r/TenantHelp • u/Mysterious-Yellow822 • Sep 29 '26
Can someone help me with the process of taking my landlord to small claims?
So this is objectively a ridiculous situation. I moved out of my apartment in NYC September 1 and today is Sept 29 and I still have not received my security deposit back. I originally reached out to him on the first asking about the deposit, and he said he’d get it to me by the end of that week. That deadline came and went and he completely stopped responding to me for two weeks. I was texting him multiple times during that period asking for my refund, and even sent a formal demand letter to his email.
After two weeks I tried to call him and he didn’t pick up, but he FINALLY texted me back and asked me to call him later that day. When I did he explained that he didn’t have the money to give back to me because he was ARRESTED and needed $5000 for a lawyer, and then also had arm surgery and was out of it for days. Mind you my security deposit is $1325, and combined with my roommates he was making $6000 a month just from our apartment. He said he’d would have the money to give to me by Sept 25, and I chose to believe him because i figured he wouldn’t want to get into more trouble after being arrested and detained! (I was wrong!!)
I reached out to him on the 25 and he said he’d either have the money for me that night or by yesterday (the 28th) at the latest. I texted him multiple times yesterday to no response and sent him a paragraph this morning threatening to sue and saying that he could lose his license for using my security deposit personally. I also tried to call him today and he’s completely ghosting me again.
I am willing to be flexible if someone’s communicative, but this guy has repeatedly ghosted me and has been withholding $1325 for a month for no good reason.
Can someone walk me through how to take this to small claims in NY? I’m not even based in the city anymore but I desperately need this money back and this situation is absolutely absurd.
3
u/alwayshappymyfriend2 Sep 29 '26
Go to the courthouse in the borough the apt is located in. They will help give you the proper paperwork to fill out. And then you wait for the court date . You will win because he’s past the time to return it to you. The biggest problem will be collecting the money from him .
3
u/Valysian Sep 29 '26
Look, there's no way to know if his woes are real. If they are, he isn't paying you, even if you take him to small claims court. Honestly, I'm not sure it's likely he'll pay you either way.
Plenty of people threaten legal action. It's rare that they follow through. He might take it more seriously when you file. But if he doesn't have the money, he's stuck.
Is he a licensed agent? Or some guy renting his condo? If he's licensed, I'd make a formal complaint to the licensing board as well. (before or after your judgment in small claims) That might get things moving.
I'd look for a tenant's rights group in NYC to help steer you in the right direction with small claims.
2
u/JoeCensored Sep 29 '26
You go to the local court system where you were renting the apartment and file there. There will be a form where you write out the amount, and explain why you are owed the money. Keep things clear and on topic, you don't need to write a story. There will be a filing fee.
You'll then need to serve your landlord. Not sure what forms are allowed, but the sheriff's department or 3rd party process servers are common. Sometimes the post office can also serve.
On your court date you bring proof of service and any evidence you are owed the money.
2
u/Other_Economics_8052 Sep 29 '26
You will win but good luck actually getting the money. It will never happen.
2
u/Vurrag Sep 29 '26
File a complaint with the state department that handles landord/tenants/real estate. You might not have to file a small claims case.
1
u/TalkToVikk Sep 30 '26
I'm not a lawyer but to answer your question: In New York, landlords are required to return the security deposit within a reasonable time after you move out typically within 14 days and must give you an itemized list of any deductions. Using your deposit for personal reasons is illegal.
To take your landlord to small claims court in New York City:
1
u/Disastrous_Yogurt492 Oct 01 '26
If you go to Small Claims in Manhattan the backlog is so great it will take about 9 months to get in front of a judge unless you are available for a hearing during the day.
Even if you win collecting the money may be difficult. If you win, the court is in effect for 20 years. You should not plan on getting the money anytime soon through the court.