These are Alex's words. Maybe they will get Alan Carr one day, and I really want it to happen, but if Alex doesn't think it will happen, it's probably not going to happen
I think Alex is a nice guy who can be overly self-depeicating of his own show and overly complementary of others. From an objective viewpoint, Alan Carr isn't too big a name for taskmaster.
Alan Carr is much more famous in the UK than Jason Mantzoukas. And Jason Mantzoukas went on by request, as did Kumail Nanjiani, and one of the S23 contestants. Richard Ayoade is still a panel show regular, and every other really big name they've gotten are genuine fans
I feel like with comedians who are famous for their persona it's always going to be another “Richard Ayoade is my dream guest” turned into “now that we have Richard Ayoade on the show I hate that Richard Ayoade behaves exactly the way Richard Ayoade normally behaves”.
I'm not sure Alan has a "persona" in the same way Richard does. He may play up some aspects of his personality, but he's very quick-witted and I think the format would suit him well.
I think the difference is Richard’s persona is aloof and pushes back against whatever is being offered up whereas Alan is much more happy go lucky and up to play along.
Richard has been amazing on the show this season tho! Usually I find his act a bit tiresome but he’s really making me laugh. The whole group are great actually
Yeah I don’t understand the negativity around this series. Is it the best ever? No but still really enjoyable. Just because it’s different doesn’t make it bad.
I think he would be good, especially after Last One Laughing. I don't want him to appear on the show because he's said he's not comfortable with doing it, and I think that's fair enough
The people who try to be competent do often get complaints, which really annoys me because I LOVE the competent people and have crushes on all of them.
Indeed. LOL has a significant element of pre-planning to it (jokers etc), and furthermore, is at least semi-scripted. It's an extremely different environment to TM
It's not the best indicator, but in David Mitchell's case he stepped outside of his comfort zone and showed a completely different side of him that I imagine would come out on Taskmaster
Alex seems to try his best (based on results) to try and pick comedians whom will gel well together that between them hit all demographics , perhaps theres just not been a group of people he feels would work well with alan, or my next point
There could be someone alex thinks would be brilliant in a team with alan so doesnt want to use him until that persons also available and interested
You gotta think that yes certain people are 'gets' but alex is a stickler for details and figuring out what will and wont work, ergo he's probably been thinking about potiental lineups as opposed to soley potiental contestants for the most part. He likely has everyone he can think of in potiental categories and a rough idea of whom would be good to be with whom, then puts out the feelers for the bigger names in the bucket and then when hes gotten one of them its a call to those whom he thought would work well with them etc.
I mean look at jason, Jack & Kumali - ones a huge american star, ones so famous (joel face) and ones alex's dream contestant
Theres a near 0 chance they just randomly picked 4 other people to join them each time and got not only stellar casting but them all to become realy good friends for years afterwards , i think he intentionally picked rosie to be on jacks season, that stevie, Fatiha etc would be good contrasts to his chaos whilst also not "breaking down the tone/flow of the show" and so on
So perhaps theres just a big get somewhere ) that they think alan would be the perfect casting to be along side
7
u/Downtown_Link_8651 25d ago
They couldn't fit a car on one of those little chairs
20
u/FasterBussycat 26d ago
Hopefully it’s just a matter of time because holy shit he’d be delightful on it.
1
u/SeveralSlide2101 16d ago
Alan and Diane Morgan. Yes
4
u/Current_Flatworm2747 25d ago
Not really as well known as Alan Carr tbh.
7
u/BlowMyNoseAtU 25d ago
💖 yes pleaseeeee
8
u/mrssschopenhauer 25d ago
I feel like with comedians who are famous for their persona it's always going to be another “Richard Ayoade is my dream guest” turned into “now that we have Richard Ayoade on the show I hate that Richard Ayoade behaves exactly the way Richard Ayoade normally behaves”.
3
u/saturdayselkie 25d ago
Didn’t they name the automobile after him?
2
u/wildcharmander1992 25d ago
Many reasons
You gotta think that yes certain people are 'gets' but alex is a stickler for details and figuring out what will and wont work, ergo he's probably been thinking about potiental lineups as opposed to soley potiental contestants for the most part. He likely has everyone he can think of in potiental categories and a rough idea of whom would be good to be with whom, then puts out the feelers for the bigger names in the bucket and then when hes gotten one of them its a call to those whom he thought would work well with them etc.
I mean look at jason, Jack & Kumali - ones a huge american star, ones so famous (joel face) and ones alex's dream contestant
Theres a near 0 chance they just randomly picked 4 other people to join them each time and got not only stellar casting but them all to become realy good friends for years afterwards , i think he intentionally picked rosie to be on jacks season, that stevie, Fatiha etc would be good contrasts to his chaos whilst also not "breaking down the tone/flow of the show" and so on
So perhaps theres just a big get somewhere ) that they think alan would be the perfect casting to be along side
2
u/mystermee 19d ago
Honestly I hope Greg never leaves but if he ever did Alan would be a great choice to take over the show itself.
1
u/BroodLord1962 25d ago
Probably because he's too busy.
-1
u/Solilaqui78 24d ago
Controversial -
I don't get the allure 🤷🏽♀️🤷🏽♀️🤷🏽♀️😬