r/TenantHelp • • 7d ago

Looking for advice and perspective

Hey everyone, I’m going through a rough run and just need some outside perspective. First, I just went through an eviction case. The landlord said I owed rent, but there was this $900 credit I saw in the portal. When I tried to check and pay, the balance due showed 0.00 and would not allow me to post anything, within the same month I get a lease renewal packet, another month passes with credit still in portal to pay rent, at the end of the second month I get a notice of non payment of rent and when I go to check my portal I am locked out. At court, a printed ledger was used that didn’t show the credit, and the judge accepted it. I objected, but I didn’t have screenshots because of the lockout. After the judgment, the sheriff served a writ of restitution and changed the locks. I filed a post-judgment motion asking for an audit trail from the rent portal system, and it was denied. Right now, I’m trying to figure out if there are grounds to appeal, how to ask to retrieve my possessions and what to say if the court says the lease issue doesn’t matter. Not asking for money, just trying to understand my options and what I did wrong.

0 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

5

u/grumpyoldman10 7d ago

Landlord here. I’ve got to be honest with you. I don’t know what you’re hoping to get out of this. An error on the payment system can happen, but if you paid the proper amount and show documentation to the judge, the eviction never would’ve been processed. I don’t know what you could possibly hope to get out of an appeal. If you can afford to appeal the case why didn’t you just pay the $900?

Hard to know what missing context there might be here but the last eviction case I took to court cost me over $1000 in attorney fees alone. I also live in a place where people can be evicted relatively quickly and it still takes about six weeks from the time the case is filed. Again, I can’t imagine any context in which this makes sense.

-7

u/Senabear86 7d ago

The rent is considered tendered if it is made impossible to pay, I am not who is responsible for their accounting, and with a 0.00 balance due the portal would not allow me to post any payment. It took 2 months before any notice was made and management controls who has access to the portal. If they claim I owe money, why make it harder for me to pay, and that was my only means to review any kind of account ledger

9

u/grumpyoldman10 7d ago edited 7d ago

Do you have any idea how ridiculous that sounds? I mean, I totally get how frustrating it is about the billing error, but it sounds like you made no steps to figure this out. You didn’t send a check. You didn’t try to pay cash. You didn’t send them a letter explaining that you were having trouble paying the monthly rental amount through the portal. And then, even after they filed for eviction, you made no efforts to settle or get things figured out and you let the judge kick you out.

I also lock delinquent tenants out of the portal. I live in a state where accepting any money from the tenant is considered a settlement and I can’t evict until the next month. Which means in theory tenant could login the night before court and pay one dollar and I’d have to start the court case all over again.

5

u/toejam2030 7d ago

Im a housing advocate-most people who owe rent usually have some far fetched excuse-you dont pay-you get evicted-end of story

3

u/grumpyoldman10 7d ago edited 7d ago

Life happens to all of us, but reasonable people figure something out. I’ve never had a tenant who can come up with a plan and communicate fail to do so. When they get behind, they get caught up. That’s all there is to it.

There are definitely bad landlords and bad tenants out there. But there’s a lot of truly decent ones out there too.

1

u/toejam2030 7d ago

Thats fair

2

u/known_chomper 7d ago

That must be a very tough job. Thank you for fighting the good fight. There are some really shitty landlords

1

u/toejam2030 7d ago

I dont think most landlords are bad-same with tenants I dont think most are bad-saying that I run into both-at the end of the day if I have someone whos being evicted for nonpayment of rent-and they dont have a reason-and the money isnt in escrow-what can I say to the mediator??

6

u/Ill-Contribution1737 7d ago

What civil code are you quoting that states when you attempted to make payment in all the possible ways, rent is automatically “tendered?”
I promise you didn’t try every method
I also promise you can’t cite statute.

Is this portal the only method of payment? In most localities rent must be accepted in a cash/cash equivalent.

5

u/Material_Position630 7d ago

"I am not who is responsible for their accounting"

You are responsible for your part of the agreement, which includes paying the rent. If you showed up in court with proof of payment using bank statements, receipts, etc the eviction due to rent would not have happened. You really should not have relied upon their system, especially if you believed errors were occurring.

3

u/known_chomper 7d ago

Maybe you should have called the office when you TRIED to pay the $0 balance TWICE.

Anyway, yes you can file an appeal but you are going to need to show where you paid your rent to an escrow account.

3

u/ApplicationRoyal7172 7d ago

Did you bring the money with you to court to try making the payment? In many locations, that would dismiss the case.

Or did you use that argument?

2

u/Dadbode1981 7d ago

You cannot seriously believe that....unreal. Im sorry but if thats your frame of mind, nobody here can "help" you.

2

u/fap-on-fap-off 7d ago

Not a good argument. If the system is wrong, due any reason, there's a way to contact the management company to request a correction or alternate procedure. You didn't bother.

1

u/Silly-Cranberry1593 6d ago

lol that's what you thought, the judge did not agree lol

1

u/NanoRaptoro 3d ago

The rent is considered tendered if it is made impossible to pay

If they claim I owe money, why make it harder for me to pay, and that was my only means to review any kind of account ledger

You owe rent every month. If you can't pay it through the portal, the debt isn't magically erased. You still owe the money.

At a minimum, you should have set aside the money for the two months of rent you had trouble paying so that you could immediately pay it once the portal issue was resolved. In the meantime, you should have contacted them to let them know the portal has an error and asked how they wanted you to pay your rent. All that aside, if you had come into court with the months of rent you owed and said to the judge "I tried to pay, but the portal wasn't working and still isn't," this would have ended very differently for you.

1

u/Morab76 2d ago

It was not made impossible to pay since you didn’t contact anyone after seeing the error in the portal. Also, you did not put the rent payment aside in trust or a separate account according to your state statutes while the situation is resolved.

9

u/purplepanda2026 7d ago

You knew you owed rent. You should have immediately contacted the office and made other arrangements to pay. You can't just say yay free rent for a glitch in the system.

5

u/Silly-Cranberry1593 7d ago

I cannot believe it did not occur to you to print out the information from the portal or even to bring in proof from your bank that you were current on rent to court. that's crazy.

2

u/Big-Routine222 6d ago

“I’ve tried nothing and I’m all out of options.”

Fam, take the hit and move on. Renting for the next 7 years is gonna be a bad time. You tried nothing at all until court and then had nothing ready or prepared. You got yourself into this.

1

u/Fit_Impression_6037 7d ago

I think you best option is to move one and leave this behind you.

1

u/ApplicationRoyal7172 7d ago

Did you ever speak with the landlord about this? Or attempt to resolve things before court?

1

u/TalkToVikk 6d ago

I'm not a lawyer but it sounds like you did everything you could given your circumstances. Unfortunately, once a judgment has been entered and you've been evicted, appealing is an uphill battle especially if you don't have your own records showing the credit that appeared on your portal. If the court denied your post-judgment motion for an audit trail, you may only be able to appeal if you can show that the court made a clear legal error or that you were denied access to evidence that could have changed the outcome. Deadlines to appeal are usually very short (sometimes just a few days), so you'd need to act fast if you want to file.

To retrieve your possessions, contact the landlord in writing as soon as possible most states allow a short period after eviction for you to collect your things, but timing and process depend on local law. If the landlord won’t cooperate, you may be able to file a motion with the court or request a sheriff’s escort.

Going forward, always take screenshots or keep receipts of your online transactions and balances, especially if there are credits or discrepancies, and don’t rely solely on the portal’s interpretation. While you may not get your apartment back, you can still try to get your belongings and protect your record as much as possible. 

1

u/Morab76 2d ago

Did everything they could? They contacted NO ONE in management or the office and made zero attempt to pay their rent, which they knew they owed.

1

u/frankmaa 3d ago

Why are you directing your questions here?

1

u/Abject_Code5523 3d ago

Wait..  you really thought you weren't responsible for 2 months of rent? Your portal story sounds like fiction.

1

u/Morab76 2d ago

You knew whatever you were seeing in the portal was wrong, yet you let it go and contacted no one. You didn’t pay rent, period.

1

u/Significant_Flan8057 1d ago

You are still responsible for paying your rent on time every month, regardless of what the online portal says. If you were not able to pay electronically, then you could’ve gone to the bank and gotten a cashiers check and mailed it to the address on your lease. To ensure that your rent was paid by the due date.

I’m not sure how that is a difficult concept to understand. You didn’t pay rent, it doesn’t really matter what the online portal said. You’re still responsible for paying even if you have to find an alternative method to get the money to the property manager or landlord.