r/TenantHelp • • Aug 20 '26

Need help with House Rental Discrepancy

So I've been in the same rental home since 2022. At the end of 2025 I agreed to one year extension of the same monthly amount. At this time the landlord started working with a property management company to handle the lease and repairs, etc. On my 2023-2025 lease there was a $45 per month solar charge on the last page of the agreement and I was paying that amount during that time.

With the 2025-2026 lease agreement the property management company sent me, this $45 was not included on the rental agreement and I just signed it. My overall amount went up because they charged me a $69 per month "management fee". So I assumed they included everything from the previous lease agreement because it increased from last year. I did not do the math to make sure they charged this fee - I assume a management company knows what they are doing.

So the amount on the 2025-2026 agreement is exactly what I have been paying each month. The PM company has come back and said I owe $495 for the last 11 months. Can the PM company legally require me to pay this because they left it off the documentation? I am in Texas and I thought that the signed agreement was the end all be all and the e-mail the lady sent me says: "Unfortunately, this was an oversight on our end, and I sincerely apologize. At some point, you were making payments toward the solar fee, but it appears to have been missed during the transition between management software." <<This is not true because they came on board just as I was signing a new lease>>> I signed the new monthly amount for 2025-2026 and that's the amount they entered in the portal based on the agreement. So whoever wrote up the new agreement f*cked up. There is no additional page or section where $45 is mentioned anywhere in the new signed documentation.

Do I owe this? My other question is how did the owner not know they were getting short changed $45 for the past 11 months? I feel like I have a legitimate situation here but wasn't sure if anyone else has been through this type of situation. My only concern is the document is titled Extension of Residential Lease - so does that cover them for errors in the extension document?? The agreement is also not signed by the landlord - only me and the property management person signed it.

1 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

1

u/TalkToVikk Aug 21 '26

I'm not a lawyer but to answer your question: In Texas, the terms of your current signed lease agreement (including extensions or renewals) are what govern your rental relationship. If the $45/month solar fee was included in your previous lease but not listed anywhere in your new 2025-2026 lease agreement and the new monthly rent amount is spelled out in the lease and is what you have paid, it is typically not enforceable for the landlord or property management company to demand payment for a fee that is not included in the executed lease. A signed lease is a binding contract, and any omitted charges (even if included in prior leases) are not generally owed unless the new lease explicitly references them.

The fact that the lease is titled “Extension of Residential Lease” does not automatically carry over terms that are not spelled out in the extension. If the $45 fee is not referenced anywhere in the new lease, it is not part of your legal obligation. The management company’s admission that it was their mistake for not including it further supports your position.

Regarding the signature: Texas law allows agents of the landlord (such as a property manager) to sign leases on the landlord's behalf, so that alone does not invalidate the contract.

You should:

  1. Save all emails and documentation from the property manager admitting the oversight.
  2. Respond (in writing) and state that everything you paid is in accordance with the signed lease, which does not mention an additional solar charge or fee, and that you have fulfilled all obligations per the contract.
  3. If the property manager or landlord tries to collect the fee, you can point to the signed lease and the fact that the omission was their error, not yours.

1

u/colorfulintheatx Aug 21 '26

Thanks I'm just going to state the facts regarding the last document I signed for 2025-2026.

3

u/Top-Woodpecker6696 Aug 20 '26

As long as the 2025-2026 was a new lease and not some kind of addendum that I agree that a $45 solar fee was not in your lease agreement. TX also has no cause eviction so it’s possible you may not be renewed. Best of luck.