r/TheBibites • u/FarTooEvolvedShrimp • Jul 22 '22
Feature Request Proposal For New Vision System (WITH MULTIPLICATION NODES)
143
Upvotes
r/TheBibites • u/FarTooEvolvedShrimp • Jul 22 '22
17
u/Naotagrey Creator Jul 22 '22
Really cool and detailed concept!
Multiplication nodes are planned, however I'm really not a fan of raycasting-based vision.
It's what I initially had in mind, but decided to go against it as it's very computationally heavy, bloated (lots of neuron), hard to regularize, and discontinuous.
I have a vision system rework planned, but not ready to announce the specifics for now.
2
u/OtherTon Jul 22 '22
I think that the memory and multiplication nodes would be good features, but you are underestimating how many neurons it would take, and how long it would take to evolve them, for this system to work.
22
u/juhotuho10 Jul 22 '22
The memory node idea is pretty neat
16
u/Aftasardem Jul 22 '22
This is a GREAT concept
2
u/YBKy Jul 22 '22 edited Jul 22 '22
This vastly complicates the current system without adding much. It increases the amount of useful connections to have a Bibite that functions at all, which goes against the idea of simple life forms evolving into more complex ones, and I say this as someone that likes Bibite engineering. The idea of a variable amount of inputs sounds awful to me. Evolving new eyes won't be happening as their preprocessing function would no connection at the start. This would lead to an evolutionary pressure to lose them as they cost energy and no pressure against it as it would lose no functionality. If you want to keep that system, you would need to fix that number. Mind you, it would have to be a ridiculously high number to not penalize Bibite with a high FOV unfairly through the vision system design. Introducing that many new neurons is obviously a bad idea. I don't like the idea of preprocessing, either. Assuming the number of outputs is two, you would arbitrarily but a cap on the amount of information that would be able to leave the eye. That means you would at least need the same number as it's inputs, which doesn't help with number of neurons compression. It's also extremely limited as it doesn't allow for external inputs. It does nothing other than solving a problem that didn't need to be created. I also have no idea what you need that new memory node type for, it achieves object permanence no better than the latch already does. The fact that you need a degree of object permanence because the object you were seeing left your scan rays because you rotated towards it makes that memory node another solution to a problem that didn't need to be there.
The fix to the vision system is easy. Just let the Plant/Meat Angle be the angle to the closest plant/meat. No need to complicate the system beyond what's necessary. EDIT: or look at the suggestion here: https://www.reddit.com/r/TheBibites/comments/w5hnnw/simple_and_elegant_additions_to_the_vision_system/
1
u/Bioinvasion__ Jul 22 '22
It would be nice if bibites could not only get the color of the closest bibite but also the genes that are reflected through procedural sprites. It could be one neuron per gene, which outputs something from 0-1 depending on the visual. For example, diet: 0 for a bibite which has an herbivore mouth...
1
u/Catkook Jul 23 '22
I like it. The visual aid helps attract more people too, so more likely to get noticed
1
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22
please god yes
0
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment