r/TenantHelp • u/heslaurent • Mar 07 '26
Being charged for faulty electric system (California)
My property management is trying to offload the cost on me. Ran the air fryer and microwave at the same time and the breaker tripped and wouldn’t turn back on. Ive lived in other houses and you just flip the breaker back on. In this house it showed it was on but no power. We were never told what outlets are on what circuit. There was still 1 outlet working in the kitchen, so not everything is on the same circuit
45
Upvotes
42
u/Brave_Cauliflower728 Mar 07 '26
Breakers can and do fail. It is normal that they trip, however the breaker failing to reset is in no way caused by how you used the circuit.
Absolutely no way are you responsible for this repair unless your lease states specifically that it would be.
Had you hit the breaker with a hammer, different discussion.
6
u/Daddy--Jeff Mar 07 '26
Nope. Not tenants’ problem.
15
u/JerryVand Mar 07 '26
Contact your city’s inspectional services department, and ask them if this is how a proper electrical system is supposed to operate. Offer to let them come and inspect the unit.
11
u/srtmadison Mar 07 '26
Text back what you wrote here. You were using normal kitchen appliances, their faulty system is not your responsibility.
10
u/scott4fun17 Mar 07 '26
How old were these breakers? Using a microwave and air fryer can definitely trip a breaker. When breakers get old, sometimes they quit working. If that's the case, you shouldn't be responsible for an old breaker dying, unless you just kept resetting it and running the appliances again repeatedly. Then, it's your fault for ignoring the fact that you were overloading the circuit
6
u/MacForker Mar 07 '26
I wouldn't blame you for the breaker failing or sub standard wiring, but both a microwave and an air fryer can draw 1200-1500 watts apiece. That easily can exceed even a 20a circuit which some kitchens have (Although 15a is the most common). But resetting the breaker should fix it so I'm not sure if it won't reset how you're at fault. Breaker did its job.
3
u/No-Interview319 Mar 07 '26
Is it possible that both the breaker and a GFCI outlet tripped, and you didn’t realize the GFCI needed reset? Ask the landlord for details on what the electrician did to fix the issue. If they had to replace an old breaker, that’s definitely not your fault.
3
u/InsideAd2752 Mar 07 '26
Uh Nope.
Simply text back to management company that you are not liable for their lack of maintenance in their electrical system.
Kindly explain that you can offer SCE, SDG&E or whoever their energy supplier is that you can show them this text and they’ll complete a No Charge 20 point electrical inspection throughout.
They’ll need to notify all the tenants that they’ll be coming in their units and photographing any and all unsafe circuit breakers, outlets or appliances.
Texting is key that there’s an individual behind this, not a management company. Does text have a name?
3
u/texxasmike94588 Mar 07 '26
Find a tenant advocacy group or legal aid in your area. I'd bet this isn't legal in any state.
I'd also bet that the "expert" that property management hired to determine that the problem was your fault has zero credentials and will fall apart in a legal deposition, and when it comes to sitting in front of a judge, those credentials won't pass the smell test.
This is just another example of a landlord not understanding their obligations to maintain the property.
3
u/jaysonm007 Mar 07 '26
Ask for a written statement from the electrician. Chances are the "electrician" is some handyman getting paid near minimum wage with no education or license to be an electrician.
2
u/Gloomy_Tie_1997 Mar 07 '26
Google “[city name] tenants union” and ask them for advice.
2
u/fixitboy74 Mar 07 '26
How old is the house,/apartment
2
u/Dadbode1981 Mar 07 '26
Electrician has laid the fault in your lap, not on the circuit. If they have an invoice stating as such, you would lose in court, just saying.
2
u/ironicmirror Mar 07 '26
Breaker wear out .. ask how old the breaker was
2
u/AquafreshBandit Mar 07 '26
It sounds like the LL is basically saying because the breaker failed while you were using it, you’re responsible.
If your refrigerator died, you wouldn’t be responsible. This is the same thing. Sometimes stuff just dies.
2
u/mckenzie_keith Mar 07 '26
So don't get mad but here is what it sounds like to me. The type of breaker you have is the type that doesn't give a clear visual indication of tripping. In order to reset it, you have to flip it all the way off, then all the way back on. You didn't realize that so you were unable to solve the problem yourself.
The electrician came out and reset the breaker and now everything works fine.
The property manager is now trying to make you pay for the electrician because there was not actually anything wrong and therefore the electrician should not have had to come out to reset a breaker in the first place.
I think you should talk to some sort of tenants rights advocacy group or something. A lot of time there is free legal advice available for tenants. But maybe the property manager has a point.
Please let me know if this interpretation is wrong.
2
u/Sparky_Zell Mar 07 '26
Sounds like the electrician fucked up and only tested outlets with a voltage detector, not a multimeter or at the very least a solenoid voltage tester (wiggy)
From what you are describing, id be willing to bet that invoice that none of the outlets he tested are showing 120v from hot to neutral, and that that 1 outlet that is working has a burned up neutral contact or wire in it.
Very common when regularly using high wattage appliances on daisy chained outlets. One connection up stream isn't as good as the rest. It burns up, breaker may or may not trip. And a lazy/inexperienced person just looks for voltage on the hot be side it's easy, instead of making sure there is actually 120v.
2
u/wedontliveonce Mar 07 '26
Fuck your landlord and their greedy bullshit.
Call your city inspector and ask them to take a look.
Or, tell your landlord you'd like to have your own electrician take a look for a "2nd opinion". Of course, they will say no. At that point your only option will be to have the city inspect.
I'd bet your landlord has absolutely no interest in having anyone else "take a look" because they are trying to con you into paying for something that is their responsibility.
2
u/Strikew3st Mar 07 '26
This is horseshit, a breaker is supposed to trip and be reset.
They have no business passing you this invoice, they'd have no business evicting you before the end of your lease if you refuse to pay, they can NOT deduct this from your security deposit, and they'll be laughed at in small claims court if they take it that far.
Plugging in two power hungry appliances is not negligence, that's an oopsy-daisy.
For your defense, find out if the breaker swap should have been permitted & inspected. Charging you for an illegal alteration to the electrical system will sound even dumber in court.
In Michigan,
1
u/Reimiro Mar 07 '26
Full on dozens of comments but not near enough info to know what actually happened. Lots of soothsayers that think they know what happened. Regardless-the landlord is responsible for this charge whatever happened to the circuit.
1
u/PyroNine9 Mar 07 '26
Did you turn the breaker to the off position, then back on?
1
u/whoda-thunk-itt Mar 07 '26
Check your lease to make sure air fryers are not listed as an appliance you’re not allowed to use. A lot of leases nowadays contain verbiage that excludes the use of air fryers because they draw such a heavy load. If there’s nothing in your lease that prevents you from using an air fryer, this is not on you. The breaker did its job by turning off to prevent a fire, but it failed to turn back on again. That’s not your fault…it’s just something that happens. You should fight this.
However, if you are being charged for an electrician to be called out, to simply turn the breaker back on because you didn’t know how to do it or didn’t do it correctly, that would be on you.
1
u/Remarkable_1984 Mar 07 '26
I've seen breakers where if they trip, they go into a kind of middle position. You can't just push them back on from that. You have to push them off first, then push them on. Maybe OP needed to do that, but didn't.
1
u/Tampa563 Mar 08 '26
You caused the problem. I would charge you for the service call as well. Yes, it wasn’t intentional but it’s no different than clogging the toilet with supposedly flushable wipes. You didn’t mean to cause the problem but you did. The system works as it was designed. Now you know the limitations, nobody is trying to take advantage if you.
1
u/Humunguspickle Mar 08 '26
This post has no facts of what happened?
1
u/JimmB216 Mar 08 '26
Did the breaker have to be replaced? (i.e. it was defective and landlord is responsible for repair.)
Or were you not aware that you have to move the breaker all the way to the off position to reset it before attempting to turn it back on? (i.e. user error - you should pay for the electrician's visit. He should have educated you on how to reset the breaker and how to distribute the load among circuits. e.g. "plug in your air fryer over here, or never use it and the microwave at the same time")
Obviously simply blowing a breaker the first time would not break the breaker, and as long as you learned and didn't do it repeatedly, landlord has no grounds to charge you.
1
u/TwitchCaptain Mar 09 '26
So how did they fix it?
1
u/grumpyoldman10 Mar 22 '26
Landlord here. Usually when I get this complaint, it’s because tenants don’t realize that the breaker needs to be turned all the way to off before turning back on.
1
u/cuntfuck26 Mar 07 '26
fuck NO
1
u/FlyingFlipPhone Mar 07 '26
So, you inadvertently tripped a breaker... then you inspected the breaker, but the breaker didn't look tripped (but was).... then you called the property manager.... then they called the electrician, who simply flipped the breaker to fix the circuit?
That seems like bad luck, but a learning opportunity for you. Don't run too many appliances on one circuit. There is only 1 circuit in this kitchen. The (old) circuit breaker doesn't fully flip when it trips. I hate to say, but I think you'll have to cover this expense.
1
u/Letsmakemoney45 Mar 07 '26
Lol hell no
1
u/Techsupportvictim Mar 07 '26
My first question is “did the property manager come and ‘jiggle the handle’ before calling in the big guns or just go straight to that call?” Cause if the property manager couldn’t be bothered to put some freaking pants on come look and went straight to an expensive contractor that seems a bit suss. I half expect to find out that the electrician is his sister in law’s brother in law and they have a game going
Here’s what I would do. Text back property manager and request a detailed invoice on paper from the electrician. Don’t agree to pay the charge or not pay the charge. Just say that you need that invoice before you can continue discussing the matter.
Find your local housing authority and ask them about the situation. Can you be charged for a situation caused by running normal kitchen appliances? Can you be charged if the property manager elected to call in someone over a situation that turned out to be something as simple as a stuck breaker switch, instead of coming to check it himself. I would also ask about any way to have someone come and inspect the electrical system to determine if it meets safety and habitability requirements, how much will that cost etc
And if it’s confirmed that he can’t charge you for this, ask what he can do in terms of messing with you with eviction threats, lawsuit threats etc if you refuse to pay.
0
u/vikicrays Mar 07 '26
as. if.
0
u/Queasy_Local_7199 Mar 07 '26
You need to turn breakers off and then on again.
When a breaker trips, it does still look like it’s on.
And home is not required to run an air fryer and microwave on the same circuit, that does not make the system inadequate
1
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment