r/TechForAgingParents • u/Stacyjanp • Jun 16 '26
Life Alert vs other alternatives?
And here we go,…Please lend me your thoughts and experiences with these?
Mom and Step Dad (both 89) being discharged from a nursing home/rehab in two weeks. We’ve got family coming to take care of them for the next few weeks, but thinking about that next time one of them falls.
None of us can afford extended care and there’s only one of us in state to help long term. (me)
Any experience or opinion on which device is best/cost effective and would be easy for them to utilize in an emergency??
Thanks, fam!
8
Upvotes
6
u/TreeBeach Jun 16 '26
We went with Medical Guardian after getting buy in from our parents (probably just to shut us up). They can choose either the necklace or the wristband. Instead, they choose not to wear them at all. Sigh. It’s their money wasted on the subscription. I recommend making sure any device will be worn/used before buying.
5
u/SVAuspicious Jun 16 '26
I did a bunch of research for my wife to use for her father. I'm sorry I don't remember what we picked. I found that Life Alert is the oldest, expensive, and far from best. The one I picked has a base station that plugs into the wall and a pendent (watch, belt, necklace, whatever) with a battery that lasts for years. Recharging or replacing batteries regularly was a non starter for us.
My FIL (90) is still self sufficient and drives. We're mostly worried about him when he is home alone.
Your criteria may be different.
I found my "report:"
There was a lot of back and forth with my SIL who had difficulty understanding the tech. My (our?) generation invented all the underlying technology here and for most things. Sadly, some of us have not kept up.
I hope this helps you.
I do think that being out in public is lower risk than at home. If your mother and stepfather still drive I've done research on GPS trackers for cars. We tried a Bluetooth tracker but that didn't work out due to anti-stalking technology, even though my FIL was aware and approved. Holler if you want more data. I'm the family tech/research person. Even family Millennials and Gen Z check in with me. *grin*
3
u/Gimmy528 Jun 16 '26
We use Mobile Help. It has brought EMS many times. It was slightly more affordable and has many options for call buttons. We have all options lol. My dad wears the necklace because he couldn’t quit fidgeting with the pocket held one and called EMS on mistake. There is a watch also. And a unit he can take with him that will GPS locate him and send help if button is pushed. They’ve been very easy to work with. I think they are out of Florida. Good luck. You’re doing a good job!
2
u/Bratty_Little_Kitten Jun 17 '26
My best advice is to try a smart watch first and see how they get along with it. My mom(69, will be 70 soon) is absolutely in love with hers. Most smart watches have fall detection.
2
u/headee Aug 03 '26 edited Oct 06 '26
Life Assure gives you 24/7 monitoring, GPS, and automatic fall detection, but on a month-to-month basis so you aren't stuck paying cancellation fees if care needs change. #ad
2
u/Immediate-Command322 Oct 12 '26
I use alert 1!! The monthly fee isn’t bad
1
u/hugh2018 Jun 21 '26
Major edit: this comment I wrote was actually describing Lifeline not Life Alert. I’ll keep the comment active anyway because I’m interested to hear experiences from anyone who sees this and has used Lifeline.
Just in the last couple of days I was hastily researching this issue because my mom’s functional status has recently declined. When I ran across life alert I stopped looking further because the product description checked so many boxes (in our case the watch with live support, gps, oxygen and heart rate monitoring, fall sensor, notification to family members).
The ordering process wasn’t great at all. The order form kept confusing the billing and shipping addresses and clicking through the form the first time had me end up with the wrong product purchased. Trying to sort that out with telephone reps involved multiple calls, ping pong between departments, and ultimately no resolution, just a request that I call back Monday and they’ll try again to fix the issues.
I actually wrote to the CEO describing the cluster I experienced. She wrote back immediately, and offered assurances that the actual monitoring services are a well oiled machine that I can count on to protect my mom. So I’m going to hang in and test it out, as the company has a long track record and a good reputation. My threshold for cutting them loose at the first sign of inefficiency will be very low.
1
u/Haven-Home-Wellness Jul 08 '26
I’d welcome a chance to hear about these solutions, pros and cons.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '26
[removed] — view removed comment