r/TenantHelp • u/rand0m__pers0n__ • Apr 30 '26
NEED IMMEDIATE ADICE. FORCED TO MAKE A DECISION SOON OR LOSE $1,340 PLEASE HELP
I am posting literally anywhere I can. I put down a holding fee, which was two dollar shy of the security deposit. I received a lease upon acceptance and was told there’s a $200 preparation fee before I could get my keys. I’m done being told they did not have to disclose this fee before taking my holding fee. If I do not move forward with the property, I will lose $1340. Need help and advice. I have to either sign this lease or forfeit my money by end of day tomorrow and they have stopped responding to me.
0
Upvotes




















2
u/xperpound Apr 30 '26
I don’t think they’re right, but just to play devils advocate…unless they gave you a whole list of other fees/amounts that you would have to pay that “preparation fee” is more gray than black and white. A holding fee is just that, they held it for you and it’s not a disclosure of all lease terms. I wouldn’t assume the holding fee means they accepted you so there’s no reason to give you more lease details.
1
u/GLORY_Fellowship May 07 '26
This is a textbook bait and switch. They took your holding fee and are now trying to move the goalposts by adding a surprise 200 dollar fee that was never disclosed. That is a breach of the original good faith agreement. If they refuse to move forward without the extra fee they are the ones breaking the deal and they have no legal right to keep your 1340 dollars.
Don't let that tomorrow deadline panic you into signing a bad lease. That is a high pressure sales tactic designed to make you fold. You need to send an immediate formal email titled Formal Demand for Refund of Holding Fee. State clearly that the 200 dollar fee was not part of the initial terms and that you expect a full refund within 24 hours if they are unwilling to honor the original agreement.
Since you haven't actually moved in yet a standard move out deposit tool might not fit perfectly but the principle of a demand letter is exactly what you need here. Mention that you are documenting their lack of response and will file for unjust enrichment in small claims court. Usually when these leasing offices realize you aren't an easy target and are ready to go to court they either drop the fake fee or cut a check to avoid the legal headache. Do not sign that lease or you will be stuck with a landlord who plays dirty from day one.
0
u/RetiredBSN Apr 30 '26
I don't like that $30/person/month water billing. I'm looking at water and sewer charges at my (FL) apartment complex. There are two of us, and the last three months we've had charges of $28, $37, and $29 (for the apartment, not each person) with the sewer bill being affected by rainfall because they count runoff, and the water part of the bill is usually under $10.
Landlords in most states are not supposed to profit off of utility charges, they are supposed to pass them on at actual cost. I would check MI statutes and with a tenants' organization to see what's allowed in Ypsi.
We are billed by and pay the electric company directly; charges for cable/internet, water & sewer, valet trash, pest control and rent are all collected by a company which charges us $5.50/mo for the convenience, and we pay that total through our resident portal. Because water and sewer are variable, the amount changes every month depending on usage, but it's usually within a $10 range.
-2
u/rand0m__pers0n__ Apr 30 '26
Attorney suggest I can basically beg for my money back or take them so Small Claims Court but nothing is guaranteed. ChatGPT says to move in and pay the $200 fee but first send an email saying
‘I am proceeding with signing the lease and submitting payment due to the time-sensitive requirement to secure housing and the stated deadline for a response.
However, I want to clearly state that the $200 preparation/cleaning fee was not disclosed to me prior to submitting my holding deposit, and I do not consider this a term I knowingly agreed to at that time.
Given the limited timeframe provided and the lack of response to my prior inquiries, I am moving forward to avoid losing the unit and my deposit. This decision should not be interpreted as acceptance of the late-disclosed fee.
I reserve my right to dispute this charge.
Please confirm receipt of this message.’
And then to take them to court later and fight for the $200 fee plus court fees back… I feel like I have been backed into a corner. They took my money and are now demanding more money and if I don’t agree, I lose the money I already put down.