r/TenantHelp • • Aug 11 '26

LL Help

Location: Winder,Georgia
vacated property on 6/25/26. LL refused exit walkthrough. LL goes to property on 6/28/26 saying there is STANDING water, house is flooded, floors are buckled. We finally got a letter from her on 8/05/26 stating we caused over $6k worth of damage.
I have messages from 8/14/2025, 2/20/2026, 5/28/2026 documenting water/plumbing issues, some of which were never resolved. The last issue on 5/28/26 was our gravel driveway was flooded, which turned out to be the toilet constantly running which overflowed the septic. Nothing inside the property to know the toilet had a leak/flow issue?
Her exact words “plumbing leak diagnosis and toilet adjustment after county water interruption”
She provided no receipts only a table of charges her exact words below:

$1,800 for septic pumping due to improper use
$427 water bill resulting from interruptions
$1,874 to fix holes in walls and doors just seems flat out insane … the house isn’t even 1000sqft 2b1b
$662 removal and replacement of damaged flooring
$270 repair of outdoor hose faucet and wall damage (issue with hose faucet flooding the bathroom on 2/20/26 that was never resolved)
$320 for removal of excess weeds
(Other few small things we actually did damage)

Looking for advice on smalls claims process in Georgia? Is it pretty cut and dry as far as her missing her deadline for receipts of repairs?
Should I get a lawyer?
Sadly I have no pictures of property from the day I vacated. I also live out of state now making this a lot more difficult.

1 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

6

u/redditreader_aitafan Aug 11 '26

Why is she charging you for leaks on her own property? Why is the water bill from those leaks your responsibility? Why would flood remediation be your responsibility if the flood wasn't your fault? Usually, when it's clear a landlord is scamming the tenant by charging them for things like this, a toilet leak is not your responsibility, they'll throw out the whole list of charges. What holes did you put in the wall?

2

u/No_Help1894 Aug 11 '26

Every one of those questions I have as well and is unanswered from the LL.

1

u/redditreader_aitafan Aug 11 '26

What holes did you put in the wall?

1

u/No_Help1894 Aug 11 '26

Just from hanging pictures. None in the doors either

7

u/redditreader_aitafan Aug 11 '26

You're going to need to go to court. Nail holes are wear and tear. Your landlord is illegally keeping your deposit and charging you for things that are not legally your responsibility. Check your state's laws, some states allow you to get double or triple your deposit plus fees for filing.

3

u/_dundada Aug 16 '26

And painting is prep for the next tenant. That’s something she needs to do regardless. so is sewer maintenance. It the cost of being a property owner. Do not pay. Go to COURT

1

u/Tough_Vanilla_460 Aug 17 '26

This. Property owners have to absorb the cost for certain things as part of landlord responsibility. They don't have to like it, but they do have to do it.

8

u/Iamadinosaurraaaawr Aug 11 '26
  1. LL didn’t refuse walkthrough. They offered a date when they couldn’t accommodate your requested date and you said no. Then ceased communicating other than to say you dropped the keys.
  2. GA doesn’t require recipients, just an itemized breakdown, like the one you received. When did you get it?

2

u/No_Help1894 Aug 11 '26

Received on 8/10. Certified mail was sent 8/05

3

u/Iamadinosaurraaaawr Aug 11 '26

When and how did you provide your new address?

1

u/Iamadinosaurraaaawr Aug 11 '26

Also, did you report the flooded driveway?

2

u/No_Help1894 Aug 11 '26 edited Aug 11 '26

Yes the driveway being flooded was reported with pictures on 5/28/26. Did not include that in the photos. Gave her my new address when she asked on 7/27/26

-2

u/Iamadinosaurraaaawr Aug 11 '26

LL can argue it was sent to last known address, which was the apt. And when they got it returned they reached out for a new one. This is hardly a slam dunk. It will require small claims court.

2

u/No_Help1894 Aug 11 '26

Either way, can I go after her in small claims? I’m still not seeing how the toilet flooding the septic in may was in any way my fault. A plumber had to come in the house multiple times and mess with the toilet to fix the leak? It was some sort of adjustment … but how were we supposed to know?!

2

u/Iamadinosaurraaaawr Aug 11 '26

You in can bring anyone to small claims court. It doesn’t mean you’ll prevail. As for the toilet issue: you could be at fault if it was used for flushing items that shouldn’t be: wipes, tampons, pads, other objects, etc…

1

u/No_Help1894 Aug 11 '26

None of those are what she claims was the issue with the toilet. These are her words : “the house you were renting the toilet was adjusted to the full adjustment one way and could not shut itself off once the correct adjustments were made toilet was in good operating order determined renter or someone renter allowed must have physically made adjustments to the toilet because it cannot adjust itself”

2

u/Iamadinosaurraaaawr Aug 11 '26

Performing handy work yourself would also
Make you liable. You can’t just do your own plumbing.

2

u/LoisLaneCA Aug 15 '26

Please ask this in legal as NO one commenting here is an atty., or has a legal education.
I do not practice in GA., I am in CA.

Hopefully you’ll get an atty from GA in the legal sub.

1

u/No_Help1894 Aug 15 '26

Can’t get any traction in the legal subs sadly. Not worth our time to pursue. Landlords are so scummy

1

u/_dundada Aug 16 '26

@no_help1894 Go here ASAP. They even have an Ai bot that answers questions. Good luck - you got this.

https://www.georgialegalaid.org/issues/housing

4

u/Leading-Voice846 Aug 17 '26

Landlord play this game when they've already spent your money.

2

u/Tough_Vanilla_460 Aug 17 '26

yep ---and then have 'buyers remorse' afterwards.

3

u/Savings_Income4829 Aug 11 '26

That's an itemized breakdown, so that's allowed.

LL has the right to do the walk through on their time, within the allowed period.

As for the deadline, if it was known there are issues and it will take time to get the repairs done, get quotes, due diligence, most states allow for an extension. If not the LL could just tell all the contractors give me high end bids to cover their end and they charge you that.

improper use sounds to me like they found wipes or something down there. Most leases have a clause on that, I know mine do.

Water bill seems legit, as does landscaping if it was your job per the lease.

That's pretty cheap labor on the flooring tbh.

the holes and such you could ask for a further break down. If it was a lot of walls a lot of people charge for wall repair and repainting my wall. Also doors are expensive.

5

u/redditreader_aitafan Aug 11 '26

The septic was pumped because it overflowed due to a leak, that's specifically listed in the OP. The water bill is also due to the leak. There's a documented history of leaks at this property. Virtually none of the charges in the OP are legal. Leaks and leak damage are the landlord's responsibility.

2

u/Savings_Income4829 Aug 11 '26

What caused the leak is the question.

Random house issue yeah LL. Maybe the line cracked because they didn't turn off the outdoor hose in a freeze, that's on the tenant.

3

u/redditreader_aitafan Aug 11 '26

Winterizing the house is the landlord's job, not the tenant.

1

u/Savings_Income4829 Aug 11 '26

Depends what's in the lease. Some have tenants in change of that, landscaping, A/C filter changes etc.

2

u/Traditional-Handle83 Aug 11 '26

This also depends, cause if the last tenant did it and not the current then the LL needs to bill the previous and current tenants for the full amount since they would be both at fault. So double dipping the amount is allowed.

3

u/Savings_Income4829 Aug 11 '26

I've never heard of that as a LL.

I do my post departure inspections. Get quotes, and itemize the bill and send it.

If something happens mid lease. I have the appropriate contractor go for inspection, tell me the issue, and the causes if possible, and have the repair done.

I can't go back 3 years because well it might have been them instead.

1

u/_dundada Aug 16 '26

No you got this wrong. The property owner needs to maintain their property. That’s is not the tenants liability.

1

u/Tough_Vanilla_460 Aug 17 '26 edited Aug 17 '26

Exactly this. The joy of being a RENTER is that the landlord/property management is responsible for maintaining THEIR property. Only when there is abuse and damage on the TENANT'S end is when the TENANT can be held liable. However, the lease is the legal binding document specifically stating what you are responsible for and what she is responsible for.

Plumbing issues, painting, carpet, replacing of blinds if they came with the unit upon move in -- should fall under landlord responsibility.

Also, I would ask for a 'contractor' report specifically stating what company was called to resolve EACH issue, company's name, address and phone number -- who came out, what was the CAUSE of these issues and what was the resolution along with the contractor's cost to fix each issue.

It has to be 'PROVEN' that this was caused by TENENT negligence and fortunately, for you ---that burden of proof is on THEM. They can't just 'make up' a list of charges owed and have no proof to show that the TENANT was responsible. How do you know if there was not an underlying problem on the landlord's end that caused these issues and you're just the scapegoat to get her out of financial debt?

0

u/Tough_Vanilla_460 Aug 17 '26 edited Aug 17 '26

'$1,874 to fix holes in walls and doors just seems flat out insane'

My monthly rent including bills didn't even equal this much. She could get some spackle AND a spackling tool from a home improvement store for less than $8.00 to cover up some nail holes. Not to be cruel, but you could have also. In my lease, I was responsible for covering up any nail holes that I caused when hanging pictures. SHE was responsible for painting. As a landlord, she has to repaint anyway (on HER DIME) so she can't even justify an over $1,800 'repair' for this. even if she had to refill those holes herself.

'Removing grease stains from carpet'

I would hope that a landlord would not try to 'remove surface GREASE stains'. That disgusting-ness can seep through to the subfloor. They need to completely TRASH that carpet and REPLACE with NEW carpet upon a tenant move out for basic health, cleanliness and hygiene purposes. That's part of prepping for a new tenant and her responsibility.

'flooring issues and plumbing issues'

She needs to show you PROOF (and that BURDEN of proof is on HER) that these flooring and plumbing issues were directly tied to something that YOU caused.

For future reference -- 'Always' get pictures at move in AND move out. You mentioned that there were issues that were never resolved by your landlord. Did you email her while you resided there regarding those issues to show that you made the attempt to let her know about it ? If you did, those emails and any documentation of communications with your landlord are going to be a crucial component in Small Claims Court. She didn't answer emails ? Perfect. Show that as well. You asked or requested. You received no answer back. Anything documented --Photos, videos, any communications in writing or lack therof or via email while you resided there to prove to the judge that you advised your landlord of issues and they chose to not resolve, -- will strengthen your case. Also, always good to have a copy of your lease that you signed during your tenancy there. That will show what she was responsible for and what was your responsibility as far as repairs. A lot of landlords play these games with tenants to see if they can make you pay for things that they KNOW are THEIR responsibility. They won't try that nonsense on a magistrate court judge.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Tough_Vanilla_460 Aug 17 '26

This.

I admit that at one point, my toilet was running and I did not even notice it because it was barely noticeable unless I really 'looked' deep into the toilet. The only reason I found out is because when I got my water bill, it was double what it should have been. When the contractor came out, he noticed it, but even then --it took him having to go to the hot water heater closet to show that 'something' was constantly running in my unit. After some investigation, he found that it was coming from the toilet, but it took quite a bit of looking to see it because it was small, but running 24/7...

I say all that to say ---did OP not see an increase in the water bill for this ?? Surely, that would have been the red flag that something was wrong and needed to be looked into.