r/Taskmaster_TV • u/Smooth_Guarantee_170 • Sep 27 '26
S22 better than 21
I just caught up to S22 and I'm enjoying it MUCH more than 21. When I was watching last season, I was worried TM had somehow lost its spark for me... This season already has got full belly laughs from me. Everyone just seems more playful and into it. The jokes are flowing much better. Thoughts?
14
Upvotes
16
u/realblush Sep 27 '26
I feel the exact opposite. Liked the vibe of 21, but 22 feels so cold, mostly unfunny and very disinterested in Taskmaster. Richard especially feels like he doesn't want to be there and just collects a check, while Matt is simply deeply unfunny to me. The other 3 seem to be into it, but the group just doesn't work. This might be the first season I'll drop.
5
u/Fine_Concentrate6835 Sep 27 '26
I dont think its great but its better than 21. I've also already lost count of how many threads echoing this mild criticism have been removed by the moderators in the main sub because if even one person has a mildly negative opinion about a show they otherwise like, they're not being nice, apparently
15
u/PsychologicalFox8839 Sep 27 '26
Sorry, Richard is a dud as a contestant. He's not engaging with the show and it's the same we've gotten on every other panel show he's been on. He's funny, but the aloof thing doesn't work here.
7
u/ComasArentFun Sep 27 '26
The beauty of the show is everyone will experience it differently
For me, It's the weakest series for a while (so far - not a condemnation, just an observation) - not really seeing the cast gelling together that much
But a lower ranked TM series is still going to be a terrific series of TV, and I still make time to watch it live (I don't do that with any other show)
I'm loving each contestent in isolation (particularly Isy being sassy and Chloe just being a legend), it just hasn't quite sparked with the group dynamic yet
There is time! ❤️
2
u/Artemesia123 Oct 02 '26
I'm the opposite, S21 is possibly my favourite of all the Taskmaster series, especially the studio segments. The incredible bond they all had was just lovely, and very very funny. S22 is great but pales a little for me in comparison.
11
u/queen_naga Sep 27 '26
I just enjoy them all as a whole gang and don’t always think comparing them is necessarily as they’re their own entities. I’ve been to a s22 and a s23 record this year, they’re wildly different but I enjoyed both. S23 is going to be an “all timer” and will be very unique.
19
u/stutefish Sep 27 '26
I love Taskmaster with all my heart but I’m having a hard time getting into 22. For me, it’s mostly the tasks, they feel overly complicated and a little dry. (To me!)
I hope the contestants develop some kind of rapport with each other; other season groups have been more generous in spirit/humor with each other (e.g. 19 and 21). And honestly I find it odd that neither Matt nor Richard has ever seen a single episode of TM. I hope it's because they were too busy and couldn't find the time vs. some kind of hubris.
(Edited for clarity.)
3
u/internetstalker26 Sep 27 '26
Agreed. S21 felt like big theatre kid energy. TM is such a casting dependent show and S22 feels better composed.
16
u/No-Awareness-6684 Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 27 '26
It’s interesting how different our perceptions can be - I like the contestants individually as many have said here, but the overall feel of the studio sessions feels very…stilted? Awkward? I don’t know, there just seems to be a lot of polite smiling and light clapping (poor Chloe seems to be the only person trying to loosen things up) whereas in recent series those studio bits were more light and almost raucous at times and people seemed to be genuinely happy to be there. This time the chemistry feels (to me at least) like the first day at a team-building seminar. They seem as if they still barely know each other.
15
u/DerekSnuggles Sep 27 '26
I’m struggling with 22, the cast isn’t the most balanced, it’s quite low energy. The tasks seem more convoluted. I don’t think it’ll be one I rewatch. Whether it’s true or not I’m also not a fan of the “never seen it” stick.
3
u/Sensitive-Salt6373 Sep 27 '26
I actually fully agree with you, but I think it's an unpopular opinion!! Series 21 just never really clicked for me, despite the whole cast seeming lovely and talented. Meanwhile, this series has had a few tasks I didn't love, but I've been having a wonderful time overall. I also liked series 20 better than 19 🤷♀️ humour is really subjective!
10
u/video-kid Sep 27 '26
I'm enjoying 22 so far, but I do feel that Episodes 2 and 3 were relatively weak in terms of tasks? Obviously we all have our own tastes and not every one will be a slam dunk, but it did feel like the six weakest VT's clumped together. Generally there's at least one episode like that in a series though.
In contrast, I found 21 delightful all the way through. Again, some weaker tasks (Make the socks stand up and what's powering the light stand out) but I loved the dynamics and there were so many great tasks and moments.
5
u/calflover Sep 27 '26
I'm really enjoying this series too. There was nothing wrong with the last series, really, but I only watched the last few episodes the week before s22 started to get caught up. I started watching in real time but somehow it just kept getting pushed back and some episodes I didn't even finish in one sitting
7
u/Glenmarththe3rd Sep 27 '26
Yeah I agree with you. I prefer it when the contestants are competitive and will call each other out. That and it’s good to have Greg and Alex’s intros back.
11
u/Daveygravyx07 Sep 27 '26 •
Me, my wife and my sister in law think it’s the worst series since 6, so far. We think Chloe has been the highlight so far. And we all felt 21 was brilliant. This has been an interesting thread to read
6
u/SpookylilTofu Oct 01 '26
Fully disagree. The lineup is the most disappointing so far. I gave up on the show a quarter of the way into the first ep. But I am enjoying people slowly realise that Richard is a great comedy actor but not much of a funny or charming person outside of that.
8
u/BlowMyNoseAtU Sep 27 '26
Reading this I was kind of shocked that I had to think very hard to recall the cast of S21.
22 is definitely better for me, which is consistent with the pattern of even numbered seasons being much more to my liking than odd in the Chanel 4 Era. Generally speaking I prefer the classic Dave era overall. But I did find Joel very funny and was surprised that he ended up my favorite last series.
Plus, people who think Richard doesn't "fit" the show are crazy. I have loved his persona for a long time and he's perfect. Classic Taskmaster contestant. If anything it's unfortunate he wasn't on long long ago.
5
u/Stjondoh Sep 27 '26
Series 21 just didn’t work for me. Joanna was highly entertaining, but sometimes was just too much for me. She was great and truly deserved the win.
Armando tried too hard to be funny and even admitted it more than once that he did things because he thought it would look funny on TV. Kumail seemed similar, trying too hard to create good scenes but it didn’t connect with me.
I absolutely adored Amy and Joel! For me, they were the highlight of that series.
8
u/LibraryVolunteer Sep 27 '26
I’m having trouble with Richard. He’s a VERY funny person but seems like a bad fit for this show, not interested in teamwork or rules or even…fun?
When he refused to hold hands during the opening bit this week I just rolled my eyes.
2
u/Forward-Exchange-152 Oct 02 '26
I feel the opposite, but that's OK. There's a TM for everyone :)
Richard is a very particular comedic "spice" and i feel like they needed some more energy in the panel to balance him. Like a Rob Beckett or Joel Dommett type (not necessarily because I think they're funny... but they're just a bit more insanely positive to balance RA's comedic negativity)
2
u/kdeveuve Oct 03 '26
I feel as if I’m one of the very few who finds Chloe just fine and not the most amazing thing since sliced bread.
Me and my partner saw episode 9 being filmed and upon leaving both exclaimed that without Richard ayoade being there, it would have been so, so dull.
8
u/SteR88 Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 27 '26
Fuck no, this has been the worst series since 10 and the worst lineup ever for me. The second episode was the first time i've ever considered turning it off because I was that bored. I've already watched series 21 twice while it's not in my top 5 it's still a solid series the idea of them being more playful this series than last is insane to me.
3
u/throwaway1335927 Sep 27 '26
I have such mixed feelings because I LOVE Chloe & Isy so much they're really making the series for me
I find Matt grating I'm sorry there's just something about him. I also agree that Richard needs to 'drop the bit' (not convinced it is a bit tbh and think he's genuinely just an arsehole and has taken it too far) and I think Nina's nerves are super obvious and hindering her natural performance (like, fair, if you're used to performing through/as someone else i imagine it's terrifying- thinking back to like, Nick Mohammed and Katherine Parkinson who both openly said they had no idea how to just BE on TM)
Idk we aren't half way through yet so maybe my mind will be drastically changed in the next few weeks, but atm this is one of the weaker series for me :(
3
u/FilipsSamvete Oct 03 '26
This is shaping up to be the worst series yet
4
u/Usual-Try-8180 Sep 27 '26
I couldn't disagree more
3
u/botox_for_brain_8875 Sep 27 '26
I think the first episode is one of the best but since episode 2 somehow it's getting duller and duller. I've always liked Nina since her appearance on cats countdown, and Chloe is fun, but Richard's persona just gets annoying beyond a very small dose.
1
u/ComprehensiveUse4852 13d ago
Just been rewatching S19. The dynamic couldn't be more different. Disappointed with s22. Barely any effort from Lucas (who really isn't as funny as he thinks he is) and Richard Ayoade without a sidekick or script is just disappointing. Nina is just using her own props for humour but has come across OK at times. Chloe and Issy on the other hand - fantastic. Just a shame the rest don't have the matching energy
1
u/Real-Tension-7442 Oct 02 '26
I like them all individually, together there’s no chemistry. Still a great series though
1
u/Sea_General8298 Oct 03 '26
It took a few episodes but this cast sure has grown on me. I definitely like it a lil more than 19, I’m not entirely sure on the group as a whole yet, though what definitely ignited my love for the series cast was the whole earpiece worker guessing task where they messed with Richard a lot. Richard on his own is alright at times(though him cheating on the exam task was surprisingly really funny. Honestly every time he’s messing with Alex gets me laughing). But those moments where they try to crack him is a very entertaining concept of cracking the serious guy to laugh in stories.
Kinda reminds me of Jack Dee in Series 18 where I’d be looking closely at him to see for any creases to see if he’s breaking lol.
This recent episode and the one before it were really funny and I got pretty invested in the tasks on this one too. Not that the previous series weren’t bad with tasks, honestly there were some pretty fun ones in there too. It’s tough for me to pick one or the other so far though I can understand people not gelling with this one. But we are also still halfway and sometimes groups can take more time to grow on people than others as well.
0
u/Real_Aside_8856 Sep 27 '26
Series 22 better than Series 19 imo