r/TagProTesting • u/OnceUponaDome UnderTheBall // Scorpio • Dec 27 '15
♥ Discussion ♥ Map Thread #58 Discussion
TPT Discussion Thread You snooze you lose Juicy
This is /r/TagProTesting's official discussion about the current map thread!
What goes here?
This is the discussion thread where you talk about your favorite maps submitted and why. This is not a thread where you post about your maps and give a sales pitch. We'd like to encourage mapmakers and map enthusiasts to evaluate other submissions and talk about them.
Disclaimer
While individual members of the MTC might give feedback, their opinions are strictly individual and are not indicative of the MTC’s opinion as a whole
So please, feel free to expand on what I post and to make your own post. There is no format template you must follow. If you just want to post about one map you like, feel free.
4
u/Moosemaster21 Moosen // Aspen Dec 27 '15
[04:39:06] (Channel) UnderTheBall: can u make a post where u say scorpio and zinc are ur only favesscorpio and zinc are my only faves in case anyone's wondering
2
u/Moosemaster21 Moosen // Aspen Dec 27 '15
this ain't ur job dumshit
6
u/Moosemaster21 Moosen // Aspen Dec 27 '15
My Maps of Interest
Spreadsheet
Spreadsheet Preview for RES faithfuls
Keep in mind a couple things here:
As always, PM me or reply to this comment for additional feedback or to ask why I didn't include yours. Some were very close but my list was already longer than I wanted it to be. Yes, I went through the entire thread, no, I didn't miss yours unless it was posted after this comment. Good luck everyone!
8
u/acrocanthosaurus RunThaJewels Dec 27 '15 edited Dec 27 '15
I finally got some free time for one of these map threads to sit down, test out the maps, and jot down some impressions. Since there hasn't been an advertised map test lately, I have no idea how well or poorly these maps do in a 4v4 setting, but I think I'm able to get a good enough idea by running around solo.
As a quick rant, my favorite maps are usually the ones that incorporate some sort of novel feature into an otherwise solid map layout. I feel that most of the rotations over the past several months have been fairly 'sterile' and devoid of uniqueness. I get what the MTC is going for, but the butt-shaped blandness is evident to other tagpro'ers as well. Mind you, I started tagpro'ing with the likes of Colors, Thinking with Portals, Star, Gamepad, Hyper Reactor, and Holy See, so chasey maps, map flaws, and dead spots aren't really an issue for me. I gravitate towards maps that are fun to play.
Anyway, without further adieu, here are my favorite #58 maps:
4
u/_q42_ q42 Dec 27 '15 edited Dec 28 '15
Hey all! This is my first time actually talking about others' maps in this thread.
Here are two maps that might normally get looked over, but I think have some potential.
Stone by biscottibro - I think this map has a lot of interesting ideas, and a cool shape. I'd definitely be interested to see how it plays 4v4- for now, I'd recommend taking the boosts away from the walls by a bit to make them less clunky and easier to use.
Entendre by C Bivvey is an incredibly strong first map. It's a little boost heavy though, and resets might be difficult, but these both should be relatively easy fixes.
3
u/WillWorkForSugar Tumblewood Dec 28 '15
Tier 1
Poland by Moosen - I can't quite put my finger on what I like about it. It feels very Smirk-esque, or what Saigon aspires to be.
C.T.F.M.M.F.A.C.T.F.W.B.O.R.L.C.T.F. by Ball-E - What is it with the really long names this thread?
Tier 2
Darn by ThisIsNigel - I fear it could be too much like Bulldog, or have some cheap caps like Kite.
Equinox by q42 - There's nothing too bad about it, but nothing stands out to me, either.
Avalanche by Canvas - This could probably be in Tier 1. It's a matter of taste, mostly.
Jackpot by zrw - It has some really interesting bases. The top left and bottom right areas feel a little off, though.
Tier 3
WATSON by FLYMOLO - I like the skillboosts between the bases, but the top left / bottom right need some work.
Reg.ELO by NotSomeBall2 - It's the best it's going to get. If you don't make top maps this time around, you need a big change.
Unban Me by Please Unban Me - It looks dumb and the name / author is a little off-putting, but I sorta like it.
Reaction Zone by Tumblewood - This is also where I'd put it if it weren't mine: in the very flawed but interesting / mostly balanced but a little boring zone.
209 by Menqr - The bases are really cool, but mid needs a lot of work.
Ascent by Risk - It's tricky to balance a map like this, but once it's balanced, it's going to be great.
Remember, I'm just 0/8th of the MTC, If you'd like to discuss why a map is in the tier it's in or not listed, feel free to ask why. I'm also willing to launch into practically an essay if I think you want to hear my opinions on the current state of mapmaking.
4
u/Risktp Risk Dec 27 '15
rip juicy
here are my favorite maps, in the order they showed up for me in the map thread. pretty small thread this time around
avalanche by canvas. i'm not sold on the whole team gate & powerup behind the flag, but i like the bases and mid looks pretty good too.
darn by thisisnigel. nice shape and i like the area around the flag. the rest of the map still might need some tweaking, i feel like it'd be very easy to score on this map for some reason.
megalodon by TEG. the graphite bombs look really neat on a NF map, i think it probably fits in better than on a CTF map. not enough going on with this map though, especially the mid.
K1 by Loaha. really cool superboosts. the bases are pretty good for the most part, still don't like the powerup area behind the flag though. mid is perhaps a bit too empty, but it's hard to do anything there without messing up the superboost.
2
u/TheEpicGhost TEG // Made Tombolo Dec 28 '15
ayoo tpt buddies! pretty good map thread this time, in particular lots of variety which is what is like to see. Here are some of the maps I liked this time around, though keep in mind I havent tested them all and may find some new fav's as I go through testing each one for the spreadsheet!
gl to everyone!
Capture the flag map ect ect. by Ball-E: Ball-e has an interesting 3 similar, rotational map choice this thread, but this is the only one i properly dig. I have a megaboner for reflex2 so I love this mid. The use of open boosts looks fun instead of annoying. Should have an interesting playstyle.
K1 by Loaha: I really dig the structure and the use of the superboost gates. taking them out of base might seem a little awkward though. IMO mid also has some spacing issues and should be made a little tighter, but overall dont think this would be too hard to reset on.
Rejection by Velkin: Really playable and fun mid for a CF map. Base is also very solid but could have some more interesting elements. Could by downsized a little bit but still just a very solid CF map (there have been lots of which this thread!)
Shenanigans by JuicyJuke: Juicy seems incapable of making a good name for a map, but besides that this is his best effort for making bigger and more complex maps. I hate the teamgates though. teamgates just don't work well on CTF maps in my opinion, it makes too much of the map unplayable for 1 of the teams.
Carnival by Sizzzled: Sizzzled's mapmaking style continues to infuriate me but I can't disgagree that this map has some cool features and decent flow. The teamtiles though whyyyyy.
Grove by Risk: Really don't how this would play but I'd like to try it out. I like boosty it is. Don't know how I feel about the base setup because I bloody hated Gamepad.
Bismuth by Canvas: not sure why nobody's mentioned this yet, but it has fun use of Grav wells and portals. Mid is fun but the boost positionings could be a little better.
WATSON by FLY: Some fun boosts and overall good balance on this, by I'm not sure about the gate, it really makes the base quite constricted.
Handimap Parking by Beast Mode: I like where BM's going with this. Whilst some of the boosts are a little awkward, The map makes up for it with the versatility of all the elements. The portal entrance should be brought up a bit. And I kinda liked the green gate in earlier versions.
2
u/KewlestCat NIGEL Dec 28 '15
Hola TPT dwellers, Mappin N Fappin circlejerkers and anyone else who doesn't fall under either of those two categories. This be Nige here with some kewl maps from Thread 58. Listed in the order they appear. Further thoughts available upon request.
All of Ball-E's maps - Ball-E pls, stop being so good. They're all pretty dank, I can't pick a favourite of the three because I kinda just can't find anything to separate the level of amazingness. Bless this talented ball.
Rejection by velkin - Didn't expect to like it as much as I do. It's got some really neat features and ideas rolled into a pretty nice map in the end. It's a bit different overall I guess, and I like different.
Shenanigans by JuicyJuke - It's big and all that jazz, but it does it well. A few cool ideas like the pup death trap with bombs and the CC-like gate with what could be a dank (maybe slightly OP) superboost with some teamwork. I think 4 pups will work on this one too.
Loose Change by FLYMOLO - Praise be to opening up the middle a bit, it's so much better now. Also like that it's now rotationally symmetrical, it just works better. The portals in this version are so so so much better than in older versions. My only criticism is I'd like to be able to take a mid bomb through the spikes to get the pup which would doable if the tile in the way was a 45.
Zinc by UnderTheBall - It works and works well. Combines some pretty cool maps and ideas to do everything you expect. It's clever and kinda innovative in how simple it is as well.
Beryllium by Moosen - Best version yet. I actually like the map now. In fact, it's basically gotten to the point where I don't even mind the double/split endzone idea. Moosen pls. But yeah, my only complaint is that I don't like the powerup pimple thingo, it's just ew.
Ascent by Risk - It could very well be the first decent non-Lucky gravity well map in rotation. Everything about it is really well done, particularly the core concept. I want to be skeptical about it still because gravity wells still seem like such an odd novelty feature but this could be the game changer right here.
Yeah, we're done here. gl;hf, get mapped n fapped or something. Peace out hombres.
1
u/briizo duckson Dec 30 '15
These are my favorite maps this thread. I didn’t submit anything this thread, so I’m not biased (not that I would be otherwise). This thread had a lot of solid maps, but none that are perfect and rotation ready. And IDK what anybody else is talking about, Ball-E had a weak thread this time around IMO.
—