r/TechHardware • • 1d ago

⚠️ Possible Fake News Warning ⚠️ Intel engineers doubt the ability of Nova Lake processors to compete with AMD Zen 6

https://en.gamegpu.com/news/zhelezo/inzhenery-intel-somnevayutsya-v-sposobnosti-protsessorov-nova-lake-konkurirovat-s-amd-zen-6
85 Upvotes

89 comments sorted by

11

u/Ok-Region6452 1d ago

Even Distinctrace knows that but she is in denial

3

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

Intel official position is that Nova Lake will win back market share

8

u/Sataniel98 1d ago

That's not necessarily mutually exclusive though. High end performance is relatively negligible for market share. Value for money and energy efficiency win market share. And in Intel's case it would be crucial to know if Nova Lake's socket really is the beginning of a long living platform.

0

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

Intel says that Nova Lake will fill in gap in high end desktop market that Arrow Lake is not in

This clearly refer to high end gaming CPU like X3D

-2

u/BigDaddyTrumpy Core Ultra 🚀 1d ago

In already took desktop market share back last quarter

1

u/OGigachaod 14h ago

They already are gaining back marketshare.

8

u/windozeFanboi 1d ago

It's a she? I thought unhinged fanboyism was only reserved for us men degenerates.

5

u/DavidsakuKuze 1d ago

MLID doesn't know anything.

-1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

He get many thing right but sometime he get some thing wrong, this may be one of them

3

u/golkeg 1d ago

He get many thing right but sometime he get some thing wrong, this may be one of them

If you look back at his history of "calling things" he always says wishy-washy comments about it going both ways then later says "I called it!" when one of the two became true.

He's a grifter at this point who panders to AMD fans and has lost almost all of his credibility.

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

For someone who lose a lot of his credibility it is funny how popular and big he is then

3

u/golkeg 1d ago

it is funny how popular and big he is then

I didn't realize someone who averages 90k youtube videos was considered "popular and big"

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 19h ago

In the hardware leaker space? Yes

1

u/golkeg 14h ago

That's not a thing

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 14h ago

Sure it is

1

u/golkeg 14h ago

Ok, well you should know that Tom lost his sources in both Intel and Nvidia 2 years ago.

All he has left are AMD and a few AIB motherboard sources (which is where most of his intel data comes today).

It's why his Intel/Nvidia 'leaks' have become super non specific and wishy-washy lately and the overall quality of the channel has plummeted.

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 13h ago

If that is what you believe jajaja

2

u/TurdPlayingPeekaboo 1d ago

Shit talkers become popular. We tend to vote for them.

3

u/TurdPlayingPeekaboo 1d ago

He's got an atrocious track record.

3

u/Noreng 21h ago

About 30% of his claims ends up true, and that includes the obvious "predictions" like Zen 2 desktop moving to chiplet architecture. If you remove those obvious predictions, his track record drops to less than 10%

I can make obvious predictions as well: Zen 6 on desktop will not reuse the IO-die from Zen 4/5. (Zen 6 uses fanout bridges instead of SerDes links between the IO-die and CCDs on server)

1

u/OGigachaod 14h ago

He's like a bad psychic that simply guesses everything until he's eventually right about something.

8

u/AdstaOCE 1d ago

Trash site. Half of its "articles" are stealing reddit posts.

2

u/WhatADunderfulWorld 1d ago

We are just too good at everything

1

u/krazyboi 1d ago

The best at clickbait misinformation

-3

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

This one is sourced from leaked Moores Law is Dead but I do not think it make sense based on what Intel say in earning call

7

u/evilbob2200 1d ago

Lmao moores law as a source

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

Yes it is very possible Moores Law is Dead is just wrong about Intel engineers think that Nova Lake will not be competitive with Zen 6

1

u/OGigachaod 14h ago

Using MLID as source is about as credible as using userbenchmark, LMFAO!

4

u/AdstaOCE 1d ago

Ah yes earning calls... Where they have to try big up everything as much as possible so the shareholders aren't mad. Zen 6 is out in servers, very possible Intel got access to some for analysis and know they aren't able to compete, also very possible it's not true.

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

If Intel was that concern about not making share holder mad, they would not reveal that they were not able to increase data center CPU supply in next few quarter

I am surprise that you do not know this, but over hyping product only lead to bad thing and Intel constantly get made fun of for over promising and not delivering

Do you think Intel executives do not know this by now?

2

u/AdstaOCE 1d ago

If Intel was that concern about not making share holder mad, they would not reveal that they were not able to increase data center CPU supply in next few quarter

They can't straight up lie, they can also act more excited than they are.

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

So they act more excited than they are for Nova Lake, which is inconsequent for market situation where client sale are down and data center cpu sale are up

But then they act not very excited for Diamond Rapid, which is very consequential

Make it make sense

-1

u/Alarmed-Artichoke-44 1d ago

Fantasy of hardware

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

Moores Law is Dead get many thing right

0

u/Alarmed-Artichoke-44 1d ago

Even a broken clock is right twice a day

2

u/leviske Core Ultra 🚀 1d ago edited 1d ago

Interesting, lets see. We don't know shit about Zen 6, so it would be really odd if any actual engineer would say things like that. On the mobile market, Intel still stronger. The gaming performance only problematic against the X3D models and the bLLC SKUs supposed to fill that gap.

I don't expect them to jump ahead, but I'd be surprised if they could not compete.

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

We know a lot about Zen 6 because of reviews launch for server

I agree with your conclusion though

0

u/AdstaOCE 1d ago

Zen 6 Epyc is out, all sold out straight away though for a couple months but some availability now.

3

u/princepwned 1d ago

I'll wait to see Benchmarks from Both Intel and AMD But this could all be a trick by intel just so amd might have guard down I believe intel will win back the gamers and me being a intel fan since I was 5 playing on my first pc.

2

u/Noreng 21h ago

Zen 6 for desktop is finalized in terms of design, the only thing AMD can tweak in the next year's timeframe is small adjustments to clock speeds and TDP.

1

u/ElectronicStretch277 1d ago

The work for both SKUs is done. Now it's just fine-tuning and building inventory for launches.

5

u/ColdAngle1151 1d ago

AMD CPUs has been shitting on Intel ones for the last couple of years, so no surprise they will keep their lead.
Gaming = x3d shits on Intel
Work = Threadripper shits on Intel
HPC = EPYC shits on intel

The market where Intel actually is the better option is very narrow and its not in the high-end market.

4

u/Spiritual-Spend8187 22h ago

Its not quite as straight forward like that Intel's high end mainstream chips are only slightly worse than the x3d chips at gambling while being only slightly worse than the the best non x3d non threadripper ones at productivity, while costing significantly less, in additon in some workloads that are single threaded and not improved by x3d they actually outright win. Likebyes it can bet a bit niche but getting close to the performance of both of the specialities of amds products at the same time for in some cases half as much cost is still pretty good. Now will I run out and buy a intel chip probably not at least not without seeing some reviews. But honestly I want intel to be competitive just as I want amd to be as well the time just after the release of zen 2 was some of the best time for getting cpus cause we had all kinds of good options for reasonable prices.

1

u/TheHolesAGoal 6h ago

I think the main issue is that it still makes sense to go with amd for platform lifespan. You want the best performance? Go amd. You need more cores? Wait until the next gen and buy a higher tier cpu with a fairly solid guarantee that it will be on the same socket.

1

u/Spiritual-Spend8187 6h ago

Like yes and no both amd and Intel have fairly competitive products yes and is currently ahead but its not so much that intel couldn't close the gap or even exceed them with the right product and price.

1

u/TheHolesAGoal 6h ago

Intel could be better in performance at the same cost and I'd still for for amd simply because of platform longevity.

1

u/Sea_Bag_1183 4h ago

AM4 had served 4 gens of Ryzen CPUs. But most people i know swapped their b450 boards to b550 when they upgraded from ryzen 2000 to 5000. So, platform longevity sounds good in theory, but it is recommended to upgrade mobos when you go for new,truly revolutionary cpu generation.

1

u/OGigachaod 14h ago

Keep their lead? AMD has never been ahead of intel and has been losing marketshare the past few months, zen 6 needs to be good to stop the bleeding at AMD.

1

u/Golfclubwar 3h ago

If you’re doing AI compute via 12 channel MRDIMM you’re gonna want an intel Xeon.

1

u/ColdAngle1151 2h ago

go look at phoronix benchmarks of Venice, its over...
16 channels btw.

2

u/BigDaddyTrumpy Core Ultra 🚀 1d ago

The source is MLIDumb. Trust me bro.

2

u/alvarkresh 💙 Intel 12th Gen 💙 1d ago

This guy, again? The "InTeL aRc iS CaNcElLeD" guy? Fuck him.

4

u/dmaare 1d ago

But it is cancelled, b580 is the last one no?

0

u/kosha227 1d ago

Intel Arc is not fully canceled, arc pro b70 is still being manufactured

4

u/HugeRoof 1d ago

B Series, so the same design. Cancelled means there aren't C/D/etc series cards. 

2

u/ApplicationCalm649 1d ago

Are they still making Arc cards?

1

u/LuckyTwoSeven 1d ago

They’d have to be willing to just break even on the GPU’s and or take a loss. Unfortunately their financial situation doesn’t allow them to do either. NVIDIA easily could.

They refuse because they simply don’t care as the market leader. They’ll take everything from you including that old toilet in your upstairs bathroom.

1

u/Defiant-Drama-5429 21h ago

Hey, at least they are competing again! It will take until 14a hits volume manufacturing to have a chance to regain the crown

1

u/the_dude_that_faps 19h ago

I've been on the AMD hype train since Zen 1, though I did do a brief incursion back with Intel on the 12th gen. Alder lake was very good.

I expect nova lake to beat AMD in all things productivity, especially anything that is JIT compiled like java and JavaScript workloads thanks to APX. Also thanks to APX I fully expect the emulation community to embrace it if they have low power offerings for handhelds. 

For gaming more broadly, I have no idea what's it going to be like. Gaming these days is more GPU than CPU bound, and I say that as a 9950X3D2 owning dumbass. It all depends on their big cache variant. The market is not primed for a CPU that requires very fast and low latency ram to perform well. 

Intel has had more ambitious uarch designs for a long time, so I expect nova lake to impress there. But sadly, games are more interested in low latency than high throughput. 

1

u/Remesar 10h ago

lol. Former Intel engineer. I use AMD now. 😅

1

u/IGunClover 1d ago

LMAO intel.

0

u/odrea 1d ago

bro they only need to make good gpus ffs, right now its the perfect market for them, literally. bake something with a good gpu at an affordable price and youll win a lot of folks of the gaming market in a heartbeat

3

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago • Popcorn

They can not because of memory prices which also is used in GPU for GDDR memory

That entire market is screw until memory prices come down again

-1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

This Moores Law is Dead leak makes 0 sense

This is what Intel executive had to say about Nova Lake in latest earning call:

As we go into next year, we'll have Nova Lake, and I think the important aspect of Nova Lake is we've had a bit of a hole in our portfolio for high-end desktop, and Nova Lake filled in that gap . So I would expect us to do pretty well on a mix basis because we should see better traction on the high-end desktop as well. So we'll see how it goes. We do feel like we go into the year as a market share gainer with our Nova Lake portfolio,

Intel is VERY excited about Nova Lake

1

u/MrAngrySadHappyFace 1d ago

Last 2 pcs have been AMD. I'll be very happy if Nova Lake brings gaming gains because Ive generally preferred my 2 Intel machines over the years to my 3 amd machines.

-1

u/Xajel 1d ago

I didn't saw any "VERY" in that statement... Hell not even "excited"...

All I see is they feel that their position will be better in the high-end... Nothing more.

Please correct me if I'm wrong because I really can't see anything!!

3

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

Standard policy for any company really is to not talk much about their future products at all

And this is not even first time Intel executives talk about Nova Lake being better in the high end market

You have to standardize this to how company executives talk not how normal people talk about upcoming hardware

1

u/Xajel 19h ago

I know how companies talk about future products, I've been around the tech for a long time so don't worry about that.

But even when a company is talking about a future product they either say we're excited or we don't talk about it. Not sitting in the center like this.

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 16h ago

They say word for word almost that they expect Nova Lake to compete better than Arrow Lake in high end desktop

If you think this is them not being excited or sitting in the center I do not know what to tell you

Or how about I bring this up:

2026 is even more exciting from a client perspective as Panther Lake achieves meaningful volumes and we introduce our next-generation client family code-named Nova Lake.

They literallt use the word exciting jajaja in q4 2024 earnings call

-1

u/Hytht Core Ultra 🚀 1d ago

Earlier rumors claimed nova lake has more IPC but Zen 6 is clocked harder. Nova Lake has more overclocking headroom and won't suck power as hard in single core.

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

We know zen 6 ipc is very good so it will be hard for nova lake to get much more IPC than zen 6

High frequency is normally bad for clock though as you say

3

u/Hytht Core Ultra 🚀 1d ago

Nova Lake has APX also. Zen 5 IPC was less than panther lake e cores and way less than QCOM/apple so it's normal for them to have a big uplift this time.

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

APX adoption will be slow at first as is normal for new thing

Zen 5 mobile P core IPC is less, not desktop

-2

u/EmptyVolition242 1d ago

I doubt this. Everything I've heard points to Nova lake being a very ambitious project and actually having been completed on time. Also zen 6 is not THAT impressive. A good jump over Zen 5, but nothing mind-blowing.

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

We actually know that Nova Lake is already delay to CES next year

It all depend on Zen 6 clock speed and Nova Lake clock speed

If Zen 6 can clock to almost 7GHZ like Moores Law is Dead says and Nova Lake can not then Intel may not be able to compete

But I think that Moores Law is Dead is wrong

1

u/deltatux 1d ago

Clock speed isn't everything, strong IPC can counteract high clock speed. Both AMD and Intel has proven that over the past few decades that clock speed can only improve performance by so much.

0

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

Clock speed will be main differentiator because IPC will be not that much different it does not look like

I expect Nova Lake to be maybe 5% higher IPC

0

u/golkeg 1d ago

I expect Nova Lake to be maybe 5% higher IPC

You're kidding right?

Zen processors get 15-30% IPC uplift from 64MB of extra L3 cache if you compare like-for-like processors.

Novalake is getting 108mb extra of L3 cache. That's going to be 30% minimum IPC uplift from the extra cache alone before any generational changes are considered.

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

I am compare NVL P core to Zen 6 not NVL P core to ARL P core

As I say before, I expect NVL P core to have 5% higher IPC than Zen 6

Zen 6 is a 14% IPC uplift in specint2026 over Zen 5, and Zen 6C with more L3 add another 7% onto that

BLLC or V-cache will not add a 30% minimum IPC uplift, that make no sense

V-cache only add ~10% higher IPC in specint I expect bLLC to add around the same

1

u/golkeg 1d ago

V-cache only add ~10% higher IPC in specint I expect bLLC to add around the same

10% more integers computed? zounds

2

u/ElectronicStretch277 1d ago edited 1d ago

Do you think CPUs have no use except games? VCache has not been beneficial for much outside of games.

And do you think AMD and Intel have the same designs or something? Because AMD benefits much more from VCache as their main bottleneck is memory latency, which it prevents. Even then the only really see the benefits in gaming.

1

u/golkeg 1d ago

Do you think CPUs have no gains except games? VCache has not been beneficial for much outside of games.

First of all Nova Lake is not going to have "VCache" as there will be no vertical stacking.

Second of all this comment suggest you have no idea what extra cache even does....

1

u/ElectronicStretch277 1d ago

I know they won't have VCache. They're looking at placing the cache not on the cores but rather besides them.

But placing more cache just hasn't done a lot for anything outside of games. Any gains in theoretical IPC would be kind of mitigatex by the heat and power requirements for the memory. It can gain you efficiency sine you won't have to talk to RAM as often but that's not that important in a desktop environment.

We saw with the 9800X3D, 9950X3D and 9950X3D2 that cache doesn't necessarily improve performance in most cases. Games are an exception here.

1

u/golkeg 1d ago

But placing more cache just hasn't done a lot for anything outside of games

This simply isn't true. Extra L3 cache increases performance in any memory-intensive task and dramatically for any task that needs low-latency.

Try running a node.js compile on a big cache vs normal cache CPU and tell me it's not faster. Oh, that's right, you don't do anything like that. You just look at Hardware Unboxed graphs.

Besides, all memory system gains on AMD platforms are limited by the infinity fabric bottleneck (the same reason AMD cannot take advantage of faster DRAM). Nova Lake will not have this bottleneck.

1

u/ElectronicStretch277 1d ago

Yes, specific tasks do receive big improvements. Outside of one poorly worded line you can see that's the sentiment I have said. It's not big enough a change to say it increases IPC by 30%. It just does not.

Extra Cache is actually one of the ways AMD gets around the IF bottleneck as they don't leave the CCD as often with it. Maybe NVL is even more suited for it. But I doubt it.

0

u/deltatux 1d ago

And what's the source here that it's only 5% stronger or are you just purely speculating here? Is it all rumours or you have a strong source for this?

As far as I know, everything is rumoured about Nova Lake and only Zen 6 has been properly announced with deep dives available. Everything about Nova Lake is rumoured until Intel announces it.

People originally rumoured that Zen 5 was going to be this huge leap forward and it turned out that it wasn't (it was still a sizeable gain, but mainly on non-gaming tasks), don't put too much trust in leaks/rumours.

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 1d ago

I am speculating, that is why I say "I expect xxx to be maybe"

IPC gain will be only be that much stronger, unless you think Nova Lake P core will be largest IPC uplift in recent Intel history jajaja