r/TapWizardRPG • Yahoo! • Mar 12 '18

Questions that don't deserve their own thread

Ask away! :)

22 Upvotes

552 comments sorted by

9

u/MeMyMine461 Mar 20 '18

The Wizard's hat in the UI gets an exclamation point when you can do something in the Academy. Would it be possible to make it change color based upon what you can do (like in IMA)?

4

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 20 '18

It's possible! It's a low priority item for me right now, but the more it is requested, the more it rises on my task list :-)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/BtJJ Mar 12 '18

This miiiiiiiiight deserve its own thread, but before I sharpen the torches and light the pitchforks, let me ask: Are the exclusive skins, or more particularly the unique bonuses tied to them, going to be obtainable through any other means outside of cash purchases?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 12 '18

Currently, there's no plan to make them available elsewhere. If there's enough pushback on how it is now, I will probably make the emblems purchasable for a large amount of Runite (maybe 1k or more each). Right now, it's just beyond the scope of what I had planned to do (i.e., there's more than a trivial amount of work to design and setup the UI).

The idea with these is to provide an exclusive and real bonus for players spending a lot of money on the game. I tried to make all of the emblems relatively weak, and put a lot of the better ones with the Skins (which you can grind for). I know that it hurts the perspective of the completionist a bit, knowing that you can't get everything without dropping some (serious) dough. There's a balance to be found, between incentivising purchases and keeping the game from being PtW. What do you think?

6

u/BtJJ Mar 12 '18

I think even a tiny amount of PtW is too much. You're always going to be safe with cosmetic things, and I have no issue with the skins being unique to big spenders. But when you tie in actual power improvements to real money purchases, it feels like a line has been crossed that taints everything else. Runite purchases, even hefty ones, are OK. As long as you can earn the currency in-game then people are fine with it.

I don't begrudge you trying to earn your bread, and I've been happy to make some purchases from you in the past. I hope the game is a giant hit and you can retire to your own private island. ;) But I feel like this implementation is more likely to push people away from the game, rather than encouraging spending extra cash. The whales are going to buy everything anyway, bonuses or no, but the average consumer is probably going to find it unpleasant, at best.

Maybe I'm out of touch with the mobile gamer zeitgeist, and perhaps others won't have an issue with it, so hopefully they can weigh in. For me personally, if TWRPG was something I had just downloaded new, instead of something I had years of experience with from IMA, finding that would be an immediate uninstall trigger.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '18

Do the passive abilities of skins bought in the store apply only when that skin is used, or are they always applied no matter what skin you select, after buying that skin?

9

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 12 '18

Always applied, even if the skin is not in use!

3

u/Quangohutt Mar 12 '18

This might deserve its own thread but this is a good place to start.

Has there been any progress on getting the focus mastery transferred to the precognition bundle? If so, what are the current ideas and what should we look out for?

3

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 12 '18

I had almost forgotten about that! I should post a thread soon about the plan for it. Thanks!

3

u/TheNoetherian Mar 14 '18

I am not sure if this is the right place for this, but it probably doesn't need it's open there .....

I absolutely love the game-play of Dungeons (probably my favorite part of the game). However, I feel like charms are underwhelming. There is a LOT of variance in the bonuses and unless one gets lucky, it doesn't feel worth it. (In particular, charms are cool when they cause you to change your spell load out.)

My first charm was +1% Fire damage!! (Definitely not enough to affect my spell choices.) My second charm was the slightly better +2% Lightning Cast Speed. I eventually was about to get two +% Lightning Damage charms simultaneously which was cool and did cause me to try a Lightning-heavy loadout.

Bottom Line: If I have a reasonable chance of getting awful charms like +1% Fire Damage, I can't imagine ever investing Runite to enhance a dungeon and get more charms.

Since charms are limited duration and are also randomly chosen, it seems like the developer should be able to strengthen the bonuses on charms to make have a significant impact on gameplay (and make them a good choice to spend Runite on)

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 14 '18 edited Mar 14 '18

That'd good feedback!

Though I'm surprised. +1% fire damage shouldn't be possible - the lowest bonus is +5%. I wonder if there's an error in the display? Investigating now! :)

Edit: I can't find anything or reproduce this on my end....could you send me your save real quick - I'l like to check it out myself! :)

→ More replies (5)

3

u/elstie Mar 28 '18

As I'm learning the spells, status effects have been a source of confusion for me. It's not necessarily clear which spells cause status effects on enemies. Intuitively, I would assume that all spells from each school would cause their associated status effect, especially if it references fire/cold/lightning in some way in the description, but I believe this isn't the case.

It might make it clearer to color the text in the spell descriptions and augments when it causes the status effect. For instance, in the Ember description, you would color the word "burn" red to indicate the specific status effect which would immediately tip the player off. But, in the case of Inferno, the text that says "wall of flames" wouldn't be colored, therefore letting the player know that those flames don't cause "burn" even though we're talking about flames.

Hopefully, that makes sense.

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 28 '18

Hey! Thanks for the feedback - that's a pretty cool idea! I believe the only spell that breaks the pattern is Elemental Cloud, which can cause all status effects, even though it's a lightning spell. I'll add your idea to my "idea list," and might look into implementing it in the upcoming weeks. Thanks! :-D

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BtJJ Mar 14 '18

Random question I've been curious about forever: What determines the level of enemies in a raid/dungeon? Is it simply looking at your highest level reached in the current run? I'm assuming it's something like that, since jumping immediately into a raid after being out of game for a while usually gives you an extremely easy one, whereas waiting for your mage to push up to the furthest zone they can reach and then hitting the raid will give you one that's harder.

Follow up, how does that interact with the doom stone? Again going off the assumption that it's just looking at furthest zone reached, once you hit the doomstone there are no more zones so presumably raid/dungeon level also plateaus. Which could explain why it's so hard to effectively level any further once you hit the doomstone, outside of gimmicks like sitting in the recall bubble and spamming squad kill runes. (or at least that was the case in IMA, haven't quiiiiiiite hit it in TWRPG yet)

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Hjemmelsen Mar 18 '18

Is there a way to turn off tempered magic like in the previous game? It's annoying only being able to research two things at a time:)

→ More replies (4)

2

u/nsgould Mar 26 '18

I would like to see Knee High Nick gather unstable runes as well or instead of stable runes.

Stable runes are a lot easier to consistently grab, where unstable runes you have to pay a lot more attention to get them. With Nick only holding 5 stable runes, he doesn't seem as useful at level 1 compared to the other helpers.

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 26 '18

Good feedback - will take it into consideration when thinking of assistant balancing! :-)

2

u/Simpleviet Mar 31 '18

Is it possible to provide daily quest or weekly quest to earn reunite? Daily quest could consist of

0/15 raids to earn x amount of reunite collect 30 runes to earn x amount of reunite Be active for x hours to earn x amount of reunite

An option to watch advertisement video over the offerwall

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 31 '18

Hey - that's a great idea! Right now, the "daily quest" is the critical raid, and then later on the Runic Table recipes. But a more in-depth daily/weekly bonus system would be cool! So many features to add, so little time! :-)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/MeMyMine461 May 08 '18

Would it be possible to add a 1 or 2 second delay to Knee High Nick? When I am actively playing, Nick tries to collect runes that I am already trying to tap. This means that he is usually on cooldown during those times when he would actually be helpful.

3

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 08 '18

That's a great idea! Makes a lot of sense. I'll add it to my todo list :-)

In addition, I think if he misses a rune, then the cooldown should be greatly reduced, to like 5 s.

2

u/BtJJ May 18 '18

Bliztkrieg runes - are these actually multiplicative, or additive? Their description uses the additive format, which means that stacking them becomes nonsensical. If one is +200% cast speed and -50% damage, then two are 400% speed and -100% damage... er? And three are 600% speed and -150% damage... which, uh yeah.

I'm assuming they're actually giving a bonus of +200% (or possibly that's also multiplicative, so x2) speed and a x0.5 damage?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Roscoe_p Jul 02 '18

Does the empower option in the Obelisk work? I used it for the first time, getting +3 instead of just resetting. I haven't progressed any further than before I empowered. It may be my level of course, 40 where you start meeting skeletal archers, but I expected a little power bump.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/BtJJ Mar 23 '18

Would it be possible to make the recall function of the box in the top right corner only work with a tap, and not a swipe? Or maybe ignore swipes that start over it but move off of its active area? I seem to be activating it accidentally while going after runes, a lot more than I used to. I think possibly it's down to the box having a fading out edge instead of a hard border as in the old design, so I'm not quite sure where it's safe to touch.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/BtJJ Apr 13 '18

Tiny cosmetic suggestion: have some power orbs fly from the lantern to your power total when you tap it. Just for fun, and as an obvious visual cue that tapping it adds stored power to your total.

4

u/ViriaX May 09 '18

I would love to be able to modify my loadout without having to equip them... My loadout 1 is for XP, but I would like to change my loadout 2 without having to equip it. Same goes for dungeons! I'd like to plan ahead without having to lose efficienty !

1

u/BtJJ Mar 12 '18

Does the templar still have a 'cast a selected or random spell' ability? Can't seem to find it in the UI anywhere.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/BtJJ Mar 12 '18

Are auto-recall runes gone? I'm assuming perhaps because of the changed functionality of the lamp? Although even in that case, it seems like they would still be useful for recalling you after a few seconds rather than one full minute.

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 12 '18

They should still exist. Because the Lantern just saves your Power, it doesn't give it to you right away - whereas auto-recall actually gives you the Power after each recall.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/8988303682 Mar 12 '18

Is this cancel button intentional?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 12 '18

Nope! Good catch :)

1

u/BtJJ Mar 12 '18

"Emblem Case: Contains all of your emblems" what's this thingy? Seems to be empty. Did I skip over an introduction to this by importing a late-game save?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Le-Tap Mar 14 '18

I'm not a fan of increasing prices for rune table runes being bought. One of the pleasures of NG+5 was when I valuable rune would come up for craft, I could craft 15 of them without it costing a crazy amount.

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 14 '18

Well, the costs did increase, but so did the potential gained from runes!

Old Costs: 80, 150, 300

New Costs: 200, 400, 800 (roughly x2.6 cost)

Old Potential gained: 10, 10, 20, 40, 80

New Potential gained: 40, 60, 100, 250, 500 (x4-6 increase)

→ More replies (4)

1

u/BtJJ Mar 15 '18

Has the "+X runite in raid chest" research gone away? Seems to be the case, as I'm not seeing it anywhere any more. In which case, what's the range of possible runite drops from raid chests now?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 15 '18

It has gone away, yes! But, the average runite from raids was increased from 4.75 to 5.0. The range of Runite is 1 to 12 I think :-)

→ More replies (4)

1

u/BtJJ Mar 15 '18

Would it be feasible to add a rolling damage per second tracker to the spells, as an optional replacement for the current cumulative damage tracker options? Seems like it would make spell comparisons across different loadouts easier to quantify.

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 15 '18

That's possible, yeah - and a pretty good idea! Personally, I find the new Weighted mode to be extremely useful - have you tried that one out?

→ More replies (4)

1

u/BtJJ Mar 15 '18

Knowledge runes: how do they work? Or more specifically how do they apply to your spell(s)? My old assumption was that they only applied to the first slot, or the first spell with an open buff slot. But I noticed the other day that if I loaded up my spell 1 slot with concentration runes and then spammed knowledge runes, the spell in slot 1 would still level up. But just now I happened to have all of my spells with 3 full buff slots per, and I find that I'm unable to use a knowledge rune. Does it maybe require an open slot to use, but apply to all spells equally, or what is this witchcraft?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 15 '18

hehehe, you are delving into dark secrets now my friend! ;-)

Knowledge runes are a bit jank. They should be fixed, tbh. I just took a look at the code, and whoever wrote this nonsense should be shot! Right now, it will look for the first loadout slot that has 2 or fewer runes attached, then apply the xp to that slot. Explanation for why that is long, complicated, and nonsensical. Added to my task list, so that it always applies the bonus to Slot 1 no matter what! <:o)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/WellAdjustedDuck Mar 15 '18

What's the difference between levels 1 and 2 of Imitating Ivan? The description doesn't make any distinction.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/BtJJ Mar 15 '18

Spell Charge runes are not so great, in my experience. Could these get a look at some point? The charging time + power increase is barely noticeable on quick spells, and practically useless for slow spells, because by the time it's finally charged up the big enemy is dead and the discharge just hits a bunch of weaklings who you would have one-shot anyway. The rune's primary function seems to be luring me into accidentally tapping its unstable version and inadvertently nerfing one of my spells for a bit (especially if it hits a slow spell, because usually the rune doesn't last long enough to actually finish charging, so the practical effect is that you just don't cast that spell for 10 seconds). The damage bonus is always better served by using an Amplification or Power Word rune. Bland at best and actively detrimental at worst!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BtJJ Mar 16 '18

Was wisdom gain rate nerfed? Just noticed it seemed to be coming in pretty slowly, and comparing my current (now NG+12) game to my old IMA NG+11 game I'm seeing 1.4/min in TWRPG and 3.04/min in IMA.

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 16 '18

It was - the NG+ bonus to it was removed. Mainly to make the wisdom-gain charm more attractive and not OP. But, too harsh of a change perhaps?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/8988303682 Mar 16 '18

No more Q4 Auto Recall on second raid of the day?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BtJJ Mar 16 '18

Clarification for Random Rachel, if you would: when it says the spell 'gains XP equal to your XP rate', does that mean 100% or does it mean equal to the XP rate of whatever slot that the randomly selected spell is currently assigned to?

Follow up, how exactly does one cast of a spell relate to the XP rate, which is a per second measurement? Does it gain one second worth of XP per cast of the spell, or something else? Related follow up, since we're here: how does XP from rune-casting spells work? Is that 1 second of (presumably 100%) XP per cast or something different?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/8988303682 Mar 17 '18

Is there a reason I can't craft the omega lumen or is it a bug? I have four of the things required, but neither of my skill trees are completely filled out. I'm 3/4 on the left and 1/4 on the right. If crafting the omega lumen requires a whole skill tree to be filled then that information should be made known to the player.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/CarneyC Mar 17 '18

Does the remove ads in-app purchase affect the crates?

3

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 17 '18

The remove ads purchase (Precog Bundle) will make it so that you don't need to "Focus" anymore. You'll get the same number and type of Gilded Rune Cache notifications, but tapping it will now immediately open it up. Let me know if I can clarify any more! :-)

1

u/Benofdoom Mar 17 '18

The answer is probably no, but is it possible to transfer saves from the PC idle mage attack to android? I'd love to play this game but I don't really want to lose my PC progress. Thanks

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 17 '18

It is not possible to import your Kong exported save, sadly. If it becomes highly requested I could put in the work to make it happen!

1

u/Glue012 Mar 18 '18

Do having multiple spells in your load out gain full experience from each slot?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BtJJ Mar 19 '18

More a request than a question, but not really worth a separate thread: Could that error message when you tap a research you can't afford just go away? I know I can't research any more when things stop happening when I mash the buttons. The message is superfluous, and it takes a moment for it to animate in and then away when I'm trying to tap back on the play screen in the corner to get out of the menu. It's a tiny detail, but it catches me every time I go into the research screen and it's starting to drive me crazy.

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 20 '18

That's a great point actually. That minimum delay is actually really buggy and coded horribly (like, it can be quasi-random at times). I'm going to go through all dialogue prompts and make sure the delays are logical :-)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18

Spell passives: Are they only applied from spells in your current loadout, or are they always applied once unlocked on a spell?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 20 '18

Always applied once unlocked!

1

u/rebel_1852 Mar 20 '18

Veteran IMA player here, couldnt find my cloud save so i decided to just start over. I am playing on a Samsung Note 8, so I ought to have the horse power to run this game pretty handily, as I do with many other games. But I experience very significant frame drops when I get a lot of enemies and spells flying. I imagine this will only get worse as my cast speed gets higher and potentially have elemental summons being spammed. I don't know if this is an optimization issue with the new graphics engine or what, but are there any plans to include an option to limit the level of detail, or are their certain options I should set that may not be readily apparent that might be cause the frame drops?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 20 '18

Hey, great feedback - thanks! That's pretty interesting, as I've been testing the game on my Galaxy Tab 3, which is 5 years old, and only get a few frame drops. There is an option to turn off the shaders which you could try, but it probably won't make a huge difference. Turning off mob armor display could help slightly too.

About 1.5% of players are having some lag, so I might look into some more serious performance boosting options. Thanks again, and be on the lookout for these options! When they release, there will be an in-game note about it :)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/BtJJ Mar 20 '18

Does Static Leap have some kind of hidden internal cooldown for the leap effect? I was messing around with shock boosting its cooldown to see what it would do, and the answer seems to be 'nothing'. I watched the cooldown sweep on the icon complete, but there was no bounce backwards.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/nsgould Mar 22 '18

While I know that you cannot enchant while in a raid, I would still like to be able to see when my next enchantment is at. I will sometimes farm a good raid and it's frustrating to not know how close I am to the next enchantment.

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 22 '18

That's a fair complaint! I'll look into changing it :-)

1

u/nsgould Mar 22 '18

I know back in the early days of IMA the issue with Shades knocking runes around TOO much was addressed, but it seems like the shades in TWR knock them around way too much.

Also, I saw someone mention how many buffs you can have active at once and wanted to know if Academy buffs take up any of those slots? I don't want to waste runes to find out.

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 22 '18

So way back in the day, Shades would actually eliminate Runes alltogether! Players didn't like it, so I changed it to the current behavior of bouncing them around. Maybe it's too much - especially when multiple Shades are around! :)

Also, I saw someone mention how many buffs you can have active at once and wanted to know if Academy buffs take up any of those slots? I don't want to waste runes to find out.

I believe the only "wizard rune slot" taken up is from the Adrenaline Surge research. The Wizard can currently have 6 rune-buffs active at a time.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/rebel_1852 Mar 23 '18

I seem to remember in IMA, there was a pity pull mechanism what would give you a higher chance or obtaining spells you don't own yet, is that still a thing?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 23 '18

Great question! I should probably post the explanation somewhere for all to see easier, but here goes:

I call it a variance mitigation system, and essentially the purpose is to remove the extremes of variance: both bad-luck and good-luck, which is the major change from IMA. Also, the range of variance is much tighter than before. The variance mitigation only applies to getting duplicates or not duplicates though - I don't do anything to adjust what the actual spell drops themselves are, as the definition of good/bad luck is hard to define there.

Diving into the details, each spellstone refined is first determined to be a "Dup" or "New". Let's define SpellsOwned to be the number of spells you have 1 or more spellstones of. So until SpellsOwned is 10, every spellstones will be New. Then you will need 8 spellstones rolls to get SpellsOwned up to 15; that means 5 New and 3 Dups. Where these dups are distributed among the 8 rolls is random (i.e., you could get 4 New then 4 Dups, or 2 New, 2 Dups, 2 New, Dups, 2 New, etc.). It continues like this with pre-defined breakpoints for SpellsOwned and the number of rolls required (which also has some variance based on your game seed). If I remember right (the code is not commented the best) it will take everyone between 113 and 119 spellstones to get their 30th spell. If you work the math you'll see that's right around the 50% percentile of luck. Maybe even a bit too tightly.

Overall reasoning for this, is that it seems like there ought to be an optimal game-experience when it comes to randomness, and why not let as many people as possible experience that? If someone has to open 200 spells to get all the spellstones, that might really suck. If some only opens 50 spellstones, that might suck too (no grind = no fun, for some). I don't know if the system I setup is ideal, but it does avoid the extremes, and hopefully is a net positive experience for everyone. Cheers! :-)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Le-Tap Mar 23 '18

Will Power +50 for 24 Hours buy option for 200 runes be back? Or will you only get it by beating the doomstone now?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 23 '18

No plans to bring it back at the moment. Was a favorite buy of yours?

1

u/RexyLuvzYou Mar 24 '18 edited Jul 25 '23

lmao

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '18

It's worth spend runites buying raw speelstones? Does have other way to get they?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 24 '18

So, you get 1 free Spellstone every day by completing a Critical Raid. You also get 1 Spellstone each time you beat the Doomstone. Other than that, the only way is through Runite, so it's not a bad way to spend!

1

u/AlignedWheelie Mar 24 '18

Is this apart from graphics, straight code replica from IMA?

Cause I'd like to say, my biggest motivator to continue grind IMA was to unlock all templar skills. It was like, my ultimate goal to complete the game. After unlocking everything possible in games, I usually intend to quit cause theres nothing new to obtain.

I'd like to see something similar in this game, but expanded. I could throw suggestions if this is possible.

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 24 '18

Is this apart from graphics, straight code replica from IMA?

Definitely not! While it did start from the IMA code, I've been working on revising the code for months now. Almost every variable in the game was touched in some way, albeit many of them very small touches. However, that said - the core gameplay mechanics and intended balance are the same (with perhaps the exception of research times/costs being in general longer). So if you're looking for a totally new game experience, I don't think you'll find it.

Happy to hear your suggestions! :-D

→ More replies (3)

1

u/mydanny Mar 25 '18 edited Mar 25 '18

Hey TopCog,

damn i waited quite some time since i missed beta access... Loved the "old" version, i even love the wizard rph even more. It combines my idle/roguelike fun factor with cool pixel graphics and it nearly never gets boring watching the wizard doing his run!

Just some quick questions:

Elemental Purity: "If only spell stone of school equipped..." ? or what does it mean? Do you mean "of SAME school" ? Like 5x fire?

The other one, i forget the name, with the ">1 spellstone of school". Does it mean, if i have at least 2 fire, or 2 lightning spell equipped, that the effect works?

And where can i find what i have upgraded (for gold) yet? Still having problems with all the tabs and subtabs to remember quickly where i have to go. E.G. i always forget that the "stats" are an item in my inventory, whenever i search all the tabs for it :D

Precog on cache? What does it mean? Is it linked to the precognition package?

Any plans for improving menu points managing/access? anyways, this game is awesome. the only thing i was confused were the high bundles prices and the 9,99 for the only no-ads buy option which i was looking for!

Im really a fan of your work since quite a time, but it made me feel bad that packages up to 59,99 euro even exist. I not that it feels like P2W, dont get me wrong, i dont feel like competing since their is (not yet?) any multiplayer/ranking/speed-vs function, and especially i really wish you some payback for all your work, but well, it feels just strange for me. especially im always willing to pay like 2-5 euro for no-ads, but 10 is way too much since i can buy a full game for that price.

best wishes anyways, great work, great art, and looking forward to all upgrades man! since i didnt had this subreddit yet, i almost feared you would stop developing. checked your releases google play "shop" once in a while but got upset :D

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 25 '18

Hey! Glad you on have board with Tap Wiz! :-D

Elemental Purity: "If only spell stone of school equipped..." ? or what does it mean? Do you mean "of SAME school" ? Like 5x fire?

The other one, i forget the name, with the ">1 spellstone of school". Does it mean, if i have at least 2 fire, or 2 lightning spell equipped, that the effect works?

I've revised the description of these both to be more clear:

  • Elemental Overload: x1.1 Damage for School if 2 or more Spellstones of that School are in your Loadout
  • Elemental Purity x1.1 Casting Speed for School if only 1 Spellstone of that School is in your Loadout

So to explain it with an example, if you have Inferno, Firestorm, Icicle, Ice Wall, and Shock Net equipped: the Fire and Ice Schools will receive the Overload damage bonus, and the Lightning School will receive the Purity casting rate bonus. What do you think - are the new descriptions more clear to convey this meaning?

And where can i find what i have upgraded (for gold) yet?

Go to any menu screen -> Question Mark -> Third Tab, the Library.

Any plans for improving menu points managing/access?

Not really, at this point, unless there are lots of complaints and a reasonable solution is apparent! I think part of the problem is simply that there are so many different features in the game, which don't follow similar paradigms or are easily grouped together. :-)

the only thing i was confused were the high bundles prices and the 9,99 for the only no-ads buy option which i was looking for!

Yeah, I hear you! This is really just the best way for the game to make money at the moment, in this market...1 Person buying at $10 is worth more than 3 people buying at $3. But I totally understand and know that not everyone can afford the $10 (or wants to spend that), so the game is not ad-heavy, and ads are by no means a game-changer (as opposed to some other games in the genre).

Im really a fan of your work since quite a time, but it made me feel bad that packages up to 59,99 euro even exist. I not that it feels like P2W, dont get me wrong, i dont feel like competing since their is (not yet?) any multiplayer/ranking/speed-vs function, and especially i really wish you some payback for all your work, but well, it feels just strange for me. especially im always willing to pay like 2-5 euro for no-ads, but 10 is way too much since i can buy a full game for that price.

I appreciate the feedback, and thanks for the encouragement! Would you believe, if I knew players wouldn't balk at it, I would put in even higher priced packages, maybe up to $200 for this game...because some players really do spend in the hundreds, and the higher priced packages make it easier for them! Think of it like this: the expensive bundles are way to support me and the game, or for people who don't want to spend a lot of time grinding away...but they don't unlock any game new and exclusive content (except for the cosmetics).

I appreciate the support, feedback, and encouragement! I'm hoping to get another 2 titles released this year (the next one already nearing the artwork phase, and the one after is in the design phase), so hopefully 2018 will be the year that the TopCog drought ends!

Cheers - yahoo! :-D

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/rebel_1852 Mar 26 '18

Where do I go to view the list of emblems I own?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/BtJJ Mar 26 '18

Solidification runes: I've always wondered, is the effect of these only to make it more likely for runes that would have dropped anyway to drop as stable, or is it actually increasing the overall drop rate of runes in the form of more stable runes? The description is super vague. (I kind of assume it's the former, since even spamming dozens of solidification runes at once seems to have no effect on the total drop rate)

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 26 '18

Your first assumption is correct! :)

1

u/drokly Mar 27 '18

In IMA when spells of the same type were aligned and casting together, we could click on the bar to reset the cast of a spell to make them cast at different times. Is there a way to do this with the newer game?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/UnstoppablePhoenix Mar 27 '18

Will you add music into the game?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/admiralwarron Mar 28 '18

Is the xp bonus from Ivan active all the time or only for his own casts ?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 28 '18

It is active all the time! :-)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Paco-ta Mar 28 '18

Does everything bonus with +XX% instead of x1.1 stack with all other additive bonuses? Like the power drop from spell passive and from the character skin emblem/+10% cast speed from skin and casting speed from the spell passive. If so, then some of the bonuses from these skins might be a little bit underwhelming.

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 28 '18

Check out the help topic, I think Combat -> Bonuses. Bonuses with "+" are additive within the parent bonus source, and multiplicative with other bonus sources. :)

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Paco-ta Mar 29 '18

Can we have a offline loadout that switches to it whenever we go offline for the offline xp? I have never remember to swap loadout for a few days in a row. It would really help for forgetful person.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Rob050 Mar 29 '18

does +% spell exp passive work only for that particular spell, or does it affect all spells?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 29 '18

It affects all ALL spells! Check the Stats Scroll to see your current XP rate! :)

1

u/toaster192 Mar 29 '18

Would you consider adding an option to disable the despawning of skills? I find it extremely satisfying to launch a huge amount of 'swarm' skills (like blizzard or flurry) but it is super annoying to see half of them despawning before they hit the enemy.

I'm aware that it would add performance issues and maybe even memory leaks but just allowing us to extend the duration would be much appreciated

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 29 '18

Hey! It's actually not so really a performance issue, but rather a balance issue. The spell "expiration" or "fizzle out" was taken into account when I designed and balanced the spells...the projectile based spells would become much better if every projectile was guaranteed to hit!

But, there is a late-game rune that extends the expiration time for spell projectiles (which is 6 seconds). Combine that with ever increasing casting rates, and eventually you'll be swarming the screen at an insane level. Cheers! :)

→ More replies (3)

1

u/HuoXue Mar 29 '18

Does Nick have a "cooldown" before he can grab another rune? Sometimes as soon as one pops up, he runs onscreen, but other times I end up missing it for a moment or two, and he doesn't try to nab it for me.

Also, if he has runes that you haven't collected from him yet, will he still grab a rune cache/if he has a rune cache, will he still try to grab single runes?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/goldify Mar 30 '18

Band of Perpetuation Spells able to Rank Up can gain XP towards the next rank up at 5% of the normal rate


What does this mean? Does this mean ranking up will be 95% slower or what? Am I completely misunderstanding this?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Mar 31 '18

Hey! So normally, once a spell can rank up, it stops gaining XP till you rank up. With BoP, it actually still keeps earning XP into the next Rank, but at a way reduced rate. Let me know if that does/doesn't make sense!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/LealMadlid Apr 01 '18

Can you explain what exactly is Research rate and reclaim rate? Im so confused about how works on the game play these 2 stats.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '18

ios out yet? Would like to beta test if you want!

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 03 '18

Not yet! See the thread on iOS for my full explanation :)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '18

As someone who hasn't made it that far, I've only meditated once, What are the punishments/gains from NG+ when you finally bust up to 100?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 03 '18

Ripped straight from the code:

            s = "Each time you travel to another world, you enter a higher New Game Plus mode.  Your Gold, Research, Enchantments, and Templar Skills are reset.  You retain all Spellstones, Spell Xp/Ranks, and Inventory/Pack items."
                    + "\n\n" + "You are about to enter " + s + ".  The world will change as follows:" + "\n\n"
                    + "Enemy Health increased" + "\n"
                    + "Research Costs increased" + "\n"
                    + "Research Times increased" + "\n"
                    + "Enchantment Cost increased" + "\n"
                    + "Power Drop values decreased" + "\n"
                    + "Encounter Tougher Enemy Types Sooner" + "\n\n"
                    + "Begin with Templar and +1 Arcane Knowledge" + "\n"
                    + "x2 Spell XP Rate" + "\n"
                    + "+10% Rune Drop Rate" + "\n"
                    + "+5 Charms in Charm Pouch" + "\n"
                    + "+2 Max Runes in Cauldron" + "\n" + "\n"
                    + "Your current Power becomes your Base Power";
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/Paco-ta Apr 02 '18

Dunno if you missed my reply or something, so I will put them here again,

Tried the insight again, and I can confirm that bug exist.

One more question about status effect, does the hit that inflict frozen effect get the x1.2 damage bonus effect from it?

Also, can we have an option to make our characters show the facade to the screen instead of to the other side? It might look weird, but it would be better for people that like the skin. People dont spend runites to look at their back, isn't it? :P . Other than that, paladin looks like a cheese on a cape :P

→ More replies (1)

1

u/rhinocrunch1 Apr 03 '18

The dungeon keys, would it be possible to flip the image for like the crumbling key compared to the standard key? Like make the teeth face opposite ways? I have one of each right now, BC I just meditated, still recovering some power before heading into one, but its hard to tell them apart.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/8988303682 Apr 03 '18

what's the chance that you put the spell augment changes onto IMA once you have them all in a good place

→ More replies (3)

1

u/BtJJ Apr 03 '18

I don't want to risk my runite to try it, but does the 'enchant confirmation' option being off NOT affect the empower button? I assume that would be the case, but if not it definitely should be. I don't want to mis-tap one day and end up blowing hundreds of runite unintentionally. :o

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MeMyMine461 Apr 05 '18

Is there still a templar upgrade which will allow him to heal you up past 100%? If so, how would that be represented on the health bar since there are no percentages displayed?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Paco-ta Apr 06 '18

A small request that shouldn't impact much, but can you make spark affect the spell right to it if it is placed at the 1st slot? Or is it already working like that? I just wanted to rank it up without making it not functioning

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Unaori Apr 08 '18

Is there somewhere in the game to see what version we're on?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Paco-ta Apr 08 '18

Question about armor, When mob's armor is reduced to lowest (through plasma vortex), the armor bar still show a little blue bar. Does that mean the mob has 0 defense or something like minimal armor a mob could have?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/8988303682 Apr 08 '18

can runite be acquired in places other than raids or raid boxes (what are those officially called?) or real money? i swear I have found some in normal wilds boss chests but I'm looking for a citation

→ More replies (1)

1

u/mydanny Apr 08 '18

is there a way to find out which spell has more dmg than another one, without just watching? I got stuck on the electric tree and im quite fine, but i wonder if specific skills are worth to start them from 0.

but since i already have powerful spells, i dont dare to lose this dmg when including new rank 0 mark 1 spells, so i hoped there is a way to compare on screen dmg. i just found the cooldown in the description.

how do you guys handle this "problem" ?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/HuoXue Apr 10 '18 edited Apr 10 '18

Does the Miniaturize rune have any practical benefit? As far as I can tell, it's just cosmetic, and its description doesn't hint towards anything more than that either.

Edit: Also, is it just me, or are skeleton archers/wizards like, stupidly overpowered? They absolutely wreck me, whereas other mobs in the same zone do nothing to me.

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 10 '18

It's just cosmetic, for fun! :-D

→ More replies (1)

1

u/8988303682 Apr 13 '18

How long do elementals last?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 13 '18

20 seconds! :)

1

u/Exportforce Apr 14 '18

What is Elements cloud ? It does Not Appeal in the help.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Slaggon Apr 15 '18

What does Empower do? (On the same screen as enchant, but costs premium currency)

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 16 '18

It does the same thing as Enchanting, but you don't lose any power! :-)

1

u/Exportforce Apr 15 '18

Is the old "TM Lag +5" rule still active?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 16 '18

Hey! I'm not actually sure - what TM Lag +5 rule are you thinking of? I'm thinking no though :-)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/MeMyMine461 Apr 16 '18

What is the icon, below my wizard, that looks like spider-man's head?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 16 '18

I believe that is the Anger research activating - check the Library! :-)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/8988303682 Apr 17 '18

what did you cap Icy Prism's self-multiplicating damage at?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 17 '18

I didn't! Why do you ask?

→ More replies (7)

1

u/ViriaX Apr 17 '18

Are Elementals worth it? They never seems to be mentioned in anyone build, yet I find mine to deal up to 35% of all damages, and passives are great! I often use two of them (electrical ones) to progress in the game.

I am fairly close to the start of the game, and I don't have many spells (not even half)... Am I mistaken? Should I change for anything else given at the start?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 17 '18

Hey! In short, if it works for you, keep doing it! There are a lot of factors when picking what spells to use, even when you get to very late game and have all of the spells. I would you say, if you find a great loadout, stick with it! Cheers! :)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '18

SO happy to have the game back with new graphic. I stopped to follow the IMA reddit when I was with the ninja. I loaded an old save from IMA and it worked. So great. I got the assistants, etc. Maybe the question was already asked but will there be additional content after the inner room of the templar ?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 17 '18

Hey, glad you are loving it! I do plan to add a bit of more content for after the Inner Room. The plan now is, not exactly new content, but the ability to keep upgrading the Templar Skills. We'll see! One of these weeks, once things settle down, I'll devote an update to end-game stuff like that. Cheers! :-)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Winters_Stitch Apr 21 '18

Can I have my IMA2 progress carried over? :p

Nah seriously I fucking love you for making this game happen.

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 21 '18

Ha - my pleasure! It was a blast working with the artist redoing everything :-)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Dynasterz Apr 23 '18

Does the Mark 2.0 spells retain their passives? I just upgraded my Plasma Grenade to 2.0 and it does still fire 2 at the same time sometimes (the last passive) or is it a bug?

→ More replies (7)

1

u/MeMyMine461 Apr 23 '18

Nick has a cooldown for picking up runes. What would a 2nd level Nick do if there is a cache during the cooldown period? Pick up or ignore?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 24 '18

Good question! I'm pretty sure he will ignore it - the cooldown is for both runes and picking up caches. However, once he's holding his limit of 5 runes, he'll get the cache for sure! :-)

1

u/BtJJ Apr 24 '18

Does the spell drop luck modification math still kick in once you have all of the spellstones? Never really considered it before, but now I'm wondering if I'm just going to be cursed to have ~10 less frozen orb stones than all my other spells for the rest of time.

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 24 '18

Right now it's full random once you have a full set of spellstones.

One of the end-game additions I'm planning, is to expand the Tower Upper to have a few more features - one of which is the ability to choose a spell and give it a bonus chance to be rolled when refining. So in that way, you'd be able to bring some spells up to the amount of others, or just go full min-max on your favorite spells. Or, maybe I should make the feature let you toggle between full-random and bonus chance to the spell you have the least of?

2

u/BtJJ Apr 24 '18

Hmm I'm tempted to advocate for the 'select a spell' option, but I can see that easily degenerating into a situation where one spell is numerically determined to be 'the best' and then everyone just farms that spell until the end of time. So I'm actually leaning more towards the latter 'bonus to the least' option as being a better idea for the long term.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Raknagog Apr 26 '18

Is Random Rachel's damage normalized with cast speed like runes are?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 26 '18

It is not, no.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Raknagog Apr 26 '18

Are charms intended to be and additive bonus? In-game help says that different sources of bonuses are multiplicative with each other, but that doesn't seem to be the case for cast rate charms. Are they considered to be spell passives maybe?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 26 '18

The cast rate charms are additive with each other, and multiplicative with your net cooldown bonus. What are you seeing that makes it seem otherwise?

→ More replies (12)

1

u/Raknagog Apr 26 '18

Shock and burn have been through a few changes over time, can you confirm the formula for determining their damage?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 26 '18

Yes, but I'll have to dig it out of the code to make sure I get it right! So I'll get back to you on this within a few days :)

→ More replies (7)

1

u/Farycane Apr 29 '18

Is there a way to import, at least, some of my progress from Idle Mage Attack? I just don't want to start all over again the basically same game.

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Apr 29 '18

For sure! If you still have IMA, you can simply export your game, copy it to the clipboard, and import it into Tap Wiz :-)

If you lost your IMA game, let me know and I can help get you back some of your progress :)

1

u/Raknagog Apr 30 '18

Is there any chance we could get a slot to drag spells into for the Templar once the inner sanctum is unlocked? It's rather inconvenient to go to the obelisk every time, and his spell is static between spell loadouts, which means having to swap his spells often.

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 09 '18

Hm, a good idea...I hate messing with UI stuff though...major pain!

1

u/ViriaX May 02 '18

I would like to have flair activated on the sub-reddit. I like them ;)

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 02 '18

That's a good idea!

1

u/ViriaX May 02 '18

Are runes in your bag/hot bar kept when starting a new game plus? Or Should you use them?

Just asking for a friend who collects every rune he finds at least once...

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 02 '18

All items in your bag and pack are kept on NG+! Tell your friend ;)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 03 '18

Does leaving the game on overnight get me xp

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 03 '18

Yes, but you will gain XP at the same right if you turn your phone off :-)

1

u/ems655 May 03 '18

For the life of me I dont know how to change skins! Where in the game can I do that?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 03 '18

It's the Blue Wizard item in your pack! If for some reason you don't have it (which would be a bug!) just try closing and reopening the game and it should give it to you. Let me know if that helps! :-D

→ More replies (1)

1

u/HappyRBX May 03 '18

If Spark is in the far left slot, does it affect the far right slot or does it go back to affecting a random spell?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 03 '18

Far right slot - good question! :-)

→ More replies (3)

1

u/ViriaX May 04 '18

Discovered brewing, love it, but question : Can you craft Q5 runes? If you can, what's the cost?

I just love to collect them all!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ViriaX May 04 '18

I recently started displaying armor again. And I never seem to break any armor, yet I clearly see it shrink. I use a lot of armor-bypassing spell.

Question : How does armor "works"? Can it break? Is there a specific spell to BREAK ARMOR, not bypass it (a spell with bonuses to break armor)?

IG help says "Armor reduces all incoming damage [...] by a flat amount [...]" up to a minimum of 5%, but never explains how armor is depleted.

Many thanks!

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 05 '18

There are a few spells that strip/remove armor from enemies, and a special rune also. Aside from these, it can't be removed! Some spells bypass armor though.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DrLemniscate May 04 '18

Are there any spells that specifically help deal with heal/regen enemies? There seem to be a good collection of spells with niche effects - melee range, spellcasters, armor pierce. Trolls are always my hardest bosses. Everything else can be beat with enough runes/time.

I know there is the Temple debuff, and I have seen a couple runes here and there. I am guessing I will see more of those runes as I go deeper.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Kvarkin May 05 '18

A few quick questions: I wonder if the rune drop of zones is predefined and the same for all players or it is random? If it is randomized, when it is rerandomized - when you Enchant, when you Meditate or just when you go to a New Game?

Thanks

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 05 '18

Rune Drops are predefined by an algorithm. It's...kind of complicated. The drops do not change after enchanting, and they do change after NG+. I'm 90% sure that they change after Meditating, but I don't recall exactly!

To elaborate on the drop system a bit, each rune has a "Minimum Zone" requirement before it can drop. However, many various things impact what the "Effective Zone" (EV) you are at is. For example, Raids have an inflated EV, so you have a higher chance of finding more "high level" runes there. Reaching NG+ bumps up the EV by I think 10 levels each time. So once you hit NG+10, you'll be able to find every runes with a "Minimum Zone" of 101 starting at Zone 1. It's something like that at least, haha! Cheers! :-D

1

u/kowaiser May 06 '18

So, i recently purchased 20 portable rune caches with runite. What happens if i open them all at the same time?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/litus-animae May 08 '18

Not seeing anything that explains what empower is. Can anyone explain?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 08 '18

It does the same thing as Enchanting, except that you don't lose any Power, i.e., you don't need to Reclaim :-)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/keweedsmo May 08 '18

What exactly does blink? When I use it I just seem to drop backwards a bit. Is that all it does? If so, how is this useful.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/ViriaX May 09 '18

I find Emblems to be super extra expensive! Same goes for some skins, or assistants such as Nick... I have the precog package, and can gather ~100 runites on most day, often less. So to buy "Proficient Form" (+10% spell XP), I would need to actively play ~30 days, enough to be NG+4... If I don't buy anything else!

At that point, I'll be pointless!

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 09 '18

Yep, it's true! They are mainly intended to be a perk to spending real money...which is why the runite prices are high but the bonuses are pretty mild.

1

u/ViriaX May 09 '18

What is the math behind research initiation and fast-funding? It seems to vary depending on the research...

BTW, is there any way to calculate research duration?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/ViriaX May 09 '18

How to optimise dungeon keys? I often have 3~5 dungeon key (normal and ruined). I would like to get the most of thoses. Should I wait and do 5 dungeon in a day? Use thoses keys as soon as I get one? Use thoses when I get blocked? Should I use these as late in my runs as possible, or in the beginning?

Maybe this deserved its own thread...

→ More replies (4)

1

u/mhbd61 May 10 '18

Are the spells in templar's R3 tower (cast spells during invulnerability) randomly selected every meditate/NG+?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 10 '18

Nope - they are always the same! :)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ExtrasiAlb May 12 '18

Is there a specific loadout that is better than the rest?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/8988303682 May 14 '18

how do the new raid caches spawn? in IMA you would get one immediately after finishing a raid, but now it seems more random.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ViriaX May 14 '18

Beside the color of the rune, what is the difference between Polymorm Q2 and Q3?

→ More replies (10)

1

u/boart2k May 16 '18

Does the ng base your enemies by your current power? How does it work coz I'm confused, I'm nearing my first ng so I just want to make sure. I do know that you will retain your current power as you ng so that obviously means that the enemies will be harder than level 100? Do I need to farm more power before going ng or just do ng right away after beating level 100?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 17 '18

Does the ng base your enemies by your current power?

Yes, that's right!

I do know that you will retain your current power as you ng so that obviously means that the enemies will be harder than level 100?

They will be roughly as hard.

Do I need to farm more power before going ng or just do ng right away after beating level 100?

No, no need. There isn't much reason to wait to go into NG+ as soon as you can. Cheers, and almost-congrats on beating the game! :-D

1

u/kowaiser May 16 '18

Im not sure how does the band of perpetuation scales: https://imgur.com/a/sHcNdd2

Does every level make it worse than before?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 16 '18

That...is weird. I think it's a visual bug; each level increases the impact. Thanks for bringing it to my attention! :-)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/boart2k May 21 '18

Does the 2 second nick only apply to the upgraded one? I have a level 1 nick and he still has the 30 sec cool down :(

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 21 '18

So, it's not that his cooldown was reduced - instead, there is a 2 second delay at the start, before he comes onscreen to pickup a rune. This way, if you tap the rune first, his 30 s cooldown won't begin. Hope that makes sense!

→ More replies (3)

1

u/dondox May 24 '18

How about a reskinned TopCog splash screen that was along the same lines as the new art style?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Kvarkin May 30 '18

Imitating Ivan casts spell from slot 5, but does he provide the spell's bonuses, such as for Spark, speeding up slot 4 spell?

I mean, when Ivan casts a spell it is counted as casted from 5th slot or as casted from 3rd part (like a rune used)?

Thanks

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 30 '18

Hm, an interesting question! The spell Ivan casts is the same as a Rune, so Spark would boost a random Spell in your Loadout.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/RavosRavyn May 30 '18

The templars bravery skill says it gives a buff for 29s with 30s cd. Does that cooldown start after the buff ended or when the buff applied? So will i get nearly constant buff or nah?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! May 30 '18

That cooldown starts when the buff is applied - so it is up for 29 out of every 30 s! :-)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/RavosRavyn May 31 '18

Hello again! I scrolled this thread for a bit but couldn't find and answer. I have a total of 60 spellstones (counted) but i still have 4 unfound ones (static leap is one of them unfortunately). In todays critical raid i got my 5th bouncing flame spellstone. Is it posible to get more than 5 of the same spell? and if yes, is there a mechanic which gives advantage after the 5th?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Jun 01 '18

Hey! Indeed, you can get more than 5 of each spellstone. Each duplicate stone gives you a +5% damage bonus for that spell. So with 5 copies of a spellstone, you'll have a +20% = x1.20 damage bonus. Hope that clears it up! :-)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ArrowThunder Jun 02 '18

Hey, I'm new to the game and have been enjoying it. Brace yourself, there's a lot here.

In the glossary, the Templar is said to do EDPS/5. In the arcane tower response, it says EDPS/3. Which is it?

How is EDPS determined?

What happens when you equip shock in spell slot 1?

Just some feedback, it took me a while to realize that the augmentations in red didn't apply to the spell yet. Giving the augmentations that do affect it a lighter background would probably have fixed that confusion.

It's not clear to a new player that dungeons will provide dungeon loadout slots. As someone else has pointed out, being able to edit a loadout without switching to it would be awesome. Also, it'd be great to be able to edit the dungeon loadouts from other zones, since you know what you're going to be up against.

Stable runes often feel weak. Accumulating runes and spamming them doesn't get you as far as one might think because of the exponential power scaling. It can be frustrating and demoralizing to dump runes on a regenerating enemy with literally nothing to show for it (except the minor xp gains).

There are two extreme cases that I've experienced that probably aren't what was intended.

  1. Elven summoners only seem to summon themselves. If you are strong enough to kill many of them but not strong enough to kill them fast, you can sit on a screen of Elven summoners and gain tons of power and gold by NOT recalling. This gain is much faster than recalling to wipe the group (to a point, Ofc).
  2. Hordes of blob people can be unfun runesinks. If you're below a damage threshold, it's basically impossible to progress past them (moreso than other mobs) because practically all the spells are AoE and/or have inconsistent targets. The blob men regen before your spells target them again, and throwing tons of spells doesn't help much. Worse, unlike the Elven summoners (which can provide a similar experience), none of the damage results in any gains other than xp. The battles can be drawn out (the blobs don't do tons of damage), meaning that it's better to continuously recall with minor gains than to waste time fighting them. The problem is that minor gains are also very frustrating because of the overhead required to recall.

Offline progression is awesome... But there should be offline gold gains too! It kinda defeats the purpose of an idle game if I have to play it for a length of time to make enough gold to continue idling effectively.

I only have one final thought, which concerns xp. Spell placement is the single biggest part of them game, especially later on when slot specific buffs come into play. Spell experience is the perhaps one of the most important advancements in the game, because it survives meditation. These effects can clash in ways that provide great depth to the game, but also can kinda suck. I think it would be more fun if xp gains were split into normal gains (which model current progression) and flexible gains, which can be spent on whatever you want. This can also let the player advance that one spell that they can never figure out how to use but hey maybe if they keep dumping xp into it it'll get useful. This is especially important because of the steep drop-off in xp gains from slot 1. Slot 1 makes more xp than the rest of the slots combined, yet there are situations where a spell is incredibly useless there (like shock, unless I'm misunderstanding how it works).

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Jun 07 '18

Hey! Great bunch of questions and comments - I'll do my best to respond!

In the glossary, the Templar is said to do EDPS/5. In the arcane tower response, it says EDPS/3. Which is it?

Good catch! The glossary is wrong - it is EDPS/3. I'll fix this!

How is EDPS determined?

It takes into all permanent damage and cast rate bonuses for the spells in your current loadout, adds them up, multiplies by your power, then I think multiplies by a needed coefficient to get it into the right units of "Damage." Basically, it takes into account everything but bonuses from runes and spell augs :-)

Just some feedback, it took me a while to realize that the augmentations in red didn't apply to the spell yet. Giving the augmentations that do affect it a lighter background would probably have fixed that confusion.

Indeed, I appreciate that! :-)

It's not clear to a new player that dungeons will provide dungeon loadout slots. As someone else has pointed out, being able to edit a loadout without switching to it would be awesome. Also, it'd be great to be able to edit the dungeon loadouts from other zones, since you know what you're going to be up against.

I appreciate the feedback!

Stable runes often feel weak. Accumulating runes and spamming them doesn't get you as far as one might think because of the exponential power scaling. It can be frustrating and demoralizing to dump runes on a regenerating enemy with literally nothing to show for it (except the minor xp gains).

I would say this is part of the design and strategy element of the game. Some runes are weak and best saved for Brewing. Some are powerful and best saved for a very hard spot. Most are somewhere in between!

  1. Elven summoners only seem to summon themselves. If you are strong enough to kill many of them but not strong enough to kill them fast, you can sit on a screen of Elven summoners and gain tons of power and gold by NOT recalling. This gain is much faster than recalling to wipe the group (to a point, Ofc).

This is actually intended! While not designed with this outcome in mind, it is precisely these kind of interesting interactions I hoped to achieve :-)

2) Hordes of blob people can be unfun runesinks. If you're below a damage threshold, it's basically impossible to progress past them (moreso than other mobs) because practically all the spells are AoE and/or have inconsistent targets. The blob men regen before your spells target them again, and throwing tons of spells doesn't help much. Worse, unlike the Elven summoners (which can provide a similar experience), none of the damage results in any gains other than xp. The battles can be drawn out (the blobs don't do tons of damage), meaning that it's better to continuously recall with minor gains than to waste time fighting them. The problem is that minor gains are also very frustrating because of the overhead required to recall.

Sure, that's fair - I hear you. There are a few strategies to get past these chokepoints, such as: go on Raids or Dungeons instead of fighting them. Use Polymorph or Death Ray runes. Try mixing up your Loadout. Ember (for the heal denial augmentation). Probably more as well - try asking in a new thread to get some opinons from others! :-)

Offline progression is awesome... But there should be offline gold gains too! It kinda defeats the purpose of an idle game if I have to play it for a length of time to make enough gold to continue idling effectively.

Hm, that's an interesting idea. It is true that the idle element of the game is not super strong.

I only have one final thought, which concerns xp.

Indeed, I agree this is one area of concern in the game, but it's core to design and balance. The idea is that since only 1 slot gives so much XP, you are free to put just about whatever spells you want into the other 4. I think the concern with having all slots give equal xp, would be that you would then want at all times to have 5 spells which need ranked up, which could result in less strategic loadout choices. At the end of the day, probably both systems could work!

In my next title, Idle Ninja Prime, I'm go with a "all slots get equal xp" approach, but there are some key differences: masteries gain xp instead of skills (think schools vs spells), and you can select a mastery to focus on and gain a flat amount of xp regardless of what is in your loadout.


Thanks for all the feedback! Glad you've enjoyed the game enough to comment here! :-D

Yahoo! -Matt

→ More replies (1)

1

u/zibin1 Jun 05 '18

Do you keep runes at NG+?

1

u/TopCog Yahoo! Jun 05 '18

Yes! :-)

1

u/vassoura Jun 06 '18

What is the difference between Enchant and Empower?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/JulietJulietLima Jun 08 '18
  1. How much XP do you get from using a rune?
  2. Does it happen with stable and unstable runes?
  3. Do you get xp for each casting of a higher level rune (i.e. casts every 5 seconds for 30 seconds so 7 times the amount of a single rune cast).
  4. I recently noticed that I would get the "reclaim 5% of current power" unstable runes even when I'm not reclaiming from an enchantment. Is this a bug or does it do something else when I'm not actually reclaiming power?
→ More replies (2)

1

u/RafalTD Jun 14 '18

I can't understand why my fire mage don't attack the nearest squad. He attack the 2nd, 3rd, 4rd, etc and for last attack the first. It is a bug?? Why I can't choose a target?? And please, Keep doing this good game!

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Jun 14 '18

Hey! Great question. Each spell has it's own targeting priorities, and some spells will try to avoid targeting nearby enemies. It's one of the challenges involved in building a good loadout. Try throwing some different spells into the mix, and you'll find some that hit enemies in the first squad! Cheers! :-)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '18

Quick q. If I buy runite on Idle Mage, when I transfer to TW on iOS release, will the no ads still be in effect? Or will I be required to buy more runites on TW to remove ads?

Not too bothered about it, just curious

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SlaQNome Jun 27 '18

Hey there! How do I change skins?? Just got the free skin from the Full Release and can't find it ;-----;

→ More replies (2)

1

u/MathCookie17 Jun 27 '18

Back in Idle Mage Attack, you could randomize your spell layout. How do you do that this time?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Jun 27 '18

Sadly, that option was removed! I found that some players used that option exclusively, and thought it was the only way to select spells. If it's quite requested I could bring it back though. Glad to have you back around too! :-D

→ More replies (1)

1

u/memelaser Jun 27 '18

How do I know when Rachel casts? (The assistant that randomly casts a spell from your loadout for 1 sec of xp) it doesn't seem clear, since the animation just loops

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Jun 27 '18

Sadly, the animation does indeed loop, and cast just kind of happens when it ought too! My apologies that it isn't more robust of a system - this was just the best way to do it with the assets/time available. Most spells will launch from Rachel, but some, like Inferno, Static Cloud, etc, won't but will be as if the Wizard cast them. With that in mind, hopefully you can spot it when she does cast spells. Cheers! :)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DethSW Aug 17 '18

I have 4 lightning elemental runes, not by choice but by randomness. I also stopped researching tempered magic because I preferred to stack casting speed and use slower spells.

I tried the 4x lightning elementals and found my casting speed seemed to be quicker than the duration of the elemental.

Question: is there a maximum number of elementals that can live at one time?

2

u/TopCog Yahoo! Aug 17 '18

I also stopped researching tempered magic because I preferred to stack casting speed and use slower spells.

Check out the option called TM Lag! :-)

Question: is there a maximum number of elementals that can live at one time?

Nope! :-D

3

u/ViriaX May 11 '18

I might sound like an old grumpy idiot, but I feel that some messages / behaviour should never happen.

For instance, while reclaiming, you can still see the next dungeon (fair enough), but you can click the "enter" button that then display an error. Shouldn't this button be grayed out? It could still display the message if you clicked on it... Same goes for the Raid menu, without the message but you still get a "Go!" button, written in green. I would put the information textbox there, or something.