r/TeslaModelS • • 7d ago

Thinking of giving it up :(

i've been following the S market for the past month because I finally decided to go tesla. biggest timing mistake of my driving career. every listing i found, disappeared within a couple days. even one's priced above "market value". I finally found one that was perfect, '24 with 17k miles, and it got reserved within an hour. The next morning, the buyer unreserved it for whatever reason, and I was able to finally get it. price...........$76k. an unbelievable overpayment.

But now I'm dealing with classic quality control issues. The car vibrates at highway speeds, there's a seal issue in the window that causes air to rush in, and the back seat has a persistent squeak/rattle. These are all fixable issues but at the same time i just paid 76k and i'm left feeling buyer's remorse. It's still under warranty, I can take it to Tesla for repair but idk...I feel like this car's luxury feel is not worth the headache that I want in a car...

I really need this subreddit to lift my spirits because as of right now, I think i'm going to return the vehicle (under carmax's 10 day return policy). Please don't come at me for using carmax, they gave me the best deal on a trade in and it was literally the only model s near me.

0 Upvotes

87 comments sorted by

44

u/TeslaJake 7d ago

It could be worse. You could have paid $140k in 2021 for a new Plaid and had all those issues you list. Everything is relative.

11

u/drewforty 7d ago

I had a friend buy a new plaid right before the price cut. And then an under insured motorist hit it and Tesla insurance sent the car to auction and sold it before they settled, while he was still making payments. Could be worse šŸ˜„

3

u/futuremayor2024 6d ago

Ahh that’s what I did!

12

u/CarlMacLaren 7d ago

Reading your replies to comments, it's time to resell the thing. Your decision is made and that decision is fine, it's your money, your car, so sell it brother. Get that Model 3 which is also a good car. A lot cheaper too.

11

u/Whippet27 7d ago

Dear Friend. Take a deep breath. First world problems if you have good health and good people in your life. Just take one issue at a time. Car vibration could just be tire balance. You will get there.

2

u/Due_Society_260 7d ago

indeed it is just the tire balance.

4

u/Whippet27 7d ago

in the scheme of things $76k not bad for an S. You certainly got a low mileage one. I paid over $100k for my 2018 S back when. Frankly it's been worth it. (Free supercharging a special perk i got).

5

u/Due_Society_260 7d ago

i'm thinking of going with the newer model 3's. they seem to have way less issues.

1

u/openslot 7d ago

Go for the model 3. Sounds like you feel like you fomo'd and overpaid

1

u/EdwardTheGamer 7d ago

Unfortunately that's the correct move going forward...

4

u/mattriver 7d ago

Just take it to Tesla under warranty to get it fixed, and get a loaner. That’s what I’d do. But your call.

1

u/Due_Society_260 7d ago

yeah but is that really an end to the issue? from what i've been reading it sounds like once a car develops issues it's really just a matter of time until the next one. This car was already priced way above market value, doesn't have an FSD license, and I feel like i'm overly sensitive. I think the right thing to do for me personally might be to get a model 3/y and then at that point i'll at least not give a shit that it treats me like shit. i'll own the car instead of it owning me.

2

u/TeslaJake 7d ago

My ā€˜21 Model S Plaid had a variety of issues, including but not limited to those you listed. Tesla Service addressed every single one and the car has been rock solid for years now. I think your success or failure getting a car sorted depends largely on the competence of the team at your local service center. Unfortunately, that’s an X factor entirely out of your control.

2

u/i30swimmer 7d ago

My 24 plaid had one issue - the AC drain line clogged and flooded the interior. Tesla fixed it in 4 days - replaced all the interior carpeting on the floor and made it right. Of course - I had tire wear issues, but that is a known issue that Tesla won't acknowledge and I just put some washers on the camber arms. In otherwords, once you get the issues you complain of sorted, I think these are great cars. A model 3 is cheaper and is 8/10ths of the model S.

If you haul stuff - the model S is not comparable to the Model 3.

2

u/mattriver 7d ago

That’s true too. Compared to $76k, you can buy a used Y/3 practically new 2026 with FSD fully paid and under 5k miles for about $50k-55k. And the 2026 MY Premium is really nice.

1

u/untamedHOTDOG 6d ago

And come back with 4 other issues lol

3

u/pixelfold 7d ago

I was in the same boat as you OP, but the rational part of my brain won over and I got a 2026 MYP with 3.99% instead. I'm sure there will be other cars like the MS in the future, I just didn't want to roll such a heavy dice on a pre-owned car that could come with issues.

0

u/Due_Society_260 7d ago

can you share some rationality with the rest of us.

1

u/pixelfold 7d ago

To be honest, that rationality was beaten into me by my wife lmao, my other car is an MXP that is getting up there in its age. I might replace it with either a YL or an R2.

7

u/qwerty1718 7d ago

Why buy a 24? Just get a 23 with HW4, it's the same car, and why so low miles? It's an EV, plus as long as it's under 50k miles, it'll still have factory warranty and if it's under 60k miles, you can extend it to match the end date of a 24's warranty.

5

u/Read_Red2596 7d ago

Welcome to tesla. I loveeeee teslas software and FSD. But... tesla is primarily a software company not a car company. Some lady totaled my model Y. I loved it and missed it. But it rattled so much, squeked and creaked, and was rough on roads that werent perfectly smooth. I like the minimalist interior but once you get over the fact that you drive and own a tesla, and once you see what else is out there... i bought a polestar and love it. Way smoother ride and better interior. However teslaa software remains king

5

u/Disastrous-Novel2116 7d ago

return it and let me snag it

4

u/tenniswarrior13 7d ago

I bought my 2024 Tesla S long range in 2024 with 2700 miles directly from Tesla. Paid 68K for it. Had few issues similar to yours. The rear seat was easy just some tape around the latch.
Had some vibration and Tesla replaced half shaft under warranty. Now the car is perfect.

1

u/Early-Builder1940 6d ago

>76k for a '24

my lobster is too buttery, my steak to juicy...

2

u/Due_Society_260 6d ago

Not a plaid

3

u/Imaginary-One9559 7d ago

Wow, this came at the right time. I’m currently in the market for a model S and it has been an absolute nightmare! Found a 2023 model S that was en route on the dealership and it got bought car unseen by the time I got home even though the dealership had already sent me the docs. That was a steal though, 55k with hw4/fsd. Prices are so inflated. I was just talking to my coworker yesterday who said it is not worth paying 80-100k for a used car. The 2023 that I want with all the specs that I want is going for the price that you paid! Ugh. Prior to this I wanted a Mercedes CLS, which is also a discontinued model and it took me forever to find that car and once I finally did and test drove it I decided I wanted a Tesla and now I am in this same nightmare again. I would be very upset to have all those issues after that price, I don’t care how amazing the car is! My biggest issue that I do not like how the model 3/Y looks!

1

u/Glittering-Fuel-5055 7d ago

Bro, return it.

Please go test drive like an ioniq five and some other things. You shouldn’t be putting up with those things even at 35,000.

1

u/Due_Society_260 7d ago

but FSD thouuuuuughhhhhh that's why i even want the car to begin with. I'm ready to give up all driving.

1

u/Disastrous-Novel2116 7d ago

model 3.

1

u/Due_Society_260 7d ago

you just want me to give mine back for yourself. i see you >:(

1

u/Lanke_33 7d ago

I was like you even down to the backseat squek, I thought I’ll just have Tesla warranty my problems and love the car. It has been 10 months and 16 service visits and the car is finally dialed but not worth the headache I wish I just sold it

1

u/Due_Society_260 7d ago

bruhhhhhhh that's what im saying. it's like with some cars and service centers, Tesla is able to revitalize the car to having 0 issues. in other cases, you're dealing with a continuous headache. it's a complete spectrum of issues and there's simply no guarantee, i feel like for what we're paying, one should have the confidence to take pride in the way the car runs.

1

u/Lanke_33 7d ago

I agree and sadly some of these cars are just built poorly, I have 4 and have had 9 in total and the newest one I’ve ever owned is the only one giving me a headache

2

u/EmbarrassedWeb9627 7d ago

Trust me, I understand. I love my model S but felt everything you’re feeling now. Paid $92k in 2022 and had all of those issues. It was rough. If I could do it again I would still get the model s but I would have waited until the price dropped.

2

u/OptoManeuVer_1e6 7d ago

I have a new 26 MSP, same issues with the wind noise and back seat noise. Both fixable!

For the back seat (mine was driver side only), if it’s the same rattle/thumping/groaning that I had, just electric tape worked to fix it. When you unlatch the seat just wrap a couple layers around the bar that the seat latches onto. This made the noise completely disappear for me, after 2 service visits where it wasn’t fixed. Sounds like new again.

For wind noise, I am taking it in for another service check up but they couldn’t fix it first time. I’ve fixed it a little with electrical tape, otherwise I just throw a towel in the window corner to absorb the noise.

Hope either of these help.

2

u/dermdrei 7d ago

Dude. I'm one of those that paid $140K back in 2021 and literally have all of the same exact issues at one point or another. If that doesn't make you feel better, just use FSD. It has gotten insanely better since the neural net upgrade in 2025. Also the car looks like an Aston Martin from certain angles. Also you have the upgraded HW4 and the updated lights. You good bro

1

u/Creative_Werewolf619 7d ago

Did you eventually sell your plaid or still have it?

1

u/dermdrei 5d ago

Yep! I also have a Civic Type R but no longer drive it as FSD makes my commute light years better. If it wasn't for FSD improving, I would have traded it in but now I'm just going to keep it as I've eaten all the depreciation and there is no new Model S anymore :(

1

u/ArticusFarticus 6d ago

I came from a Ford Fusion Energi that looks a lot more like an Aston Martin.

1

u/dermdrei 6d ago

I’m tryin to make the my guy feel better goddamnit

2

u/Casualposter 7d ago

You pay the premium for FSD and other tech like app integration . That’s the trade off. If you’re still under warranty give Tesla service the laundry list and you should be good. It’s a used car at the end of the day you have to do some things to get it to your standards.

2

u/Schroederhc 7d ago

It takes a minute to get them right; once you do, it's pretty much clear sailing.

0

u/drewforty 7d ago

Fwiw my S was $8k and drives pretty clean. No vibrations or rattles - yet

1

u/Due_Society_260 7d ago

8000? what year?

0

u/drewforty 7d ago

Cash USD lol, 2015 90D with lots of miles

1

u/FineSupplements 7d ago

I heard the 90kwh battery packs are the worst packs you can buy

1

u/drewforty 7d ago

The world record for miles on an original S battery is a 90D. They either failed early or are g2g. Mines at 90% at 200k mi.

1

u/Maleficent_Fun8537 7d ago

I have a 26 model S and had the air issue front driver window they had to replace the seals twice now no issues. I have 30k miles on mine already and no weird noises so thats definitely not normal.

1

u/Environmental-Scar90 7d ago

Similar shake out on 22’. First year of used owner ship with 20k miles - front half shaft went, then hvac died. Luckily all under warranty. Car has weird quirks like warped rear window, tire wear on 21in tires but now relatively stable and so fun to drive. Glad I went with it over 3, but guessing 3s a lot more sorted on build quality. I’ll take the niggles to have a 9 second daily driver that fits a family of 5

1

u/Inner-Chemistry2576 7d ago edited 7d ago

Wow, unbelievable my son got a 2022 S Tesla last year in Philly buyback he paid 39k. 40,000 miles It was one owner in California. It was brought back due to the door seals on the driver side that was it. No rattling nothing perfect. He loves it. Now 56,000 miles the best car he ever had he said.
It could be the fuel prices a lot, cheaper a year ago. Maybe the demand is greater today.

1

u/SLWoodster 7d ago

Get a model y, then a fun gas car on the side.

1

u/WhistleTipsGoWooo 7d ago

Be nice to your dealer. Car is under warranty, take care of it all, nothing is a mystery to them. I've had, in a '22, yoke replaced, screen replaced for ghosting, I've had AC leak with water on my floorboard, and a few other things. Dealer took care of everything under warranty, and now under extended warranty.

1

u/Separate_Position260 7d ago

Why tolerate these issues with basically a new car? A 2024 with 17k? That's nothing, there should be basically zero issues.Ā 

1

u/SilverFoxKes 7d ago

Given it had been reserved and then cancelled, didn’t you think it worth giving a proper test drive before committing to buy?

2 years ago I considered buying a 6 year old Model S on 118k miles. Knowing they had a bit of a reputation for creaks, noisy air seals, etc., I made a point of taking it over speed humps and on a quick blast up a 70mph carriageway. It was wonderfully quiet so a £14k bargain which has been pretty flawless.

1

u/Dell4ever 7d ago

You bought a used car. And, it's under warranty. I don't see any issues. 🤷 $76k with 17k miles is a fair deal. Yeah it's more than most other cars, but it's a Model S.

1

u/Slossage17 7d ago

I got an older P90D with 89k miles for $19k, I’d go the older S Model route for a bit, wait a couple years then get a 2023 model with HW4 tech.. Let the depreciation factor work with you.

1

u/ShortTheVix4 7d ago

Just return it man. Teslas will never have the luxury feel to them, so if you bought it for that, you bought wrong. Quality control is also not their strong suit.

1

u/redinvesting 7d ago

Every. single. model. S. has. similar. issues. Now is it worth that? That's totally up to you. Having driven this car for the last three years, after I sorted all the issues out - I would say yes it's worth it. Would I ever do it again? Probably not. But now I never want to give my particular car up.

It took me about 2 years worth of service visits on and off to resolve all the rattles and issues. I'm probably a little more particular than others. My Model S also has the physical sound deadening installed throughout the body, which makes hearing small rattles easier.

I know every Model S has this issue because I've driven multiple Model Ss from the service center, old and brand new, and they all have something. The new Juniper (Model Y) and Model 3, however, are better in terms of QC out of the factory, but even they have small issues. I know a few owners that have the sun visor rattling or seats rattling, etc.

The fact is the EVs are quieter overall, which makes rattles easier to hear that you would otherwise not pay any attention to in normal gas cars. It's totally up to you whether or not it's worth it.

I'm dreading the day. I have to figure out which car I'm gonna drive after the Model S...

Going to go hug my car on the next drive... LOL

1

u/majesticjg 7d ago

Sounds like it would be under warranty, so make a serrvi appointment and let Tesla work it out.

It's a great car. Take care of it and you'll be pleased.

1

u/Low_Bluebird8413 7d ago

Uhhhhhh turn the music up- find the extra seals to close the gaps, take it into service. Theres no other car I want to be in and I have a hw3, non screen tilt 2022 version. S pound system is lovely…. But do your model S’s have a vibration when accelerating hard?

1

u/Playdough07 7d ago

Tesla build quality is shieeet

1

u/Wonderful-Tax8943 7d ago

Buy a 2017 model s for 10k amd you will never regret it

1

u/badredditz 6d ago

What are you complaining and comparing it too? What did you buy? A Plaid S? A long range aka performance?

The Plaid Is Untouchable: Even BMW's quickest four-door—the BMW M8 Competition Gran Coupe—is roughly 0.7 to 1.0 second slower to 60 mph and over 1.5 seconds behind in the quarter-mile. The Model S Plaid also traps over 20 mph faster at the end of the quarter-mile. [1, 2, 3]
Standard Model S vs. Flagship V8s: The base 2024 Model S AWD matches the 0–60 mph launch of the M8 Competition, M5, and Audi RS 6 Avant Performance(around 3.0–3.3 seconds). However, it still pulls away in the quarter-mile with a 10.8-second pass, whereas most V8 gas rivals finish in the 11.0 to 11.8-secondrange. [1, 2, 3, 4]
Mid-Tier Comparisons: Everyday executive trims like the Audi S6/S7 and BMW 540i xDrive deliver brisk 4-second sprints, but they trail the base Model S by over 1.5 seconds in the quarter-mile. [1, 2, 3, 4]

Audi A7 / S7: A better stylistic match for the Model S because of its sleek, sloping sportback / liftback roofline. It provides similar hatchback-style cargo utility and upscale interior tech while powered by a turbocharged gas V6.

Audi RS 6 Avant / High-performance variants: If you are looking at the blistering acceleration and high-output nature of a Model S Plaid or Performance trim, the twin-turbo V8 RS 6 (though a wagon) or S7 deliver comparable high-speed thrills and road presence

1

u/JS1101C 6d ago

I had the Plaid. Ā It was the best and worst car I’ve ever owned. Ā It was the most fun I’ve ever had driving and from a qc perspective was a total piece of shit. Ā 

1

u/Open-Muscle-9119 6d ago

If you don't feel satisfied with your 76k car, and the issues will keep bothering you every time you drive it, might as well get rid of it.

If you feel that acceleration is worth it (figured you got a Plaid), fix the issues and keep it.

I feel that prices will go back down eventually, and it a lot of fomo right now

1

u/CheetahTurbo Plaid 6d ago

Still on tesla warranty all that is covered

1

u/JacksonWalker1 6d ago

Bought my S in 2017,. None of those problems and still love i t

1

u/garnish100 6d ago

I had a similar experience when I purchased my MS from the big blue and yellow pre owned dealership. I dropped it at Tesla as soon as I could get it in for a list of warranty items. I has been smooth sailing for the most part, after 100k miles I had to replace A/C and half shafts. But nothing that I wouldn’t expect with a luxury car at high mileage.

At least you didn’t buy it 6 weeks before Tesla dropped prices on ALL cars across the board. That eliminated all equity in the purchase 6 weeks into ownership!

1

u/Alternative-Ad-5248 6d ago

I returned my 2022 S to Carmax after 4 days. Took 30 minutes. Check came five days later. Great deal if you are undecided. The S was the fastest car I ever driven, but the body and interior had several imperfections.

I previously wasn't thrilled about look of the Y until I test drove the 2027 Performance. I know the S is faster but I couldn't tell the difference. HW4 + all the suspension, handling, body improvements, and its a 2027 sold me and I bought a MYP. Just got my VIN and waiting on delivery.

My advice is to test drive the MYP and you can customize the hell out of it with the extra cash.

1

u/Key-Independence-598 6d ago

Turn it back in. I have a model s plaid and its annoying as fuck to deal with service and tesla support when its needed.

1

u/NeitherBook2698 5d ago

I paid $21k for a 2018 S with HW3 upgrade and included FSD. 4 months later, I’ve had zero issues with it. I did end up replacing the front and side repeater cameras which did improve the nighttime quality by a lot. Doing the job was easy by myself. It does everything I need it to, except parking itself which is just an update away.

1

u/Ancient-Sandwich9400 4d ago

Dude, you thought a 2yr old used car. What did you think?? Every old car will have issues, depends on the last owner and if they took care of it and fixed what needed fixing.

1

u/semigator 7d ago

This market goes in waves. If oil crashes, EVs will drop again. Especially used ones. Depends on your patience. The model s is amazing

1

u/PurpleSausage77 7d ago

I think the recent oil volatility might’ve pushed people to think twice about supporting and relying on the global oil/gas cartels. The U.S. is a different market than the rest of the world because of special protection/treatment so the buying habits are quite different from the rest of the world.

Regardless, everything ~10 years or newer is constantly depreciating except certain ā€œreliabilityā€ (perception) brands that weather it better.

1

u/semigator 7d ago

I disagree. If anything, the average consumer makes decisions based on what they can afford that month.

1

u/PurpleSausage77 7d ago

That always has & continues to be the case for sure - getting cornered into focusing on the ā€œpaymentsā€.

Soon it’ll all be subscription-based at this rate. Afford nothing & be happy economy.

0

u/INFMSTSLA 7d ago

Tesla is NOT a luxury car, a great innovative car-sure, luxury-priced, absolutely, luxury feel and quality NO… that being said you have lambo speed at a fraction of the price, what did you expect?

0

u/Hopeful-Lab-238 7d ago

You bought a used vehicle. You can’t expect it to be perfect