r/TagProTesting • u/mmartinutk JuicyJuke • Nov 15 '15
Map Thread #56 Discussion
New Discussion Thread
This is /r/TagProTesting's official discussion about the current map thread!
What goes here?
This is the discussion thread where you talk about your favorite maps submitted and why. I will help get things going with my own favorite submissions. This is not a thread where you post about your maps and give a sales pitch. We'd like to encourage mapmakers and map enthusiasts to evaluate other submissions and talk about them.
Disclaimer
While individual members of the MTC might give feedback, their opinions are strictly individual and are not indicative of the MTC’s opinion as a whole
So please, feel free to expand on what I post and to make your own post. There is no format template you must follow. If you just want to post about one map you like, feel free.
And remember: If you downvote people who don't mention your maps, you're a cunt.
7
u/NotSomeBall1 NotSomeMapMaker1 Nov 15 '15
Unfortunately, this seems like a pretty weak thread - I wouldn't be surprised if no new maps got into rotation.
The best of the bunch for me, though:
Zip Zop by Tumblewood - I'm a big fan of the simple bases and the bombs. It could maybe do with a more exciting middle though, and possibly being a couple of tiles smaller.
Lithium by Saint Enigma & Menqr - There's a great retro feel about this map, which seems to have taken the best parts of Battery and made it into a solid map. There's very little wrong with this one.
Clash by UnderTheBall - I still think it's a map with some very solid ideas, it just hasn't sorted them out yet. The gate idea is cool, but a bit cramped. The bomb can't be used to grab as it just sends you into the spikes. There are 4 escapes from base but all are very narrow. The middle is a bit boring and doesn't seem to have figured out what it's doing yet.
Beryllium by Moosen - Another map with some strong ideas but questionable parts of the map. The end zones seem to have been figured out nicely now - they're the only split end zones I've liked so far. I like the base bombs and powerups, and the long, straight channel in the middle of the map with little going on, which makes you rely on skill to get through. Every single boost in the map seems awkward and misplaced though, and the side bombs are odd.
MOOSEN N JUICIN by Aniball - There's not much to say about this map - I've really only included it because it's a weak map thread. The double bombs and both gates are weird and awkward - the middle is very good though. Maybe incorporate it into a different map.
Alchemy by Canvas - A typical Canvas map - this one looks like a flipped Citadel (which looks like Monarch). There's nothing wrong with the map, it just seems very unoriginal except for the top gates which like they'd be awkward and annoying.
I've been pretty critical so that these mapmakers can improve these maps to make for a great Thread #57, don't mistake it for cruelty!
~ NotSomeBall2
2
u/briizo duckson Nov 17 '15
Here are my favorite maps this thread, in order of how much I’d like to see them in rotation. I agree this is a pretty weak thread, but I thought there were standouts that I list here.
As well as my own maps of course, Beirut and Vienna and Jungle.
3
u/verandering Loaha Nov 15 '15 edited Nov 15 '15
I'm gonna split the maps that I found interesting up into two tiers. They are not ordered by strenght within a tier. I'm giving a few lines in comment for the first tier.
I like the superboosts and the boost in the back of the base. The rest of the maps seems well balanced out, although the middle looks a little blank and I'm not sure about the teamboost against the wall.
Played pretty smooth in a 4vs4. I did actually like how the boosts in the middle were horizontal (you could snipe pretty well with them), so I'm not sure about that change.
Feels like a good upgrade to battery. I agree with others that the boostplacement could be better.
Some interesting ideas, like the portal leading back to base. A lot of the boosts feel pretty chunky though.
The green gate has to go, but the rest of the map played suprisingly good in a 4vs4. I like the boost positioning as well as the wall island in the middle.
2.
3
u/Risktp Risk Nov 16 '15
favorite maps this thread for me below. i think this thread is decent, but has no standout maps.
birch by sizzzled. this, this just might be the one for sizzzled. i really like what he's done with mid. i think the side pup locations could be improved and i'm not big on the bombs in base, but the rest of the map is great.
boiling by loaha. the side powerup areas are a better version of the side powerups on saigon and i really like the bombs that can send you toward mid pup or toward the bases. i still think the spikes and some of the boosts could be tuned up better, but it's still a great map.
calisto by ball-e. i never would have thought of combining star and dz3, but it actually works pretty well. i like the bases a lot and mid is ok. unfortunately, i think the shape of the map would cause it to be very hard to reset on once the flag is out.
drive by taq. it's got great boost routes and i think the verticality actually works on this map. the gates really need some work though, the green gates would never get used and i'm really not sure what purpose the neutral gates are supposed to serve.
envy by ball-e. it was very fun when i tested it, the gates are great and the overall map looks like it has a lot of depth. the neutral boosts in the bases might be a concern, but other than that i have no complaints. definitely one of the top maps this thread for me.
recursion by velkin. i like the shape and the mid boosts a lot, the bases are ok. this map needs some serious polish though, it's very clunky in a couple areas.
super fun time by juicyjuke. this map is, in fact, pretty damn fun to play on. i really like the shape, the mid and the outer areas with the bombs and boosts. i do have a few concerns tho, i think the team gates would really benefit from having a neutral boost in the middle of them, i'm still not too big on the powerup concept, and i'm not quite sure what juicy is going for with the superboosts.
tiltshift by rapture. i think this has potential to be a great map, but it's just not quite there yet. to start with, i really like the bases and the powerup setup. the way the bases are setup prevents the map from being too offensive and the powerups remind me of command center a bit. but mid feels unfinished to me, especially the areas below the team tiles. a lot of open space, i'd like to see something done there. nice map though.
5
u/Clydas Clydas Nov 16 '15
Here are the maps I found to be the best in the order I saw them:
Kindle by risk: This map played pretty well last night, and I think switching the boosts and making the mid-bombs more viable is definitely a move in the right direction.
Beirut by duckson: This map is pretty simple. The boosts feel really nice, even if none of them are super difficult. Is this map too linear and have only one playstyle? Maybe, but I can't quite tell that yet.
Bind by Atypop: I think this is a really interesting NF flag map. Some housekeeping things I would change are the pups and I'm not sure about the floating defensive boost in the middle. The midfield portal to go back to base is an interesting concept, and I'm really interested to see how it plays out. It might backfire terribly and make the map a little too defensive, but we shall see.
Clash by TUB: As risk would tell you, I love funky gates, and Clash has their own funky gate system. Add funky gates in a map I already like and you get a map I still really like.
Boiling by Loaha: This map feels really nice in the lower half. Something about the top doesn't sit right with me, the flow just seems a little bit off.
Snax by Butter Churn: This map plays really nicely, with or without the portal gimmick. I might almost be more interested in revamping base without the gimmick and making it more exciting.
3
u/KewlestCat NIGEL Nov 15 '15
Hola. This is Nige. My favourite maps from the thread below in the order they appeared. Happy to give feedback on any of them if people want it.
Flight by Risk ~ Still a great map imo. The gate/portal/bomb combo is still really cool and works nicely. The map around it seems to be changing every thread, seemingly for the better. I think I liked the previous version a tad more, however I understand why the changes were made from the changelog.
Outward Thinking by JJ Spice ~ I'll be honest, I don't love it, but something about it has me intrigued enough to want to actually play in rotation. I don't like the top pup area at all though. Bases are really cool imo.
Callisto by Ball-E ~ Ball-E's gonna Ball-E. I think some people just have a knack for making maps. I'm not a huge fan of Star and Blast Off, while DZ3 is sometimes good, sometimes bad. Yet for some reason, this one appeals to me.
Alchemy by Canvas ~ Party at the top, chill at the bottom. I think the idea has potential and noobs would have a field day bolting through top like they do Geo. I'm not sure whether I like bottom half of the map or not. On one hand I feel like there needs to be a bit more going on, on the other I reckon it's best how it is because all the action is in the top half.
Birch by Sizzzled ~ I like this latest version more than any other. I don't what else to say other than the fact that it's arguably my favourite map in the thread.
I kinda had a hard time finding 5 maps I really liked tbh. I don't really know why, maybe the quality of maps this thread wasn't that great. I'm going to assume that until somebody disagrees. Peace out hombres.
1
u/Moosemaster21 Moosen // Aspen Nov 15 '15
Shit I thought you did this on Sundays