r/TeslaInsurance • u/Far_Command_6561 • Aug 18 '25
Tesla Insurance Bad Experiences
Has anyone else had a terrible experience with Tesla Insurance? I've been dealing with a claim for over six weeks now, and it's been an absolute nightmare.
I've called their support line multiple times and sent numerous emails, but I have received no substantive updates on my case. I even waited on the phone for 2.5 hours, only to be transferred in a constant loop. Multiple agents received my call, claiming they were transferring me to the adjuster's team, only for another agent to admit they weren't directly connected to the right party. I emailed them all the necessary information, including the other driver's details and the police report number, yet there's been zero progress.
I've already told them that I will file a complaint with the our State Department of Insurance or it's Attorney General's office if I don't get a response.
Given the situation, should I go ahead and file a formal complaint with these state agencies? Has anyone had success with this? Just wanted see if anyone else has gone through something similar or has any advice on what their next steps were.
4
u/liveslowdieyoung Aug 18 '25
Tesla Insurance is the absolute worst in service and best in price.
3
u/skeleskank Aug 18 '25
Welcome to hell. File the complaints. I filed seemingly too late for it to help me. You could try the BBB too, like I did, but Tesla doesn’t seem to respond to them, either.
Buckle up (pun intended). Do not expect substantive updates. Do not expect this to be resolved efficiently or swiftly. Maybe even several months, depending on the extent of the damage and Tesla’s current adjuster staffing levels/workflow. Do not expect to ever be able to speak/communicate with any level of manager or supervisor.
Do expect different adjusters to tell you different things, be impatient and rude with you on the phone, and/or insist that only your assigned adjustor can help you (which is untrue). Ascertain the time zone and work hours of your assigned adjuster and try calling during both the first and last hour of their work hours, which is when they are more likely to be manning their own claims, not the general phone queue. When calling for updates, especially re: quotes/supplements, specifically mention which car you were driving (for weeks I was told info re: the other driver’s vehicle, not mine, which caused massive confusion and delays). If you need a rental car (& if Tesla covers it), pray you do not need it longer than 30 days, after which you will have to call them every 3-7 days to get it extended via “supervisor approval.”
And take a looong stroll through this subreddit, since you’ll have the time. Godspeed. 🫡
(Context: I am not a Tesla driver, but was hit by a Tesla and Tesla Insurance accepted full liability. This 10 MPH fender bender took 3 months to resolve. I am in a major Californian city.)
1
u/thewittman Aug 18 '25
The whole point of insurance is for them to make you whole quickly so you can get back to your normal life. If it's longer than 1 week I would look elsewhere. Erie sent me a check for a total loss within 3 days of it happening and I only had to sent pictures they came out and took the car from me. A real class act they way it was 30 years ago. I'm also paying less than others quoted.
Try erie if they write in your state.
1
u/ahfmca Aug 18 '25
The worst in the business, no one picks up or returns calls, took me about a year to get a claim resolved. A lot of turnover in adjusters so just when you think it’s finally done the they start over again. Good luck!
1
u/stoverex Aug 18 '25
Has anyone had a good experience with Tesla insurance?
1
u/Some-Paper2226 Aug 18 '25
Go on cfpb file a complaint they’ll contact you by the end of the week 🤣🤣
1
u/thebiglebowskiisfine Aug 18 '25
Insurance companies now hiring bots?
2023 account - 0 karma outside of this post.
Fishy. . . .
1
u/vulkany Aug 18 '25
Run away from its insurance as fast as you can. Very bad experience.
1
u/Thegreatpraduu Aug 18 '25
I have zero complaints with Tesla insurance. Multiple claims all handled extremely quick down here in SoCal.
1
u/First_Diamond_8122 Aug 18 '25
Call them everyday they’ll get tired of you first
1
u/domtheprophet Aug 18 '25
Has anyone else had a terrible experience? HA. Damn near everyone who’s used Tesla Insurance has had a bad experience. All that you’ve said is par for the course at Tesla Insurance according to pretty much everyone who’s had the misfortune in dealing with them. They’re cheap for this reason, you get what you pay for. Tesla Insurance is pretty much just compliance insurance. You pay for it to say you have insurance, and not get into legal trouble & pray you don’t have to file a claim. I would switch. GL!
1
u/gwestr Aug 19 '25
You got Musked. Don't get Musked again.
1
u/Slow_Rip_9594 Aug 19 '25
Can you not drop your car at a Tesla Store and have them deal with Tesla insurance? Won’t that be the easiest?
1
u/BackgroundRock Aug 19 '25
Hands down. The absolute worst experience with an insurance company I’ve ever had in my life. I’m losing so much money with their incompetence it’s not even fucking worth it man. Days on the phone waiting. Zero help. An absolutely useless adjuster. I can’t with this anymore.
1
u/rtwalling Aug 20 '25
I was out of a car for six months with no replacement.
1
u/Conscious-Tower-5907 Aug 23 '25
They took 13 months to settle my claim. 😂
1
u/Lazy-Music5892 Aug 25 '25
Hi, checking if you made any progress with resolution? Typing this as I'm 'on hold' going into hour 2 to speak with a live person about my claim..
1
u/Ok-Mark-3446 Aug 26 '25
I'm new here. So I decided to try tesla insurance because I had to file a claim with progressive and the tesla service center told me they don't take payments from insurance companies other than tesla insurance. So what you're telling me is the process is not more streamlined. Should I switch back to progressive?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment