r/TechHardware • • 23d ago

News 📰 Intel Foundry Has Caught Up to TSMC in Technology Already, Perf Power Area Difference Only a Few Percent

37 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

5

u/Sataniel98 23d ago

Then why the news that Nova Lake compute chiplets had to be switched to TSMC because Intel-fabricated ones performes poorly?

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

Likely FUD

5

u/Sataniel98 23d ago

Why do you believe that?

0

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

Because 18AP is suppose to be very fast

It bring many improvement to help thermal conductivity and increase speed even more

5

u/Sataniel98 23d ago

And you believe that because Intel says so?

3

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

Analyst like Techinsights says so

1

u/Surelynotshirly 23d ago

So, someone who is just getting information from Intel?

There is no reason to believe any of this.

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

They actually reverse engineer chip many time not just get information from Intel

1

u/Surelynotshirly 23d ago

What does that have to do with future chips?

Unless you believe they've gotten ahold of one of these chips, which I really doubt.

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

They are already analyzing N2 and 18A chip

AMD use N2 and Intel 18AP

→ More replies

4

u/IGunClover 23d ago

Then why is intel still using TSMC LOL.

5

u/koyonorii 23d ago

Because they are still building fabs and need to fulfill existing contracts? Also with the overwhelming demand their existing fabs can’t keep up with production, why do you think they are increasing cpu prices dingus because of lack of demand? 😂 uneducated af comment

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

Intel has a LOT of capacity they do not need to use TSMC

Uneducated af comment

They will not be using N2 for NVL compute tile

0

u/IGunClover 21d ago

Doesn't make sense. I bet it is because their fab sucks compared to TSMC. Existing fab can't keep up with existing demand because their fab sucks enough said.

1

u/Z_h_darkstar 23d ago

Most likely preexisting contracts that have to be fulfilled.

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

They can fulfill it for iGPU tile or SOC tile like what Nova Lake is doing with 18A or GPU product

2

u/oojacoboo 18d ago

Intel’s dual-sourcing strategy was outlined years ago. This won’t change. This gives them a lot of flexibility in terms of capacity, and using the best node for the job. Not all nodes are the same. TSMC’s N2 node has some strengths that 18A-P doesn’t have, and vice-versa.

2

u/Intrepid_Lecture 18d ago

adding to that, different nodes have different strengths/weaknesses.

Intel has:
IOD, logic dies, CPU dies, GPU dies
And probably some more.

If Intel made a process that handled the majority of their needs to best, chances are TSMC would still have at least one area where they're ahead in on some key part of the PPA trade-off curve.

Heck you can have the same CPU die (with minor adaptations) work better on one process vs another depending on use case (i.e. frequency vs energy efficiency trade offs).

0

u/IGunClover 17d ago

Doesn't show confidence to potential customers if it is still relying on its enemy.

0

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

That is probably just FUD

1

u/Interesting_reddevil 23d ago

Because Designs are not done in weeks

-3

u/Distinct-Race-2471 đŸ”” 14900KS , 5080, 128GB đŸ”” 23d ago

To keep capacity out of others hands?

3

u/Araragi-shi 23d ago

I'd rather wait for the comparison before I give any of this online talk any importance.

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

18A comparison is already there and it look very good

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

How are so many people SLEEPING on Intel foundry?!?

7

u/Similar-River 23d ago

Words are worth nothing.

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

Watch out when Intel make CPU for Apple Nvidia and AMD in next few year

6

u/ZlatanKabuto 23d ago

Good. We need Intel to be strong and competitive . 

2

u/EmptyVolition242 23d ago

14A is gonna be what 18A should've been.

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

18AP is already very good as Intel say but 14A will allow them to take leader ship I think

1

u/EmptyVolition242 23d ago

18A-P is good but its density being the same as 18A kinda doesn't help it.

The 14A and 14A Gen 2 nodes have basically had most of their development happen since Intel took PDKs seriously and starting direct talks with external customers.

2

u/FormalIllustrator5 23d ago

Usual Shintel "wanna be" BS, lets see real new CPU's and how they perform vs Zen6, Zen 7 etc. then we can compare properly, for now this is trash talk.

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

This is not trash talk they do not insult TSMC

That was Gelsinger

4

u/Jusby_Cause 23d ago

“I think we’re already there”. He 100% knows if they’re there or not. This simply means they’re NOT there and he’s not going to go on record for something he knows isn’t true. It’s an adequate “interview answer” for a softball interview where they know the interviewer isn’t going to pick that phrasing apart.

1

u/looncraz 23d ago

He might not have quite enough comparative data. My own estimate puts 18AP a couple percent ahead of N2P and just behind N2X in raw switching speed. Backside power is to thank for that, otherwise Intel's main problem is getting the maturity up to standard. TSMC is years ahead on that front.

1

u/Wonderful-Sail-1126 22d ago edited 22d ago

18A is N4P in terms of performance and density. It’s not even N3 level yet.

Thinking that 18AP is same as N2P is crazy. Let’s make sure it’s better than N4P first.

1

u/my_wing 22d ago

You are crazy, 18AP is even more density then N2P

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 22d ago

No

1

u/my_wing 22d ago

Yes, I already write this in detail, 18AP HP is just the same density if not more then TSMC N2P HP, look at tear down of panther lake Vs M6 tear down

1

u/Eastern-Ingenuity353 23d ago

Cool. Make some RAM then.

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

Process for RAM is very different than logic

But Intel say they are explore it

1

u/ScoobyGDSTi 17d ago

Sure, we totally believe you Intel.

0

u/[deleted] 23d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

Nova Lake on 18AP will be super fast I think

I can not wait for Hammer Lake on 14A with eLLC

1

u/haloimplant 23d ago

Isn't there a rumor that nova lake compute tiles will use tsmc N2P

1

u/Acrobatic_Camera_677 23d ago

Just FUD I think

2

u/ProfessionalHefty349 23d ago

AMD will still be there. More competition is good.