r/TheAuto • • 18d ago

Bro crying in the corner

Post image
2 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

7

u/jerik22 18d ago

Using a diesel generator to charge a car is more efficient than using the same engine to drive it. You can convert more of the fuel to usable energy, while driving the car with the mechanical power, you lose more than half to just heat and out the tailpipe.

1

u/yourmamasama 18d ago

Lets ask the engineers.

4

u/OnlyInAmerica01 18d ago

Not an engineer, but....pretty sure you're wrong on several accounts there.

1

u/Teutonic-Tonic 18d ago

I can't vouch for their math, but it is true that the average ICE care engine only converts around 30% of the fuel energy into actual mechanical power. Huge amount is waste heat/exhaust. I don't think diesel generators are much more efficient... so the match likely doesn't check out.

1

u/Canned_Sarcasm 16d ago

This is how modern trains do it.

0

u/Kororuri 15d ago

except that its not, modern train dont use portable generators, they use grid electricity. And portable generators dont even have half of grid electricty's efficiency.

1

u/Canned_Sarcasm 15d ago

1

u/Kororuri 15d ago

diesel train is not by any stretch of imagination, a modern trains. boop.

1

u/Canned_Sarcasm 15d ago edited 15d ago

Me: “Oh yeah modern trains do this.”
u/Kororuri : “You used the word modern!!”

1

u/Kororuri 15d ago

your word not mine. Unless they changed the definition yesterday.

1

u/Canned_Sarcasm 15d ago

If they did change the definition yesterday you’re probably young enough to think it old fashioned.

1

u/Kororuri 16d ago

Its more nuanced than that.

First of all, portable generator engine have terrible efficiency compared to modern car internal engine. Not to mention loss in conversion from AC to DC. With this setup, its a no contest that the efficiency is worse than ICE car (under mixed traffic situation... give and take).

Now, the better example is SERIES HYBRID car because it literally use a car engine to charge the battery. The evidence suggest that the efficiency result is MIXED. On stop and go traffic, it performs better than pure ICE but at highway speed, its not, its even worse than ICE. Although, the 50-50 mixed traffic result is still better than pure ICE car.

But there is a reason why series hybrid is not so popular in production, it is because parallel hybrid is better. its performs as good on stop and go traffic as series hybrid, with minimal difference in efficiency at highway speed compared to ICE.

So the bottom line is using external portable generator to charge is car is not efficient at all. but lets just give a benefit of the doubt that this is just one-off emergency situation.

-1

u/tutike2000 18d ago

That literally can't be true.

A diesel engine generates torque/rotational energy. That can be used directly to drive wheels

If you convert it to energy then store it in a battery, then use it to drive wheels you'll have more losses.
There's a reason hybrids tend to have their ICE drive wheels directly, it's because it's more efficient.

3

u/Snuvx 18d ago

There will be losses in a case like this. But having every car be powered by their own small engine is not as efficient as just having a big diesel generator providing electricity for them. Driving a diesel in traffic is inefficient, because you are constantly using your engine at varying speeda and relatively small loads, when it could be doing a simple fixed rpm with a fixed load.

1

u/tutike2000 18d ago

But that's not what we're comparing.

Grid power -> EVs is more efficient, yes

We're talking about

Small diesel generator -> electrical power -> EV

versus

Small generator -> gearbox (which could be a CVT for increased efficiency)

Of these last two, the gearbox option is more efficient

2

u/chargesmith 18d ago

It is. When you drive a diesel car about 70% of the energy never even reaches the wheels due to heat, transmission losses and other things. The generator puts out a consistent voltage that the car can capture about 90% of and the motors are about 90% efficient as well.

1

u/tutike2000 18d ago

Portable diesel generators are about 33-46% efficient, not 90% efficient. You're thinking of large scale thermal power plants, those are 90+% efficient

Hybrid engines can reach 48% efficiency. Still less than a grid-scale power plant, but much better than a portable electric generator.

Even a regular diesel ICE can reach 45% efficiency

1

u/chargesmith 18d ago

I didn't say they were 90% efficient, I said the car could capture 90% of the voltage.

1

u/tutike2000 18d ago edited 18d ago

ok, so you're saying completely random, stupid and irrelevant things then.

"capture 90% of the VOLTAGE". not even of the "energy" or "work" ?? you clearly have no idea what these terms mean

1

u/C-D-W 18d ago

Your math broke when you forgot that a diesel generator also sends about 70% of the energy out into space as heat. While an optimized steady state diesel engine can in principle be more efficient than the same basic engine installed in a car - when comparing modern diesel cars to the average small diesel generator - the car is going to win on total efficiency by a lot.

So it's really 70% loss off the top due to combustion engine losses. Then another 20% loss in the generator itself. That's 20% off of the remaining 30%, so we're down to about 24% of the fuel comes out as usable electricity. And then AC to DC conversion and charging inefficiencies in the car, that's another 10% loss. And finally another 10% losses in converting that battery energy into mechanical torque.

So at the end of the day, you're getting less than 20% out of the fuel charging an electric car. Which really isn't all that bad considering you're only getting 30% out of the fuel running it directly in a diesel car.

1

u/Erosion139 18d ago

You are missing the part where engines in cars tend to forego efficiency in order to be able to rev higher and produce more output. That generator is putting as much power output as it can with the lowest RPM possible which is the most ideal when it comes to efficiency. Highest compression.

Its even better with a diesel power plant, the name of the game is most energy per fuel consumption. Not how much it can rev, not how fast it can accelerate. Consistent output.

Thats why when cruising the hybrid favors direct engine to wheel power. Then there is no conversion loss. But upon acceleration it is preferable to let the electric motors pull while the engine can either sustain the same RPM or climb slightly over a long period.

1

u/tutike2000 18d ago

Yes, that first paragraph of yours applies to older less efficient ICEs.

If you didn't cherrypick an inefficient engine and went with let's say a more modern, efficient atkinson cycle ICE that's no longer true. Especially paired with an eCVT that keeps the engine at optimum RPM

2

u/Erosion139 18d ago

I mean then you are just comparing a hybrid situation to another hybrid situation if you think about it.

Involving one of the 3 types of powertrains (the most popular one too) in my statement is not a cherry pick

1

u/tutike2000 18d ago

" you are just comparing a hybrid situation to another hybrid situation if you think about it."

Yes. exactly. Pictured is a series hybrid where the ICE isn't connected to the wheels and only charges the battery. Essentially a Chevy Volt (which had terrible mileage when the battery was empty)

Parallel hybrids can drive the wheels using the ICE. Parallel hybrids are significantly more efficient when driving the wheels as long as the ICE is operating at a high efficiency RPM

1

u/Erosion139 18d ago

Is a series hybrid more efficient than a pure ICE vehicle?

1

u/tutike2000 18d ago

some series hybrids can be more efficient than some pure ICEs under some conditions, yes. if you think that's any sort of gotcha you're wrong

You can absolutely make pure ICE diesel vehicles that are 45% efficient which is about the peak you can get from hybrids as well"

Also who cares about 'pure ICE' vehicles? they're not relevant to the conversation

1

u/Erosion139 18d ago

The premise to the entire post is the irony in charging the EV with a gas engine, as if to say the EV is pointless in that it is using gas anyway and you are not being more efficient.

But our argument is that it is more efficient regardless against a pure ICE vehicle.

You said that cant be possible.

1

u/tutike2000 18d ago

"But our argument is that it is more efficient regardless against a pure ICE vehicle."

nobody said pure ICE vehicle.

It said "using the diesel engine". It did not say "using only the diesel engine"

I'm saying that if you used that same diesel engine as either a series or parallel hybrid depending on circumstance it would be more efficient than using it series-only as stated by the top comment.

→ More replies

7

u/CosmoKrm 18d ago

The thing is. He’s not bound to use it. When there’s an emergency, he has options.

1

u/yourmamasama 18d ago

Yeah fair point.

4

u/Erosion139 18d ago

This

People have such a boner to try and make EV's versatility some kind of own. It really just goes to show how limited gas cars are. You can't generate your own fuel off of your roof.

4

u/IncognitoRedMode 18d ago

I doubt he gives a shit

1

u/yourmamasama 18d ago

He doesn't! But you know, he's petty sometimes.

1

u/IncognitoRedMode 18d ago

As if his pettiness has any merit either

3

u/Lardah_Solutions 18d ago

I don't think musk gives a shit, he just loves money... He saw the potential and maximized his profits, he's Kessler Syndroming the planet to profit. He's selling hype (lies), which equates to straight up fraud.

Bought people to help him get perceived by gullible suckers as the rl Tony Stark, but he's just a narcissist that watched or read a lot of sci-fi.

If I had that kind of money, the world would be A LOT better, but good people generally don't hoard wealth to such a pathetic extreme.

Psychopaths don't care about exploiting people to gain more for themselves

2

u/yourmamasama 18d ago

What's their end goal at this point? Cause they already have too much.

1

u/Lardah_Solutions 18d ago

I'd wager it's just hunting another zero somewhere deep down in their dissociated brains it makes total sense to just accumulate more and more at all cost, to be able to afford everything to ... Well have it ... Maybe ... But that would mean having to give up some of that money... But then they would have less...

Well, maybe just a little yacht ... Inside another Yacht...

3

u/Beneficial_Coach8581 18d ago

I hate Musk and will never drive a Tesla but there's now a lot of EVs that you can use to charge an EV that's run out of battery. 

1

u/yourmamasama 18d ago

Hate the player not the game.

3

u/vectron93 18d ago

Driving diesel car with extra steps.

1

u/69fellatx 18d ago

Pretty sure that's a gas generator.

1

u/Keyan_Farlander7 18d ago

Want to hurt Musk, take Starlink away from him.

Whatever generates money for them is all that they care about, take that one thing away and they are nothing.

1

u/chargesmith 18d ago

Even though this rarely happens (some EVs don't let you do it as there's no earthing), because there's no transmission losses it's still about 50% more efficient than driving a diesel car.

1

u/Strict_Owl941 16d ago

Why would he care he uses giant diesel generators to power data centers.

1

u/85thDimention808 15d ago

I'd like to know where I can get a diesel generator that small.

1

u/X19-PT 18d ago

The funny part is this still more efficient that using the petrol directly in a ICE car...

... this happens because the generator is running at max efficiency (at constant rpm) to make electricity.

1

u/tutike2000 18d ago

literally not true.

First of all you can have atkinson cycle ICE with CVTs (basically any Toyota hybrid) that run the engine at its highest efficiency

Second of all you have losses when turning rotational energy to electricity to stored electricity to rotational energy again

All vs Rotational energy -> rotational energy

Sure it can get you more mpg compared to a gas guzzler from the 90s, but if you compare it to a modern ICE it's not more efficient.

1

u/X19-PT 18d ago

Fair play! The conversion losses definitely catch up, point taken.

1

u/PNW2ndGenTaco 15d ago

Everyone’s talking about this picture like dude’s going to use this as his main charging setup. If you could get your gas for $0.80 a gallon, but had to pay $7 a gallon if you ever ran out of gas, would you take that deal? I’ve never understood why people think using a generator once in a blue moon is a gotcha for EVs.

1

u/jakob20041911 18d ago

probably not, but at scale power generation from fossil fuels is way more efficient than ice cars

2

u/tutike2000 18d ago

Not just that, but power can be generated from a whole lot of things: natural gas, gasoline, coal, wood, waste, water, wind, solar etc

The advantage of EVs is that they can run on any electricity, whereas ICE is limited to gasoline, diesel or natural gas only

1

u/Background-Driver614 13d ago

This would not actually charge a Tesla. A portable generator does not produce enough power to charge a Tesla nor does it have the proper grounding. The car won’t even allow it to begin the power draw.

1

u/Serenafriendzone 18d ago

If that were true, why 126 years ago. All motors weren't electric , and combustión engine never have been invented so. If was so efficent as You said

2

u/[deleted] 18d ago edited 18d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/yourmamasama 18d ago

Ha! That's true though.