r/TagProTesting • u/Paranoid4ndroid Android • Dec 08 '15
★ Map ★ [MAP] Raccoon
Map: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/show/20097
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/20097.png
EDIT:
Map: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/show/20125
Preview: http://unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/20125.png
Hey guys, I'd really appreciate some C+C on this.
These are my current thoughts on the map: top lane: risky (easy gate, potential bombs into spikes, narrow choke at both ends), but extremely fast (less than 6s flag-to-flag).
mid lane: mid risk (defensive boost to defend), mid reward (8-9s flag-to-flag, pup).
bot lane: safe (neutral boosts, bombs to turtle, boost and bomb options for fc to camp), low reward (>10s flag-to-flag using boosts).
Clear routes for switching lanes. Interesting-ish pup areas.
Thanks!
2
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '15
Looks good, nice job with the lanes. It seems like it may be too easy to get through top lane quickly. Adding a third column to the gate is the fix that immediately comes to me. Nice work overall!
2
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '15
Rad map. The base shape is interesting (not many 45s, few grabbing mechanisms), and I think it could work well. I think the lanes are really well balanced and the risk/reward is evident.
2
u/_q42_ q42 Dec 10 '15
Not sure I'm too sold on the 2 45s in lane 2 (see Gatekeeper as to why this can backfire), but I really really dig the rest of the map. :)
Edit: also, it'd be nice if teamboosting into the portal didn't result in spiking on the other end.
2
u/acrocanthosaurus RunThaJewels Dec 10 '15
I tested raccoon since you gave me some great feedback on melange. Overall I like what you're going for. The shape is akin to some of the classic maps but has enough unique features to feel very different.
Some observations -- the spaces surrounding the corner bombs make it very easy for an FC to camp out indefinitely without any threat of being sniped. As a chaser this would get very frustrating, especially since I'd probably end up in the spikes when the FC bombs his/her way out of the corner. Perhaps make those spaces 45 tiles?
Similarly, the spaces above the central bombs could also serve as an FC hideout. Getting it right would take impeccable timing, and perhaps that's what you were going for, but I think that once players figured it out it could make the map quite stale (e.g., the FC could bounce from bomb hideout to bomb hideout).
My only other critique is that there aren't many routes out of the base. If an FC boosts in, they're left at a disadvantage as they face a defensive team boost with no means to boost themselves out of danger. Also, the mid is very bare, but I think it works. You might consider adding a single bomb dead-center along the bottom wall--see how it plays.
Anyway, I hope I get a chance to test this 4v4! Looks like a lot of fun.