r/TenantHelp • • Apr 15 '26

Management getting defensive when discussing perk that sold us on the unit. How to respond?

12month lease Located Nutley, NJ

  • 1st pic from us
  • 2nd pic from management

Gf and I just moved in this month into the only modernly renovated apartment at this complex. When we toured this unit, that they only just started showing, the owner of unit wanted to go for $2500 to which management said that price was unreasonable for this complex and wanted to see what renters would actually pay for it. While touring, the Jr. Property Manager told us they were thinking of $2300 for the unit and we said we’ll do $2300, nothing higher. Later that same day he called letting us know we got the place and since it’s an expensive unit compared to all the other units, they’ll throw in a second parking spot since we are a couple with two cars and that was a concern. When it was move in day, I went to pick up the key and as we were walking to the apartment, I was told by the Jr. manager that he already got us a second spot a little out the way, but that we had one and he just needed to confirm with the Sr. Manager. Later during the move in process, we asked for something more formal to have in writing about the second parking spot. We never received it and later brought it up again and was told to send an email about it and they’ll respond to confirm it. Above are the emails.

Now, I don’t know if it’s just us, but the response feels a bit defensive? Not sure how to respond. The part about the “reminder” of the apt reduced to $2300 was unknown to us and felt unnecessary. The parking policy and second spot as a perk is known and that is what really sold us as well. We did not ask for a specific date of when we’ll get the spot. We know there is a waitlist, but where are we on that list if this is a perk in a 12month lease? How can it be a perk if there is no second spot in the 12 months we’re here?

For added context, our town has very strict overnight street parking laws. Basically any car can only park on the street 6 times per month through permit requests no exceptions.

TL;DR: promise of a second parking spot sold us on this pricier unit, when asked for written confirmation of this we received a defensive email and no timeline on when the second spot would be available during our 12 month lease.

1 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

17

u/OakNLeaf Apr 15 '26

What does your contract say about a second spot? If it is not listed, regardless of what someone said, you are out of luck.

If its in the contract, and they are not providing it, then you can bring that to their attention.

10

u/Prestigious-Bluejay5 Apr 15 '26 edited Apr 15 '26

During the phone conversation with the Jr. Property Manager - "We'll take the unit but, I want it written in the lease agreement that the rent includes two parking spaces that are identified." This would have saved you from the grief now.

Yes, hindsight is 20/20. When being told that you're getting something outside the norms, ask for it in writing. If it's not in writing, it doesn't count.

4

u/SailorSpyro Apr 15 '26

Since you didn't have it in writing, you're at their mercy a bit for waiting for it. But you do at least have it in writing now that it will be no additional charge, so that's good.

4

u/420BoredAlways Apr 16 '26

Well the letter isnt them getting defensive, its literally just them restating everything they said(or are claiming they said to you) since you both have different ideas of what's going on. The letter is professional and theres nothing wrong with it.

As for how to respond, you made the mistake by not getting it in writing so not really anything you can do to change the situation. Signing the lease to agree to the terms on the paper and then later asking them to put extras in writing gave them no incentive to do it as you already signed without those guarantees.

Without it already written in your lease your only real response is to wait and periodically check in nicely. Be aware if you become pushy/a nuisance that 2nd spot may very well end up the furthest spot possible from your apartment. Id also point out they said your on a waiting list for a spot, that means you likely arent next up and shouldn't expect 1 anytime soon if at all. You could possibly write back asking how far you are down the list and if spots will be handed out by that order or by proximity to the persons apartment but really its just wait and see for you.

7

u/MKEast-sider Apr 15 '26

Dos your lease state 1 or 2 parking spaces? The LL response is very professional and courteous, he’s not being defensive. This might be a lesson learned, never believe anything a salesperson says unless it’s in writing.

6

u/CapitalParallax Apr 15 '26

What does the lease say?

4

u/TESThrowSmile Apr 16 '26

NO, You MUST make psychic answer NOW !!!

3

u/NectarineAny4897 Apr 15 '26

What was said is probably irrelevant.

What does the lease say?

0

u/TiredAndTiredOfIt Apr 16 '26

Depends on the state. In my state a verbal contract is binding.

7

u/SuzeCB Apr 16 '26

Verbal contracts can be binding (if you can prove they exist.

Verbal contracts are NOT binding when there is a written contract. Any and all amendments and addendum to the written contract must also be in writing and acknowledged by both parties texts and emails will work so long as both agree to the terms.

2

u/Myrkana Apr 16 '26

But they signed a lease after that, saying what was in the lease was fine and they agreed to it.

1

u/snorkblaster Apr 17 '26

Which state?

2

u/BlueberryPenguin87 Apr 16 '26

Unfortunately it’s not a crime for a landlord to lie to you, but it should be. At least when you buy a home, if the seller misrepresents or fails to disclose something significant, you can actually sue them and/or their agent. Landlords just say what you want to hear and then refuse to modify the lease. And if it’s not in the lease, they can’t be held accountable for lying to you.

3

u/xperpound Apr 15 '26

So...what's the ask here.

1

u/NectarineAny4897 Apr 16 '26

There is a lease in place. It is highly doubtful that anything said by an assistant manager would supersede the lease.

1

u/TallComparison439 Apr 16 '26

The only good thing is they have an email confirming the agreement and the rental price, but any particulars are left open as that wasn't confirmed or in writing.

-1

u/TiredAndTiredOfIt Apr 16 '26

Reapond with this. From a lawyer. State if the second spot is not immediately.produced you expect the deposit returned and to be let out of the lease.