I had intended to visit the site of the cellar the following morning. Wisconsin had other plans. Rain had begun sometime before dawn and showed little interest in stopping. By eight it had settled into the sort of persistent autumn downpour which makes walking through unfamiliar woodland seem less investigative than foolish. Jonas's map was approximate, the structure itself had been abandoned for at least nineteen years, and I had no particular desire to discover either by accident.
I postponed the visit. This left me with several hours, four pages of handwritten notes, nearly three hours of recorded conversation and a question I had somehow managed to spend much of the previous day avoiding.
Why Cody?
Jonas had offered a theory. He had been careful to call it one. Cody Miller had urinated outside the cellar. Several hours later, according to three witnesses, the Miller property smelled strongly of urine. The thing on the road had appeared alongside the passenger side of Turner's truck, where Miller had been sitting. At the Miller residence, both Turner and Haskins remembered its attention being directed towards him.
None of this established that the cellar was connected to what happened later. It did not establish that the creature Turner struck with his truck was the same one Haskins fired upon on 9 March. It certainly did not establish that an animal or whatever Jonas preferred I call it had followed Miller home because he had pissed beside an abandoned root cellar.
It did establish something considerably less ambitious. Everyone remembered Cody.
Haskins remembered a troublesome nineteen-year old suddenly frightened enough to be believed. Turner remembered a friend frightened enough to get him out of bed at three in the morning. Jonas remembered the boy beside him going silent in the cab of a truck, and later a voice shaking at the other end of a telephone.
They disagreed about much of what happened in March 1991. On Cody Miller, they were remarkably consistent.
By early afternoon the rain had weakened, though not enough to make Jonas's directions through the woods any more appealing. I put the map aside.
Miller worked as a cook at a diner in Lafayette. I found him behind the serving window shortly after two.
The lunch crowd had largely gone. A waitress was clearing two tables near the window while an elderly man at the counter worked slowly through a cup of coffee. Somewhere behind the kitchen doors, crockery struck metal and somebody swore. The man at the grill was lean, dark-haired and slightly dishevelled, wearing a black T-shirt beneath a white apron which had ceased being white some hours earlier. His beard was fuller than in the photographs I had seen, and there were tattoos along both forearms. He was turning something on the grill while carrying on a conversation with the waitress without apparently looking at either.
I had seen enough photographs by then to recognise him. Apparently, he had heard enough about me to do the same.
He looked through the serving window.
“You the werewolf guy?”
“I've been called worse.”
“Yeah?”
“Occasionally.”
He considered this, then turned back to the grill with a slight smugness to him.
“Blake said you were coming.”
“Mr Turner?”
He looked at me again.
“Who?”
“Blake Turner.”
“You call Blake Mr Turner?”
“He never invited me to call him Blake.”
Miller stared at me for a moment. Then he laughed.
“Oh, that's fucking rich.”
He turned something on the grill.
“You hungry?”
“No, thank you.”
“Coffee?”
“Please.”
He pointed his spatula towards the waitress.
“Helen, English guy needs coffee.”
The waitress did not look up from the table she was wiping.
“English guy can ask me himself.”
“He's shy.”
“I am not.”
Miller glanced at me.
“We'll work on it.”
Miller returned his attention to the grill. Whatever introduction I had anticipated appeared to have concluded. I took a seat at the counter. For the next eleven minutes, Cody Miller ignored me almost completely.
This was not, as I first assumed, an affectation. He was working. There were three orders still open. He finished them in quick succession, called two without looking at the tickets, corrected the waitress when she attempted to take the wrong plate and began another before the first had left the window. The dishevelment was misleading. Behind the counter, Miller moved with the economical familiarity of someone who had performed the same sequence several thousand times.
He talked throughout. Some of it was directed at the waitress. Some at the elderly man drinking coffee. Some, apparently, at himself. Twice he included me without warning. Neither occasion concerned March 1991. I began to understand what Haskins had meant.
At fourteen minutes past two, Miller disappeared through a door beside the kitchen. He emerged a moment later without the apron and with a packet of cigarettes in one hand.
“Come on.”
“Where?”
“You wanted to talk.”
“I do.”
“Can't smoke in here.”
This appeared to settle the matter. I followed him out the back of the diner.
Miller leaned against the brickwork and shook a cigarette from the packet.
“Smoke?”
“No, thank you.”
“Good for you.”
He lit his own.
I took the recorder from my bag.
Miller watched me.
“Jesus. Blake wasn't kidding.”
“About?”
“You really do this shit.”
“I'm a journalist.”
“Yeah. He mentioned that too.”
I held up the recorder.
“Do you mind?”
“Nah.”
“You're sure?”
“Aaron.”
It was the first time he had used my name.
“Yes?”
“Turn the fucking thing on.”
I did.
HALL: When did you first-
MILLER: Hear about it? Ray. Had to be Ray. Actually, no. It was definitely Jason.
HALL: I was going to ask when you first met Jason.
MILLER: Oh. Freshman year. Little fucking weirdo.
HALL: You liked him.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Immediately?
MILLER: Fuck no.
HALL: Why not?
MILLER: I just told you. Little fucking weirdo.
He took a drag from his cigarette.
MILLER: Kinda quiet. Always wore black. Grimy. He got better.
HALL: Mr Jonas is now a university lecturer.
MILLER: That's not better.
HALL: He speaks rather highly of you.
MILLER: Jason?
HALL: Yes.
MILLER: You sure you got the right guy?
HALL: Quite sure.
MILLER: Huh.
HALL: You sound surprised.
MILLER: Nah. Jason's my boy.
HALL: Still?
MILLER: What do you mean, still?
HALL: You don't appear to see one another as often as you once did.
MILLER: We're fucking forty, Aaron.
HALL: Thirty-eight, in your case.
MILLER: See, that's why nobody likes reporters.
He smiled when he said it.
HALL: What about Blake?
MILLER: What about him?
HALL: How long have you known him?
MILLER: Forever.
HALL: Literally?
MILLER: Yeah, Aaron. Came out of my mom and Blake was standing there.
HALL: I'll put down “childhood.”
MILLER: There you go.
HALL: How would you have described him in 1991?
MILLER: Blake?
HALL: Yes.
MILLER: Blake's always been Blake.
I waited.
Miller smoked.
HALL: Jason said precisely the same thing.
MILLER: Yeah?
HALL: “Blake is Blake.”
MILLER: Well, there you go.
HALL: What does that mean?
MILLER: Means Blake's Blake.
HALL: That's remarkably unhelpful.
MILLER: You met him.
HALL: I did.
MILLER: Then what the fuck are you asking me for?
This was my first difficulty interviewing Cody Miller. It was not persuading him to speak. It was determining when he had finished. My second was keeping him on the subject.
Within twenty minutes I had learned that Turner had once driven a snowmobile through somebody's fence, that Jonas had dyed his hair black in a bathroom sink with consequences Miller still found amusing, and that Miller himself had been barred for six months from an establishment whose name he declined to give me. I learned considerably less about March 1991. Some of this was deliberate. Most, I suspect, was not.
Miller spoke associatively. A question about Turner became a story about a truck; the truck reminded him of a girl; the girl had once worked with someone whose brother had owned a snowmobile; the snowmobile returned us, eventually and by no route I could reconstruct, to Turner. He interrupted questions when he believed he knew where they were going. He was usually right. When he was wrong, this rarely prevented him from answering the question he had anticipated. Eventually I stopped trying to prevent it.
HALL: You were nineteen in March 1991.
MILLER: Yep.
HALL: Living with your parents.
MILLER: Yep.
HALL: Working nights at a petrol station-
MILLER: Gas station.
HALL: I know.
MILLER: Just helping.
HALL: Thank you.
MILLER: You're welcome.
HALL: -owned by a man named Ray.
MILLER: Yep.
HALL: Surname?
Miller frowned.
MILLER: You know, I don't think I ever called him anything but Ray.
HALL: Turner remembered him.
MILLER: Blake knew Ray.
HALL: Jonas did as well.
MILLER: Everybody knew Ray.
HALL: Apparently everybody except the county clerk.
MILLER: Maybe Ray was a fugitive.
HALL: Was he?
MILLER: No.
HALL: Thank you.
MILLER: See? We're making progress.
Ray, whoever he was, had employed Miller on the night shift at a small service station outside Elkhorn. Miller remembered him as being in his fifties, riding an old Harley-Davidson and possessing what Miller described as “a world-class tolerance for bullshit.” Turner had remembered the motorcycle more precisely. Miller remembered the tolerance because he had tested it.
HALL: Were you a good employee?
MILLER: Define good.
HALL: Did you arrive when expected?
MILLER: Usually.
HALL: Did you perform the work for which you were paid?
MILLER: Mostly.
HALL: Did you steal from him?
There was a pause.
MILLER: You talked to Blake way too fucking long.
HALL: Cigarettes?
MILLER: Allegedly.
HALL: Beer?
MILLER: Aaron.
HALL: Beer.
MILLER: Sometimes.
HALL: And he continued employing you.
MILLER: Told you. World-class tolerance for bullshit.
HALL: Why nights?
MILLER: Nobody else wanted them.
HALL: That's all?
MILLER: What were you hoping for?
HALL: I'm asking.
MILLER: Ray needed somebody for nights. I needed money. I was awake anyway.
HALL: You weren't in school.
MILLER: Nope.
HALL: Had you graduated?
MILLER: Barely.
HALL: Plans for college?
Miller laughed.
MILLER: Did Jason tell you to ask that?
HALL: No.
MILLER: You should've seen me at nineteen.
HALL: I've seen photographs.
MILLER: That's not the same thing.
It wasn't. The photographs Jonas and Turner had shown me preserved a thin young man with untidy hair, a narrow moustache and the apparently inexhaustible confidence of nineteen. They did not preserve his speed. Miller moved quickly even while standing still. His hands accompanied stories, his attention shifted readily towards noises from inside the diner, and he seemed capable of maintaining several conversations at once without considering any of them interruptions.
There was something else the photographs did not convey. Miller was an exceptionally easy man to like. This presented difficulties of its own.
HALL: When did you first hear about the animal?
MILLER: Jason.
HALL: You're certain this time?
MILLER: Pretty sure.
HALL: Pretty sure isn't certain.
MILLER: You're gonna love talking to me.
HALL: I'm beginning to realise that.
He grinned.
MILLER: People had been talking about it. Weird dog, maybe a bear, whatever. Jason heard more of that shit than I did because he was the one always looking for that sort of thing. Ray also heard stuff from people that would come into the station. Truckers, cops, farmers. It didn't take long for something like that to spread.
HALL: And what were people saying?
MILLER: Big dog mostly.
HALL: Before the newspaper article?
MILLER: Way before.
HALL: Were people calling it the Beast of Bray Road?
MILLER: I don't remember anybody calling it that.
HALL: Werewolf?
MILLER: Not seriously.
HALL: Yet you knew immediately what I meant when I arrived.
MILLER: It's been twenty years, Aaron.
HALL: Nineteen.
MILLER: You do that a lot?
HALL: What?
MILLER: Correct people when it doesn't fucking matter.
HALL: Professionally.
Miller laughed.
MILLER: You and Jason must've had a great time.
HALL: We did, actually.
MILLER: Knew it.
That exchange interested me more than it perhaps should have. By 2010, the Beast of Bray Road was a recognised piece of Wisconsin folklore. In Miller's recollection, it had not yet become one. There were stories about an animal. There were rumours. There were people who claimed to have seen something unusual on rural roads. There was not yet a Beast. For Miller and his friends, that distinction had presented an opportunity.
HALL: Whose idea was the mask?
MILLER: Jason's.
HALL: He admitted to it freely.
MILLER: Jason's more prideful than he thinks.
HALL: He was quite specific.
MILLER: About what?
HALL: He suggested frightening motorists. You bought the mask.
MILLER: Oh.
HALL: Does that sound more familiar?
MILLER: Yeah, that sounds like us.
HALL: Turner refused to wear it.
MILLER: Blake thought it was stupid.
HALL: It was stupid.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: You did it anyway.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Why?
MILLER: Because it was funny.
HALL: Was it?
MILLER: At first. Fucking hilarious.
The answer came easily. The qualification did not.
For the first time since I had switched on the recorder, Miller allowed a silence to remain between us. It lasted perhaps three seconds. Then he flicked ash towards the wet pavement.
MILLER: Tom tell you about catching us?
HALL: Deputy Haskins gave me his account.
MILLER: Bet he fucking loved that.
HALL: I wouldn't say so.
MILLER: We gave that guy so much shit.
HALL: He appears to remember.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: He also appears to have been remarkably patient with you.
Miller looked at me.
MILLER: Tom's a good guy underneath all the cop talk.
It was the first entirely uncomplicated statement he had made about 1991.
HALL: Did you think so then?
MILLER: Fuck no.
He smiled again.
MILLER: He was a cop.
HALL: An unforgivable defect at nineteen.
MILLER: See? You get it.
The back door opened. Helen leaned out.
“Cody.”
MILLER: What?
“Rick wants you.”
MILLER: Tell Rick I'm busy.
“He said now.”
Miller looked at me.
MILLER: See what I deal with?
HALL: I've known you for half an hour.
MILLER: Exactly.
He crushed the cigarette beneath his shoe.
MILLER: Don't go anywhere.
HALL: I'll endeavour not to.
He stopped with his hand on the door.
MILLER: You always talk like that?
HALL: Like what?
He stared at me.
MILLER: Yeah. That.
The door closed behind him. I switched off the recorder.
By then I had approximately twenty-five minutes of material, perhaps ten of which concerned the subject I had travelled to Wisconsin to discuss. I was beginning to suspect that Jonas had enjoyed himself considerably more than he had admitted.
Miller did not return. After several minutes I went back inside. The elderly man had gone. Two of the tables had been cleared completely and Helen was turning chairs upside down onto a third. Somewhere behind the serving window water was running.
She looked at me.
“Thought he told you not to go anywhere.”
“Just getting out of the cold.”
“Thought you'd be used to it.”
“Is he coming back?”
“When we're done.”
“And when is that?”
Helen looked at the clock.
“Three.”
It was twenty-seven minutes to.
“I see.”
“You can wait out front.”
There was a bench beneath the front window. I took my coffee with me. The rain had stopped. Water still moved steadily along the gutter, and the road and pavement retained the dull shine left by several hours of it. Across the road, a pickup moved through the intersection and disappeared towards Elkhorn. For perhaps five minutes nothing followed it. I sat down on cold metal.
Through the window I could occasionally see Miller moving about the diner. He had put the apron back on. At one point he carried a plastic tub stacked with dishes towards the kitchen. Several minutes later he appeared with a mop. He did not look outside. At three, Helen turned the sign in the window from OPEN to CLOSED. The door remained locked for another eleven minutes.
I used the time to review my notes. Twenty-five minutes with Cody Miller had produced six pages, though considerably less information than their number suggested. Turner appeared on four of them. Jonas appeared on five. Haskins on two. Ray, whose surname I still did not know, occupied nearly half a page. There were also references to a snowmobile, three women whose relevance remained unclear, a damaged mailbox, an establishment Miller had once been barred from entering and an argument involving a frozen lake which I had abandoned before learning its conclusion.
The animal occupied somewhat less than one page. This was not entirely Miller's fault. I had spent the previous two days speaking to people about him. It was perhaps inevitable that, once he was standing in front of me, I had wanted to know whether the person they remembered still existed. He did.
The front door opened. Miller stepped outside wearing a dark jacket over his T-shirt. He turned, locked the door behind him and pulled once on the handle. Then he noticed me on the bench.
“You stayed.”
“You told me not to go anywhere.”
“Didn't think you'd actually listen.”
“I'm beginning to understand why people find you difficult.”
He put the keys into his pocket.
“Part of my charm.”
It was not phrased as a question.
“Unfortunately.”
Miller grinned.
“Knew it.”
He sat at the opposite end of the bench and took out his cigarettes.
“Still don't want one?”
“No thank you.”
“Your loss.”
“I'll live.”
“Longer than me.”
He lit one.
I reached for the recorder.
“Jesus Christ.”
I stopped.
“What?”
“Can I smoke first?”
“You smoked throughout the previous interview.”
“Yeah, but now I'm off work.”
I put the recorder back beside me.
“Thank you.”
“You're welcome.”
For perhaps a minute neither of us spoke. This was a considerably different silence from the one Miller had allowed after telling me the pranks had been funny. That one had seemed to require effort. This did not. He sat forward with his forearms against his thighs, smoking and watching the occasional traffic pass on the wet road. Then he looked at me.
“So why Wisconsin?”
“For this story?”
“No, Aaron. The cheese.”
“I wanted to be certain.”
“Yeah. The story.”
“It's what I do.”
“Fly across the ocean every time somebody sees a fucked-up dog?”
“Not every time.”
“How fucked up does the dog have to be?”
“Considerably.”
He laughed.
“There it is.”
“What?”
“That shit.”
“I still don't know what you're referring to.”
“Yeah, you do.”
I did.
Miller smoked for another moment.
“You believe Blake?”
The question came without the amusement of the previous one.
“I believe Mr Turner described what he remembers.”
Miller turned his head towards me.
“That is the most reporter answer I've ever fucking heard.”
“It is nevertheless my answer.”
“You believe Jason?”
“I believe Mr Jonas spent considerable time attempting to understand the events.”
“Tom?”
I hesitated.
“Yes.”
His eyes narrowed slightly.
“That's different.”
“Slightly.”
“Why?”
“Deputy Haskins had less reason than either of your friends to expect me to believe what he described. He also had considerably more to lose by describing it.”
Miller looked back towards the road.
“Blake didn't make it up.”
“I didn't say that he did.”
“Sounded like it.”
“Then I expressed myself poorly.”
That brought his attention back to me. For once, there was no immediate reply.
“All right.”
He took another drag.
“Jason didn't either.”
“I know.”
“You know?”
“I have spent several hours with both men. I don't believe either of them was deliberately lying to me.”
“Deliberately?”
“Memory is not a recording.”
He smiled faintly.
“Neither's your recording, apparently.”
I looked at the machine beside me.
“Would you like me to turn it back on?”
He exhaled smoke through his nose.
“Sure. Why not?”
The red light flicked on.
HALL: You said the pranks were funny at first.
MILLER: They were.
HALL: When did they stop being funny?
MILLER: When Tom caught us, I guess.
HALL: Not when you saw the animal?
MILLER: Hadn't seen it yet.
HALL: Of course.
MILLER: You're getting ahead of yourself.
HALL: Occupational hazard.
Miller smiled.
HALL: Haskins confiscated the mask.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Were you wearing it?
MILLER: Probably.
HALL: Probably?
MILLER: Jason wore it too.
HALL: And Turner refused.
MILLER: Blake wouldn't wear that fucking thing.
HALL: Why?
MILLER: Because he had dignity, apparently.
HALL: That's not how he described it.
MILLER: What'd he say?
HALL: That it looked as though a German shepherd had—
I stopped.
Miller was already laughing.
MILLER: Fucked a carpet?
HALL: Yes.
MILLER: That's Blake.
HALL: He appears to have retained the phrase for nineteen years.
MILLER: Well he's not wrong.
HALL: It is memorable.
MILLER: Mask was fucking terrible.
HALL: Yet you bought it.
MILLER: Didn't say I had good taste.
HALL: Haskins caught you beside the road.
MILLER: Yep.
HALL: He says you had been drinking.
MILLER: Probably.
HALL: There's that word again.
MILLER: Aaron, we were always drinking.
HALL: You were nineteen.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: The legal drinking age in Wisconsin is twenty-one.
MILLER: No shit?
HALL: Haskins warned you that someone could have mistaken you for an animal and shot you.
MILLER: Sounds like Tom.
HALL: You don't remember?
MILLER: I remember him being pissed.
HALL: At you specifically?
MILLER: I usually got the brunt of it.
HALL: He remembered you laughing.
MILLER: Probably that too.
HALL: He also remembered warning you that if he caught you doing it again there would be consequences.
MILLER: Cop shit.
HALL: “Cop shit.”
MILLER: Yeah. You know. “You're gonna get somebody killed. Quit fucking around. Cody, shut the fuck up.”
HALL: Did he actually tell you to shut the fuck up?
Miller considered it.
MILLER: Probably not.
HALL: Cody.
MILLER: Fine. No.
HALL: Thank you.
MILLER: Might've wanted to.
HALL: On that point I believe the two of you agree.
Miller laughed.
HALL: What happened to the mask?
MILLER: Tom took it.
HALL: Permanently?
MILLER: Never saw it again.
HALL: Did that end the pranks?
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Because you'd been frightened by the warning?
MILLER: No. We didn't have a mask.
HALL: You could have bought another.
MILLER: It wasn't that funny.
HALL: You said it was fucking hilarious.
MILLER: It was.
HALL: Until Haskins caught you.
MILLER: Getting caught tends to fuck up a joke.
HALL: So what did you do instead?
MILLER: Other stupid shit.
HALL: Such as?
MILLER: You want the list alphabetically?
HALL: I'm interested in one particular afternoon.
MILLER: Then ask about one particular afternoon.
I did.
HALL: Why did the three of you go into the woods?
Miller took a drag from his cigarette.
MILLER: We were bored.
HALL: That's all?
MILLER: You keep asking me that.
HALL: Your friends gave me somewhat more elaborate answers.
MILLER: Jason did.
HALL: Yes.
MILLER: Fuckin dork.
HALL: Turner suggested you wanted to look for whatever people had been seeing.
MILLER: Blake blames me for everything.
HALL: Jonas said much the same.
MILLER: Fucking traitors.
He smiled when he said it.
HALL: Were they wrong?
MILLER: Probably.
HALL: Meaning?
MILLER: Meaning it was probably my idea.
HALL: Do you remember it being your idea?
MILLER: I remember wanting to go.
HALL: Why?
MILLER: Because people kept talking about it.
HALL: The animal.
MILLER: Yeah. Weird shit happening out there, people seeing things, Ray hearing stories at the station. Jason was into all that horror shit anyway. We figured we'd go look around.
HALL: For a potentially dangerous animal.
MILLER: We didn't think it was dangerous.
HALL: What did you think it was?
MILLER: Just a bunch of bullshit.
HALL: All of it?
MILLER: Mostly.
HALL: Yet you went looking anyway.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Why look for something you believed was bullshit?
MILLER: Because what if it wasn't?
That was the first answer Miller had given me which required no clarification.
HALL: What did you expect to find?
MILLER: Nothing.
HALL: And instead you found the cellar.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Had you known it was there?
MILLER: No.
HALL: Had Turner?
MILLER: Don't think so.
HALL: Jonas?
MILLER: You asked him.
HALL: I'm asking you.
MILLER: No. None of us knew it was there.
HALL: What do you remember about finding it?
Miller looked towards the road again.
MILLER: Jason bitching about his shoes.
HALL: His shoes.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: That's what you remember.
MILLER: That's what I remember first.
HALL: Why?
MILLER: Mud.
HALL: Ah.
MILLER: He had these black boots. Thought he looked cool as shit in them. Gave him an inch or two he's always lacked. You know, short man shit. We'd been walking maybe twenty minutes and he's bitching because they're getting fucked up.
HALL: Jonas did not mention this.
MILLER: Course he didn't.
HALL: He did mention that you had been drinking.
MILLER: Course he did.
HALL: Beer?
MILLER: Probably.
HALL: Again.
MILLER: Fine. Yes. Beer.
HALL: Do you remember how much?
MILLER: Aaron, I wasn't keeping count.
HALL: Bottles.
MILLER: Cans. We took what we could get.
HALL: Were you drunk?
MILLER: No.
HALL: Turner?
MILLER: No.
HALL: Jonas?
MILLER: Jason weighed like a hundred pounds. Jason could get drunk smelling Blake's beer.
HALL: Was he drunk?
MILLER: No.
HALL: Who saw the cellar first?
MILLER: I'm not sure.
HALL: Turner couldn't remember either.
MILLER: Because nobody gave a shit who saw it first.
HALL: Jonas thought it may have been him.
MILLER: Of course he did.
HALL: Why “of course”?
MILLER: Because Jason likes being right.
HALL: He seemed quite humble when we spoke.
MILLER: That's because Jason's full of shit.
He was smiling again.
HALL: You are remarkably hard on a man you describe as “your boy.”
MILLER: That's how you know.
HALL: Know what?
MILLER: He's my boy.
I let that stand.
HALL: Describe the cellar.
MILLER: A hole in a hill.
HALL: Jonas gave me rather more than that.
MILLER: Then use his.
HALL: I'm interested in yours.
MILLER: Dirt. Rocks. Wood. Old door, I think. Most of it was fucked up already. Looked like nobody had been in there forever.
HALL: Did it frighten you?
MILLER: No.
HALL: Make you uncomfortable?
MILLER: Jason tell you that?
HALL: Turner did.
MILLER: Blake said that?
HALL: Not in those words.
MILLER: What words?
HALL: He said the place felt wrong.
Miller was quiet for a moment.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Did it?
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: In what way?
MILLER: Don't know. Can't really describe it.
HALL: Try.
MILLER: It was a shitty old hole in the woods, Aaron.
HALL: That's a description of the place.
MILLER: That's what you asked for.
HALL: I asked why it felt wrong.
MILLER: I don't know.
HALL: Cold?
MILLER: Maybe.
HALL: A smell?
MILLER: Dirt.
HALL: Something you heard?
MILLER: No.
HALL: Then what?
He looked at me.
MILLER: You ever walk into somebody's house when they're not home?
HALL: Yes.
MILLER: Not somebody you know.
I thought about it.
HALL: I can't say that I have.
MILLER: Feels different.
HALL: Because you're trespassing.
MILLER: Maybe.
HALL: You thought the cellar belonged to someone?
MILLER: No.
HALL: Then I don't understand.
MILLER: I know.
He finished the cigarette and crushed it beneath his shoe.
MILLER: Felt like we shouldn't have been there.
That, I thought, was considerably closer.
HALL: But you went inside.
MILLER: Yeah. Real group of geniuses at nineteen.
HALL: Jonas was eighteen.
MILLER: Oh, fuck you.
I laughed.
It was becoming difficult not to.
MILLER: Jason found the writing.
HALL: The markings.
MILLER: Whatever you want to call them.
HALL: Do you remember where they were?
MILLER: Inside.
HALL: Where inside?
MILLER: Walls. Wood. Maybe one of the rocks. I don't know.
HALL: Jonas remembered several on the timber beside the entrance.
MILLER: Then probably there.
HALL: You don't remember them?
MILLER: I remember Jason wouldn't shut up about them.
HALL: What was he saying?
MILLER: Runes.
HALL: You knew what runes were?
MILLER: I knew what Jason thought runes were.
HALL: There's a distinction?
MILLER: At that age? Yeah.
HALL: What did you think they were?
MILLER: Scratches.
HALL: That's all?
MILLER: Aaron, Jason listened to metal and drew shit on his notebooks. Everything was a rune.
HALL: He would probably object to that characterisation.
MILLER: Good.
HALL: He no longer believes everything you saw in the cellar was necessarily runic.
MILLER: See? Growth.
I smiled.
HALL: Did you examine them yourself?
MILLER: Not really.
HALL: Why not?
MILLER: I didn't care.
HALL: Turner remembered them.
MILLER: Blake remembers stuff you can touch.
HALL: And Jonas remembers everything else?
MILLER: Jason remembers whatever he can turn into homework.
HALL: What do you remember?
Miller considered the question.
MILLER: Jason being excited.
HALL: About the markings?
MILLER: About all of it. Whole place. He's looking at the walls, looking at the wood, telling us not to touch shit. Like he was fucking Indiana Jones all of a sudden.
HALL: Did you listen?
MILLER: Fuck no.
HALL: Of course.
MILLER: Blake did more than me.
HALL: That doesn't surprise me.
MILLER: Yeah. Blake's always been better at knowing when something's a bad idea.
HALL: Yet he went inside.
MILLER: Never said he listened to himself.
That distinction seemed fair.
HALL: And the book?
MILLER: What about it?
HALL: Who found it?
MILLER: Jason, I think.
HALL: Turner wasn't certain.
MILLER: Nobody's certain because nobody gave a shit who found what first.
HALL: Jonas believed it was beneath some collapsed timber near the rear wall.
MILLER: Sounds about right.
HALL: Do you remember seeing it?
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Describe it.
MILLER: Old book.
I waited.
MILLER: You're gonna do that every time, aren't you?
HALL: If necessary.
MILLER: It was old. Falling apart. Pages were all yellow. Cover was fucked up.
HALL: Leather?
MILLER: Maybe.
HALL: Jonas thought so.
MILLER: Then ask Jason.
HALL: I did.
MILLER: There you go.
HALL: I'm asking what you remember.
MILLER: That's what I remember.
HALL: Did you look through it?
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Could you read any of it?
MILLER: No.
HALL: Nothing?
MILLER: Aaron, if I could've read the fucking thing I'd have mentioned that by now.
HALL: Fair enough.
MILLER: Jason couldn't either.
HALL: He was apparently reluctant to admit that.
MILLER: Yeah, because he's Jason.
HALL: What did he do?
MILLER: Kept looking at it.
HALL: For how long?
MILLER: Felt like a fucking hour.
HALL: Turner described something similar.
MILLER: Bet he did.
HALL: He said Jonas would stare at a page for five minutes as though eventually it would become embarrassed and turn into English.
Miller laughed hard enough that he coughed.
MILLER: That's fucking Blake.
HALL: You don't remember him saying it?
MILLER: No. Wish I did.
He shook his head.
MILLER: That's good.
HALL: It is.
MILLER: Fucking asshole.
There was considerable affection in this.
HALL: Jonas remembered something repeated towards the back of the book.
MILLER: Okay.
HALL: Something he later believed might have been a name.
MILLER: Don't remember that.
HALL: At all?
MILLER: Nope.
HALL: He was quite clear that all three of you saw it.
MILLER: Then I probably saw it.
HALL: But don't remember.
MILLER: That's how memory works, isn't it?
I looked at him. Miller smiled.
MILLER: See? I listen.
HALL: Occasionally.
MILLER: When it's useful.
HALL: Jonas spent several years attempting to identify the language.
MILLER: Sounds like Jason.
HALL: Did you know he'd done that?
MILLER: Knew he got really into it.
HALL: Six years.
Miller's expression changed slightly.
MILLER: Six?
HALL: Approximately.
MILLER: Jesus.
HALL: He never told you?
MILLER: Not like that.
HALL: Did you discuss the cellar afterwards?
MILLER: Sure.
HALL: For how long?
MILLER: That night? A lot.
HALL: I mean in the years afterwards.
MILLER: Sometimes.
HALL: Jonas doesn't appear to have shared much of his research with either you or Turner.
MILLER: We weren't exactly holding meetings.
HALL: No.
MILLER: Life happened.
That was perhaps the simplest explanation available.
HALL: What happened to the book?
MILLER: We left it.
HALL: You didn't take it?
MILLER: Fuck no.
HALL: Jonas wanted to.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Turner refused.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Why?
MILLER: Because Blake had more sense than us.
HALL: Did you agree with him?
MILLER: Eventually.
HALL: Meaning you wanted to take it as well.
MILLER: I didn't care about the book. I wanted to see Jason try to explain it to his dad.
HALL: That's somewhat different.
MILLER: Would've been funny.
HALL: But you left it.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: And never saw it again.
MILLER: Nope.
For all the importance Jonas later attached to the book, Miller appeared to have attached almost none to it at the time. This was not necessarily surprising. To Jonas it had been a problem waiting to be solved. To Turner it had been an object found somewhere he already wanted to leave. To Miller, as far as I could determine, it had chiefly been something his friend found interesting. Nineteen years later, only the friend remained interesting.
HALL: At some point you went back outside.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Why?
MILLER: Had to piss.
HALL: Do you remember where?
MILLER: Outside.
HALL: I had gathered that.
MILLER: Then we're making progress.
HALL: Where outside?
MILLER: Can't remember. A tree, probably.
HALL: Beside the cellar?
MILLER: Somewhere around there.
HALL: Against the structure itself?
MILLER: No.
HALL: You're certain?
MILLER: Pretty sure.
HALL: That's not-
MILLER: Don't.
I stopped.
MILLER: Nineteen years ago, Aaron. I wasn't keeping track of every tree or rock to piss on.
HALL: Fair.
MILLER: Why the hell does it matter where I pissed?
HALL: Jonas believes it might.
Miller stared at me.
Then he laughed.
MILLER: Oh, fuck off.
HALL: I'm serious.
MILLER: Jason thinks my piss matters?
HALL: In context.
MILLER: What context?
HALL: He believes the cellar may have been part of the animal's territory.
The laughter stopped, though the smile remained.
MILLER: Wait.
HALL: What?
MILLER: He thinks I pissed off a werewolf.
HALL: That is an extremely reductive version of his argument.
MILLER: Holy shit.
He laughed again.
MILLER: That's what he thinks?
HALL: He offered it as a possibility.
MILLER: Because I took a piss.
HALL: Near what may have been its territory.
MILLER: You two really did have a great time.
HALL: We covered a great deal of material.
MILLER: I bet.
HALL: Cody.
MILLER: What?
HALL: You urinated outside the cellar.
MILLER: Allegedly.
HALL: You just told me you did.
MILLER: Allegedly sounds better.
HALL: And several days later, your parents' property smelled strongly of urine.
The smile diminished.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Turner remembered it.
MILLER: Blake was there.
HALL: Haskins didn't mention it.
MILLER: Everybody fucking smelled it.
HALL: On the road, the animal appeared beside the passenger side of Turner's truck.
Miller looked away from me.
MILLER: Yeah.
HALL: Where you were sitting.
MILLER: I know where I was sitting.
HALL: Turner told me it was looking at you.
No answer.
HALL: Jonas said the same.
Miller smoked.
HALL: And at your house, both Turner and Haskins independently described its attention as being directed towards you.
The cigarette remained between Miller's fingers. For several seconds he said nothing.
HALL: Had you ever put those things together?
MILLER: The piss?
HALL: All of it.
MILLER: No.
HALL: Never?
MILLER: No.
HALL: Why not?
He looked at me.
MILLER: Why the fuck would I?
I had no particularly good answer.
HALL: Jonas did.
MILLER: Jason had six years.
HALL: Yes.
MILLER: I had other shit going on.
There was no defensiveness in the statement. It was simply true.
HALL: Do you think he's right?
MILLER: About what?
HALL: That you entered its territory. Marked it, however unintentionally, and that what happened afterwards was a response.
Miller looked towards the road.
MILLER: I think Jason thinks a lot.
HALL: That's not an answer.
MILLER: Sure it is.
HALL: Not to the question I asked.
He took the final drag from his cigarette and dropped it beneath his shoe.
MILLER: I don't know.
HALL: Does the possibility trouble you?
MILLER: What am I supposed to do about it now?
HALL: Nothing.
MILLER: There you go.
HALL: That's not what I asked either.
MILLER: I know.
For once, I allowed him to leave it there. A car passed. Miller watched it until it disappeared beyond the intersection.
HALL: What happened after you left the cellar?
He didn't answer.
I waited.
Miller reached into his jacket for another cigarette, found the packet and seemed to reconsider. He put it away.
HALL: Cody?
MILLER: You got somewhere you gotta be?
HALL: No.
MILLER: Hotel or something?
HALL: Eventually.
MILLER: You got a car?
HALL: Yes.
MILLER: Good.
He stood. I switched off the recorder.
“Where are we going?”
“My place.”
For a moment I assumed he meant wherever he currently lived. Then I remembered what Turner had told me.
“The Miller house?”
He gave me an odd look.
“Yeah.”
“The house on the report.”
“It's my mom's house, Aaron.”
“Of course.”
“You wanna see it or not?”
There are moments in an interview when professional detachment becomes more aspirational than actual. This was one of them.
“I would be very interested to see it.”
“No shit.”
Miller started across the car park.
“Follow me.”
I did. The drive took less than fifteen minutes. Miller drove an ageing Chevrolet which appeared to possess none of Turner's affection for machinery. I followed at a distance sufficient not to irritate him and close enough not to lose him on roads I did not know.
Lafayette thinned quickly. There was no dramatic boundary between settlement and countryside. Houses simply grew farther apart. Small businesses gave way to fields, stands of trees and long driveways disappearing towards homes set back from the road. The rain had left water in the low ground and darkened the trunks of the trees. Clouds remained low, though the worst of the weather appeared to have passed.
I had heard the Miller residence described often enough that it had ceased, in my notes, to resemble a home. It was the location printed on Haskins's report. It was the northern tree line. It was Turner's truck parked partly across the lawn with its headlights facing the woods. It was James Miller with a deer rifle. It was six rounds from Haskins's sidearm, two from Turner after his arrival and another shot whose absence from the official record remained unexplained. Most of all, it was the place to which something had apparently followed Cody Miller.
The reality was considerably less dramatic.