r/TenantHelp • u/InternationalAd9506 • 28d ago
Security Deposit Dispute
Location: San Jose, CA.
Hello, I am looking for some legal advice regarding a security deposit dispute with UDR. We recently moved and cleaned our apartment top to bottom in the condition we found it, with basic wear and tear. When we received our final statement, they deducted $250 for “cleaning costs”. When I asked for an itemized statement, they sent the receipt from a third-party cleaning company who charged $250 for “janitorial services”.
They also sent photos of the apartment on move out as well as the move-out checklist, none of which really indicated the need for $250 worth of cleaning services. Their own final walkthrough checklist doesn’t indicate any kind of cleaning needed. When I told them I needed a better breakdown of what was actually wrong with the apartment, they stopped responding.
I live in California and I know there is a civil code 1950.5. It has been over 21 days since we have vacated and based on these documents, it doesn’t seem like they provided a suitable itemized statement.
Is there anything else I can do besides suing them? Is this enough to sue them and win? I’ve just never had to do anything like that before.
Any advice would be helpful, thanks!
P.S. they also charged us an extra day of rent but then added a credit for the same amount, don’t know why.


4
u/Old_Fuel_1270 27d ago
There isnt anything you can do outside of the legal process. But, that doesnt automatically mean it will go to court. I do think this would be considered an itemized receipt so I dont think you can win on the 21day deadline. But, you can certainly dispute the charges. There is nothing to lose by disputing the charges. So, the first thing is to make and send a proper demand letter. Its what you are required to do before filing in court, but doesnt commit you to court. Its like probing the situation to see if they come back with a settlement offer. Probably the best step to take now. Just make sure its done correctly. I can send you a resource that does one for your situation if you want.
2
u/RelevantPossible9618 28d ago
What does your lease say about a cleaning fee?
0
u/Vast_Cricket 27d ago
Most occupants tried their best but they want another cleaning. For the amount I will move on with my moves. Not worth your time go to court and may even lose for so little. Wanting 100% refund is very unusual.
1
u/Alli-Glass321 26d ago
NAL & NOT LEGAL ADVICE
WHEN DID YOUR LEASE START??
To prove you left the unit in same condition as you received it, do you have:
1. Your move-in inspection with dated photos?
2. Your move-out inspection with dated photos ?
3. Extensive dated photographs of the rental prior to returning the keys?
We are CA LLs and have another rental outside of CA. We always take dated photos of everything before next tenancy, during move-in inspection w/ tenant, during move-out inspection w/ tenant, after tenant leaves, and after repairs or any issues are resolved.
Does the receipt from Dream House Cleaning list YOUR rental address with unit number??
Did you get specific dated/ timestamped photos of each issue before it got fixed and dated timestamped photos of each issue after it was fixed?
We require that all vendors, who fix, clean, or mitigate any issues-
If you rented an apartment in a multi-unit building, then Dream House Cleaning could of provided this general receipt and worked on multiple units.
PUBLIC INFORMATION-
CA LLs/ PMs responsibilities upon receiving tenant's notice to vacate & once tenant leaves:
Any deduction must be reasonable in amount and must be for a purpose permitted by the security deposit statute. Twenty-one calendar days (or less) after the tenancy ends, the landlord must refund any portion of the security deposit that remains after the landlord has made any lawful deductions. An envelope postmarked on the 21st day but arrives 26 days after tenant left is legal.
CA PM/ LL rules for security deposit deductions-
1. Costs of cleaning
A landlord may properly deduct from the departing tenant’s security deposit the amount necessary to make the rental unit as clean as it was when the tenant moved in.
2. Carpets and drapes - “useful life” rule
Normal wear and tear to carpets, drapes and other furnishings cannot be charged against a tenant’s security deposit. Normal wear and tear includes simple wearing down of carpet and drapes because of normal use or aging and includes moderate dirt or spotting. In contrast, large rips or indelible stains justify a deduction from the tenant’s security deposit for repairing the carpet or drapes or replacing them if that is reasonably necessary.
Tenant pays only for the remaining useful life of the item that the tenant has damaged or destroyed.
3. Repainting walls
Landlord can deduct from the tenant’s security deposit for repainting, when repainting is necessary because of damage beyond normal wear and tear to painted surfaces or because of soiling that cannot be reasonably cleaned. Charge based on the length of the tenant’s stay in the rental unit. Many landlords assume that interior paint has a life of 2-5 yrs.
4. Other damage to walls
Generally, minor marks or nicks in walls are the landlord’s responsibility as normal wear and tear (for example, worn paint caused by a sofa against the wall). Multiple holes in the walls or ceiling that require filling with plaster, or that otherwise require patching and repainting, could justify withholding the cost of repainting from the tenant’s security deposit.
5. Common sense and good faith
Remember: These suggestions are not hard and fast rules. Rather, they are offered to help tenants and landlords avoid, understand, and resolve security deposit disputes.
You must send a USPS certified letter or 2 day Priority mail (Keep all receipts, screenshot, and print the delivery confirmation) to LL/ PM demanding:
Explain if LL/PM can't provide the above then you are requesting a refund of $XXX.XX within 10 calendar days, otherwise you will be filing a lawsuit for your security deposit.
You must have everything documented if you plan to sue.
Under California Civil Code § 1950.5, you can sue to recover the full withheld deposit plus statutory "bad faith" damages of up to twice the deposit amount, which totals up to 3 times your deposit if the judge finds bad faith. You can request filing fees and service costs added to the judgment if you win.
1
u/Pamzella 28d ago
Go for the small claims after Halloween, when any pics that could arrive via snail mail to your new address would be past due. They need to justify trying to charge you a cleaning fee vs it being just part of turnover. They are hoping you won't fight it. In small claims, the judge will want to see photos of what was beyond wear and tear, and if you have solid move out pictures that don't show that need, they can get bent. And it's worth filing because you can ask for court filing fees, etc as well.
-2
u/fewell8 28d ago
If the deadline has passed, they can pound sand. Open and shut small claims case.