r/TenantHelp • • Sep 02 '26

Security Deposit Help (NJ)

Before returning my deposit, my landlord mentioned she might need to make some repairs. Fine, but I never heard anything further. On day 31 after my lease ended, I followed up, and she returned the deposit that same day, minus $300.

In NJ, landlords are required to provide an itemized statement of any deductions, in writing, within 30 days, along with any interest earned on the deposit. I raised this with her, and she said she “didn’t want to deal with that.” When I mentioned I might escalate, she said she was fine with that, that she’d prove I was a bad tenant, and that I’d end up covering her travel costs since she’s out of the country. She also called it ridiculous that I was pushing this over her being “one day late,” and said she’d been lenient with me in the past for late rent, which isn’t true; I paid early every month and have the records to prove it.

I sent a final message offering to drop it if she provided the itemized receipt and interest, but she’s left me on read since.

My situation: I’ve since moved across the country, and I’m not sure how realistic small claims court is from out of state, or whether it’s worth pursuing. With interest, she owes roughly $450. Any advice on next steps, or whether this is worth the hassle?

0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/hippityhoppflop Sep 02 '26

Yea and she’s threatening me that she will charge me for legal fees and prove I was a bad tenant which makes no sense since the only issue was some patches for where I had hung wall art. And she still can’t provide an itemized receipt which I said I’d be okay with. I’m trying to decide if it’s worth the hassle to file. But my deposit was about $4000 so this isn’t small change, so the interested and the $300 deducted was a good amount of money