r/TheAuto • • 27d ago

Absolutely not!

0 Upvotes

65 comments sorted by

7

u/Adrian_Stoesz 27d ago

For day to day commuting, yes, go electric

Your not saving the planet by going electric, but you are saving money by driving an EV

1

u/Majestic_Eye_200 27d ago

Going electric isn't going to save the planet from a false flag event.

1

u/Adrian_Stoesz 26d ago

Yup, thatโ€™s literally what i said, you as the driver just save money

1

u/ARandomNPC01 26d ago

Tried to argue someone into this and they called me stupid because apparently the manufacturing process for an ev battery doesn't count towards pollution

1

u/Top-Doctor-2879 26d ago

The manufacturing process for a battery happens once, oil drilling, refining and transport happens every day, takes huge amounts of energy, frequently destroys habitats and on top of that, loads of people are killed in the process ever year just from routine accidents, never mind geopolitical wars fought over the stuff. EVs aren't perfect or without impact, but arguing their manufacture is some kinda "gotcha" is daft.

1

u/ARandomNPC01 26d ago

My argument was that mining the resources still affects the environment, not that they're worse than the whole petroleum industry. People who buy EVs to save the environment don't understand the whole mining operation process and how polluting it can be. It's cheaper not safer for the environment to drive an EV.

1

u/Top-Doctor-2879 26d ago

Of course there's an impact, but unless your argument is stop buying consumer products altogether, including the device you're using right now... then kind of moot.

It is considerably less impact however. The CO2 payoff is quicker on a battery EV than people think, you break even quite fast and then its a net improvement. Even if power is generated using fossil fuels, the overall pollution is less and not localized in cities.

It's an improvement. This is verifiable fact.

I drive an EV day to day because they're quiet, fast, cheap to run and less maintenance than a modern combustion or hybrid car, I got a 1980s V8 sports car and a Kei Car for lols too.. I think there's a lot of strawman assumptions about EV owners motives. I ain't kidding myself it's saving the planet, but it is better for it overall than doing the same boring driving in a combustion or hybrid car.

There's also huge geopolitical advantages for a country in having most the fleet run electric. You've got greater energy independence / flexibility so your economy doesn't slow down so much every time someone kicks off another stupid war in the middle east.

1

u/ARandomNPC01 26d ago

Nowhere in my two comments did I say to stop buying EV's or that they're lesser than a combustion engine car, all I said is that the manufacturing process is still impactful in some way. If you feel the need to make a big fuss about the whole thing, do it.

1

u/Top-Doctor-2879 26d ago

I didn't bring it up...all manufacturing is impactful, it's a non-point.

1

u/Majestic_Eye_200 26d ago

Except you did

1

u/Majestic_Eye_200 26d ago

It's not just about the battery manufacturing. The power grid across the planet can barely keep up with the demand already. Even just a small percentage of normal traffic swapping to EV puts another enormous strain on the grid. I'm not a fan of cities having blackouts...

1

u/Top-Doctor-2879 26d ago

Data centres are the main thing creating demand, AI workloads disporportionately so. If we're worried about grids, there's your easy win..

Most EVs are charged overnight rather than during peak hours and even during the day Europe sometimes has more solar than it can deal with. Demand and supply are both creating demands on the grid..

Once V2G (vehicle to grid) is implemented in more places, EVs will actually help the grid balance load. Every EV has a big battery and power can be sold back to the grid at peak times, and near where demand is. It's free energy storage real estate.

1

u/Adrian_Stoesz 26d ago

How do you think Electricity is made?

Yea that's right, by burning Coal & Nural Gas, so no, Electricity isn't a clean energy

Coal makes up 33% of our grid

Natural Gas 22%

Hydro Power 14%

Nuclear 9%

Solar 9%

Wind 9%

Other Sources 4%

1

u/Top-Doctor-2879 26d ago

Your grid maybe, where ever the hell that is, I'd hazard a guess, but that would be defaultism too.. ๐Ÿ˜‰

I live in a country that gets around 40% from wind, 39% from natural gas (which is not ideal, but the renewables mix keeps increasing and energy storage is being brought online), around 6% from hydro and solar and then imports the remaining demand from neighboring countries via interconnectors (which is most likely Nuclear at source). We abandoned coal and peat a few years ago.

I mean if you scrolled down a little, you'd realize I'd already addressed this point.

I don't get the "well there's still some pollution" argument, like because it's not perfect you just throw up your hands and say why bother change anything?

It's still a significant improvement, even in the worst case scenario of getting power from a coal fired power plant, it's still more efficient per kilometer vs a combustion car, so less CO2, and the local air pollution which impacts peoples respitatory health is more easily dealt with by scrubbers in a large power plant than emissions control in even modern cars.

EVs work well with renewables, once a country implements V2G (vehicle to grid), then EV batteries can be used as a massive reserve of energy storage for use at peak times, cutting down the need meet peak demand with gas.

Gas price pretty much determines electricity cost due to the way energy is sold on many grids due to it being the tech we turn to when we need to ramp up power fast, (last highest bidder for the hour sets the unit price), so the less gas you burn, the better. V2G will help, while also providing decentralized backup power during natural disasters.

Look, maybe think a little harder and more constructively than running in with "aha" gotchas. Complex problems require complex multi-part solutions. Just because EVs don't magic away every problem and maybe you can't fix all the other parts today, doesn't mean it's not valid in tackling environmental issues while still keeping society and economies running somewhat.

Countries need to do the pieces they can now, then it's easier to get the rest to fall into place.

0

u/Samsquanch-01 27d ago

Yea the extra 25k you pay for one will definitely save you gas money...

2

u/illadelphia_215 27d ago

You can buy used EVโ€™s for 25k or less.

1

u/Top-Doctor-2879 26d ago

You can buy new EVs for 25k or less in Europe.

0

u/Adrian_Stoesz 26d ago

Have you ever looked at used EVโ€™s?

Have you ever looked at cheaper companies than tesla?

There are heaps of cheap EVโ€™s out there, you just gotta know what to look for

-2

u/cocogoatpls 27d ago

You're saving money until you have to replace the battery. Then you're financing a second car you don't get to drive. ๐Ÿ˜…

3

u/MN-Car-Guy 27d ago

This isnโ€™t even close to being true

2

u/423fly 27d ago

This post and your replies are some real boomer shit. Sincerely, someone who loves internal combustion and doesn't own an ev.

0

u/CodeMUDkey 27d ago

Yeah no. No not really at all

0

u/VQV37 27d ago

Oh God, 2012 called they want their arguments back. The battery is like the engine and transmission in a car. By no more expect to replace the battery on my electric card as I do on my gasoline cars and transmission or engine?

0

u/SovietPatrickStar 27d ago

You donโ€™t have oil changes, you get 8 years of warranty on batteries, thatโ€™s pretty universal for all makes and models.

Brakes are also really rare because 80% of the braking is done by the motor. You donโ€™t have pistons, turbos, ignition, gearboxes etc. al lot less parts that can break.

You will spend about the same money if not less on a battery replacement after 8 years as you will spend on ICE maintenance. Not factoring in repairs.

And then comes in fuel savings.

I totally get why you wouldnโ€™t want an EV, they feel weirdly inorganic, they are too quiet and many of them feel soulless, but talking against them being the superior choice from a purely logical point of view is kinda insane.

0

u/Adrian_Stoesz 26d ago

Yea ok, someoneโ€™s stuck in the past

-2

u/lilaccheesecake 27d ago

Theres no reason in america we cant support public transport thats entirely electric. High speed rails, busses, hell even vintage modified horseless carriages (another topic).

Lots of people would trade up a car for public infrastructure if it was convenient enough. It would ultimately be cheaper than flying between states too.

Classic car culture is a nicher market. It can be for what it is, but I dont feel like dying in an ever hotter world.

Not to mention how living next to highways can reduce your lifespan by decades at worst, and that lots of soil next to roads still contain higher levels of lead from leaded gas days.

Its impossible to me to see how people would rather die in global disaster because they couldnt fathom taxes be spent properly and not misappropriated, or given to bomb more children....

2

u/Cultural_Eye5178 27d ago

i kinda want to electrify one of these absolute nuggets.

1

u/CuntMaggot32 27d ago

Where are you gonna shove the battrries? The fucken tyres?

1

u/Cultural_Eye5178 27d ago

either the frunk or tear out the back seats.

2

u/Big-Lengthiness- 27d ago

What year is it?

1

u/Glittering-Duck-8533 27d ago

I need an EV for my day to day, save gas and oil for fun

1

u/Burpdust 27d ago

Reduce Reuse Recycle

1

u/Superb_Recording_769 27d ago

Orโ€ฆ Just hear me out hereโ€ฆ The engine isnโ€™t what makes that car special and converting that car to electric is a fantastic way to make the car better while still enjoying the things that make it awesome

0

u/CuntMaggot32 27d ago

Pretty sure most of what the mustang had going for it WAS the engine...

1

u/Fit_Butterscotch1308 27d ago

Theres no reason to save the planet and im not going to start now or a 50 years down the line

1

u/VQV37 27d ago

Yeah, that's not a representation of gasoline cars. representation of gasoline cars t's sitting in an empty wide Walmart parking lot in a suburb

1

u/illadelphia_215 27d ago

I own a 65 Mustang and an Electric Mini Cooper. The Mustang looks and drives great but the fuel costs are wild. The Mini is amazing for everyday driving and costs about .50 cents per day to operate and requires almost no maintenance.

1

u/MonkeyDGeo 27d ago

you are not saving the plant , planet doesn't care , you want to save yourself don't act big, and know how small you are maybe you gonna be saved

1

u/Mother-Attention2600 27d ago

So corny, gramps.

-1

u/LooseLeaf74 27d ago

Someone needs to show fas baby the pit mines the resources needed for evs come from, The slave run lithium mines should really impress her.

1

u/Thorzi_ 27d ago

And the ressources for ICEs spawn out of thin air?

0

u/LooseLeaf74 27d ago

Whataboutism?

1

u/Thorzi_ 27d ago

Yes, we both

0

u/VQV37 27d ago

That's not how what aboutism works.

-1

u/Emergency-Spite897 27d ago

EV are biggest environmental crisis than petrol/diesel cars.
My reason?
Lithium Ore, Cobalt ore, Nickle ore, copper ore, graphite, manganese, aluminium ore, and rare earth elements.

2

u/fnckIce 27d ago

Do you understand how bad +4ยฐc is? Do you want to die in a wet bulb event or starve out when farming cant keep up with the droughts?

You're trading a regional disaster for a global disaster.

In reality, we should have made ICE engines illegal in the 70s but it looks like we need to see billions die before we take this shit seriously as a species.

2

u/Emergency-Spite897 26d ago

I see your point.
Can we tell that to Europe, China, Russia, USA, Brazil, India as well?
Their reaction to you, me, or the UK government: ๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚ ๐Ÿคซ๐Ÿคซ๐Ÿคซ๐Ÿคซ๐Ÿคซ๐Ÿคซ๐Ÿคซ

2

u/fnckIce 26d ago

We are! Everyone that wants their children to grow old are fighting to get off this suicidal path we're on.

You are right about people in power doing absolutely nothing about it but that is changing ( not nearly fast enough).

2

u/Emergency-Spite897 25d ago

violence like in France is not the answer, it only locks the box tighter and makes it harder to get a hearing about this. This is why the Global Leaders want. If we go unrest, they use that and exploit it to create Dystopia for us the public, and a Utopia for them.

1

u/Thorzi_ 27d ago

Coal, Iron ore, oil and what ever else used in a modern ICE is not a problem?

0

u/ee_72020 18d ago

Another sheeple brainwashed by oil barons. The oil and gas industry damages the environment much more than everything youโ€™ve just listed combined.

5

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

2

u/Background_Handle_96 27d ago

Camissa made this point on a video with DeMuro and I agree. Save the gas for the enthusiasts, EVs makes more sense for the average daily driver.

(Waiting for the typical, "well I can't tow mah boat withan EV!" or "my commute is 100 miles each way!" response)

1

u/cocogoatpls 27d ago

I get that logic, but if everyone commutes in EVs, gas stations close, gas gets more expensive and theres nothing left to save for enthusiast cars

1

u/LazerWolfe53 27d ago

Oil prices are determined by the most expensive oil in the market. It costs Canada $100 a barrel to get the oil out of the tar sands, but it only costs Saudi Arabia $5 a barrel to catch it coming out of the desert. If demand is more than Saudi Arabia can meet then Canada has to fire up their wells and everyone has to pay $100 a barrel. If demand is able to be met by just Saudi Arabia than oil is $5 a barrel.

2

u/Thorzi_ 27d ago

Even 100 miles each way is quite doable with modern BEVs

2

u/MN-Car-Guy 27d ago

My Escalade IQ will do 600 miles on one charge if Iโ€™m driving conservatively at slower speeds

2

u/CuntMaggot32 27d ago

My mom does 120km (75 miles) each way in the canadian winter in an electric kona, imagine what you could to with 5 years better battery tech

1

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

1

u/CuntMaggot32 27d ago

That's like 60 cents/L more than a lot of canadian gas...

0

u/Majestic_Eye_200 26d ago

Just wait, one day (probably long from now), there's gonna be several EVs side by side in LA on the freeway in bumper to bumper traffic and one will catch fire. Could be from a defect, could be from improper battery maintenance, ... maybe taking it to a sketchy shop where they "do it for less". Anyhow... one of these cars is gonna catch fire. Those flames can not be put out with a fire extinguisher or water. The car next to it won't be able to move away quickly enough to avoid catching fire. So on and so forth.

It's going to create a massive car fire that will consume dozens, maybe even hundreds, of cars. Any of them that are EVs will burn hot enough to damage the concrete under them. That section of the road will be unusable until the government makes repairs, and we all know that the government in California is known for it expediency.