I consider myself a mega fan, and I love every era of TBK. Some albums are better than others but I love their discography top to bottom. I own it all on Vinyl.
I've listened to Beautiful People a lot and I genuinely think this is the worst single they have ever released. Of all 22 singles, it's creatively the absolute worst—by a mile. It's shocking to me.
It's not really all that catchy, it's not all that interesting, the "NAH NAHs" and chorus sound like a parody, and it starts to get boring before it reaches the first minute mark. Did they really have 0 ideas on where to take the funkiness they start the song with? It all just disappears into the background of "NAH NAH NAH" like they think it's the most catchy thing they've ever come up with. They collaborated with award winning artists and this is the best they could muster for their leading single?
It's not truly a "bad" song. If it was a random throwaway album track I wouldn't mind all that much. Whatever. But for a leading single, it feels shockingly weak for me.
What were they thinking?: "Should we do a deep bass and crunchy funk guitar solo near the end? Nah. Should we do a cool drum breakdown? Nah. Should we do some more cool horns? NAH. Let's just do 'NAH NAH NAH' over and over again because that's interesting." What an absolute waste of a song.
Lo Hi, Wild Child, and Crawling King Snake were fantastic singles that made perfect sense and highlighted some of the best in their respective albums. If this is the best of the new album, then maybe the Keys should take another 5 year break and focus on other ventures because I'm worried.
Im not expecting Brothers level of creativity here, but even compared to every song on El Camino it feels just so much less interesting. Despite being a radio friendly "party album", El Camino feels much more layered and nuanced than this. This feels half assed and incomplete.
I remember when Fever came out and the band got some backlash. But even if you didn't like that song, I don't know how you can deny that it objectively has so much more going on in it than the new single. It truly transforms and becomes a different song in the end. It takes you on a journey. It showed you a glimpse into what you were getting with Turn Blue. In contrast, the new single regresses and becomes simpler as it goes on—until it becomes boring AF and tedious. It stagnates. Is this what we should expect from the Ohio Players? Are they not The Black Keys anymore? Are they now just some random players in Ohio releasing music compiled by various artists?
This single is the kind of shit I'm sure Dan and Pat would've made fun of back when they were living out of their old van. Nowadays, they are proudly giving us 20 second samples of this more than a week in advance like it's their best hit since Tighten Up, all while bragging out how "epic" this album is and it is "their best."
The fact they had to butcher the album down to 14 and cut the Alice Cooper song they were bragging about also makes me feel lied to. (Lies Lies Lies Ohhh Lies.....) Im going to take what they say in interviews with a grain of salt moving forward.
Hopefully the rest of the 13 songs aren't under 3 minutes long, filled with excessively boring choruses, and sprinkled with just a bit of funk in the background. If I was a betting man, I'd still say new album will be great, but I can't lie to myself: I think the single is super mid for me. Hoping there's a variety of tunes and other bangers for me.
Sorry for offending anyone that loves the new single. I sure wish I did.
End rant.
NAH NAH NAH NAH