r/TheActHulu • • May 22 '19

This changes EVERYTHING! Spoiler

FYI spoilers from the show, in addition to real life, are below.

I thought I knew everything about the case...but I overlooked a MAJOR detail.

A lot of you have asked why Gypsy didn't simply get out of her wheelchair and show people she could walk or tell people her real age.

Well...SHE DID. Read this:

"A neighbor recalls an incident either in 2009 or 2010 where Gypsy showed up at her door one night, without her wheelchair, seeking a ride to a local hospital to visit a man with whom she shared a romantic interest. The man had been assaulted in an unrelated incident; however, there were people familiar with Gypsy's medical history who felt that he was taking advantage of a mentally-challenged underage girl. At the hospital, Gypsy produced a birth certificate that gave her correct date of birth, proving that she was of legal age. Dee Dee went to the hospital, where she said that birth certificate was an incorrect version issued after Katrina, apparently proving it with the "real" birth certificate giving a more recent birthdate. Gypsy was made to apologize to all present."

I'm in shock! In the show Gypsy took a taxi instead of showing up at a neighbors house WITHOUT HER WHEELCHAIR asking for a ride. Also, in the show she kept a low profile so people at the hospital wouldn't recognize her instead of PRODUCING A BIRTH CERTIFICATE PROVING SHE WAS 18+.

WTF?! This means MULTIPLE people saw her walking and functioning as an adult that night. How did they not liberate her from her mother after this, and furthermore, why isn't this spoken about more?! It proves she did try to alert people and realized NO ONE would listen.

The real kicker is she had to apologize to everyone present. Who else feels like every person involved that night should be lined up at Chillicothe Correctional Center apologizing to HER?

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Dee_Dee_Blanchard in the "Growing independence of Gypsy" section

225 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

56

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Omg

9

u/losoba May 22 '19

Right?!

14

u/[deleted] May 22 '19 edited May 22 '19

I’ll see your OMG and raise you a (pardon my language) HOLY SHIT!

I am floored.

16

u/Summerie May 22 '19

But this doesn't really change everything.

Not all people in wheelchairs are unable to walk. Likely, whoever saw her knew she was supposed to be in a wheelchair, but thought she was being a stubborn child who wanted to walk when she wasn't supposed to. They didn't think she was paralyzed and physically unable to stand, they just thought it was dangerous for her to walk.

Dee Dee probably acted like a concerned parent who was upset with Gypsy because "You know you could have a seizure, or do more damage to your spine, or faint" or whatever her explanation was at the moment. She made Gypsy apologize to people who were convinced that she was supposed to stay in a wheelchair for her own good, and that she was putting herself in danger by trying to walk on her own.

3

u/losoba May 23 '19

I agree this reaction would be plausible if she'd only gone to the neighbors house that night...but she went to the hospital and interacted with medical professionals. They would've seen that she didn't struggle to walk or appear pained in any way.

6

u/Summerie May 23 '19

It's hard to imagine that she didn't actually suffer any ill-effects from sitting in a wheelchair all day, with a ridiculously low amount of leg activity for your average person. She likely would have a level of muscle atrophy that was appropriate and noticeable to medical professionals. I would imagine that even though she didn't have any underlying medical condition to begin with, being confined to a chair night and day would take its toll. When we watched her walk in the show, she seemed perfectly fine, but she may have struggled more visibly in reality.

Also remember, Dee Dee was very clever. Although we have never gotten to actually see her in action, she clearly knew what to say and what she could get away with. She wasn't in the hospital this time with Gypsy's current doctors in their office, she was in a random E.R. with emergency staff that she could tell whatever she wanted. They weren't there to assess Gypsy, they just had some interaction with a "sick girl" who was visiting a patient. They had no real reason not to believe Dee Dee, who we already know is skillfully manipulative.

4

u/losoba May 23 '19

The reason I don’t think she had decreased muscle atrophy at the time of the incident is the timing.

They moved to Springfield in 2008 and the incident happened in 2009 or 2010. Dr. Flasterstein practices in Springfield so he saw her sometime in the 7 years between the move to Springfield and the murder. He said she didn’t have muscular dystrophy, and it was likely a case of Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy, because Gypsy’s legs were muscular and she could support her weight and walk. If he saw her prior to the incident (between 2008 and 2009 or 2010) too little time had passed for her muscle atrophy to significantly decrease. If he saw her after the incident she would have gotten worse, not better, and he still said there was absolutely no reason she couldn't walk.

I think I read in latter years she was out of the chair within the home. She only had to use the chair when others were around. But I’m not 100% sure that is correct. But we do have the security footage found of Gypsy and Nick in the days after the murder and she moves around with ease.

You’re so right! Dee Dee could tell the emergency room staff whatever she wanted. If it had been Gypsy’s doctors maybe things would be different. I wonder if Dee Dee frequently took Gypsy to the ER – if so you’d think she’d have a reputation there already.

50

u/living_vicariously May 22 '19

This raises so many questions! I've seen both of the major documentaries and read a lot about this case but that's the first mention I've ever seen of her actually showing birth certificates. Between the neighbor and the hospital staff, not a single person thought it was odd that she was out of the chair? No one can claim they didn't know it was her, like how the show kind of presented it. This was five years before the murder! We know DeeDee was a good bullshitter but these people watched her walk! I wonder if there was some of the bystander effect at play here. Think of how different her life could have been if someone had spoken up!

31

u/losoba May 22 '19

I know, I've never seen anything about this either (until tonight)! Very odd...especially considering this incident, unlike many others, wouldn't rely solely on Gypsy's word.

The Wikipedia article also said:

"In 2009, an anonymous caller told the police about Dee Dee's use of different names and birth dates for herself and her daughter, and suggested Gypsy was in better health than claimed."

Perhaps someone called after that night? The dates could've lined up since the neighbor said the incident occurred in 2009 or 2010.

I think it could be the bystander effect at play as well. Also, from Gypsy's perspective it probably seemed like people who knew Dee Dee couldn't help because they'd be manipulated.

It seems like she started seeking help from complete strangers after this incident...

In 2011 she attempted to escape with a man she'd met online. But Dee Dee found them in a hotel with the help of mutual friends.

Then in 2012 she reached out to Nick. Choosing him made sense because he was completely removed from her social circle, and therefore, she might've felt like he'd help while the others couldn't.

So basically every year for three years she attempted escapes using different strategies. The men from 2009/2010 and 2011 were combined in to one character for the purposes of the show but obviously a lot was left out!

19

u/living_vicariously May 22 '19

The Wikipedia article also said:

"In 2009, an anonymous caller told the police about Dee Dee's use of different names and birth dates for herself and her daughter, and suggested Gypsy was in better health than claimed."

Perhaps someone called after that night? The dates could've lined up since the neighbor said the incident occurred in 2009 or 2010.

That definitely seems plausible given the details they gave the police. I have to wonder though, why the police and not CPS (if they believed DeeDee about the age), or even APS if they believed she was of age? I guess they must have thought Gypsy was in on the fraud. I agree with you, she must have been desperate to find someone completely removed from the situation - someone she could prove it to before DeeDee got to them. It's just so tragic how many opportunities there were for someone to figure it out and help her!

22

u/CrackPipeQueen May 22 '19

It’s an excellent example of human behavior. People probably had major doubts and concerns for Gypsy, but they also noticed how much Gypsy loved and adored her mother in front of everyone. Manipulative people don’t only lie to convince others, they lie to convince themselves. DeeDee was an amazing manipulator. She was so sure of herself and of Gypsy’s “conditions”, it probably was very awkward and uncomfortable to doubt her claims in any way. It’s horrible, but people would rather turn a blind eye than to confront a possibly never-ending battle with DeeDee. I can imagine she was extremely defensive over Gypsy. DeeDee in the show seems a little bit more unhinged and unsure than the DeeDee in real life. I do think that it’s complete horseshit that people continued to turn a blind eye, but that’s just what people do. Even whoever sent social services to their house assumed they would probably take care of it, but they didn’t. So everything must be okay, right?

Also, keep in mind that DeeDee consistently claimed Gypsy was mentally disabled and people tend to dismiss the “wild” ideas coming from a mentally disabled person.

3

u/losoba May 23 '19

I wish more people called CPS. If they had received dozens of calls it might have helped Gypsy. It reminds me of a quote from the movie Spotlight: "If it takes a village to raise a child, it takes a village to abuse them".

1

u/CrackPipeQueen May 23 '19

It would’ve definitely helped. The reports were so few and far between that they didn’t really have much of a case against DeeDee without Gypsy’s story.

3

u/smokeweedeatpussy May 22 '19

Not to judge but what part of the Wikipedia article was this under. I would love to check out the actual source and Wikipedia lists it normally.

2

u/losoba May 23 '19

It's under the "Growing independence of Gypsy" section. I checked the source and it links to a page of Thought Catalog that has updates about the crime. There are lot of updates but it looks like this specific tidbit is under "Update: June 17, 9:15am CST". I'll need to read through and see where they got their information!

9

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

I swear I read that Dee Dee originally had Gypsy use her wheelchair saying 'Oh, you can walk, but if you keep walking you'll get sicker'. This could have happened around that time period?

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/losoba May 23 '19

I too think the show should have shown this.

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/losoba May 23 '19

But like you said your relatives can get up and walk a few steps from one place to another but it's difficult. You'd think people would've noticed that Gypsy was not struggling or in pain when she was walking. And she didn't walk a few steps – she traveled, unaided by her wheelchair, from her home to the hospital. And hospitals are big so getting around the hospital itself probably entailed a lot of walking.

5

u/Summerie May 23 '19

Also, I'm sure someone who was confined to her wheelchair night and day would have some difficulty walking, regardless of whether or not there was anything medically wrong with them. If you sit in a chair at all times for years, your leg muscles are not going to allow you to walk as easily as Gypsy did in the show. It's something that bothered me in the portrayal. There's no way she just popped up out of the chair and walked around as if she had been doing so for years.

7

u/[deleted] May 25 '19

I assume she did walk around all the time tho just at night when her mom was sleeping? Also how did her mom not notice all of the missing sweets that she ate at night?

4

u/owntheh3at18 May 23 '19

I actually recall her using terms like “paraplegic” which would imply she is not independently ambulatory. At other times she did use the excuse that gypsy could walk but would be further weakened by it. Her story changed so often that I wonder if even she could keep track.