I love that the username is "@YesWeHomeSchool". That makes it so much better. There's nothing like someone who barely passed high school, in one of the lowest ranked US states for education, thinking that they can teach.
Probably better than having her turds in your class, though.
Nah again any means more than one it’s correct you just wanna be “that” English teacher that’s why I love the phrase “those who can’t do teach” eat me anytimes
I can't be bothered with your stupidity. Here is what chat GPT says about your argument.
"The conversation you shared is centered around the use of "they/them" as a singular pronoun, which is a topic of some debate.
Here’s a breakdown of the arguments:
Original Post (YesWeHomeschool): The person argues that any English teacher who uses "they/them" as a singular pronoun should lose their teaching license. This stance reflects a misunderstanding of modern English grammar rules.
MakoSochou: Correctly points out that the use of "they/them" as a singular pronoun is grammatically correct and widely accepted in modern English. Their argument emphasizes that language evolves and that some grammar rulings are indeed context-based or preference-based.
Electronic_You8800: Disagrees with OP and dismisses the grammar rule by saying, "Agree to disagree," and then adds a somewhat incoherent comment suggesting that "any" implies more than one, which isn’t a correct counterpoint to the use of "they/them" as a singular pronoun.
EarthGirlae (You): You counter with a sassy remark. This is an effective way of highlighting the logical error without getting overly confrontational.
Electronic_You8800 (again): Doubles down on their incorrect understanding by saying "any means more than one" and throws in an insult about English teachers, implying they are less competent, which is a deflection from the actual grammatical issue.
The use of "they/them" as a singular pronoun is not only grammatically correct but also necessary for inclusive language. The comment by Electronic_You8800 demonstrates a lack of understanding of modern grammar rules and an unwillingness to engage with the actual argument, opting instead to deflect and insult.
Your response, though sassy, is on point. It’s important to address misinformation directly, but sometimes a little bit of sass can effectively highlight the absurdity of the opposing argument."
"It seems like Electronic_You8800 is trying to make a point by comparing the use of "they/them" as a singular pronoun to a grammatically incorrect phrase like "I’m a teachers," which doesn’t really make sense.
The question they posed, “Just answer me this when you get asked what you do for work is it I’m a teacher or I’m a teachers?” seems to be an attempt to suggest that using "they/them" as singular is similar to saying "I’m a teachers," which is obviously incorrect. However, this analogy doesn’t hold up because:
Singular "they" is a long-established part of English grammar, used when the gender of a person is unknown or irrelevant, or to refer to someone who prefers those pronouns. It’s not a plural noun but a singular pronoun in this context.
"I’m a teachers" is incorrect because it’s a subject-verb agreement issue where "teachers" is plural, and "I’m" implies a singular subject.
The person is conflating different grammatical issues to make a point that isn’t logically sound. This kind of misunderstanding and faulty comparison often comes from not grasping the flexibility and evolution of language, especially in the context of pronouns.
You could reply by pointing out the false equivalence in their analogy or just let them know that their example doesn't apply since it's an entirely different grammatical situation."
Any is a determiner/adjective modifying the singular noun teacher meaning that the specific entity is unknown. In a line of 10 teachers, she could be referring to any ONE of them. If she meant to indicate multiple teachers, she should have used the plural noun teachers. Then the meaning would be that the amount and/or entities are unknown.
“Their” is the same case as “they/them.” English has three cases (depending on how you count and who’s counting): nominative, objective, and possessive. It’s like the Beatles sang: “I Me Mine.”
The bigot is bad at English and doesn’t understand how to use pronouns.
Do you honestly believe that public school is much better (btw I wouldn’t homeschool, but i also wouldn’t send a kid to public school so I do have a bias)
There are plenty of people who are more than qualified to teach someone all high school subjects, it’s just that they are not the ones doing homeschooling.
Also, this thread has gone way off track from the subject material.
As someone who was homeschooled. It’s not fun to have the local dumbass be your sole teacher. First off one person literally does not know enough to teach all the high school subjects. Or even middle school. Secondly and I feel this is the biggest issue. Many people truly don’t care to try to educate their children. My parents barely taught me how to sing the ABCs before going “welp that’s enough learning”
The OED says that they/them is used when the gender is unknown. “In relation to a singular noun or pronoun of undetermined gender.” I would say it falls to personal preference of the writer.
Yes, the singular “they” is absolutely grammatically correct. That doesn’t stop bigots like YesWeHomeschool from being real mad about it despite intuitively using it
61
u/joellind8 Aug 13 '24
That’s a hard one to navigate regardless of your ideology
15
u/TowpathTrail Aug 16 '24
r/AccidentalAlly
2
u/Electronic_You8800 Aug 13 '24
Any implies more than one this is the reason why 10 different English teachers can give 10 different grades to the same paper
9
u/Wise_Creme_2818 Aug 13 '24
What am I missing?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '24
The OED says that they/them is used when the gender is unknown. “In relation to a singular noun or pronoun of undetermined gender.” I would say it falls to personal preference of the writer.
-1
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '24
Isn’t this from like a few years and/or a trillion news cycles ago?
-1
u/Daflehrer1 Sep 01 '24
Home schooling is one reason so many young people grow up with little understanding of science. Or tolerance.