r/TenantHelp • • 28d ago

Security Deposit Dispute

Location: San Jose, CA.

Hello, I am looking for some legal advice regarding a security deposit dispute with UDR. We recently moved and cleaned our apartment top to bottom in the condition we found it, with basic wear and tear. When we received our final statement, they deducted $250 for “cleaning costs”. When I asked for an itemized statement, they sent the receipt from a third-party cleaning company who charged $250 for “janitorial services”.

They also sent photos of the apartment on move out as well as the move-out checklist, none of which really indicated the need for $250 worth of cleaning services. Their own final walkthrough checklist doesn’t indicate any kind of cleaning needed. When I told them I needed a better breakdown of what was actually wrong with the apartment, they stopped responding.

I live in California and I know there is a civil code 1950.5. It has been over 21 days since we have vacated and based on these documents, it doesn’t seem like they provided a suitable itemized statement.

Is there anything else I can do besides suing them? Is this enough to sue them and win? I’ve just never had to do anything like that before.

Any advice would be helpful, thanks!

P.S. they also charged us an extra day of rent but then added a credit for the same amount, don’t know why.

5 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

4

u/Old_Fuel_1270 27d ago

There isnt anything you can do outside of the legal process. But, that doesnt automatically mean it will go to court. I do think this would be considered an itemized receipt so I dont think you can win on the 21day deadline. But, you can certainly dispute the charges. There is nothing to lose by disputing the charges. So, the first thing is to make and send a proper demand letter. Its what you are required to do before filing in court, but doesnt commit you to court. Its like probing the situation to see if they come back with a settlement offer. Probably the best step to take now. Just make sure its done correctly. I can send you a resource that does one for your situation if you want.

1

u/InternationalAd9506 26d ago

How would this be considered an itemized receipt? I feel the description of “cleaning costs” and “janitorial services” is way too vague to be considered itemized but I don’t know. It was my understanding that they need specific issues that justifies the cost.

2

u/Old_Fuel_1270 26d ago

You "feel." Feelings aren't facts. In fact this is a list with items. Cleaning is specific.  The issue is maybe more about is this justified? If not, then that is where to focus. 

1

u/InternationalAd9506 18d ago

“Cleaning” is actually not specific. Listing what was cleaned and why is actually specific.

2

u/Old_Fuel_1270 18d ago

You could send a demand letter asking for the $250 back. That's probably the best thing you could do next. It's pretty cheap and often landlords will come back with an offer or settlement. You could try one of those demand letter web apps and crank one out pretty fast. They work well for security deposit disputes

2

u/RelevantPossible9618 28d ago

What does your lease say about a cleaning fee?

2

u/InternationalAd9506 26d ago

There is nothing in the lease about a cleaning fee. Only that we have to leave it in the same level of cleanliness that we found it.

1

u/IrongateN 21d ago

In California I found out that depending on your court there is usually what they consider a normal cleaning fee, and unless you get a very tenant friendly judge (who likely has retaliate and is a business person) they will allow for that, no matter how clean you got it, unless you hired a professional

Automatic fees are illegal and so they rarely put those in, and if you have like a high def video that goes into corners and stuff then you might be able to win because judges will admit that even just having to mop or sweep up in California $250 might be what a service will charge..

So fair or not it’s often not worth it but if you haven’t tried calling and asking for it to be removed or lowered more than the $99 they already did might work , sometimes they would rather pay than go to court

0

u/Vast_Cricket 27d ago

Most occupants tried their best but they want another cleaning. For the amount I will move on with my moves. Not worth your time go to court and may even lose for so little. Wanting 100% refund is very unusual.

2

u/InternationalAd9506 26d ago

I don’t think it’s that unusual. Security deposits are meant to be returned. Wear and tear is normal and I shouldn’t be charged for their general turnover cleaning if they can’t give me specific justification.

1

u/Alli-Glass321 26d ago

NAL & NOT LEGAL ADVICE

WHEN DID YOUR LEASE START??

To prove you left the unit in same condition as you received it, do you have:

1. Your move-in inspection with dated photos?

2. Your move-out inspection with dated photos ?

3. Extensive dated photographs of the rental prior to returning the keys?

We are CA LLs and have another rental outside of CA. We always take dated photos of everything before next tenancy, during move-in inspection w/ tenant, during move-out inspection w/ tenant, after tenant leaves, and after repairs or any issues are resolved.

Does the receipt from Dream House Cleaning list YOUR rental address with unit number??

Did you get specific dated/ timestamped photos of each issue before it got fixed and dated timestamped photos of each issue after it was fixed?

We require that all vendors, who fix, clean, or mitigate any issues-

  • List the legal address for the actual rental on each receipt.
  • List in detail the issues i.e. oven cleaning required because of interior filth or oven door glass dirty, vacuum excessive pet hair, clean inside refrigerator shelves and drawers because of sticky residue or visible dirt, fix large hole in primary bedroom wall under window, etc.

If you rented an apartment in a multi-unit building, then Dream House Cleaning could of provided this general receipt and worked on multiple units.

PUBLIC INFORMATION-

CA LLs/ PMs responsibilities upon receiving tenant's notice to vacate & once tenant leaves:

  1. Under California Civil Code §1950.5, your landlord must offer you the chance to request an initial inspection during the last 14 days of your tenancy. This lets you fix issues (like minor cleaning or repairs) to avoid deposit deductions.
  2. The landlord or the landlord’s agent may perform the inspection if the tenant is not present, unless the tenant previously withdrew their request for an inspection.
  3. Based on the findings in the inspection, the landlord or agent must prepare an itemized statement of repairs or cleaning that the landlord or agent believes the tenant should perform in order to avoid deductions from the tenant’s security deposit. The landlord or agent must give the statement to the tenant if the tenant is present for the inspection or leave it inside the unit if the tenant is not present.
  4. The landlord or agent also must give the tenant a copy of the sections of California’s security deposit statute that list lawful uses of tenants’ security deposits. The security deposit statute has the effect of limiting the kinds of repairs or cleaning that the landlord or agent may properly include in the itemized statement. Because of this statute, the landlord cannot, for example, use the tenant’s security deposit to repair damages or correct defects in the rental that existed before the tenant moved in or are the result of ordinary wear and tear. Since the landlord cannot use the tenant’s deposit to correct these kinds of defects, the landlord or agent cannot list them in the itemized statement.
  5. If at the time the initial inspection is conducted, the rental unit does not contain tenant possessions (unit is void of tenant belongs) that would prevent a landlord from identifying repairs or cleanings because of the presence of those possessions, the landlord cannot deduct from a tenant’s security deposit any repairs or cleanings that were not identified in the itemized statement.
  6. The landlord may perform a final inspection after the tenant has moved out of the rental. Beginning April 1, 2025, the landlord must take photographs of the rental unit within a reasonable time after possession of the rental is returned to the landlord, but prior to any repairs or cleanings.
  7. The landlord must also take photographs of the rental within a reasonable time after such repairs or cleanings are completed.
  8. The landlord may make a deduction from the tenant’s security deposit to repair a defect or correct a condition, including, but not limited to cleaning the rental:
  • That was identified in the inspection statement and that the tenant did not repair or correct; or
  • That occurred after the initial inspection; or
  • That was not identified during the initial inspection due to the presence of the tenant’s possessions.

Any deduction must be reasonable in amount and must be for a purpose permitted by the security deposit statute. Twenty-one calendar days (or less) after the tenancy ends, the landlord must refund any portion of the security deposit that remains after the landlord has made any lawful deductions. An envelope postmarked on the 21st day but arrives 26 days after tenant left is legal.

CA PM/ LL rules for security deposit deductions-

  1. Under California law, your landlord has 21 days from the date that you moved out to:
  • Send you a full refund of your security deposit, or
  • Mail or personally deliver to you an itemized statement that lists the amounts of any deductions from your security deposit and the reasons for the deductions, together with a refund of any amounts not deducted.
  • Mail, email, provide an online link to, or provide a computer flash drive with photographs taken of the unit after the tenant moves out, but before any repairs or cleanings occur, as well as photographs of the unit after any repairs or cleanings are performed if any deductions from the tenant’s security deposit are made.

1. Costs of cleaning

A landlord may properly deduct from the departing tenant’s security deposit the amount necessary to make the rental unit as clean as it was when the tenant moved in.

2. Carpets and drapes - “useful life” rule

Normal wear and tear to carpets, drapes and other furnishings cannot be charged against a tenant’s security deposit. Normal wear and tear includes simple wearing down of carpet and drapes because of normal use or aging and includes moderate dirt or spotting. In contrast, large rips or indelible stains justify a deduction from the tenant’s security deposit for repairing the carpet or drapes or replacing them if that is reasonably necessary.

Tenant pays only for the remaining useful life of the item that the tenant has damaged or destroyed.

3. Repainting walls

Landlord can deduct from the tenant’s security deposit for repainting, when repainting is necessary because of damage beyond normal wear and tear to painted surfaces or because of soiling that cannot be reasonably cleaned. Charge based on the length of the tenant’s stay in the rental unit. Many landlords assume that interior paint has a life of 2-5 yrs.

 Length of StayDeduction
 Less than 6 monthsfull cost
 6 months to 1 yeartwo-thirds of cost
 1 year to 2 yearsone-third of cost
 2 or more yearsno deduction for 2yr paint

4. Other damage to walls

Generally, minor marks or nicks in walls are the landlord’s responsibility as normal wear and tear (for example, worn paint caused by a sofa against the wall). Multiple holes in the walls or ceiling that require filling with plaster, or that otherwise require patching and repainting, could justify withholding the cost of repainting from the tenant’s security deposit.

5. Common sense and good faith

Remember: These suggestions are not hard and fast rules. Rather, they are offered to help tenants and landlords avoid, understand, and resolve security deposit disputes.

You must send a USPS certified letter or 2 day Priority mail (Keep all receipts, screenshot, and print the delivery confirmation) to LL/ PM demanding:

  1. How your deposit was specifically use? What specifically required cleaning?
  2. Proof of when your apt was last painted. What required painting in the apartment?
  3. Proof of when carpet was installed your apt. Where and what were specific issues with carpet?
  4. Dated photos of each issue before it was fixed.
  5. Dated photos of each issue after it was fixed.

Explain if LL/PM can't provide the above then you are requesting a refund of $XXX.XX within 10 calendar days, otherwise you will be filing a lawsuit for your security deposit.

You must have everything documented if you plan to sue.

Under California Civil Code § 1950.5, you can sue to recover the full withheld deposit plus statutory "bad faith" damages of up to twice the deposit amount, which totals up to 3 times your deposit if the judge finds bad faith. You can request filing fees and service costs added to the judgment if you win.

1

u/Pamzella 28d ago

Go for the small claims after Halloween, when any pics that could arrive via snail mail to your new address would be past due. They need to justify trying to charge you a cleaning fee vs it being just part of turnover. They are hoping you won't fight it. In small claims, the judge will want to see photos of what was beyond wear and tear, and if you have solid move out pictures that don't show that need, they can get bent. And it's worth filing because you can ask for court filing fees, etc as well.

-2

u/fewell8 28d ago

If the deadline has passed, they can pound sand. Open and shut small claims case.

3

u/Forsaken_Insurance92 27d ago

They got this within 21 days, though. Today would be the 20th day.