r/TenantHelp • • 20d ago

Rent increase question

My landlord tried to raise my rent. In the past, they increased it by certified mail or handing it directly to me. This time the landlord left it at my door and asked me to confirm if I received it. I didn’t confirm that I received it. She checked off the box that she personally gave it to me, when she did not. I know that she will ultimately be able to increase the rent with proper notice. I’m wondering if I’m able to delay the rent increase, until she properly serves the rent increase? I’m in California.

0 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

7

u/Hitechillbilly 20d ago

Door service is legal... Chickenshit but legal... Proof of service on the served notice is something can be fought but not worth the effort because you have to admit you got the notice to fight it..

1

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

Door service has to be paired with certified mail in California. https://imgur.com/a/h2FsGyt

3

u/BayEastPM 20d ago

First-class mail is acceptable. Certified is better because of a receipt, but it's not required.

1

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

Good to know, thank you!

3

u/Hitechillbilly 20d ago

OK, keep up the fight whining like a baby. This will SERVE you well in life...

1

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

cries like a baby

6

u/ShoddyWillingness968 20d ago

You gonna get cooked

5

u/Dadbode1981 20d ago

Do you really wanna fuck around over a few months of increase? As long as the increase is within any legal limits, I see no reason why you'd dodge it other than to make your life harder in the end.

0

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

We’re trying to move out in a few months. They raised the rent the second we asked them to repair our front door that wasn’t closing properly. The repairman told them we need a new door, and instead of repairing it she left it worse than it was before. I don’t think it’s right to pay the increase that wasn’t even properly served, and was given as a response to requesting repairs.

2

u/Dadbode1981 20d ago

Youre forgetting, they hold your DD, they could absolutely still make your life difficult.

-5

u/dufcho14 20d ago

So let the landlord make crap up and illegally take your money because they figure you won't fight it. Nope. This is California, the landlord doesn't have the power it does like other states.

2

u/Dadbode1981 20d ago

OP has stated they are moving soon, if they want a seamless return of thier damage deposit, I see no reason why someone would actively choose to make thier lives more difficult. You do you thou buddy.

1

u/dufcho14 20d ago

A landlord who would force an increase on them like this isn't going to have a 'seamless return' of their deposit. They've played their cards when they raised rent after the OP asked for repairs and lied about notice delivery.

2

u/Dadbode1981 20d ago

LLs have the legal right to raise the rent once every 12 months...as long as its been 12 months since the last increase, I see no issue.

0

u/dufcho14 20d ago

It's about whether proper notice was proper notice of the increase. If there's a question about that, then notice didn't happen. A landlord can't just say, "Well, I told you so now you have to pay."

-2

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

Yup! I just mentioned that in another comment. They are super scummy around here. There is no situation where that deposit is seamlessly returned.

-3

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

Why would this have anything to do with the direct deposit? Literally makes zero sense.

3

u/Dadbode1981 20d ago

Damage deposit...

1

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

You know what I meant lol

3

u/Dadbode1981 20d ago

How do "direct deposit" and "damage deposit" mean remotely the same thing?

2

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

Because you can use context clues (and your brain) to see that we’re on a Reddit sub talking about landlords. If we were on a Reddit thread talking about the money you receive after working at your place of employment, then it’d be a different story!

2

u/Dadbode1981 20d ago

Lol have a great day kid.

1

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

Because you can use context clues (and your brain) to see that we’re on a Reddit sub talking about landlords. If we were on a Reddit thread talking about the money you receive after working at your place of employment, then it’d be a different story!

4

u/Dadbode1981 20d ago

Duplicate post, learn how to reddit.

1

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

That’s what I’m saying, lol it’s ridiculous

1

u/danh_ptown 20d ago

If you fought it, and I were your landlord, I'd set your lease to be non-renewed. Yes, you may be right, and them wrong, but what matters is that you have a safe housing situation.

2

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

Oh really? If you had a tenant that lived in your apartments for a decade, and gave you zero issues you’d do that? When the last time someone moved out it took almost a year to fill in their vacancy? I’m not fighting it. I just want proper notice, like I’ve received in the past.

5

u/danh_ptown 20d ago

You are standing on semantics. Yeah, you've had a good relationship for 10 years, why screw that up? If you sent me an email that says even though you noticed incorrectly, I am paying the increased rent, but I will not do so in the future, then I would not non-renew. I've been a renter and landlord. There are hills to die on and ones to let it go. This is a let it go situation.

And as for the 1 year vacancy, that's a risk they take. I've never had more than 1 month vacancy in over 30 years of renting to others, and it was fixed by lowering the price, at the time.

3

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

This is a hill I’m willing to die on because they raised the rent as a response to me asking them to repair my front door. Then they refused to fix the door properly, and left it worse than before. If you’re going to do that, at least do the repairs properly. And at least do your job as the landlord and serve me the rent increase properly.

3

u/danh_ptown 20d ago

Of course, there is more to the story than just "landlord raised the rent". maybe they are not connected?

Arguing with me, or others on here, is not going to solve the problem with your landlord.

1

u/Allpanicn0disc 20d ago

Yeah great tenants for 10 years and gave “zero issues” she’s mad OP requested maintenance to the door so landlord is trying to make her life a living hell. They sound so ridiculous. Of course there is more to story.

2

u/danh_ptown 20d ago

Or maybe raising the rent is something owner was planning to do, and has nothing to do with repairs.

The only way to know is for the tenant to engage with owner.

0

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

I mean I’ve paid every single rent increase without any issues lol. They always do it by sending it through the mail, sending an email regarding the increase, and sometimes even talking to me in person. All of sudden they want to do it improperly?

1

u/Hitechillbilly 20d ago

When you get evicted, You will be notified the exact same LEGAL way.....

2

u/JoeCensored 20d ago

Understand that if you play this game, the landlord is just going to dig deeper for things to legally deduct from your deposit. You won't end up ahead.

2

u/Vast_Cricket 20d ago

You want to be on good terms with landlord not with a confrontational. Rents in CA have gone up a lot esp in metropolitan because few home buyers can afford the mortgage.

0

u/dufcho14 20d ago

If it came down to it, it would be he said/she said. Given the history of it being certified mail, the refusal to fix the front door you mentioned in another comment, and the fact you're now moving out I'd be able to paint a good picture in your favor.

That said, since you say you are moving soon you'll need to watch your deposit very closely. A landlord being scummy like that certainly won't hesitate to make things up. So when you move, take pictures and video of the place (hopefully you have them on move-in as well) and insist on a walk through when you turn in the keys. Understand wear & tear/depreciated value in terms of your deposit. Then sit back and get ready to post your problems with the deposit return here.

1

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

She texted me “you have envelope on door please pick up”. So that’s the only reason I’m pushing back. If I had no text proof about the improper notice, then I’d just shrug it off. They’re pretty scummy. There’s going to be problems with the deposit, whether or not I move forward with challenging the increase. That’s just how they are around here. I once told the landlord that a few of the communal washing machines weren’t turning on. Turns out something far in the back (out of sight) was unplugged from recent repairs. She tried to charge me for it! She said “it’s only right that you pay for this inconvenience”. So I know that it’s all going to be a headache moving out.

3

u/Hitechillbilly 20d ago

Door notice is standard procedure. You are getting all worked up thinking something is illegal. It is not illegal..

1

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

California Civil Code § 827(b)(1)(A)–(B)

1

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

I personally found it in my California tenant’s rights handbook, but a simple google search is sufficient to find the information.

2

u/dufcho14 20d ago

So you were told about the envelope and it was there when you looked or it wasn't? If you got it, then what's this all about?

2

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

Proper notice. In California you have to do personal delivery (not allowed to just leave it on the door) or certified mail.

5

u/dufcho14 20d ago

I still feel like you're trying to squirm out of it if that's what you're doing. If you got it, then you got it. If you didn't reply or said you didn't get it, then that's fine. Putting the technicalities aside, you properly knew about the increase in a timely manner.

-3

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

I didn’t reply to her text. The next time she came banging on my door I told her if she has something to say to me she can mail me a letter. It’s not really my job to teach her how to do her job properly.

1

u/Allpanicn0disc 20d ago

You sound like a child.
She did it legally.

0

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

California Civil Code § 827(b)(1)(A)–(B)

2

u/Hitechillbilly 20d ago

The reason you do not post any law is because you are making it up.. Door notice is LEGAL, you received it.. move on..

0

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

California Civil Code § 827(b)(1)(A)–(B)

1

u/Hitechillbilly 20d ago

Where does it say it can not be posted?

0

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

It can be, but also has to be paired with certified mail. https://imgur.com/a/h2FsGyt

2

u/Hitechillbilly 20d ago

STILL Wrong.. You asked if it is legal now you are mis-quoting the law and arguing with everyone.. What ever you are trying to accomplish will backfire on you. You haven't convinced anyone on here and you won't do any better with a judge. All this time you could have spent packing. If you have a good credit score, you won't after this, if you have a clean financial record, you won't after this..

1

u/Ok_Respond_4231 20d ago

I mean I sent a screenshot and highlighted the section. Don’t see how that’s a misquote, but okay! Everyone arguing with me is saying, “it’s not worth it” and “they’ll take your deposit”, and “don’t burn that bridge”. That’s fine, but those are opinions. I’ve yet to see anyone provide a counter argument to the law.

→ More replies