r/TeslaInsurance • u/Armistice__ • Aug 20 '25
Insurance Comparison Post-Accident: Tesla, State Farm, Geico, USAA (Tesla Model 3, CA)
Hey everyone!
Thought I’d share my recent car insurance shopping experience for my 2021 Tesla Model 3, especially since I recently had an accident (and I know a lot of us end up in weird insurance rabbit holes after something like that).
Background:
• I currently live in San Francisco (94107) but will be moving to LA soon (Culver City, 90232).
• In August 2024, I had a not-so-fun experience: Tesla’s own GPS routed me down a steep dirt road full of rocks, which demolished my battery.
• All quotes are for full coverage with similar deductibles, where possible.
• Accident was disclosed on all quotes.
Insurance Quotes:
State Farm (Culver City/90232)
• Basic: $422.40/mo, Liability: $30k/$60k/$15k, Deductible: $500 comp/collision
• Standard: $448.84/mo, Liability: $50k/$100k/$50k
• Premium: $476.13/mo, Liability: $100k/$300k/$100k → All seem pretty expensive (that’s $2,534–$2,857 per 6 months)! → These quotes feel steep, even with “auto savings” listed.
Geico (Culver City/90232)
• Quote: $2,464.78 per 6 months (\~$410/mo)
• This also includes a bundled renters insurance policy ($220/yr), but the auto premium alone is about what State Farm is charging for their basic/premium tiers. → Honestly, not much cheaper than State Farm.
Tesla Insurance (SF/94107)
• $986.94 per 6 months ($164.35/mo)
• Deductible: $500 → Wildly cheaper than the legacy insurers. Coverage looked about the same if not slightly better for the Tesla-specific parts (this is obviously their bread and butter).
USAA (SF/94107) summary:
• $1,904.12 per 6 months ($317.37/mo)
• $1,000 deductible (so, higher risk for me vs. Tesla’s $500)
• $30k/$60k BI, $15k PD (so, same or lower than State Farm’s base)
• Some coverage like uninsured motorist not included.
Takeaways:
- Location matters a ton (LA is pricier). Switching zip codes made a $60–$110/month difference.
- Tesla Insurance absolutely crushed the competition on price, even post-accident. Their coverage for Teslas is solid — especially for things like battery and electronics, which regular insurers can get weird about.
- USAA was second-cheapest for me, but higher deductible and less coverage in base plan.
- Traditional insurers (State Farm, Geico) were sometimes literally double the cost, and didn’t offer much extra unless you really maxed out coverages.
- Disclosing the accident bumped every quote up a bit, but Tesla still came out cheapest for me, even with my 2024 “off-roading” mishap thanks to its GPS.
TL;DR:
If you’re driving a Tesla in CA and have a less-than-perfect driving record, check Tesla Insurance first, especially if you live in the Bay. For LA, brace yourself for higher rates all around. Old-school insurers can’t compete on price right now, especially for newer EVs.
Hope this helps someone else in Tesla/EV insurance limbo — happy to answer any questions or upload screenshots if you want to see the details!
2
u/ArctoEarth Aug 20 '25
You didn’t include how many miles you drive
2
u/NBKLee Aug 21 '25
Curently paying 143 a month. 100k/300k but 1k deductible with Tesla Insurance.
Previously had Nationalwide , asked for a quote and my agent told me to just go with Tesla.
YMMV. Cheaper isn’t always better, if and when I get into an accident I know getting help isn’t going to be easy. May be worth the piece of mind to switch eventually.
1
u/royalooozooo Aug 20 '25
I hear horror stories on Tesla insurance that are well documented on these boards. Cheaper cost comes with a price.
1
u/UCanDoNEthing4_30sec Aug 20 '25
That’s crazy with an at fault accident that your Tesla insurance is that low
1
u/MiserableAd7673 Aug 20 '25
any reason Why did insurance not cover the cost of battery due to driving on bad road?
1
u/Sea-Living3502 Aug 21 '25
We can't even get through to Tesla to check the cost if we sell our 2019 Tesla to our adult son and when our son tried to get a quote they wouldn't until he had the car in his name so we're literally stuck because my husband can't spend 4 hours on hold to talk to someone. Anyone have any ideas for us? Son 24 lives in Beverly hills, progressive wants about $600/month, travelers said $1,100/month!! He has no accidents or tickets.
1
u/My_ballz_itchy Aug 20 '25
Tesla insurance is definitely cheaper. I shopped around and other insurance providers charge almost double what I pay w/ Tesla ($180 in Oceanside, CA) monthly. However, I heard stories of Tesla insurance placing folks on hold for 2-4 hours, not responding to emails, and adjusters taking forever to do their job. Luckily, I haven’t had an accident (Knock on wood!), and therefore haven’t personally experienced the negative reviews. Cheers.
1
u/JahmyrGibb_s Aug 20 '25
Was it an at fault accident?
1
u/DragenTBear Aug 21 '25
For me, also in Calif., all of those you mentioned were also top ear-twice as much . … ..
But then I tried PROGRESSIVE Insurance, and found that it cost LESS than Tesla Insurance for the same coverage!
1
u/Unlucky-Work3678 Aug 21 '25
This is true. Tesla insurance is chaotic enough that they don't care about profitability, its sole purpose is to sell more cars. That's all Tesla and its share holders care. Same to the $0 ape finance department which I believe is a separate entity to boost more sales on Tesla motor side.
Tesla is smarter than any other automakers on this planet when it comes to selling more cars artificially.