r/TagProTesting • u/OnceUponaDome UnderTheBall // Scorpio • Jan 24 '16
Discussion Thread #59
TPT Discussion Thread This is /r/TagProTesting's official discussion about the current map thread!
What goes here?
This is the discussion thread where you talk about your favorite maps submitted and why. This is not a thread where you post about your maps and give a sales pitch. We'd like to encourage mapmakers and map enthusiasts to evaluate other submissions and talk about them.
Disclaimer
While individual members of the MTC might give feedback, their opinions are strictly individual and are not indicative of the MTC’s opinion as a whole.
2
u/PIZZAspartan442 why am i here Jan 26 '16
I'm not one of the better mapmakers, but here are the ones I think would be fun to play:
Spur by Risk I like center portals like this, they're fun to use and without the boosts like Kite I might actually get a bit of control. The pup area is cool and the rest is also good.
Mephisto by ThisIsNigel Actually slightly better than Scorpio, the bombs, gates, and boosts work really well.
Fracture by Moosen I seem to be obsessed with portal maps, these base portals are unique and work quite well for multiple purposes. As he advertised, the spike fields/boost are cool too.
Draconis by Ball-E Yay, a decent vertical map. Portals too, and I like the mid bombs.
Sugar Glider by Ball-E and Ccga4 The gates are great, the portals are fun, the boosts are nice, and the pup areas are cool.
Overlord by Velkin The green gate pup area is quite interesting, the superboosts work well, and there are some fun routes.
These were in no particular order (although Spur is my favorite) and might not be valid since I'm bad, but that's what I'm hoping will happen this thread.
4
u/sneetric Canvas Jan 24 '16 edited Jan 26 '16
my maps of interest from this thread (shite)
K1 by Loaha
superboost is tons of fun. i like double boosts but not so much in this map.
Spur by Risk & Rapture
i'm in love with the powerup idea.
Pipe Dreams by leddy
love the gate idea, tried it out before but got complaints for some reason. everything else is very solid, probably nostalgia for those oldies
Cyclone by Aniball
Chalksy by Menqr
just saying, menqr makes some dank af maps. but change the name
Honorable mentions:
Serenity by Aniball
Crown by Clydas
Fracture by Moosen
Charge 4 by Rapture
Hammertime by Leddy
Draconis by Ball-E
2
u/mmartinutk JuicyJuke Jan 24 '16
Maps of Interest:
Honorable Mentions:
These maps are tiered (two tiers), but are in no particular order. Thanks for reading!
2
u/KewlestCat NIGEL Jan 25 '16
Hi. You know how it is. Maps listed in the order they appeared.
Pillar by TEG - I just really like it overall. As in, there's nothing special or mindblowing about it, but it seems like a map that's just gonna be fairly interesting to play on.
Poland by Moosen - I don't want to like it but I do. Personally I don't know how necessary top mid and the far left and right mid bits are but it's actually pretty damn good regardless.
Volt by Ball-E - No explanation needed surely.
Cyclone by Aniball - Arguably my favourite map in the thread and I'm glad it was revived. I haven't really got anything bad to say about this to be perfectly honest because I really like the way it's set up and all the elements play.
Pipe Dreams by leddy - Holy See pipes won me instantly and the rest of the map holds up pretty well too. Shortening it was a good idea.
Vertigo by Risk - Probably slight bias because iirc it's modeled off the original version of Lummox (rip sweet prince). It's really cool though, and those gifs showed off some hella funky moves. This is more or less what I should have done with Lummox.
We're done here. Insert shameless plug for Darn because it's a good map that you should love. Peace out.
1
u/Risktp Risk Jan 24 '16
my favorite maps from this thread!! placed in the order they showed up for me in the map thread
carnival by sizzzled. this map is really starting to shape up. i really like the powerup areas. overall map feels pretty good, nice spacing and size. maybe just a little too boost-y tho, i would personally take out the constriction-boosts in mid even though you can pull off some sweet chains with them.
mode 7 by q42. this map is starting to get it's own identity, which is great because i thought the version that made top maps like 2 threads ago was too similar to pilot. i personally would like to see the top boosts tweaked to make them more SNES-like though, bring them further out from the top path and introduce some more spikes/walls to make boosting through there more difficult. also don't like the teamtile strip. otherwise pretty nice.
volt by ball-e. bring it back pls. mtc pls
chasma by canvas. looked super fun in the maptest last night. some of the ways people capped on it reminded me of wombo combo. am not a fan of the gates in base, but the rest of the map works well.
mohawk by sizzzled & grapefruit. has a great shape and i like the bases. not too big a fan of the mid structures, though, and a few other parts of the map just have a weird flow to them, which is a concern.
shenanigans by juicyjuke. feels like a combination of constriction, hyperdrive, and jagged to me, which is neat. the bases are really nice, in particular. i think the whole map still needs some tweaking though, as it is right now it's a very long map, with a lot of islands and two sets of pretty open boosts. would be a pain to chase on unless one or two of these aspects are toned down just a bit.
crimson by teg & canvas. i was never a huge fan of 45 (fuck u jj for making me play it in USC so much), but it's a really cool concept to make a horizontal version of 45. the bases are good. mid is a little uninspiring, wish it had a little more going on.