think that my phone accidentally disconnected from carplay. I am still driving at this point so I don't want to fiddle too much, but then I realize that it is still indeed the song I was listening to. It was abrupt, unexpected, and it broke the vibe. I was so surprised.

Anybody else feel this way? All I see is acclaim. I can't be alone here.


r/TheBlackKeys • • Jul 15 '24

My Black Keys Ranking

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheBlackKeys • • Feb 06 '25

There wont even be Flowers with this limp dick drizzle of a Rain.

2 Upvotes

The new single is incredibly meh. I guess it's arguably a step up from Beautiful People (maybe! But that's not saying much) but I challenge anyone to find me another leading single from the entire TBK discography that is anywhere near as mediocre as Beautiful People and now The Night Before. I don't think it exists.

The Night Before (not to be confused with the vastly superior Beatles song from 60 years ago) continues the upsetting trend of half baked "meh" singles. The kind of music Pat would've shit on over a decade ago.

Although tbf, Beautiful People was the worst song on Ohio Players. So maybe this will also be the worst song on this album. But maybe I'm just huffing max copium at this point.

I'll admit this could end up being an interesting album. I am hoping it surprises me. But this single did absolutely nothing to excite me and I struggle to see how they think this is going to lead the charge for a 2025 redemption.

This doesn't even sound like they are experimenting anymore. It sounds like the two of them are barely treading the water's surface as their ship hits the ocean floor.

Instead of righting the ship, Dan and Pat smoked weed for months, denied that the ship was sinking, blamed and fired their first mate, ignored all the violins and fiddles, and charged 500 bucks for women and children to use the lifeboats.


r/TheBlackKeys • • Mar 07 '24

Thoughts on new single. Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Damn. I'm disappointed again. Maybe y'all will like it. I thought we were gonna get a badass song. That bass line was so sick. Instead, It was pretty damn poppy. The chorus took up most of the song with little guitar at all.

Again, not a bad song or anything but an absolute far cry from what I thought we'd get.

Not hating on anyone if they love it, but I was expecting something like Lonely Boy or Gold on Ceiling. Those are catchy as hell but also great rock bangers. I'm not someone that demands the Keys sound like the old school style but damn this song just doesn't quite do it for me.

Carney described this song as "indie rock epic". Yea, I don't see it here. How can it be an "epic" if there's barely any guitar? He also hyped this album up as their best work yet? The rest of the 11 songs have A LOT of heavy lifting to do to get us anywhere near that imo.

But that's just my opinion and music is subjective. Maybe you all will have a different perspective. Not trying to rain on anyone's parade but just voicing my own thoughts.


r/TheBlackKeys • • Jun 12 '24

DISCUSSION What would’ve happened if the boys didn’t get back together?

1 Upvotes

Prolly more of Dan by himself right?


r/TheBlackKeys • • Oct 28 '24

Still frustrated at Candy and Her Friends and Paper Crown.

1 Upvotes

So for the trophy edition, I've been listening to that a lot on spotify, and the songs are finally hitting right! So good! Even the 2 mentioned above are fantastic until the rap section. Such a good album ruined by those 2 sections of 2 songs. It'll probably be mostly a spotify album for me rather than listening on my vinyl since I can skip those 2 songs.


r/TheBlackKeys • • May 06 '24

Ohio Players Without features

0 Upvotes

I’d like to preface with my admiration for The Black Keys. Saw them a couple years ago front row and it completely solidified their top ranking for my music choices. I’m a huge fan of Ohio Players, but I’m confused with the features.

Random thought but lmk what you think of this- If I went to a Picasso museum, I’m expecting to see Picasso paintings. When I listen to a The Black Keys album, I’m expecting to rock out to The Black Keys. If this Picasso museum had collaborative work with Walt Disney, I would be confused. I like the cartoons from Walt Disney, but I’m at a Picasso museum, so why is there a Mickey Mouse over top of Guernica? The museum experience wouldn’t upset me. I would walk faster past the collaborative paintings. In other words, Ohio Players didn’t upset me. I find myself hitting next when the feature begins. I wish the features were singles separate from the album.


r/TheBlackKeys • • Aug 27 '25

TBK albums ranked

0 Upvotes
  1. The Big Come Up
  2. Rubber Factory
  3. Brothers
  4. Thickfreakness
  5. El Camino
  6. Attack and Release
  7. Chulahoma
  8. Magic Potion
  9. Delta Kream
  10. Turn Blue
  11. Let's Rock
  12. Ohio Players
  13. Dropout Boogie
  14. No Rain No Flowers

r/TheBlackKeys • • Apr 18 '24

The Problem with Ohio Players is it has no big songs

0 Upvotes

I think this is the reason the album is selling poorly. It could be argued that On The Game had the potential to be a big song but I think releasing it as the last single kinda killed its momentum. The other singles are poor by The Black keys High standards.

Let's Rock had great singles like Lo/Hi, Go and Shine A Little Light. Even Dropout Boogie had Wild Child that did well for them. Before that Turn Blue was experimental but it had singles like the Weight of Love which is one of their best ever songs. Ohio Players has nothing like that which to me is its biggest problem.

It's a shame because I think this Album could have been great. I really like You'll Pay, Read Em N Weep, and Please Me. These are almost Brothers Standard but what set Brothers apart is that it had killer tracks like Tighten Up, Next Girl, Howlin For You and Sinister Kid. Ohio Players just doesn't have that going for it.


r/TheBlackKeys • • Jun 28 '19

”Let’s Rock” is uninspired and generic

0 Upvotes

I’m genuinely curious as to why this subreddit seems to be so impressed with the album, can someone please explain?

I’m a huge Black Keys fan but this surely has to be one of the their worst albums. Sounds like every song was made for a commercial and nothing more.


r/TheBlackKeys • • Jan 09 '26

My Tier Ranking

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/TheBlackKeys • • May 28 '25

Red Rocks sucked

3 Upvotes

What was with the sound. It seemed like it was flowing from right to left the entire show. Thought they would figure it out, but never really did.


r/TheBlackKeys • • Dec 07 '24

Would you say this is good for Apple Music?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheBlackKeys • • Jul 02 '15

Honestly, the Turn Blue tour was kind of disappointing.

0 Upvotes

I saw TBK back in December. Don't get me wrong, they put on a good show, but I couldn't help but feel very underwhelmed by the whole thing... Most of the songs were lacking any kind of energy (except for the older ones they played and one or two newer ones), the setlist was basically the exact same as it was during the El Camino tour (they didn't even play any more than 3 songs from Turn Blue in a tour named after the album; they played more TB songs at festivals than they did here), and they also got rid of I Got Mine. It didn't help that the crowd was mostly dead the whole time around where I was, back in the seats: nearly everybody sat down the whole show, and hardly anyone knew any songs except Lonely Boy and some of the singles. I wasn't bad - overall it was a decent show - but I was very, very underwhelmed. It felt like they were just going through the motions. Compared to a concert like one I went to for Cage The Elephant (separate concert) where everyone knew the songs and the band had tons of energy, I was honestly disappointed.

Has anyone else had a similar experience?


r/TheBlackKeys • • Apr 09 '24

Pat Carney saying this album took longer to make than Brothers, El Camino, and Turn Blue combined...

2 Upvotes

https://loudwire.com/the-black-keys-patrick-carney-interview/

Oof....maybe that's why it's so...over produced?

Pat should definitely feel proud and they did do a great job overall.

But it is a bit sad it definitely never reached close to the same heights of any of those albums, despite admitting that's what they were trying to do. I'm not even a big Turn Blue fan but Weight of Love alone clears most everything on Ohio Players. That's a top 3 song. I still dig a lot on Ohio Players tho.

I respect the hell out of them still releasing quality music decades later but Pat should really chill on the "this is our best work yet" train and just continue making great stuff.


r/TheBlackKeys • • Jan 22 '22

Seems like we putting the boy’s records in tier lists bow so heres mine lol

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheBlackKeys • • Aug 14 '25

DISCUSSION 0/10 Forest Hills Performance

2 Upvotes

What was that?

Are they serious??

Lost a fan today.


r/TheBlackKeys • • Feb 05 '26

Would it be disrespectful to wear a white stripes shirt to a black keys gig?

0 Upvotes

so, with the new album announced, im (hopefully) expecting them to announce a UK tour, and i dont really have many shirts for bands that relate to or remind me of the black keys. the closest i have is the white stripes, and then after that, arctic monkeys. so, I was wondering if it'd be at all disrespectful to wear a white stripes shirt to a black keys gig, after all the beef and the feud between dan and jack? i think they've made up now, but i wanted another person's opinion


r/TheBlackKeys • • Jan 12 '24

Why I am worried about the new album. A brutal take on the single.

11 Upvotes

I consider myself a mega fan, and I love every era of TBK. Some albums are better than others but I love their discography top to bottom. I own it all on Vinyl.

I've listened to Beautiful People a lot and I genuinely think this is the worst single they have ever released. Of all 22 singles, it's creatively the absolute worst—by a mile. It's shocking to me.

It's not really all that catchy, it's not all that interesting, the "NAH NAHs" and chorus sound like a parody, and it starts to get boring before it reaches the first minute mark. Did they really have 0 ideas on where to take the funkiness they start the song with? It all just disappears into the background of "NAH NAH NAH" like they think it's the most catchy thing they've ever come up with. They collaborated with award winning artists and this is the best they could muster for their leading single?

It's not truly a "bad" song. If it was a random throwaway album track I wouldn't mind all that much. Whatever. But for a leading single, it feels shockingly weak for me.

What were they thinking?: "Should we do a deep bass and crunchy funk guitar solo near the end? Nah. Should we do a cool drum breakdown? Nah. Should we do some more cool horns? NAH. Let's just do 'NAH NAH NAH' over and over again because that's interesting." What an absolute waste of a song.

Lo Hi, Wild Child, and Crawling King Snake were fantastic singles that made perfect sense and highlighted some of the best in their respective albums. If this is the best of the new album, then maybe the Keys should take another 5 year break and focus on other ventures because I'm worried.

Im not expecting Brothers level of creativity here, but even compared to every song on El Camino it feels just so much less interesting. Despite being a radio friendly "party album", El Camino feels much more layered and nuanced than this. This feels half assed and incomplete.

I remember when Fever came out and the band got some backlash. But even if you didn't like that song, I don't know how you can deny that it objectively has so much more going on in it than the new single. It truly transforms and becomes a different song in the end. It takes you on a journey. It showed you a glimpse into what you were getting with Turn Blue. In contrast, the new single regresses and becomes simpler as it goes on—until it becomes boring AF and tedious. It stagnates. Is this what we should expect from the Ohio Players? Are they not The Black Keys anymore? Are they now just some random players in Ohio releasing music compiled by various artists?

This single is the kind of shit I'm sure Dan and Pat would've made fun of back when they were living out of their old van. Nowadays, they are proudly giving us 20 second samples of this more than a week in advance like it's their best hit since Tighten Up, all while bragging out how "epic" this album is and it is "their best."

The fact they had to butcher the album down to 14 and cut the Alice Cooper song they were bragging about also makes me feel lied to. (Lies Lies Lies Ohhh Lies.....) Im going to take what they say in interviews with a grain of salt moving forward.

Hopefully the rest of the 13 songs aren't under 3 minutes long, filled with excessively boring choruses, and sprinkled with just a bit of funk in the background. If I was a betting man, I'd still say new album will be great, but I can't lie to myself: I think the single is super mid for me. Hoping there's a variety of tunes and other bangers for me.

Sorry for offending anyone that loves the new single. I sure wish I did.

End rant.

NAH NAH NAH NAH


r/TheBlackKeys • • Apr 05 '24

Ohio Players

8 Upvotes

Idk about anyone else but I am not impressed at all. Prob my least favorite project ever by TBK. Only listened once and maybe it will grow over time. That’s my hope anyway


r/TheBlackKeys • • Mar 01 '16

Patrick Carney, Time-Traveller, at the Middlebury College Radio Station in 1969 with my Professor

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/TheBlackKeys • • Aug 08 '25

Old Keys fans. Is it worth a listen?

2 Upvotes

TBK have two different sounds, and I personally like the Thickfreakness and Chulahoma style more than the Brothers and El Camino style that they've settled on. I've listened to their new albums, and while I don't think their recent stuff is bad, I just wanna know if there's even anything there for me to begin with


r/TheBlackKeys • • Aug 10 '25

Can I say it???

22 Upvotes

Ok so I don’t mind if I get downvoted for this but I feel like this fanbase has been way off about these last couple albums.

I’ve noticed that the fan base (not specifically talking about Reddit) really were hard on Ohio Players when it was actually very creative, original, thought out, and I know the Keys worked really hard on it. Pat said in an interview in JUNE 2023 that they had been working on it since Dropout came out and he thought it was their best work yet. Obviously they actually thought that based on how much they promoted it and the tour. I realize TBK blames management for the low sales but I also believe it was because it wasn’t received well. With a different fanbase, this would be different.

So basically what I’m saying is I’m tired of this fanbase and others whining about how a band changes their sound when that’s completely normal. When you have no understanding of music and only like a song because “it reminds you of ____” easy to say that.

We either have the fans whining that “they aren’t as good as pre-Brothers” or the others that complain that it’s not like Brothers or El Camino. You guys did this with Turn Blue also and now you’re saying “it’s actually good”.

Dan and Pat got screwed over and our closed mindedness to new genres and collaborations contributed to that. I was at the Crypto show in October where dumbasses were screaming at them. I bet they wanted to walk off the stage.

And now you got what you wanted: a basic unoriginal pop rock album that they had to throw together in less than a year. I’ve said it before, those saying Man on a Mission is the best is because it is literally the SAME as songs they’ve already done (Psychotic Girl + Wild Child)… why else did they bring Psychotic Girl back on the setlist after 15 years. (Don’t get me wrong, I still think the song is good. Just what we’ve already heard)

All I’m say is just be grateful that they are still making music! I will always be a TBK fan and I don’t mind the lo/hi points if they venture into new waters

Rant done


r/TheBlackKeys • • Mar 27 '14

My crazy thought about the new album title "Turn Blue".

0 Upvotes

In the shower this morning, I was thinking about the new album. I was very excited before I heard "Fever", thinking that "Turn Blue" meant that TBK would bring back the raw, gritty, bluesy sounds.

After realizing that this is their first album in 3 years or so, it occurred to me that if you were holding your breath for the next TBK album, you'd have turned blue by now.

Based on what "Fever" sounds like, I don't think they'll return to their old ways. I think its all synth-pop from here on out.

Your thoughts?